Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1988-049

1988-049Kanag

Texte intégral

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTO RN EY GENERAL April 5, 1988
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 88- 4 9
The Honorable Bruce F. Larkin
State Representative, Sixty-Second District
State Capitol, Room 273-W
Topeka, Kansas 66612
Re: State Boards, Commissions and Authorities -- State
Board of Agriculture; Election and Duties of Board
-- Position on Legislative Issues; Selection of
Members
Synopsis: The Kansas state board of agriculture may take a
position on matters of public policy involving
agricultural issues. The method of selecting
members to the board as provided in K.S.A. 1987
Supp. 74-502 and 74-503 does not contravene the
constitutional equal protection rights of Kansas
residents. Cited herein: K.S.A. 46-221; 46-222;
K.S.A. 1987 Supp. 74-502; 74-503; K.S.A. 74-504;
74-504a; 74-504b; 74-530; U.S. Const. Amend. 24;
Kan. Const. Bill of Rights § 7.
*
Dear Representative Larkin:
As State Representative for the Twenty-Second District, you
ask our opinion on two matters concerning the Kansas state
board of agriculture (board).
Your first question is whether the board may take a position
supporting or opposing public policy issues. The board of
agriculture is a state agency created pursuant to a
legislative act, K.S.A. 74-502 et seq. The Kansas
statutes concerning state governmental ethics exempt from the
definition of "lobbyist" "any state officer or employee
engaged in carrying out the duties of his or her
office. . . ." K.S.A. 46-222(b)(1). The secretary of the
board of agriculture and board members are "state officers or
employees" as that term is defined in K.S.A. 46-221.
It is the duty of the board to publish an annual report on
"the condition of agriculture throughout the state." Each
legislator is to receive a copy of this report. K.S.A.
74-504. In addition, the board may gather other information
that "may be of value in promoting the agricultural industry
of the state." K.S.A. 74-504. The board is authorized to
provide statistical services "[t]o meet the needs and
increasing demands for factual data in agricultural and
marketing research. . . ." K.S.A. 74-504a. K.S.A. 74-504b
grants the board authority to obtain certain information and
"such other data as may be of service in the upbuilding and
prosperity of the state's agriculture. . . ." It is the duty
of the division of markets within the board of agriculture "to
perform acts and to do, or cause to be done, those things
which are designed to lead to the more advantageous marketing
of agricultural products of Kansas." K.S.A. 74-530. House
Bill No. 2517, signed by the governor on March 22, 1988,
broadens the powers under K.S.A. 74-530 to achieve this
purpose.
Clearly, the purpose of the board of agriculture is to provide
information about the current condition of agriculture in
Kansas and to promote the state's most important industry. To
conclude that the board could not speak out on the issues of
the day would contradict this purpose. Therefore, it is our
opinion that the board of agriculture may take a position on
matters of public policy that involve agricultural issues. As
this is an official function of the board, the provision of
the state governmental ethics act pertaining to lobbying do
not apply.
Your second question concerns the method of selecting members
of the board. The board is composed of two members from each
of the six agricultural districts. K.S.A. 1987 Supp.
74-503. At the annual meeting, board members are elected by
delegates chosen by farm organizations across the state.
K.S.A. 1987 Supp. 74-502 describes the selection of
delegates:
"(a) The farm organizations specified in
this subsection, whether now organized or
hereafter to be organized under the laws
of Kansas, shall be allowed to select
delegates for attendance at the annual
meeting of the state board of
agriculture. The delegates shall be
selected in accordance with the following:
(1) One from each county or district
agricultural society composed of one or
more counties;
(2) one from each state fair or statewide
fair;
(3) one from each county farmers'
institute;
(4) one from each county farm bureau
association with a voting membership of
not less than 100;
(5) one from each county farmers' union
with a voting membership of not less than
100;
(6) one from each county grange with a
voting membership of not less than 100;
(7) one from each of the eight Kansas
co-op council districts with member
co-ops composed of producer membership
of not less than 100;
(8) one member of the Kansas livestock
association from each county in which the
Kansas livestock association has a voting
membership of not less than 100;
(9) one from each county national
farmers' organization with a voting
membership of not less than 100;
(10) one from each county Kansas
association of wheat growers organization
with a voting membership of not less than
100;
(11) one from each association of state-
wide character representing a particular
kind or a particular breed of livestock;
(12) one from each association of a
statewide character for promotion of a
farm crop or crops; and
(13) one from each nonprofit association,
with a voting membership of not less than
100, of statewide character for the
promotion or representation of a specific
industry in agribusiness. . . .
