Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1988-125

1988-125Kanag

Texte intégral

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL August 31, 1988
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 88- 125
Larry Montgomery
Executive Director
Kansas Lottery
128 North Kansas Avenue
Topeka, Kansas 66603
Re: State Boards, Commissions and Authorities--State
Lottery; Kansas Lottery Act--Co-Promotional
Agreements
Crimes and Punishments--Kansas Criminal Code;
Crimes Affecting Public Morals--Illegal Lotteries
Synopsis: The described co-promotional agreement between
the Kansas Lottery and a private business: 1) is
excepted from the trading stamp act; 2) is
permissible as a promotion which furthers the
purpose of the lottery act; 3) is not an illegal
lottery if one of the three elements of a lottery
(prize, consideration, chance) is eliminated from
the operation; and 4) may advertise that every
ticket purchased will be accompanied by a bonus
which is redeemable through the private business.
Cited herein: K.S.A. 21-2801; 21-2803; K.S.A. 1987
Supp. 21-4302; 21-4303; K.S.A. 1987 Supp. 74-8704;
Kan. Const., Bill of Rights, §2, Kan.
Const., Art. 15, §3c.
Dear Director Montgomery:
You request our opinion regarding a co-promotional agreement
into which the Kansas Lottery is considering entering with a
private business. The name and logo of the private business
would appear on a coupon stub attached to instant Lottery
tickets. You explain that each coupon will entitle the ticket
purchaser to either a free food product normally sold by the
business, or to a discount on such food products upon
redemption at the business. Specifically, your questions are:
"1. Since it appears that coupons such as
those described are governed by the
Trading Stamp Act, would they fall within
the exemptions presented in K.S.A. 21-2803?
"2. Is there any legal impediment or
prohibition which would preclude a
co-promotional agreement with a private
business in which the name and logo of the
business would appear on a Lottery ticket
sold and advertised by a State agency?
"3. Is it legally permissible, in the
co-promotion described in which every
ticket contains a tear-off coupon
providing either a free food product or a
discount on another product, to state that
there is a 'prize' -- or words of similar
import -- with each ticket purchase?"
We will address your questions in the order in which they were
asked.
The trading stamp act, K.S.A. 21-2801 et seq., prohibits
the distribution of stamps or coupons, in connection with the
sale of goods, which are redeemable for anything of value.
Clearly, assuming the Kansas Lottery is a "person, firm,
association or corporation" covered by the Act, a coupon
obtained through purchase of a lottery ticket which is
redeemable for a free food product or a discount on a food
product falls within the act's proscription. You question,
however, whether the distribution and redemption of these
coupons are excepted from the act pursuant to K.S.A. 21-2803
which provides:
"This act shall not apply to any coupon,
ticket, certificate, card or other similar
device which is issued, distributed,
furnished or redeemed:
"(a) By a manufacturer or packer, when
such coupon, ticket, certificate, card or
other similar device is redeemable:
"(1) Without or with accompanying cash,
for any product of the manufacturer or
packer or for one specified and particular
product not manufactured or packed by the
manufacturer or packer; or
"(2) by the manufacturer or packer in
cash.
"(b) By a retailer, when such coupon,
ticket, certificate, card or other similar
device is redeemable by the retailer, with
or without accompanying cash, for any
product which the retailer normally sells
in its usual course of business."
We believe the Kansas Lottery would fall within the exception
for manufacturers or packers, subsection (a), and the private
business in question would be excepted as a retailer under
subsection (b).
The Kansas Supreme Court has interpreted K.S.A. 21-2803(a) as
allowing "a manufacturer or packer in connection with his
manufactured or packed product [to] include in the package
certain stamps or other items which are redeemable."
Cushenbery v. Shanahan, 190 Kan. 720, 721 (1963). The
term "packer" is not defined in the trading stamp act. Under
the rules of statutory construction, words used in statutes
must be attributed with their common, ordinary meanings unless
the context clearly requires otherwise. J.A. Tobin
Const. Co., Inc. v. Kemp, 239 Kan. 430 (1986). This is
particularly true of penal statutes, such as K.S.A. 21-2801,
which must be strictly construed against the State. State ex
rel. Stephan v. Pepsi-Cola General Bottlers, Inc., 232
Kan. 843, 846, 847 (1983). "Packer" is defined generally as
"[o]ne who packs goods . . . for transportation and sale."
The American Heritage Dictionary 493 (2d College Edition
1983). The Kansas Lottery meets this definition as it
receives bulk shipments of lottery tickets manufactured
outside the State and, upon receiving orders from retailers,
packs the orders and distributes the tickets to the
retailers. Thus, coupons which are distributed by the Lottery
