Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1987-114

1987-114Kanag

Texte intégral

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL August 5, 1987
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 87- 114
Joseph W. Snell
Executive Director
Kansas State Historical Society
120 W. Tenth
Topeka, Kansas 66612
Re: State Departments; Public Officers and Employees --
State Historical Society -- "Project" Defined
Synopsis: The change or amendment of a municipal zoning
ordinance is a "project" within the meaning of
K.S.A. 75-2716(c) and K.S.A. 1986 Supp. 75-2724.
Accordingly, a city is required to give the state
historic preservation officer notice and an
opportunity to comment when such change or
amendment is being considered. The term
"environs," as used in the Kansas historic
preservation act, may include property surrounding
a designated historic site even though said
properties are not adjoining. Cited herein:
K.S.A. 75-2715; 75-2716; K.S.A. 1986 Supp.
75-2724; 77-201 second.
Dear Mr. Snell:
As Executive Director of the Kansas State Historical Society,
you request our opinion on the interpretation of K.S.A.
75-2701 et seq., the Kansas historic preservation act.
Specifically, you ask whether a change of zoning would
constitute a "project" under K.S.A. 75-2716(c) and K.S.A. 1986
Supp. 75-2724. You inform us that in January, 1987, the
city of Lawrence approved a zoning change for six lots across
the street from the east boundary of the Old West Lawrence
Historic District. The city did not contact the preservation
office of the State Historical Society for review of the
effects of the zoning change.
Kansas' historic preservation law requires Kansas governmental
agencies and municipalities, including cities, to give the
state historic preservation officer notice and an opportunity
to investigate and comment upon any proposed project which
affects recognized historical properties. Specifically,
K.S.A. 1986 Supp. 75-2724 provides:
"The state or any political subdivision
of the state, or any instrumentality
thereof, shall not undertake any project
which will encroach upon, damage or
destroy any historic property included in
the national register of historic places
or the state register of historic places
or the environs of such property until
the state historic preservation officer
has been given notice and an opportunity
to investigate and comment upon the
proposed project. . . ." (Emphasis
added).
K.S.A. 75-2716(c) defines "project" to include:
"(1) Activities directly undertaken by the
state or any political subdivision of the
state, or any instrumentality thereof;
(2) activities undertaken by a person
which are supported in whole or in part
through grants, subsidies, loans or other
forms of financial assistance from the
state or any political subdivision of the
state, or any instrumentality thereof; and
(3) activities involving the issuance of
a lease, permit, license, certificate or
other entitlement for use, to any person
by the state or any political subdivision
of the state, or any instrumentality
thereof." (Emphasis added).
The Kansas Supreme Court has held that in determining
legislative intent, courts are not bound to an examination of
the language alone but may properly look into the causes which
impel the statute's adoption, the objective sought to be
attained, the statute's historical background and the effect
the statute may have under the various constructions
suggested. State, ex rel., v. City of Overland Park, 215
Kan. 700 (1974); In re Petition of City of Moran, 238
Kan. 513, 520 (1986). In the case at hand, legislative
history is particularly important in gaining a clear
understanding of the meaning of the term "project".
In 1979, this office was asked to determine whether a zoning
change by the city of Wichita constituted a "project" within
the meaning of K.S.A. 75-2724. Attorney General Opinion No.
79-292 opined that, based upon then-existing state historic
preservation law, the construction or destruction of a
historic physical environment by a government unit was a
"project" within the meaning of the Act. However, the absence
of either a statutory definition for "project," or other
expression of legislative intent, caused the Attorney General
to conclude that the term "project" under Kansas' historic
preservation law was not intended to include zoning activities
of Kansas municipalities. Thus, a change in zoning did not
require the city to give the state historic preservation
officer notice and an opportunity to comment.
Subsequent to the issuance of Opinion No. 79-292, 1981 Senate
Bill No. 322 was passed by the Kansas legislature. According
to the Senate Ways and Means Committee minutes of April 6,
1981, the bill was requested by the Kansas State Historical
Society in response to Opinion No. 79-292, because the opinion
stated that the term "project" in current law included only
those activities in which a governmental unit is an active
participant and not those in which the governmental unit plays
a regulatory role. Further, the minutes state:
"S.B. 322, as amended would define