"(b) In addition to the delegates
provided for in subsection (a) of this
section, one individual from each of the
counties may attend the annual meeting of
the state board of agriculture as a
delegate, if a petition is signed by not
less than 100 qualified electors of the
county who are agricultural producers or
landowners and who are not voting members
of the farm bureau association, farmers'
union, grange, national farmers'
organization, Kansas association of wheat
growers or Kansas livestock association or
who are voting members of any such farm
organization which has a voting membership
of less than 100."
The statute also requires each delegate to be "directly
involved in the industry of agribusiness represented."
You are concerned about the legality of the requirement that a
person be a member of a certain organization in order to
participate in the delegate selection process. Specifically,
you question whether mandatory membership in an organization
which collects dues is an "indirect poll tax" violative of the
Kansas Constitution. Before addressing this issue, we must
point out that K.S.A. 1987 Supp. 74-502(b) provides a means
by which a person may be a delegate from his or her county
without being a member of a farm organization.
A "poll tax" is a fee which must be paid before an elector may
exercise his or her right to vote. The Twenty-Fourth
Amendment to the United States Constitution provides that an
individual cannot be denied the right to vote in a federal
election for failure to pay a poll tax. Section 7 of the Bill
of Rights to the Kansas Constitution states that "[n]o . . .
property qualification shall be required . . . for any vote at
any election. . . ." Further, the United States Supreme Court
in Harper v. Virginia State Board of Elections, 383 U.S.
663, 666, 86 S.Ct. 1079, 1081, 16 L. Ed. 2d 169 (1966), held
that state imposition of a poll tax violates the Equal
Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment to the United
States Constitution. The basis of the court's decision was
that the right to vote is a fundamental right and that wealth
has no relation to voter qualifications. Id.
We were asked in Attorney General Opinion No. 79-243 whether
the method of selecting board members meets the constitutional
mandates of the judicial doctrine of "one person, one vote"
derived from the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth
Amendment. We concluded that "the equal protection of Kansas
residents is not denied by the membership selection process of
an administrative body having the limited powers of the
Kansas state Agricultural Board."
In our prior opinion concerning the selection of board
members, we examined the powers and duties of the board of
agriculture. In noting that the Kansas courts have not
applied the suffrage mandates of the equal protection doctrine
to statutorily created bodies such as the board, we stated:
"Courts of other jurisdictions have had
occasion to address the subject with
regard to administrative or legislative
bodies akin to the Board herein, and such
federal and state courts have consistently
considered the nature of the powers of
the body in question . . . as the
determinative factor in applying or
refusing to apply the suffrage mandates of
the equal protection clause." Attorney
General Opinion No. 79-243, p. 4 (emphasis
added).
Analysis of various cases from federal and state courts
revealed that the equal protection doctrine is applied to
entities which exercise general governmental powers. Since
the board "is a mere agent for the state legislature in the
area of state agricultural matters" and "is merely a creation
of a body politic (the state legislature) and derives its
powers only from this source," we concluded that the method of
selecting board members did not violate the "one person, one
vote" doctrine of the Equal Protection Clause.
In the present case the question is whether the equal
protection of Kansas citizens is violated on the basis that
dues which may be required to be a member of the organizations
involved in the delegate selection process constitute an
indirect poll tax. We believe our analysis in Attorney
General Opinion No. 79-243 is applicable to this situation.
The board of agriculture, created by legislative act, is an
administrative agency. Unlike the state legislature, city
councils, or county commissions, the board is not a
representative body with general governmental powers.
Delegates and board members are not chosen to represent the
citizenry of Kansas. Instead, they are selected from groups
of people who are most affected by this administrative
agency. Therefore, we must conclude that the selection of
delegates from organizations which may charge dues does not
violate the equal protection of Kansas citizens.
In summary, the board of agriculture may take a position on
matters of public policy involving agricultural issues. The
method of selecting members to the board as provided in K.S.A.
1987 Supp. 74-502 and 74-503 does not violate the Equal
Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment to the United
States Constitution.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF KANSAS
Rita L. Noll
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:JLM:RLN:bas

Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude

Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.