Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1987-092

1987-092Kanag

Texte intégral

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL June 18, 1987
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 87- 92
The Honorable Eric Yost
State Senator, Thirtieth District
3015 Longfellow Court
Wichita, Kansas 67226
Re: Constitution of the State of Kansas--Executive--
Governor's Duties for Legislature; Messages;
Special Sessions; Adjournment
Constitution of the State of Kansas--Legislative--
Organization and Sessions
Synopsis: Although there is no constitutional limitation as
to subject matter which may be considered by the
Kansas Legislature when it is called into special
session, the legislature may adopt a rule or
resolution which would restrict the subject matter
of bills which may be introduced during such a
session. There is no constitutional limitation
upon the length of a special session, and any such
limitation included within a gubernatorial
proclamation (calling the legislature into special
session) would be of no legal effect. Bills and
resolutions introduced, but not acted upon, during
the 1987 regular session of the Kansas Legislature
may not be carried over to a special session, and
all bills and resolutions enacted during a special
session must have been introduced during that
session.
Joint Rule No. 4 of the Senate and House of
Representatives of the State of Kansas prescribes
deadlines for the introduction and consideration of
bills by referring to a specific calendar day "of
any regular session." Based upon that language,
the rule would not seem to apply to a special
session of the legislature. Cited herein: Kan.
Const., Art. 1, §5; Kan. Const., Art. 2, §8.
*
Dear Senator Yost:
You request our opinion concerning legislative activity which
would or would not be proper during a special session of the
Kansas Legislature. Your specific questions, and our
responses thereto, are set forth below.
"1) [I]s there any limitation on the subject matter which can
be dealt with during such a Session?"
Article 1, Section 5 of the Kansas Constitution confers
authority on the governor to call the legislature into special
session, and provides as follows:
"The governor may, on extraordinary
occasions, call the legislature into
special session by proclamation; and shall
call the legislature into special session,
upon petition signed by at least
two-thirds of the members elected to
each house. At every session of the
legislature the governor shall communicate
in writing information in reference to the
condition of the state, and recommend such
measures as he deems expedient. In case
of disagreement between the two houses in
respect of the time of adjournment, the
governor may adjourn the legislature to
such time as he deems proper, not beyond
its next regular session."
The above-quoted constitutional provision was construed in
Farrelly v. Cole, 60 Kan. 356 (1899), wherein the
court stated as follows:
"As stated by Judge Cooley, the
legislature in this state, when convened,
could wholly ignore the reasons given by
the governor calling it together, and
disregard entirely all suggestions made by
him touching the necessity of proposed
legislation. Not being restricted by the
Constitution to the consideration of
matters within the limits of the
governor's proclamation, it might proceed
to enact laws having no relevancy to the
object for which it was convened." 60
Kan. at 380.
Modern authorities concur with the conclusion in the
Farrelly case. See 72 Am.Jur.2d, States §59; 73
Am.Jur.2d, Statutes §35. Accordingly, it is our opinion
that there is no constitutional limitation as to subject
matter which may be considered by the Kansas Legislature when
it is called into special session.
"2) [I]s there any minimum or maximum number of days the
Session can be called for, and can the Governor include such
limits in his call for a Special Session?"
There is no constitutional provision limiting the length of a
special session of the Kansas Legislature. Although Article
1, Section 5 of the Kansas Constitution (quoted above) confers
authority upon the governor to adjourn the legislature when
there is a disagreement between the two houses regarding the
time of adjournment, it does not provide for any executive
limitation upon the length of a special session. Therefore,
it is our opinion that there is no constitutional limitation
upon the length of a special session of the Kansas
Legislature, and that any such limitation included within a
gubernatorial proclamation (calling the legislature into
special session) would be of no legal effect.
In passing, we note that the Florida Supreme Court has held
that the calling of an extra session of the Florida
legislature is an exercise of executive discretion, and that
the governor has power, in the exercise of that discretion, to
prescribe a time limitation in the proclamation calling a
