Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1988-117

1988-117Kanag

Texte intégral

I
t:
,¥
!1"·
,;
!,
STATE OF KANSAS
OFFICE OF THE ATTORNEY GENERAL
2ND FLOOR, KANSAS JUDICIAL CENTER, TOPEKA 66612
1sERT T. STEPHAN 	MAIN PHONE t913J 296'2215
CONSUMER PROTECTION 296·375 I	
• 	ATIO::SNEY GENERAL
~
~
August 	22, 	1988
t
~-
t·.',
ATTORNEY 	GENERAL 	OPINION 	NO. 	88- 	117
Lewis 	C. 	Carter, 	Clerk
Kansas 	Supreme 	Court
Kansas 	Judicial 	Center
Topeka, 	Kansas 	66612
Re: 	Laws, 	Journals 	and 	Public 	Information 	-- 	Records
Open 	to 	Public 	-- 	Documents 	Concerning 	Attorneys
who 	Fail 	to 	Timely 	Pay 	the 	Registration 	Fee
Synopsis: 	The 	letter 	of 	notice 	sent 	by 	the 	Clerk 	of 	the
Supreme 	Court 	to 	attorneys 	who 	fail 	to 	register 	and
J 	pay 	the 	fee 	for 	renewal 	of 	their 	license 	by 	July 	1
each 	year, 	and 	the 	return 	receipt 	are 	public
records 	as 	that 	term 	is 	defined 	by 	the 	Kansas 	open
records 	act 	(KORA), 	K.S.A. 	45-215 	et~-
These 	documents 	are 	subject 	to 	mandatory 	disclosure
as 	the 	letter 	constitutes 	correspondence 	intended
to 	give 	notice 	of 	an 	action 	relating 	to 	a
regulatory 	and 	enforcement 	responsibility 	of 	the
C1 erk ' s 	office . 	K . S . A . 	19 8 7 	Su pp • 	4 5 - 2 21 (a) (14 ) .
The 	list 	of 	attorneys 	certified 	by 	the 	clerk 	to 	the
Supreme 	Court 	who 	have 	failed 	to 	register 	and 	pay
the 	fee, 	and 	an 	order 	of 	the 	Supreme 	Court
suspending 	an 	attorney 	from 	the 	practice 	of 	law 	for
that 	reason 	are 	also 	public 	records 	which 	must 	be
disclosed 	to 	the 	public 	upon 	request. 	Cited
herein: 	K.S.A. 	45-215; 	45-216; 	45-217; 	K.S.A. 	1987
Supp. 	45-221.
* 	* 	*
i
t .•
'
"' :
Lewis 	C. 	Carter
Page 	2
Dear Mr. 	Carter: ,<
As 	Clerk 	of 	the 	Kansas 	Supreme 	Court, 	you 	ask 	our 	opinion
concerning 	the 	Kansas 	Open 	Records 	Act 	(KORA), 	K.S.A. 	45-215
et~· 	Your 	office 	is 	charged with 	the 	responsibility 	of
administering 	the 	Supreme 	Court 	Rules 	governing 	the
registration 	of 	attorneys 	in 	the 	State 	of 	Kansas. 	Supreme
Court 	Rule 	No. 	208(a) 	requires 	attorneys 	to 	annually 	"on 	or
before 	the 	first 	day 	of 	July, 	register 	with 	the 	Clerk 	of 	the
Appellate 	Courts 	upon 	such 	form 	as 	thi Clerk 	shall 	prescribe"
and 	to 	pay 	the 	annual 	registration 	fee. 	Paragraph 	(e)
provides 	as 	follows:
"The 	Clerk 	of 	the 	Appellate 	Courts 	shall
mail 	a 	notice 	to 	any 	attorney 	who 	has
failed 	to 	comply with 	subsection 	(a) 	that
his 	right 	to 	practice 	law 	will 	be
summarily 	suspended 	thirty 	days 	following
the 	mailing 	of 	notice 	if 	such 	registration
fee 	is 	not 	paid 	within 	that 	time. 	The
notice 	shall 	be 	forwarded 	to 	his 	last
known 	address 	by 	certified 	mail, 	return
receipt 	requested. 	The 	Clerk 	shall
certify 	to 	the 	Supreme 	Court 	the 	names 	of
attorneys 	who 	fail 	to 	register 	and 	pay
said 	fee 	within 	said 	period 	of 	time.
Thereupon, 	the 	Court 	shall 	issue 	an 	order
suspending 	said 	attorneys 	from 	practice 	of
law 	in 	this 	state 	and 	the 	Clerk 	shall 	mail
a 	copy 	of 	the 	order 	to 	the 	administrative
judge 	of 	the 	attorney's 	district." 	235
Kan. 	CXXVII.
You 	ask 	whether 	your 	office 	must, 	pursuant 	to 	the 	KORA,
disclose 	upon 	request 	copies 	of 	the 	registered 	letters 	giving
notice 	to 	attorneys 	that 	their 	annual 	registration 	and 	fee 	are
overdue, 	the 	return 	receipt 	to 	the 	clerk's 	office, 	and 	the
certified 	list 	of 	attorneys 	who 	failed 	to 	register 	and 	pay
their 	annual 	license 	fee 	within 	the 	allotted 	time 	period.
The 	KORA 	provides 	that 	public 	records 	of 	public 	agencies
must 	"be 	open 	for 	inspection 	by 	any 	person .•.. " 	K.S.A.
45-216(a). 	The 	office 	of 	Clerk 	of 	the 	Appellate 	Courts 	is 	a
public 	agency 	as 	it meets 	the 	definition 	stated 	in 	K.S.A.
45-217 (e) (1):
Lewis 	C. 	Carter
Page 	3
