Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1986-164

1986-164Kanag

Texte intégral

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL. November 24, 1986
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 86- 164
Thomas Kelly
Director, Kansas Bureau of
Investigation
1620 S.W. Tyler
Topeka, Kansas 66612
Re: Automobiles and Other Vehicles--General
Provisions--Regulatory Provisions; Vehicle
Identification Number; Check of Assembled Vehicles
by Highway Patrol; Vehicle Seizure and Disposition
Synopsis: K.S.A. 1985 Supp. 8-116a provides for the
assignment of a new VIN to vehicles that have
been assembled or restored, or upon which the
proper identification number is in doubt. The
'vehicle is checked for stolen parts; if none are
found, a new VIN is assigned and the vehicle
returned to its owner in accordance with the
procedure outlined. If there is evidence of fraud,
the vehicle must be seized and disposed of as
mandated by K.S.A. 1985 Supp. 8-116 and K.S.A.
22-2512. However, the forfeiture provisions of
K.S.A. 1985 Supp. 8-116 and K.S.A. 22-2512 do not
authorize an ex parte destruction or sale of
priv without some compliance with due
process rForirementsrequirements of notice and an opportunity
to beunder K.S.A this reason, the disposition of
vehiclesan ini-,K.S.A. 1985 Supp. 8-116 must be
determined in an_in rem proceeding filed by the
state. Cited herein: K.S.A. 1985 Supp. 8-116;
8-116a; K.S.A. 22 - 2512; 74-2135.
Dear Mr. Kelly:
As Director of the Kansas Bureau of Investigation, you request
our opinion regarding the disposition of a vehicle seized
pursuant to K.S.A. 1985 Supp. 8-116. Specifically, you
inquire as to the proper method and procedure to be followed
in disposing of a vehicle where K.S.A. 1985 Supp. 8-116 and
K.S.A. 1985 Supp. 8-116a provide different means of
disposition of vehicles without a vehicle identification
number.
In your request letter you set forth the following fact
situation: The vehicle in question had been damaged in
shipment and the manufacturer removed the vehicle
identification number (VIN) and sent the truck to a local
dealer; the local dealer repaired the truck and donated the
truck to the Kansas University Athletic Department. An
employee of the Athletic Department discovered there was no
VIN when he began the process of registering the vehicle;
the lack of a VIN was then brought to the attention of a law
enforcement officer who considers the vehicle contraband and
believes it should be destroyed.
The statute in question, K.S.A. 1985 Supp. 8-116, states:
"(a) It is unlawful to sell, barter or
exchange any motor vehicle, trailer or
semitrailer, or to own or have the custody
or possession of a motor vehicle, trailer
or semitrailer, the original vehicle
identification number of which has been
destroyed, removed, altered or defaced,
except as contemplated by K.S.A. 1984
Supp. 8-116a when no part of the motor
vehicle, trailer or semitrailer has been
stolen and a vehicle identification number
has been assigned to the motor vehicle
according to law. Violation of this
subsection (a) is a class C misdemeanor."
(Emphasis added.)
In 1984 the legislature amended K.S.A. 8-116 by adding the
underscored exception. An examination of the legislative
history of the act in which the amendment appears (L. 1984,
ch. 25), is not helpful in fixing any specific legislative
intent behind the above-underscored language. However,
several basic tenets of statutory construction may be applied
to determine the legislature's purpose. First, the act must
be read in pari materia with other acts which deal with
the registration and operation of motor vehicles, and, if
possible, harmonized so that all may be given force and
effect. Capital Services, Inc. v. Dahlinger
Pontiac-Cadillac, Inc., 232 Kan. 419 (1983). Further, in
determining legislative intent, it is proper to consider the
purpose to be accomplished and the effect of various
constructions. Jackson v. City of Kansas City, 235 Kan.
278 (1984). Finally, if a statute is susceptible of more than
one construction, effect should be given to that reading which
gives effect to the intent and purpose of the legislature,
even if such a construction may not be within the strict
literal wording of the statute. Brown v. Keill, 224
Kan. 195 (1978).
Given the above principles, it is our opinion that the
legislature did not intend to require both the absence of
stolen parts and the presence of a vehicle identification
number in order that the exception apply. Doing so would lead
to an absurd result since the statute to which the exception
refers provides for the assignment of a vehicle identification
number in this circumstance. A statute should never be given
a construction that leads to an absurd result. State v.
Roudybush, 235 Kan. 834 (1984).
To reiterate the facts, you state that the VIN was removed
by the manufacturer and that the vehicle was repaired by a
local dealer. The common definition of repair is "to restore
to sound condition after damage or injury." The American
Heritage Dictionary, New College Edition 1102 (1976).
K.S.A. 1985 Supp. 8-116a provides in part:
"When an application is made for a vehicle
which has been assembled, reconstructed,
reconstituted or restored from one or
more vehicles, or the proper
identification number of a vehicle is in
doubt, the procedure in this section shall
be followed. . . ." (Emphasis added.)
Accordingly, based on the facts you presented, the proper
method and procedure for disposing of the vehicle in question
