Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1987-038

1987-038Kanag

Texte intégral

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GEN ER AL February 25, 1987
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 87- 38
The Honorable Vincent K. Snowbarger
Representative, 26th District
Capitol Building, 446-N
Topeka, Kansas 66612
Re: Constitution of the State of Kansas --
Miscellaneous -- State Owned and Operated
Lotteries
Synopsis: The constitutional provision permitting a
state owned and operated lottery would allow the
state to advance and market any game or
combination of games as long as there is
consideration, chance and a prize involved in
each game. Cited Herein: Kan. Const., Art. 5,
§3C; L. 1986, ch. 414.
*
Dear Representative Snowbarger:
As Representative for the Twenty-Sixth district, you ask
our opinion as to the definition of the word "lottery."
Specifically, you question whether the game "lotto" is
allowed by the Kansas constitutional provision, Art. 15,
§3C.
The constitutional provision as voted on and passed by the
Kansas electorate did not define or restrict the term
"lottery," nor did it define or restrict itself to any
specific games. The definitional responsibility of
defining "lottery" is therefore passed to the courts of
this state. State v. Nelson, 210 Kan. 439, 445 (1972).
In Nelson, the Court stated that "[t]he definition should
achieve a consistency so that it shall not be taken to mean
one thing at one time and another thing at another time."
Id. at 445.
In Higgins v. Cardinal Manufacturing Co., 188 Kan. 11
(1961), the Court stated that a constitution is not to be
narrowly or technically construed but its language "should
be held to mean what the words imply to the common
understanding of men." This position was adopted in the
later case of State, ex rel., v. Highwood Services,
Inc., 205 Kan. 821 (1970), when the court used resources
available around the time the Kansas Constitution was
adopted in 1859 to define "lottery." The Court wrote in
Highwood at 825 and 826 that "in ascertaining the
meaning of constitutional provisions courts should consider
what appears to have been the intendment and understanding
of the people at their adoption. (See, also, State v.
Sessions, 84 Kan. 856, 115 Pac. 641)." Thus, in
defining the term "lottery" the Court has adopted common
usage definitions.
In Highwood, the Court's research included the
following:
"In Abbott's Law Dictionary, published in 1879, we
have found this definition of a lottery:
"'A scheme for the distribution of prizes by
chance, among buyers of the chances.
"'Such schemes were formerly very common, were
authorized by law, and were even set on foot, in
many instances, by the authorities, for raising
revenue for public or benevolent purposes. In
view of the ill effects of the element of
gambling involved, they are now very generally
made unlawful.'
"Foremost among the citations appended to the text,
the author has placed the following:
"'A lottery is a distribution of prizes by chance
or lot, where a valuable consideration is given
for the chance of drawing a prize. United States
v. Olney, 1 Abb. U.S. 275.,' (1868).
"Webster's Third New International Dictionary,
unabridged, (1964) conveys much the same idea as it
defines lottery:
"'a scheme for the distribution of prizes by lot
or chance; esp.: a scheme by which prizes are
distributed to the winners among those persons
who have paid for a chance to win them, usu. as
determined by the numbers on tickets as drawn at
random (as from a lottery wheel).'
"To similar effect, see Oxford Illustrated Dictionary
(1962) and The Random House Dictionary of the English
Language, the Unabridged Edition (1967)."
The court has refined the various definitions into three
required elements in order to be recognized as a lottery in
Kansas. "The court has held that the essential elements of
a lottery are three: (1) consideration, (2) prize, and (3)
chance. (State, ex rel. v. Bissing, 178 Kan. 111, 283
P.2d 418)." Highwood, 205 Kan. at 823. Using this
three element definition the court has adhered to the
constitutional provision banning lotteries and struck down
such efforts prior to Kan. Const. Art. 15, sec 3c. "The
State, ex rel v. Mercantile Association, 45 Kan. 351, 25
Pac. 984, [distribution of prizes by chance]; In re
Smith, Petitioner, 54 Kan. 702, 39 Pac. 70, [sale of
lottery tickets]; The State, ex rel v. Fair Association,