"'Public 	agency' 	means 	the 	state 	or 	any
political 	or 	taxing 	subdivision 	of 	the
state, 	or 	any 	office, 	officer, 	agency 	or
instrumentality 	thereof, 	or 	any 	other
entity 	receiving 	or 	expending 	and
supported 	in whole 	or 	in 	part 	by 	public
funds 	appropriated 	by 	the 	state 	or 	by
public 	funds 	of 	any 	political 	or 	taxing
subdivision 	of 	the 	state."
A "public 	record" 	is 	"any 	recorded 	information, 	regardless 	of
form 	or 	characteristics, 	which 	is 	made, 	maintained 	or 	kept 	by
or 	is 	in 	the 	possession 	of 	any 	public 	agency." 	K.S.A.
45-217(f) (1). 	Thus, 	the 	notice, 	return 	receipt, 	and certified
list 	are 	public 	records. 	Not 	all 	public 	records, 	however, 	are
required 	to 	be 	open 	for 	public 	inspection. 	K.S.A. 	1987
Supp. 	45-22l(a) (1) 	provides 	that 	records, 	the 	disclosure 	of
which 	is 	prohibited 	or 	restricted 	by 	law, 	are 	not 	subject 	to
disclosure 	under 	the 	KORA. 	In 	addition, 	K.S.A. 	1987 	Supp.
45-22l(a) (2)-(36) 	lists 	records 	which 	a 	public 	agency 	has
discretion 	to 	keep 	confidential.
We 	are 	not 	aware 	of 	any 	state 	or 	federal 	law 	or 	Supreme 	Court
Rule 	which 	prohibits 	disclosure 	of 	the 	documents 	in 	question.
However, 	one 	of 	the 	exceptions 	to 	mandatory 	disclosure 	states:
"Correspondence 	between 	a 	public 	agency
and 	a 	private 	individual, 	other 	than
correspondence 	which 	is 	intended 	to 	give
notice 	of 	an 	action, 	policy 	or
determination 	relating 	to 	any 	regulatory,
supervisory 	or 	enforcement 	responsibility
of 	the 	public 	agency 	or 	which 	is 	widely
distributed 	to 	the 	public 	by 	a 	public
agency 	and 	is 	not 	specifically 	in 	response
to 	communications 	from 	such 	a 	private
individual." 	K.S.A. 	1987 	Supp.
45-221 (a) (14).
The 	notice 	sent 	to 	attorneys 	who 	failed 	to 	renew 	by 	July 	1 	is
"correspondence 	between 	a 	public 	agency 	and 	a 	private
individual." 	The 	letter 	from 	your 	office 	provides 	in 	part:
"With 	the 	above 	in 	mind 	and 	in 	compliance
with 	Supreme 	Court 	Rule 	208 	you 	are 	hereby
notified 	that 	if 	payment 	is 	not 	received
within 	thirty 	(30) 	days 	following 	the
mailing 	of 	this 	letter 	your 	right 	to
Lewis 	C. 	Carter
Page 	4
practice 	law 	in 	the 	State 	of 	Kansas 	will
be 	summarily 	suspended." 	(Letter
attached).
Attorneys 	who 	are 	delinquent 	in 	their 	renewal 	of 	license 	are
still 	licensed 	to 	practice 	law 	in 	Kansas. 	An 	attorney 	is 	not
suspended 	from 	practicing 	law 	for 	failure 	to 	renew 	her 	license
until 	an 	order 	of 	suspension 	is 	issued 	by 	the 	Supreme 	Court.
However, 	we 	must 	conclude 	that 	the 	letter 	of 	delinquency
constitutes 	"notice 	of 	action, 	policy 	or 	determination
relating 	to 	any 	regulatory 	••• 	or 	enforcement 	responsibility
of 	the 	public 	agency," 	as 	it 	gives 	notice 	of 	a 	summary
proceeding 	if 	the 	attorney 	does 	not 	effect 	renewal.
Therefore, 	the 	letter 	to 	the 	attorney, 	the 	return 	receipt, 	and
the 	Supreme 	Court's 	order 	suspending 	an 	attorney 	for 	failure
to 	renew 	her 	license 	are 	public 	records 	subject 	to 	mandatory
disclosure.
You 	also 	ask 	whether 	the 	list 	you 	compile 	and 	certify 	to 	the
Supreme 	Court 	of 	attorneys 	who 	have 	failed 	to 	register 	and 	pay
the 	renewal 	fee 	must 	be 	open 	to 	the 	public. 	In 	our 	opinion,
this 	list must 	be 	disclosed 	upon 	request 	as 	it 	is 	a 	public
record. 	We 	are 	not 	aware 	of 	any 	law which 	closes 	this
document, 	and 	none 	of 	the 	exceptions 	in 	K.S.A. 	1987 	Supp.
45-22l(a) (2)-(36) 	appear 	to 	apply.
Very 	truly 	yours,
~FROBERT 	T. 	STEPHAN
ATTORNEY 	GENERAL 	OF 	KANSAS
('y 	-~ 	' '""' 	' '	- 	,~~~'--'<.....~ • ·, ~_\('\...
Rita 	L. 	Noll
Assistant 	Attorney 	General
RTS:JLM:RLN:bas

Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude

Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.