special session. In re Advisory Opinion To the Governor,
206 So.2d 212 (Fla. 1968). Also, as to special
apportionment sessions, the Florida court has held that the
governor has no power to prescribe a time limitation.
Florida Senate v. Graham, 412 So.2d 360 (Fla. 1982). A
comparison of the Florida and Kansas constitutions reveal
significant differences in the executive authority to call
special sessions, and in our judgment the above-cited
Florida cases are not relevant in construing the subject
provisions of the Kansas Constitution.
"3) [D]o the existing rules of the Legislature govern its
actions during a Special Session, and if so, what kind of
deadlines (if any) would exist for the consideration of bills
and resolutions by either House, or by the committees of
either House?"
Article 2, Section 8 of the Kansas Constitution empowers each
house of the legislature to establish its own rules. It has
been held that each house is to be the sole judge of its
procedure, Leek v. Theis, 217 Kan. 784, 814 (1975), and
that non-observance of legislative rules will not render a
statute invalid. 73 Am.Jur.2d, Statutes §49. Since
legislative rules are not, in and of themselves, of
constitutional significance (i.e., a violation of one or
more legislative rules will not invalidate an enactment
resulting from such a violation), and the Kansas Supreme Court
has held that each house of the legislature is to be the sole
judge of its procedure, it would not be appropriate for this
office to interpret or apply legislative rules.
Although we believe that each house of the legislature is the
most appropriate body to determine when its rules apply, we
would observe that Joint Rule No. 4 of the Senate and House of
Representatives of the State of Kansas prescribes deadlines
for the introduction and consideration of bills by referring
to a specific calendar day "of any regular session."
Accordingly, said rule would not seem to apply to a special
session of the legislature.
"4) [Clan the Legislature deal with legislation which has
already been introduced, or must all bills and resolutions
which are considered during the Special Session be introduced
during that Session?"
Article 2, Section 8 of the Kansas Constitution deals with the
timing and duration of regular sessions of the legislature,
and provides, in part, as follows:
"Bills and concurrent resolutions under
consideration by the legislature upon
adjournment of a regular session held in
an odd numbered year may be considered at
the next succeeding regular session held
in an even numbered year, as if there had
been no such adjournment." (Emphasis
added.)
In accordance with the above-quoted language, bills introduced
in the 1987 regular session, and not acted upon, may be
considered at the next succeeding regular session, i.e.
the 1988 session. However, the above-quoted constitutional
provision does not indicate that bills under consideration at
the adjournment of a regular session (held in an odd numbered
year) may be considered at an intervening special session, and
there is authority that a special session should be treated as
separate and independent from a regular session. 81A C.J.S.
States §49. Therefore, it is our opinion that bills and
resolutions introduced, but not acted upon, during the 1987
regular session of the Kansas Legislature may not be carried
over to a special session, and that all bills and resolutions
enacted during a special session must have been introduced
during that session.
"5) [I]s there any limitation on which committees can be
convened for the purpose of considering whatever legislation
is deemed proper in your answer to Question #4?"
There is no such constitutional limitation.
6) May the legislature "pass a resolution limiting the subject
matter which can be dealt with" during a special session?
A legislature may not adopt rules for the passage of statutes
which conflict with provisions of the state constitution. 73
Am.Jur.2d, Statutes §49. A rule which would restrict the
subject matter of bills which may be introduced during a
special session would seem to be in harmony with the
constitutional basis for such a session, i.e. a
gubernatorial finding that an "extraordinary occasion"
exists. Specifically, notwithstanding the fact that the
legislature may consider any subject matter during a special
session (see answer question number 1 above), an
"extraordinary occasion" seems to suggest a restricted problem
requiring legislative attention. Accordingly, it is our
opinion that the legislature may adopt a rule or resolution
which would restrict the subject matter of bills which may be
introduced during a special session.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
Attorney General of Kansas
Terrence R. Hearshman
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:JLM:TRH:jm

Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude

Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.