Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1988-088

1988-088Kanag

Texte intégral

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL July 1, 1988
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 88- 88
Stanley C. Grant, Ph.D.
Secretary
Kansas Department of Health and Environment
Forbes Field
Topeka, Kansas 66620-0001
Re: Laws, Journals and Public Information--Records Open
to Public; Certain Records Not Required to be Open;
Laboratory Records
Synopsis: Several exceptions to the open records act permit
the secretary of Kansas Department of Health and
Environment, in his discretion, to refuse
disclosure of records maintained by that agency
when those records are generated from laboratory
tests concerning sexually transmitted diseases.
Disclosure of those records may be obtained by
consent of the individual whose name appears on the
record. The secretary may not disclose records
pertaining to prenatal syphilis tests without
consent of the woman. Cited herein: K.S.A.
45-216, 45-217, 45-218; K.S.A. 1987 Supp.
45-221(a)(1)-(3), (30),(d); K.S.A. 60-427, 60-437,
65-118, 65-119, 65-127, 65-153f, 65-153g, 75-5608;
K.S.A. 1987 Supp. 77-201 Thirteenth; K.A.R.
28-1-2; 5 U.S.C. §§552, 552a (1984).
* *
Dear Secretary Grant:
As secretary of the Kansas Department of Health and
Environment (KDHE), you have requested our opinion
concerning certain records maintained by KDHE.
Specifically, you inquiry whether laboratory records
maintained by the agency must be released to the Department of
Social and Rehabilitation Services (SRS) upon request.
You advise that, pursuant to K.S.A. 65-153f and K.S.A.
75-5608, KDHE performs laboratory tests concerning sexually
transmitted diseases. The tests are performed at the request
of certain physicians at no cost. SRS has requested access
to records pertaining to these tests in their investigation of
fraudulent claims for reimbursement by the physicians. KDHE
maintains that the records are confidential pursuant to K.S.A.
65-118.
Initially, KDHE is a public agency within the meaning of
K.S.A. 45-217(e), and laboratory records are public records
within the meaning under K.S.A. 45-217(f). Your inquiry is
therefor subject to analysis of the Kansas open records act
(KORA), K.S.A. 45-215 et e2a . Both the spirit and
letter of the act require that records maintained by a public
agency be accessible to any person except as otherwise
provided by the act. K.S.A. 45-216(a); K.S.A. 45-218(a). We
believe that SRS is a person within the meaning of KORA.
K.S.A. 1987 Supp. 77-201 Thirteenth. Unless another law
requires disclosure, public agencies are not required to
disclose records listed in K.S.A. 1987 Supp. 45-221(a). Four
such exceptions appear relevant to your inquiry.
The first relevant exception to the requirement of disclosure
appears in K.S.A. 1987 Supp. 45-221(a)(1). That paragraph
excludes records the disclosure of which is prohibited by
federal or state law. While we do not intend an exhaustive
discussion of the requirements of federal law relative to
disclosure, we do note that KDHE is not subject to the
mandates of the Privacy Act, 5 U.S.C. §552a (1984), which may
prohibit disclosure of the records in question without consent
of the individual. See Forsham v. Harris, 445 U.S. 169,
63 L.Ed.2d 293 (1980); United States v. Orleans, 425 U.S.
807, 48 L.Ed.2d 390 (1976); UNT v. Aerospace Corp., 765
F.2d 1440 (9th Cir. 1985); St. Michael's Convalescent
Hospital v. California, 643 F.2d 1369 (9th Cir. 1981).
Regarding state law, laboratory records pertaining to the
prenatal syphilis tests are confidential within the
limitations of K.S.A. 65-153f and K.S.A. 65-153g. However,
these sections apply only to records regarding tests conducted
under that section. You have indicated that the laboratory
records in question relate to this and other diseases.
Separate authority is required to conclude that records of
laboratory tests for diseases other than prenatal syphilis
must be kept confidential. You have cited K.S.A. 65-118 as
such authority. That section mandates that certain persons
report to the appropriate county or joint board of health, or
local health officer, information indicating that a person is
suspected of suffering from or has died from a contagious or
infectious disease. K.S.A. 65-118(a). Infectious or
contagious diseases are designated at K.A.R. 28-1-2.
Information thus communicated must be forwarded to KDHE.
K.S.A. 65-119(a). Both sections make provisions for
confidentiality of the information reported. K.S.A.
65-118(c); K.S.A. 65-119(b). Violation of those sections is
an unclassified misdemeanor. K.S.A. 65-127. We do not
believe that these sections prevent disclosure of laboratory
reports maintained by KDHE for tests performed in the
situation you have described. The statutes relate to the
reporting of information for the general health and welfare of
the public. The requirements of confidentiality strike a