89 Kan. 238, 131 Pac. 626, [bets on horse races]; State,
ex rel., v. Fox Kansas Theatre Co., 144 Kan. 687, 62 P.2d
929, [theater bank night]; City of Wichita v. Stevens,
167 Kan. 408, 207 P.2d 386, [punch boards]; State v.
Brown, 173 Kan. 166, 244 P.2d 1190, [punch boards];
State, ex rel. v. Bissing, 178 Kan. 111, [parimutuel
betting on dog races]." Nelson, 210 Kan. at 444.
In considering the lottery provision, numerous individuals
and state agencies advanced definitions for the term
lottery. Included in the minutes were reports that "new
forms of lottery games are constantly being invented,"
Minutes of the House Federal and State Affairs Committee,
January 16, 1986, testimony of Ross Mills, Legislative
Research Department, Attachment A., and "there are
currently several types of lottery products being played
. . . weekly game or draw lottery . . . instant lottery
ticket . . . online system . . numbers game . . . pick
four." Minutes of the House Federal and State Affairs
Committee, January 16, 1986, testimony of Secretary of
Revenue Harley Duncan, Attachment B.
It was further presented that some states have restricted
their lottery to specific games. Minutes of the House
Federal and State Affairs Committee, January 21, 1986,
testimony of Patrick J. Hurley, Attachment C. The Kansas
Legislature did not preclude any specific game or games
with the language used in 1986 Senate Concurrent Resolution
1609, L. 1986, ch. 414.
In Attorney General Opinion No. 87-16, this office
indicated that:
"[t]he intent and understanding of both the
legislature and the people seems to have been to have
a government controlled lottery as a revenue raising
measure. Minutes of the House Federal and State
Affairs Committee, January 21, 1986, testimony of
Secretary of Revenue Harley Duncan, Attachment A.
"It appears that the intent of the voters in approving
the lottery was to allow closely regulated gambling
and to raise money for the state. A multi-state
lottery would not be repugnant to the intent of the
constitutional provisions."
In our judgment, the game "lotto" would fall within the
scope of the Kansas constitutional "lottery" amendment
since it is an unrestricted provision. The lottery could
include both an active game and a passive game. An active
game has been recognized as a lottery game in which the
player takes action to determine the outcome by choosing a
number or set of numbers to bet on, attempting to match the
numbers later drawn. A passive game is a lottery game in
which the player takes no active part in determining the
outcome; the ticket sold is either a winner or a loser, and
no choices of numbers are made. Minutes of the House
Federal and State Affairs Committee, January 16, 1986,
testimony of Secretary of Revenue Harley Duncan.
Attachment B. Again, to be recognized as a lottery the
three (3) essential elements must be present in either an
active or passive game.
The Kansas Supreme Court in Highwood, supra, came to
the conclusion that:
"In short, we entertain the opinion that not only in
1859, when the constitution was adopted, and in 1895,
when K.S.A. 21-1506 was enacted, but in recent years
as well, the common understanding of a lottery
entertained by men in general has been that a
consideration of value must flow from those who
participate. We gravely doubt that had the ordinary
man in the streets in 1859 been able to envision the
advent of television he would have characterized as a
lottery the give-away program known as Dialing for
Dollars." 205 Kan. at 826.
In keeping with the court pronouncement that the definition
must remain constant and should withstand the test of time,
any game, no matter the extent of player participation or
the title assigned to the game, be it "lotto" or "casino
gambling," as long as it is state owned and operated and
involves the essential elements discussed above, it would
be classified as a lottery.
It is therefore our opinion that a state-owned and
operated lottery could include any game or combination of
games as long as there is consideration, chance and prize
involved in each game. Such a game would not be repugnant
to the intent of the constitutional provision.
Very truly yours,
Robert T. Stephen
Attorney General
Brenda L. Braden
Deputy Attorney General
RTS:BLB:may

Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude

Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.