and redeemable with or without accompanying cash for one
specified and particular product not manufactured or packed by
the Lottery are excepted from the trading stamp act. However,
each coupon must be redeemable for only one product, i.e.
the same coupon cannot be redeemed for one of several
options. Pepsi-Cola General Bottlers, Inc., 232 Kan. at
847.
Similarly, the private business involved would meet the
exception stated in K.S.A. 21-2803(b). The coupons will be
redeemed by a retailer, with or without accompanying cash, for
products which the retailer normally sells in its usual course
of business.
You next ask whether there might be any other legal impediment
to this type of co-promotional agreement. We have narrowed
this broad question to two issues: 1) Whether a state agency
may promote a private industry in the course of advancing its
own interests; and 2) whether the proposed coupon "giveaway"
constitutes an illegal lottery.
K.S.A. 1987 Supp 74-8704 authorizes the Kansas Lottery to
"[e]nter into contracts for such promotional services . . .
as needed to operate the Kansas Lottery." You indicate that
the co-promotional agreement in question will greatly
benefit the Lottery. Every instant Lottery ticket sold will
be accompanied by a coupon redeemable for something of value,
either a free food item or a discount on a food item. The
Lottery is responsible for no costs associated with the
offering of these coupons beyond what it would expend to
operate the game without the coupons. In our opinion, if this
agreement will serve to promote the Lottery and thus further
the purpose of the Lottery Act, it is within the scope of the
Kansas Lottery's authority. This is true regardless of
whether the activity also promotes a private business. The
Kansas Lottery should take care, however, to not unfairly
advantage one private business over another. To avoid
conflict with the Kansas Constitution, Bill of Rights, §2
(Equal Protection and no special privileges) other businesses
should be given similar opportunities based on their ability
to help promote the Lottery.
Participating in a lottery is a class B misdemeanor. K.S.A.
21-4303. Participation in the state owned and operated
lottery is not included in this prohibition. K.S.A. 1987
Supp. 21-4302(2). The three essential elements which, when
combined, constitute a lottery are consideration, prize and
chance. State ex rel. v. Highwood Services, Inc., 205
Kan. 821, 823 (1970). Article 15, section 3c of the Kansas
Constitution authorizes a state owned and operated lottery.
While the Kansas Lottery will control the sale of tickets
which are to be accompanied by the private business' coupons,
we do not believe the entire operation is run by the State.
The private business will determine the types and quantities
of food items for which coupons may be redeemed and these food
items and their values will not be considered in the Lottery's
prize structure. Thus, in order to avoid being an illegal
lottery, one of the three elements listed above must be
eliminated. For instance, in addition to being able to obtain
a coupon by purchasing a Lottery ticket, the private business
may provide a toll-free number for persons to call to receive
free coupons for similar food items and discounts. The number
must be toll-free so that people do not have to pay to get a
coupon. This is so because consideration is defined as
"anything which is a commercial or financial advantage to the
promoter or a disadvantage to any participant." K.S.A. 1987
Supp. 21-4302(3). Alternatively, the element of chance could
be eliminated by making the "prize" offered known to the
participant before the ticket is purchased. In this way the
participant is no longer taking a chance on what the coupon
may be redeemable for; its exact value (amount and type of
item) is a known factor.
Finally, you question whether advertising "a prize with every
ticket purchased" would be considered deceptive. This
language imports that a Lottery prize will accompany every
ticket purchased, whereas in reality the "prize" will consist
of a coupon redeemable by a private business, with or without
accompanying cash, for one of its regularly sold food items.
Because the implication is misleading we believe that such
advertising would be deceptive and suggest that the Lottery
instead advertise that every ticket purchased will be
accompanied by a "bonus" offered by or through the private
business.
In conclusion, The described co-promotional agreement
between the Kansas Lottery and a private business 1) is
excepted from the trading stamp act; 2) is permissible as a
promotion which furthers the purpose of the lottery act; 3) is
not an illegal lottery if one of the three elements of a
lottery (prize, consideration, chance) is eliminated from the
operation; and 4) may advertise that every ticket purchased
will be accompanied by a bonus which is redeemable through the
private business.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
Attorney General of Kansas
Julene L. Miller
Deputy Attorney General
RTS:JLM:jm

Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude

Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.