balance between the duty of the practitioner to the patient
and to the public. The laboratory tests as you have
described, however, are not involved with the reporting
requirements. Rather, the tests are conducted as a
proprietary function of the department, and may or may not
produce information that a person is suffering from or has
died from an infectious contagious disease. In summary,
K.S.A. 1987 Supp. 45-221(a)(1) only authorizes an agency to
refuse disclosure of prenatal syphilis tests.
The second relevant exception to the mandatory disclosure
requirement appears in K.S.A. 1987 Supp. 45-221(a)(2). That
paragraph excludes records which are privileged under the
rules of evidence. One such privilege is the
physician-patient privilege as provided in K.S.A. 60-427. The
physician-patient privilege is an exclusionary rule of
evidence to prevent disclosure of confidential communications,
and may be invoked in civil actions and misdemeanor criminal
cases, subject to statutory exceptions. Attorney General
Opinion No. 87-139. The purpose of the privilege is "to
encourage persons needing medical treatment to seek it."
State v. George, 223 Kan. 507, 510 (1978). The language
of the evidentiary rule indicates that the privilege also
prevents disclosure of information by agents of the
physician. See, e.g., K.S.A. 60-427(a)(4), (g). The
privilege is terminated if the holder of the privilege is
waived. K.S.A. 60-437.
Whether or not this privilege is abrogated by federal or state
law is undecided in this state. In Matter of Camperlingo
v. Blum, 56 N.Y.2d 251 (1982), the court held that
application of a balancing test indicated an intent by the
state and federal legislatures to abrogate the privilege.
That determination was made in light of a state regulation
made pursuant to federal law which required, by agreement,
maintenance of records by service providers and access to
those records by appropriate state agencies. We have located
no similar agreement or regulation applicable in this state.
It would therefor appear that, absent an agreement or
legislative mandate, the privilege would protect patient
records unless the patient consented to release of such
records.
The third relevant exception to the KORA mandating
disclosure of public records appears at K.S.A. 1987 Supp.
45-221(a)(3), which pertains to medical records of
identifiable patients. This exception is clearly intended to
protect the identity of individuals who may wish to keep their
personal medical affairs private. As the exceptions in K.S.A.
1987 Supp. 45-221(a) are discretionary, it would appear that
the secretary of KDHE may, in his discretion, refuse to
disclose the materials contained in the records. In
exercising discretion, the secretary may consider a waiver or
release by the individual whose name appears on the record.
The fourth relevant exception to the mandatory disclosure
requirement appears at K.S.A. 1987 Supp. 45-221(a)(30), which
pertains to records "containing information of a personal
nature where the public disclosure thereof would constitute a
clearly unwarranted invasion of personal privacy." The
records in question may easily fall into this category.
Similar language of the Freedom of Information Act, 5 U.S.C.
§552(b)(6) (1984) was construed in Rural Housing Alliance v.
United States Department of Agriculture, 498 F.2d 73 (D.C.
Cir. 1974), in which the court held that an individual's
right of privacy should be balanced against the public's right
to government information. Regarding the laboratory test
records maintained by KDHE, it would appear that such a
balance would tip strongly in favor of the individual.
Disclosure of the records would place in the public light the
fact that the named individual receives public assistance and
was tested for a variety of sexually transmitted diseases.
While the individual's name may be deleted pursuant to K.S.A.
1987 Supp. 45-221(d), such would render the record useless for
the purpose requested by SRS. As with previous exceptions,
it would appear that no unwarranted invasion of privacy would
result if the individual consented to disclosure of the record.
In conclusion, it is our opinion that several exceptions to
the open records act allow the secretary of KDHE, in his
discretion, to refuse disclosure of records maintained by that
agency when those records are generated from laboratory tests
concerning sexually transmitted diseases. Disclosure of those
records may be obtained by consent of the individual whose
name appears on the record. The secretary may not disclose
records pertaining to prenatal syphilis tests without written
consent of the woman.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
Attorney General of Kansas
Mark W. Stafford
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:JLM:MWS:jm

Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude

Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.