'project' to include not only activities
paid for or supervised by a government
unit, but also activities for which
governmental authorization is
necessary. . . ." (Emphasis added).
In our opinion, the committee minutes clearly indicate that
the 1981 legislature intended activities which require
governmental authorization, such as a change in zoning, be
included within the statutory definition of "project."
We note also the remarks of Joseph W. Snell, executive
director of the Historical Society, before the Senate Ways and
Means committee regarding 1981 Senate Bill No. 322. Mr.
Snell pointed out that the bill was consistent with federal
law and more progressive laws of other states which require
public input not only where a government unit is the principal
sponsor of the destruction of historic property, but also
where funding or sponsorship of the activity is private, if
the activity requires official approval in the form of a
license or permit from some government body.
In addition, his testimony indicates his belief that under
1981 Senate Bill No. 322, acts of local governments approving
changes in zone designations would constitute governmental
action subject to Kansas' historic preservation law. In Mr.
Snell's words:
"The local unit of government is not a
passive partner where a zoning change is
required to permit private development
projects. . . . The acts of local
governments in approving private projects
or changes in zone designations
constitute 'governmental action' which
should be subject to our historic
preservation law." (Emphasis added).
The Attorney General's office also testified before the
committee regarding 1981 Senate Bill No. 322. Our written
testimony states:
"Under Senate Bill No. 322, 'projects'
sponsored and funded by governmental units
would be covered, as well as, projects
with non-government sponsors where
government action or approval is required
to make the project possible. In short,
if government is to participate in a
project which infringes on historic
properties the Kansas historic
preservation law would apply." (Emphasis
added).
While the Attorney General's testimony does not specifically
refer to the term "zoning," it does reflect his belief that
under 1981 Senate Bill No. 322, any government action which
makes possible an infringement on historic properties should
be subject to Kansas' historic preservation law. A change in
zoning is a quasi-judicial function of a municipality which,
simply stated, entitles the owners of certain property to use
it for purposes different from those previously authorized;
but for the change in zoning, the property could not be used
for a new and different purpose. Just as in the case about
which you inquire, the action of the city in changing the
zoning designation of certain lots entitles the owners of
such property to use it for purposes that were not permitted
prior to the amendment or change. It is the action of the
municipality in amending or changing the zoning designation
which makes the new use possible.
While the language of the statute itself referring to
"entitlement for use" is sufficiently broad to cover a change
in zoning, there is further reason to construe this language
broadly. The Kansas historic preservation act contains a
section which declares historic preservation to be the policy
of the state. K.S.A. 75-2715 provides:
"The legislature hereby finds that the
historical, architectural, archeological
and cultural heritage of Kansas is an
important asset of the state and that its
preservation and maintenance should be
among the highest priorities of
government. It is therefore declared to
be the public policy and in the public
interest of the state to engage in a
comprehensive program of historic
preservation and to foster and promote the
conservation and use of historic property
for the education, inspiration, pleasure
and enrichment of the citizens of
Kansas." (Emphasis added).
Where the policy of an act is to protect the public, the act
should be considered remedial in nature. It is fundamental
that legislation which is remedial should be liberally
construed to effectuate the purpose for which it was enacted.
Smith v. Marshall, 225 Kan. 70, 75 (1978). Furthermore, a
statute which is designed to protect the public must be
construed in light of legislative intent and purpose and is
entitled to a broad interpretation so that its public purpose
may be fully carried out. Johnson v. Killion, 178 Kan. 154,
158 (1955). See also, Gonzales v. Callison, 9 Kan.
App. 2d 567, 570 (1984).
After reviewing the plain language of K.S.A. 75-2716(c) (3), as
well as the committee minutes and testimony from the
Historical Society and the Attorney General's office, and
applying commonly accepted rules of statutory construction,
we must conclude that the purpose and intent for amending
K.S.A. 75-2716 in 1981 was to include certain zoning
activities within the definition of "project" under Kansas'
historic preservation law. Thus, in our opinion, a Kansas
municipality is required to give notice and an opportunity to