is spelled out in K.S.A. 1.985 Supp. 8-116a:
"The owner of the Vehicle shall request
the Kansas highway patrol to check the
vehicle. At the time of such check the
owner shall supply the highway patrol with
information concerning the history of the
various parts of the vehicle. Such
information shall be supplied by affidavit
of the owner, if so requested by the
highway patrol. If the highway patrol is
satisfied that the vehicle contains no
stolen parts, it shall assign an existing
or new identification number to the
vehicle and direct the places and manner
in which the identification number is to
be located and affixed or implanted."
The particular circumstances and facts as presented come
within the purview of K.S.A. 1985 Supp. 8-116a. This is not
to say, however, that this is the only statute that may need
to be addressed in the resolution of this problem.
Regulations concerning check of vehicle identification numbers
under K.S.A. 1985 Supp. 8-116a are authorized by K.S.A.
74-2135 which states:
"Concerning motor vehicles upon which such
checks are made, such rules and
regulations may provide for tests and
procedures to detect evidence of possible
fraud or other improper conduct relating
to certificates of title, odometers,
other violations of K.S.A. 8-611 and
amendments thereto and vehicle
identification numbers.!! (Emphasis
added.)
In accordance with the statute cited above, if there is
detected evidence of possible fraud relating to vehicle
identification numbers then K.S.A. 1985 Supp. 8-116 applies
because the vehicle no longer comes under the exception. The
seized vehicle should then be disposed under section (c) of
K.S.A. 1985 Supp. 8-116. It states:
"(c) Every law enforcement officer in this
state having knowledge of a motor vehicle,
trailer or semitrailer the vehicle
identification number of which has been
destroyed, removed, altered or defaced
shall seize and take possession of such
motor vehicle, trailer or semitrailer,
arrest the owner or custodian thereof and
cause prosecution to be brought in a court
of competent jurisdiction. The
provisions of K.S.A. 22-2512 and
amendments thereto shall apply to any
motor vehicle, trailer or semitrailer
seized under this section." (Emphasis
added.)
The provisions of K.S.A. 22-2512 apply to the property seized
pursuant to K.S.A. 1985 Supp. 8-116 and, in pertinent part,
that statute provides as follows:
. . . When property seized is no longer
required as evidence, it shall be disposed
of as follows:• . . . (4) Articles of
contraband shall be destroyed, except
that any such articles which may be
capable of innocent use may in the
discretion of the court be sold and the
proceeds . . . [paid to the state
treasurer]. (6) Unless otherwise provided
by law, all other property shall be
disposed of in such manner as the court in
its sound discretion shall direct."
(Emphasis added.)
K.S.A. 22-2512(4), relating to the disposition of articles of
contraband, provides for destruction, except that any such
article which may be capable of innocent use may in the
discretion of the court be sold and the proceeds paid to the
state treasurer. If evidence of fraud is uncovered and
disposition of the vehicle in question is to be governed by
K.S.A. 1985 Supp. 8-116 rather than 8-116a, it may be that the
vehicle has some innocent use as evidenced by its use by the
Kansas University Athletic Department.
However, the forfeiture provisions of K.S.A. 22-2512(4) do not
authorize an ex parte destruction or sale of private
property without some compliance with due process requirements
of notice and an opportunity to be heard. See Kansas v.
Durst, 235 Kan. 62 (1984). Durst involved an appeal
by the State of Kansas from an order in a criminal action
directing the return of certain property seized at the time of
the arrest of the defendant, to its purported owner. The
state sought a mandatory application of K.S.A. 22-2512(4) as a
simple post judgment order in a criminal case without any
notice to or opportunity to be heard by those who might have
an interest in the property to be destroyed. The Court
concluded that it would be a violation of the right to due
process of law to apply the forfeiture provisions of K.S.A.
- 22-2512(4) in the manner requested by the state. The Court
found that the state was therefore required to proceed in some
manner against the property itself in order to afford due
process to those who might have an interest in the property.
Accordingly, the proper method and procedure for disposing of
a seized vehicle pursuant to K.S.A. 1985 Supp. 8-116 is to
have the state file an in rem proceeding against the
property itself.
In conclusion, it is our opinion that under the facts
presented the applicable statute for the disposition of the
vehicle in question is K.S.A. 1985 Supp. 8-116a. Because this
vehicle has been restored, it should be checked for stolen
parts pursuant to K.S.A. 1985 Supp. 8-116a. If there is no
evidence of fraud, a new VIN should be assigned and the
vehicle returned to its owner in accordance with the procedure
outlined in the statute. If, however there is evidence of
fraud, the applicable statute is K.S.A. 1985 Supp. 8-116 and
the disposition of the vehicle should be determined by the
court in an in rem proceeding filed by the state.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
Attorney General of Kansas
Guen V. Easley
Special Assistant Attorney General
RTS:JLM:GVE:jm

Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude

Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.