Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1987-044

1987-044Kanag

Texte intégral

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL
March 5, 1987
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 87- 44
Joseph Snell
Executive Director
Kansas State Historical Society
120 West Tenth
Topeka, Kansas 66612-1291
Re: State Departments; Public Officers and Employees
-- State Historical Society -- Deaccessions Policy
Synopsis: K.S.A. 75-2701(a) does not restrict the type of
party with whom the Kansas State Historical Society
may arrange a sale or exchange of duplicate
materials or materials outside its fields of
collection. Therefore, the Historical Society may
deal with private citizens in making these sales or
exchanges.
Since K.S.A. 75-2701(a) speaks only in terms of
sale or exchange, the Historical Society is
prohibited from donating items which are duplicates
or are outside its fields of collection to other
institutions. Cited herein: K.S.A. 75-2701;
75-2703; 75-2704.
Dear Mr. Snell:
As executive director of the Kansas State Historical Society
(Society), you ask us to review a manual recently devised by
the Kansas Museum of History entitled Collections Management
Policy. Specifically, you ask two questions related to the
museum's deaccessions policy, which we will address
separately.
First, you inquire as to whether the museum's deaccession's
policy would limit the Society's ability to trade or sell
property in situations permitted by statute, but prohibited by
the museum department's policy. You inform us that the museum
will only deal with public-oriented parties, such as similar
institutions and non-profit organizations, because it wishes
to maintain the public's confidence that the museum will care
for donated items, and that the museum will benefit the public
through the donor's generosity. Citing an example where the
Society would lose a beneficial resource if it could not sell
or trade duplicate or inappropriate artifacts for items
currently in the hands of private persons, you ask whether the
museum's exchange of an artifact to the non-profit Kansas
State Historical Society corporation in return for an artifact
obtained by the Society from a private person would be legal.
K.S.A. 75-2701(a) provides:
"The state historical society, heretofore
organized under the incorporation laws of
the state, shall be the trustee of the
state, and as such shall faithfully expend
and apply all money received from the state
to the uses and purposes directed by law,
and shall hold all its present and future
collections of property for the state, and
shall not sell, mortgage, transfer, or
dispose of in any manner or remove from its
building or buildings, except for temporary
purposes, any article thereof, or part of
the same, without authority of law except
that this shall not prevent the sale or
exchange by the society of its publications,
duplicate materials or materials outside its
fields of collection, that it may have or
obtain. ,(Emphasis added).
K.S.A. 75-2701(a) does not restrict the type of party with
whom the Society may arrange a sale or exchange of duplicative
or inappropriate materials. Therefore, we believe that state
law, unlike the museum's Collections Management Policy,
would allow the Society to deal with private individuals for
purposes of these sales or exchanges. In our opinion, subject
to the Society's approval, the museum is free to set up its
own internal policy which is more restrictive than K.S.A
75-2701(a), thus permitting the museum to deal only with
public entities. However, this restrictive policy, which
applies only to the museum, would not prohibit the Society
from dealing with private individuals as allowed by K.S.A.
75-2701(a).
Second, you ask whether the Society is precluded from donating
items which are duplicates or are outside its fields of
collection to other organizations, since K.S.A. 75-2701(a)
refers only to the possibility of a sale or an exchange. The
statute neither expressly prohibits nor authorizes the Society
to donate such items. Therefore, it is necessary to determine
legislative intent. "The fundamental rule of statutory
construction, to which all others are subordinate, is that the
purpose and intent of the legislature governs when that intent
can be ascertained from the statute." Szoboslay v.
Glessner, 233 Kan. 475, 477 (1983).
In our opinion, the fact that the legislature did not
expressly authorize the Society to donate duplicative or
inappropriate materials when it provided it with authority to
sell or exchange them (K.S.A. 75-2701), suggests that the
legislature did not intend for the Society to have this
option. K.S.A. 75-2701 was originally part of the 1879 law
which made the Society a state agency and trustee for state
historical property. See L. 1879, Ch. 167 § 1-3.
Although these sections have been amended several times
through the years, the language with which we are concerned
has remained unchanged. If the legislature had intended to
give the Society the option to donate, it could have so
provided through an amendment to the statute.
Another well-founded rule of statutory construction is that
"in order to ascertain legislative intent, courts are not
permitted to consider only an isolated part or parts of an act
but are required to consider and construe together all parts
thereof in pari materia." Szoboszlay v. Glessner,
supra at 478. Attorney General Opinion No. 81-62 relied on
this rule when it considered whether the language in K.S.A.
75-2701 et seg. would allow the museum to sell duplicative
publications, even though K.S.A. 75-2703 only expressly
provided for their exchange. Since K.S.A. 75-2701 and K.S.A.
75-2704 both refer to the museum's authority to sell or
exchange duplicative and inappropriate materials, we opined
that it was consistent with apparent legislative intent to
infer that the museum could sell as well as exchange
duplicative publications.
We do not feel similar reasoning can be used in the case at
hand. Nowhere else in the act is the museum empowered to
donate objects to other institutions. This fact is persuasive
when considered with the purpose for which many donations to
the museum are made. When a donor gives an object to the
museum, it is generally his or her desire to benefit the
museum. To remain consonant with this intent, our legislature
has authorized the museum to sell or trade duplicative or
inappropriate materials, thus indirectly fostering the donor's
intent that the museum benefit from the gift. If the museum
simply gave such items away, this intent would not be realized.
A third rule of statutory construction which is applied to
clear and unambiguous statutes is the maxim expressio unius
est exclusio alterius (the expression of one thing is the
exclusion of another). In re Petition of City of Shawnee for
Annexation of Land, 236 Kan. 1, 14 (1984). We find K.S.A.
75-2701 to be clear and unambiguous. The statute prohibits
the State Historical Society from disposing of in any manner
or from removing from its building or buildings any property
which has been entrusted to the Society, with the exception
"that this shall not prevent the sale or exchange by the
society of its publications, duplicate materials, or materials
outside its fields of collection, that it may have or
obtain." Under this rule, by expressly providing for the sale
or exchange of items, the legislature has excluded the Society
from having the option to donate.
In light of the aforementioned rules of statutory construction
and relevant statutes, we conclude that the museum is not
authorized by law to donate duplicative or inappropriate items
to other institutions. Accordingly, references in the policy
manual to such gift-giving powers should be deleted. See
"Deaccession Procedure" 5(a) and (b), p. 17.
We wish to call your attention to another portion of the
Collections Management Policy which we believe to be in
violation of state law. The section entitled "Deaccession
Procedures" states that disposal by witnessed destruction is
an appropriate deaccession method for items which are
hazardous, damaged beyond repair, or which have insignificant
sale or exchange value. However, K.S.A. 75-2701(a) prohibits
the Society from disposing of property without authority of
law. In that our research has revealed no legislative
authority for disposing of property in this manner, we believe
this deaccession procedure should be deleted from the policy
manual. To solve the problem of disposing of excess
materials, we suggest that the Society either provide for the
temporary loan of such items to an appropriate organization,
or arrange for the sale of these items at a nominal price.
(K.S.A. 75-2701; 75-2704).
In summary, K.S.A. 75-2701(a) does not restrict the type of
party with whom the Kansas State Historical Society may
arrange a sale or exchange of duplicate materials or materials
outside its fields of collection. Therefore, the Historical
Society may deal with private citizens in making these sales
or exchanges.
Since K.S.A. 75-2701(a) speaks only in terms of sale or
exchange, the Historical Society is prohibited from donating
items which are duplicates or are outside its fields of
collection to other institutions.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF KANSAS
Barbara P. Allen
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:JLM:BPA:bas

Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude

Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.