Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1987-133

1987-133Kanag

Texte intégral

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL September 9, 1987
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 87-133
Philip C. Lacey
City Attorney
400 East Kansas Avenue
P.O. Box 1008
McPherson, Kansas 67460-1008
Re: Cities and Municipalities--Public Recreation and
Playgrounds--Recreation Commission; Certification
of Budget; Tax Levys
Synopsis: A joint (city-school district) district
recreation system established under the provisions
of L. 1987, ch. 71, §4(c) is a "new recreation
system" and is subject to a one mill levy
limitation (for general purposes) in its first year
of operation. (L. 1987, ch. 71, §§4, 6.) The
aforesaid levy limitation applies where a joint
district recreation system "replaces" a city
recreation commission which levied 3 mills under
K.S.A. 12-1901 et seq. Cited herein: K.S.A.
12-1901; L. 1987, ch. 71, §§4, 6.
Dear Mr. Lacey:
You request our interpretation of Chapter 71 of the 1987
Session Laws of Kansas. Specifically, you advise that the
city of McPherson has a city recreation commission which has
been operating at the 3 mill levy limitation prescribed by
K.S.A. 12-1901 et seq. You indicate that there has been
discussion of reorganizing the recreation commission under the
provisions of L. 1987, ch. 71, §4(c), so that the recreation
commission would be a joint recreation commission of the city
of McPherson and Unified School District No. 418. Your
question is whether the joint recreation commission would be
"a new recreation commission" as that term is used in section
6 of the act. Additionally, you ask whether the city and
school district could approve a budget in excess of one mill
for such a joint commission, if it constitutes a "new
recreation commission."
Chapter 71 of the 1987 Session Laws of Kansas recodifies
recreation commission statutes. Section 2 of the act provides
for the continuation of pre-existing recreation commissions:
"Any recreation system created under the
provisions of Article 19 of Chapter 12 of
the Kansas Statutes Annotated prior to the
effective date of this act shall continue
in existence but shall be operated under
the provisions of this act."
Section 6 of the act provides for certification of recreation
commission budgets to the city or school district "which shall
levy a tax sufficient to raise the amount required by such
budget," subject to the following proviso:
"The city or school district shall not be
required to levy a tax in excess of the
maximum tax levy set by the city or school
district by current resolution. In the
case of a new recreation commission
established under the provisions of this
act, such levy shall not be required to
exceed one mill. Whenever the recreation
commission determines that the tax
currently being levied for the commission,
as previously established by the city or
school district, is insufficient to
operate the recreation system and the
commission desires to increase the mill
levy above the current levy, the
commission shall request that the city or
school district authorize an increase by
adopting a resolution declaring it
necessary to increase the annual levy.
The city or school district may authorize
the increase by resolution, but such
increase shall not exceed one mill per
year. The maximum annual mill levy for
the recreation commission general fund
shall not exceed a total of four mills."
(Emphasis added.)
In our judgment, the term "new recreation commission," as used
in the above-quoted statutory excerpt, clearly refers to a
recreation commission established under the provisions of
chapter 71 of the 1987 Session Laws, as opposed to a
recreation commission which was in existence prior to July 1,
1987.
In regard to your second question, i.e. whether a city and
school district could approve a budget in excess of one mill
for a joint city-school district recreation commission
established under section 4(c) of the act, the aforesaid
section provides as follows:
"The governing body of any city and any
school district may initiate the
establishment of a joint recreation system
by adopting a joint ordinance or
resolution proposing to establish a joint
recreation system and to levy an annual
tax not to exceed one mill for such
recreation system and to pay a portion of
the principal and interest on bonds issued
pursuant to K.S.A. 12-1774, and amendments
thereto. The proposal shall be submitted
for approval by the voters of the city or
school district, which ever has the
greater assessed evaluation, at an
election called and held in the manner
provided by the general bond law, and the
cost of the election shall be borne
equally by the city and school district."
(Emphasis added.)
As the above-quoted statute indicates, the proposal which is
submitted to voters is to establish a joint recreation system
and "to levy an annual tax not to exceed one mill for such
recreation system." The initial one mill levy limitation
seems to be at variance with the language of section 6, which
provides that the levy for a new recreation commission "shall
not be required to exceed one mill." In resolving this
discrepancy, we are guided by the following rules of statutory
construction:
"When a statute is susceptible of more
than one construction it must be given
that construction which, when considered
in its entirety, gives expression to its
intent and purpose, even though such
construction is not within the strict
literal interpretation of the statute.
"In order to ascertain the legislative
intent courts are not permitted to
consider only a certain isolated part or
parts of an act but are required to
consider and construe together all parts
thereof in pari materia.
When the interpretation of some one
section of an act according to the exact
and literal import of its words would
contravene the manifest purpose of the
legislature, the entire act should be
construed according to its spirit and
reason, disregarding so far as may be
necessary the strict letter of the law."
Gnadt v. Durr, 208 Kan. 783
(1972), Syllabi 2-4.
Applying the above quoted rules of statutory construction, it
seems inconceivable that the legislature would provide for
submitting to voters a proposal "to levy an annual tax not to
exceed one mill" for a joint recreation system if such one
mill limitation were not to be effective for at least the
first year of operation of a joint recreation system.
Accordingly, even though section 6 of the act might seem to
suggest that a city or school district could levy more than
one mill for the initial year of operation of a new joint
recreation commission, we reject such interpretation. In our
opinion, such a new recreation commission is subject to a one
mill levy limitation in its first year of operation, and
thereafter such levy may be increased by not to exceed one
mill per year, up to a maximum levy of four mills.
In summary a joint (city-school district) district recreation
system established under the provisions of L. 1987, ch. 71,
§4(c) is a "new recreation system" and is subject to a one
mill levy limitation (for general purposes) in its first year
of operation. (L. 1987, ch. 71, §4, 6.) The aforesaid levy
limitation applies where a joint district recreation system
"replaces" a city recreation commission which levied 3 mills
under K.S.A. 12-1901 et seq.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
Attorney General
Terrence R. Hearshman
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:JLM:TRH:jm

Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude

Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.