Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1987-138

1987-138Kanag

Texte intégral

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL September 18, 1987
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 87- 138
The Honorable Ed C. Redmon
State Fire Marshall
Landon State Office Bldg.
Suite 901
900 S.W. Jackson
Topeka, KS 66612
The Honorable Phil Kline
Representative, 19th District
7505 West 93rd Street
Overland Park, KS 66212-2243
Re: State Departments; Public Officers and Employees
--Private Investigative or Security Operations --
Arson Investigation by Licensed Engineers;
Testimony by Out-of-State Arson Investigators
Synopsis: 1) Engineers and private arson investigators
consulting in cases requiring the use of their
technical knowledge are exempt from K.S.A.
75-7b01(a).
2) Persons may testify as expert witnesses in
Kansas in matters in which they are qualified, even
though they may not be licensed within that
profession by the State of Kansas. Cited herein:
K.S.A. 60-456b; 75-7bOla; 75-7b02(a).
Dear Rep. Kline and Mr. Redmon:
Each of you have asked questions regarding the applicability
of the private investigator licensure act to expert witnesses
who testify in Kansas in certain instances. Mr. Redmon asks
whether an out-of-state arson investigator may lawfully
testify in Kansas as to the origin or cause of a fire without
being licensed as a private investigator. Representative
Kline asks whether engineers who testify as experts must be
licensed as private investigators. Since the same body of law
is implicated in the answers to both requests, we have decided
to answer in a single opinion.
K.S.A. 75-7b01(a) defines "detective business" as:
"the furnishing of, making of or agreeing
to make any investigation for the purpose
of obtaining information with reference
to: Crime or wrongs done or threatened
against the United States or any state or
territory of the United States; the
identity, habits, conduct, business,
occupation, honesty, integrity,
credibility, knowledge, trustworthiness,
efficiency, loyalty, activity, movement,
whereabouts, affiliations, associations,
transactions, acts, reputation or
character of any person; the location,
disposition or recovery of lost or stolen
property; the cause or responsibility for
fires, libels, losses, accidents or
damage or injury to persons or to
property; or securing evidence to be used
before any court, board, officer or
investigating committee." (Emphasis
added).
K.S.A. 75-7b02(a) prohibits persons from engaging in detective
business in this state unless such person is licensed as a
private detective.
The question you ask is one of first impression in Kansas,
however, the issue has been addressed elsewhere. In
Kennard v. Rosenberg, 127 Cal. App. 2d 340, 273 P.2d
839 (1954), the California appeals court ruled that the
investigative license requirement for two chemical engineers
and one private arson investigator hired to investigate a fire
was unnecessary. In Kennard, all three men were deemed to
be expert witnesses. However, their testimony was challenged
because they lacked the requisite private investigator
license. This license is required under the Cal. Bus. &
Prof. Code 752(a), "for persons obtaining information on the
cause or responsibility for fires . . . accidents or damage to
property, or securing evidence to be used before any court."
This language is identical to that contained in K.S.A.
75-7b01(a).
In deciding the licensure requirement for the three men was
unnecessary, the Kennard court stated:
"The uncontradicted evidence is that none
of the plaintiffs herein were engaged in
the private detective business or
represented themselves to be so engaged.
Plaintiffs Kennard and Drake were
licensed engineers and as such were
authorized to make investigations in
connection with that profession. Section
6701 Bus. & Prof. Code. It seems quite
clear that the private detective license
law was not intended by the legislature to
place a limitation on the right of
professional engineers to make chemical
tests, conduct experiments and to testify
in court as to the results thereof. A
physician, geologist, accountant,
engineer, surveyor or a handwriting
expert, undoubtedly, may lawfully testify
in court in connection with his findings
without first procuring a license as a
private detective, and, as in the instant
case, a photographer may be employed to
take photographs of damaged premises for
use in court without procuring such a
license. Likewise, plaintiff Wolfe, who
was hired as a consultant and expert and
not as a private detective and
investigator was not required to have a
license as such before being permitted to
testify in court as an expert."
In Benton v. Union Pacific Railroad Co., 430 F.Supp.
1380 (D. Kan. 1977), the United States District Court held
that:
"A Kansas Statute adopted from another
state carries with it the construction
placed upon it by the courts of that
state."
Although there is no finding that our Private Investigator
statutes were modeled after California's, the similarity in
language tends to bring the statutes under the purview of
Benton.
Further, in 26A C.J.S. Detectives §3 it is stated that a
"license law" need not apply to persons conducting tests, or
consulting in cases requiring the use of their technical
knowledge.
It is our opinion that, following the reasoning of Kennard
and Benton, Kansas would exempt engineers and private
arson investigators offering expert testimony in court from
K.S.A. 75-7bOla licensure requirements.
Kansas State Fire Marshall Ed C. Redmon also asks whether an
expert witness has to be licensed by Kansas in the field in
which he is testifying in order to qualify as an expert.
Presently there are no Kansas statutes that mandate a license
within a specialty field in order to be deemed an expert
witness. Specifically, K.S.A. 60-456(b) states that expert
witnesses are limited to, "facts or data perceived by or
personally known . . . to the witness, and within the scope of
the special knowledge, skill, experience . . . possessed by
the witness."
In Hayes v. United States, 367 F.2d 216, 222 (1966) the
Tenth Circuit held:
"It is well settled law that medical
experts may . . . testify in matters
concerning which they are qualified, even
though they may not be licensed to
practice medicine in the jurisdiction
involved." [32 C.J.S. Evidence §546
(92) pp. 336-346].
In Dickey v. Corr-A-Glass, 3 Kan. App. 2d 721
(1979), the Kansas Appeals Court reaffirmed stating:
"we hold that a witness may not be
disqualified from testifying as an expert
solely because he is not licensed in this
state."
Citing both Hayes and Dickey as precedent, it is our
opinion that a person deemed by the court to be testifying as
an expert need not be licensed within that profession by the
State of Kansas.
Accordingly, our responses to the specific questions which
have been posed are as follows:
1) Engineers and private investigators
are exempt from K.S.A. 75-7b01 et seq.,
private investigator licensure
requirements.
2) Expert witnesses may testify in Kansas
to matters in which they are qualified
without being licensed in that profession
by the State of Kansas.
Very truly yours,
ROBERTT.STEPHAN
Attorney General of Kansas
Brenda L. Braden
Deputy Attorney General
RTS:BLB:cy

Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude

Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.