Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1987-188

1987-188Kanag

Texte intégral

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL December 29, 1987
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 87-188
Mr. Jim Pringle
Cowley County Attorney
311 S. Summit
Arkansas City, KS 67005
Re: State Departments; Public Officers and Employees --
Public Officers and Employees -- Open Public
Meetings; Bodies Subject Thereto; Cowley County
Developmental Services; Project Independence
Synopsis: A private, nonprofit corporation is subject to the
Kansas Open Meetings Act if it receives public
funds in its operations and acts as a governmental
agency in providing services to the public. As
Cowley County Developmental Services and Project
Independence meet both requirements, it is our
opinion that the boards of directors of these
organizations are subject to the Act. Cited
herein: K.S.A. 75-4317; 75-4317a; K.S.A. 1986
Supp. 75-4318.
* *
Dear Mr. Pringle:
As Cowley County Attorney, you have requested our opinion
concerning the applicability of the Kansas Open Meetings Act
(KOMA), K.S.A. 75-4317 et seq., to the board of
directors of Project Independence, a private, nonprofit
corporation managed by Cowley County Developmental Services
(CCDS).
In your letter of inquiry you have provided background
information concerning CCDS and Project Independence. - We
understand that CCDS is a community-based agency licensed by
the Department of Social and Rehabilitation Services (SRS)
to serve mentally handicapped adults. You inform us that
CCDS received and spent approximately $1 million in 1986.
Of that, 72.1 percent of the funds were received from
government sources. Government funding, including a
county-wide mill levy and SRS grants, is expected to provide
more than 50 percent of the agency's revenue this year.
Organized ten years ago by the Cowley County Board of
Commissioners, CCDS is governed by a nine-member board of
directors. Before March 1987, board members were appointed by
the county commissioners. As a result of a new contract with
the county commission, board members are now selected and
appointed by existing board members.
Among the services CCDS provides is residential housing
through group homes. These homes include an older home rented
by CCDS and five homes constructed in 1981 with federal
Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) funds.
HUD insures the mortgage on the property and subsidizes the
rent. These federally financed homes are owned and
administered by Project Independence. A three-member board
governs this private, nonprofit corporation. Vacancies on the
board are filled by existing board members.
We understand from your letter that in 1981 CCDS took over
the operation and management of Project Independence and
continues to receive a monthly management fee from Project
Independence. In January 1987, the CCDS board of directors
hired a manager for the project. CCDS and Project
Independence each pay half her salary. You also state that
CCDS hires, supervises and pays the group home supervisors.
In addition, the county commissioners recently approved the
use of mill levy funds by the CCDS board to improve and
expand its supervision of the homes.
We have been informed that, to be eligible for state funds,
SRS guidelines for the residential housing program must be
met. CCDS' license to run the homes and its budget are
subject to annual SRS approval. Reports concerning the
operation of the program are required to be submitted to SRS
at least annually for review.
You ask whether the board of directors of Project Independence
must comply with the KOMA. By its terms, the Act applies to
"all meetings for the conduct of the
affairs of, and the transaction of
business by, all legislative and
administrative bodies and agencies of the
state and political and taxing
subdivisions thereof, including boards,
commissions, authorities, councils,
committees, subcommittees and other
subordinate groups thereof, receiving or
expending and supported in whole or in
part by public funds. . . ." K.S.A. 1986
Supp. 75-4318(a).
The above language sets forth a two-part test which must be
met for a body to be included within the act's provisions:
(1) the body is a legislative or administrative agency of the
state or one of its political or taxing subdivisions, or is
subordinate to such a body; and (2) the body receives,
expends, or is supported in whole or in part by public funds,
or, in the case of subordinate groups, by a parent or
controlling body which is so supported. It is clear that the
second prong of this test is met as Project Independence
receives public funds, including federal monies from H.U.D.
and county tax revenues through CCDS, to run the homes.
Receipt of public funds will not subject an entity to the
provisions of the KOMA unless the first test is also met.
See Attorney General Opinions No. 82-256 (Kansas
Cosmosphere); 81-253 (planned parenthood); 81-94 (Hayden
high school); 79-221 (private nursing home). The more
difficult question is whether Project Independence is an
administrative agency of the state. The term "public agency"
is not defined in the Kansas open meetings law. However,
prior Kansas Attorney General opinions have identified four
criteria to be used in determining whether a body is a public
agency:
"1) If the agency has the authority to
make governmental decisions and act for
the state, it is covered by an open
meetings law. If it only collects
information, makes recommendations or
renders advice, it is not. McLarty v.
Board of Regents, 231 Ga. 22, 200
S.E.2d 117, 119 (1973).
2) Does the agency have independent
authority in the exercise of its
functions? Soucie v. David, 440 F.2d.
1067 (D.C. Cir. 1971).
3) Is the agency subject to governmental
audits or otherwise have its business
procedures supervised? Rocap v.
Indiek, 539 F. 2d 174, (D.C. Cir.
1976).
4) Finally, one court has defined
'governmental agency' to include corporate
instrumentalities that accomplish public
ends, both governmental and proprietary.
Ratan Public Service Co. v. Hobbes,
76 N.M. 535, 417 P. 2d 32 (1966)."
Attorney General Opinions No. 84-10 pp.
2-3'; 79-219 pp. 3, 4; 79-284 p. 3.
Examination of the above criteria in Attorney General Opinion
No. 79-219 led to our conclusion that area agencies on aging
which were private, nonprofit corporations not affiliated with
local governments were covered by the KOMA. We stated that,
while the state department provided funding and approved the
agencies' plans, the local agencies themselves had
