Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1988-062

1988-062Kanag

Texte intégral

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL May 4, 1988
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 88- 62
The Honorable Henry Helgerson
State Representative, Eighty-Sixth District
State Capitol, Room 273-W
Topeka, Kansas 66612
Re: State Departments; Public Officers and Employees --
Kansas Tort Claims Act -- Liability of Governmental
Entities for Damages
Synopsis: When the state operates an information network, it
may be subject to liability for damages if
liability would exist were the network operated by
an individual. To state a cause of action for
negligence, an injured party must show a duty, a
breach of that duty, and damages which were caused
by the breach of duty. The state, in operating an
information network, may be gratuitously rendering
services which are recognized as necessary for the
individual's protection, thus giving rise to a
duty. If negligence is established, the state may
avail itself of exceptions from liability found in
the tort claims act. Cited herein: K.S.A.
75-6101; 75-6103(a); K.S.A. 1987 Supp. 75-6104.
Dear Representative Helgerson:
As Representative for the Eighty-Sixth District, you request
our opinion regarding state liability in providing information
to disabled individuals and their families concerning certain
services available to them. Your inquiry arises in deciding
whether, in operating an information network, the Kansas
Department of Health and Environment (KDHE) should provide
information only on service providers that are licensed or
certified by the state, or whether the information network
should provide information on all service providers with a
blanket disclaimer about the quality of the services.
Regarding the possibility of state liability for distributing
information about available disability services, we direct
your attention to the Kansas tort claims act, K.S.A. 75-6101
et seq. This act makes liability the rule, subject to
several exceptions, for governmental entities and their
employees when the employees are "acting within the scope of
their employment under circumstances where the governmental
entity, if a private person, would be liable under the laws of
the state." K.S.A. 75-6103(a).
The Kansas Supreme Court stated the elements of negligence in
Kansas in an advisory opinion to the 10th Circuit:
"Negligence exists where there is a duty
owed by one person to another and a breach
of that duty occurs, and, if recovery is to
be had for such negligence, the injured
party must show a causal connection between
the duty breached and the injury received,
and that he or she was damaged by the
negligence." Durflinger v. Artiles,
234 Kan. 484, answer to certified question
conformed to 727 F.2d 888 (1983).
In short, negligence does not exist if there is no duty owed
to the victim. Finkbiner v. Clay County, 238 Kan. 856,
862 (1986).
One means of establishing the existence of a duty and a breach
of that duty is discussed in the Restatement (Second) of Torts
§ 324A (1965), which states:
"One who undertakes, gratuitously or for
consideration, to render services to
another which he should recognize as
necessary for the protection of a third
person or his things, is subject to
liability to the third person for physical
harm resulting from his failure to
exercise reasonable care to protect his
undertaking, if
"(a) his failure to exercise reasonable
care increases the risk of such harm, or
• • •
"(c) the harm is suffered because of
reliance of the other or the third person
upon the undertaking."
Section 324A was adopted in Kansas in Schmeck v. City of
Shawnee, 232 Kan. 11, 24 (1982).
By attempting to provide information about services to
families and disabled persons, it is at least arguable that
the state is undertaking to render services to another which
should be recognized as necessary for the protection of a
third person, thus establishing a duty.
The second prong in establishing liability in negligence is
whether there is a failure to exercise reasonable care in
providing the service, and whether such failure increases the
risk of harm. Therefore, if the network provides information
which is, or should be known by the state to put the party in
danger, then the state may be liable for damages caused by the
service provider. It would appear that reasonable inquiry
regarding the service provider prior to including the provider
on the list would increase an injured party's burden of
establishing liability. Notwithstanding that reasonable care
is exercised in providing the service, liability may exist if
the injured party relied on the network's undertaking. To
establish such a claim, the victim would be required to show
that the information provided by the network was coupled with
a statement, either expressed or implied, regarding the value
of the services. A disclaimer of liability based on such a
statement would not be valid if found to be unconscionable.
While unconscionability is a factual question, we believe
that, based on Wille v. Southwestern Bell Tel. Co., 219
Kan. 755 (1976), a disclaimer would not be unconscionable if
it gives notice that the information network is not attended
with a statement upon which the other party may rely.
If liability is established, the state may avail itself to any
one of a number of exceptions to liability found in K.S.A.
1987 Supp. 75-6104. The applicability of an exception must
be resolved in a case-by-case determination of particular
circumstances surrounding the claim.
In conclusion, it is our opinion when the state operates an
information network, it may be subject to liability for
damages if liability would exist were the network operated by
an individual. To state a cause of action for negligence, an
injured party must show duty, a breach of that duty, and
damages which were caused by the breach of duty. By operating
an information network, the state may be gratuitously
rendering services which are recognized as necessary for the
individual's protection, thus giving rise to a duty. If
negligence is established, the state may avail itself of
exceptions from liability found in the tort claims act.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF KANSAS
Mark W. Stafford
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:JLM:MWS:bas

Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude

Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.