comment to the state historic preservation officer prior to
changing its zoning laws which affect historic property.
We emphasize two points in reaching this conclusion. First,
as pointed out by Mr. Snell in his testimony before the 1981
Kansas legislature, a government unit is just as much a party
to the destruction of the historic properties when it
approves the demolition of a historic building as when it
funds the demolition. Second, as noted by Mr. Snell and
the Attorney General's office in testimony, K.S.A. 75-2716(c)
and K.S.A. 1986 Supp. 75-2724 do not absolutely prohibit
destruction or alteration of historic properties. Rather, they
provide a procedure for preventing ill-considered destruction,
and an opportunity for state and local officials to consider
preservation issues.
You next inquire whether the Historical Society should be
allowed to review demolition and moving permits for buildings
located on the six rezoned lots across the street from the Old
West Lawrence Historic District. K.S.A. 1986 Supp. 75-2724
provides that a political subdivision of the state shall not
undertake any project:
"[W]hich will encroach upon, damage or
destroy any historic property . . . or
the environs of such property until the
state historic preservation officer has
been given notice and an opportunity to
investigate and comment upon the proposed
project. . . ." (Emphasis added).
As previously indicated in this opinion, the damage,
destruction or encroachment of a historic physical environment
by a government unit or by a non-governmental entity or
person with the license, permit or approval of a governmental
unit is a "project" within the meaning of the historic
preservation act. The issuance of a demolition permit or
building permit constitutes governmental action sufficient to
trigger the notice and comment provisions of the Kansas
historic preservation laws. See Attorney General Opinion
No. 79-292. Thus, the only remaining issue is whether the
specific buildings in question lie within the "environs" of
the Old West Lawrence Historic District. Although this
factual determination can best be made by the Historical
Society, we observe that the legislature chose to include in
the protections provided by the Kansas historic preservation
act not only properties on the state and national registers of
historic places, but also those sites which lie within the
"environs" of historic properties.
Generally, in construing a statute, words and phrases should
be construed according to the context and approved usage of
the language (See K.S.A. 201 Second), and words in common
use are to be given their natural and ordinary meaning. In
re Petition of City of Moran, 238 Kan. 513, 519-520
(1986). In the absence of case law construing "environs" as
used in K.S.A. 1986 Supp. 75-2724, we look to rules of
statutory construction and a general dictionary definition of
"environs" to interpret this term.
"Environs" is defined in Webster's Third New International
Dictionary 760 (1968) as "the suburbs or districts around
about a city or other populated place," and "any adjoining
or surrounding region or space." (Emphasis added). Given
this definition, it is our opinion that buildings located on
lots across the street from a historic district would lie
within the "environs" of the historic district. Although the
lots do not "adjoin" the historic district, they do "surround"
it. (See Attorney General Opinion No. 79-207, for a similar
interpretation of the term "environs" allowing a city to issue
industrial revenue bonds for the development of a site which
"surrounds," but does not "adjoin," issuing city.)
As noted previously in this opinion, a statute which is
designed to protect the public must be construed in light of
legislative intent. Johnson v. Killion, supra;
Gonzales v. Callison, supra. The legislature's choice
of the term "environs" should be read to effectuate the
purpose of the Act, namely the protection of historic
properties from unnecessary destruction, damage or
encroachment. See K.S.A. 75-2715; K.S.A. 1986 Supp.
75-2724. Assuming the Historical Society determines that the
buildings are within the environs of the historic district,
K.S.A. 1986 Supp. 75-2724 would require the city of Lawrence
to give the state historic preservation officer notice and an
opportunity to comment on the demolition and moving permits.
In summary, the change or amendment of a municipal zoning
ordinance is a "project" within the meaning of K.S.A.
75-2716(c) and K.S.A. 1986 Supp. 75-2724. Accordingly, a
city is required to give the state historic preservation
officer notice and an opportunity to comment when such change
or amendment is being considered. The term "environs," as
used in the Kansas historic preservation act, may include
property surrounding a designated historic site even though
said properties are not adjoining.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF KANSAS
Barbara P. Allen
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:JLM:BPA:bas

Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude

Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.