considerable influence over the program. "In essence, the
area agencies do a great deal of the state department's work,
at least on a local level. This would seem to constitute
'governmental affairs' of the kind that the Act intended to be
open to public scrutiny. . . ." (p. 4).
In Attorney General Opinion No. 79-284, we were asked whether
the board of directors of McPherson County Diversified
Services, Inc., was subject to the KOMA. MCDS, a
nonprofit corporation which operated almost totally on moneys
derived from tax revenues, provided social services to the
developmentally disabled citizens of McPherson County. In
concluding that the entity was subject to the KOMA, we noted
that the board was required to report to the county commission
concerning the handling of its funds and the types of services
it provided. We also stated:
"MCDS provides programs which would
otherwise have to be offered by the state
or one of its political and taxing
subdivisions, if they were to be offered
at all. This would seem to constitute
"governmental affairs" of the kind which
the Act intended to be open to public
scrutiny, since the way in which such
tax-supported programs are run would be of-
keen interest to many citizens." Attorney
General Opinion No. 79-284, p.3.
We recently opined in Attorney General Opinion No. 87-143 that
Three Rivers, Inc., a private, nonprofit corporation, was
subject to the KOMA. Three Rivers operates the Three Rivers
Independent Living Resource Center, a rural center for
independent living for disabled persons. We stated:
"Three Rivers, Inc. meets the first test
as it operates as an administrative
agency. The Independent Living Resources
Center must meet state guidelines and be
approved by the state. The actual
operation of the Center, however, rests
with the Board of Directors. In providing
services for disabled persons, it appears
that Three Rivers is carrying on an
activity that would otherwise be handled
by a governmental subdivision." (p.4).
After examining the above-listed factors and our prior
opinions, we conclude that Project Independence meets the
first test as it operates as, and is managed by, an
administrative agency. CCDS is a public agency subject to
the KOMA as it meets both tests. First, it receives public
funds, including public funds in connection with the group
homes. Second, in providing services to the mentally
handicapped, including managing the group homes, CCDS is
carrying on an activity that would otherwise be handled by a
governmental subdivision. Project Independence, therefore,
also meets the second test as it is performing a governmental
function through its group homes. Project Independence
contracts with CCDS to manage these homes which must meet
state guidelines and be approved by the state. Since both
tests are met, it is our opinion that Project Independence
must comply with the provisions of the KOMA.
The facts in the present situation are different from those in
Memorial Hospital Ass'n, Inc. v. Knutson, 239 Kan. 663
(1986). In that case Memorial Hospital Association, a
nonprofit corporation, operated Memorial Hospital. The
hospital and surrounding property were owned by the county and
leased to the Association by the Board of Trustees of Memorial
Hospital. The Trustees, appointed by the county
commissioners, received the county mill levy funds designated
for hospital maintenance and capital improvements and
determined how the funds were to be spent for these- purposes.
239 Kan. 664-65. The Kansas Supreme Court ruled that, while
the Trustees were required to comply with the KOMA, the
Association was not subject to the act. The court noted that
a specific statute, K.S.A. 19-4611, allowed the Board of
Trustees to lease the county hospital property. The Court
also found that the Association was not controlled by, or
advisory to, the county commission or the Trustees. In
addition, the public funds received by the Association (which
amounted to about five percent of its gross revenues) were
spent for maintenance and capital improvements as determined
by the Trustees. 239 Kan. at 672. Therefore, the court
concluded:
"Where the board under 19-4611 leases the
hospital property to another, the lessee
is not subject to the open meetings
requirement of the KOMA if the lessee:
(1) has no governmental decision-making
authority to expend public funds, and (2)
is an independent entity which by contract
agrees to provide hospital services under
a lease of hospital property from a board
of trustees." 239 Kan. at 672.
The boards of directors of CCDS and Project Independence are
administrative agencies of the state as they perform
governmental functions and spend public funds. While Memorial
Hospital Association received only five percent of its
revenues from the mill levy, over 70% of CCDS' budget is
from public moneys. In Memorial Hospital Association the
public funds were used only for maintenance and capital
improvements. The decisions concerning these funds were made
by the Trustees, a public body subject to the KOMA. CCDS
and Project Independence, however, directly receive public
moneys to provide services for the mentally handicapped. In
making decisions concerning the use of such funds, they are
performing a governmental function.
The boards of CCDS and Project Independence are also
different from Memorial Hospital Association in that the court
found that the Association was an independent entity not
subject to any governmental control. In the present case the
residential housing project must meet SRS guidelines, SRS
must approve the budget, and program reports must be submitted
to the state. The facts concerning the boards of directors of
CCDS and Project Independence are distinguished from the
facts in the Memorial Hospital Association case. Clearly,
CCDS and Project Independence are administrative bodies
which receive and expend public funds.
In summary, a private, nonprofit corporation is subject to the
Kansas Open Meetings Act if it receives public funds in its
operations and acts as a governmental agency in providing
services to the public. As Cowley County Developmental
Services and Project Independence meet both requirements, it
is our opinion that the boards of directors of these
organizations are subject to the Act. Cited herein: K.S.A.
75-4317; 75-4317a; K.S.A. 1986 Supp. 75-4318.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF KANSAS
Rita L. Noll
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:JLM:RLN:bar

Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude

Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.