Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1986-149

1986-149Kanag

Texte intégral

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL October 20, 1986
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 86- 149
Frank C. Beyerl
Greenwood County Attorney
408 N. Main
Eureka, Kansas 67045
Re: Labor and Industries -- Workmen's Compensation --
Performance of Community Service
Synopsis: K.S.A. 1985 Supp. 44-508, as amended by L. 1986,
ch. 189, §1, broadens the definition of "employer,"
and "workman, employee or worker" for purposes of
community service work. This amendment to the
Workmen's Compensation Act allows offenders
sentenced or assigned to community service work to
be covered by workers' compensation, during the
time they are performing community service work, if
the entity(ies) receiving or assigning such work
so elect(s). In that K.S.A. 1985 Supp. 44-508, as
amended, specifically includes persons performing
community service work within the definition of
"workman, employee or worker," we withdraw Attorney
General Opinion No. 82-213, which concluded such a
person is not a workman, employee or worker under
the terms of the Workmen's Compensation Act prior
to the amendment. Cited herein: K.S.A. 44-501
et seq.; K.S.A. 1985 Supp. 44-508, as amended
by L. 1986, ch. 189, §1; Supplemental Note on House
Bill No. 2891.
Dear Mr. Beyerl:
As county attorney for Greenwood County, you request our
opinion on a question involving the meaning of a recent
amendment to K.S.A. 1985 Supp. 44-508. Specifically, you
inquire as to whether the county will be liable for injuries
which a juvenile or convicted DUI defendant incurs while
performing community service work ordered by a judge. Your
question concerns the definition of "employer" and "employee"
as defined by the Kansas Workmen's Compensation Act, K.S.A.
44-501 et !2a .
In 1982, Attorney General Opinion No. 82-213 concluded that an
offender sentenced to community service is not a workman,
employee or worker, as those terms are defined by K.S.A.
44-508(b) of the Workmen's Compensation Act, and is therefore
not covered by the terms of the Act. This conclusion was
based on numerous court decisions holding that for the
provisions of K.S.A. 44-501 et seq. to apply, there must
be an employer-employee relationship in existence. See
Dorst v. City of Chanute, 185 Kan. 593 (1959), and cases
cited therein at 597.
In 1982, K.S.A. 44-508(b) defined workman, employee or worker
as follows:
"'Workman' or 'employee' or 'worker'
means any person who has entered into
the employment of or works under any
contract of service or apprenticeship
with an employer. Such terms shall
include but not be limited to:
. . . persons in the service of the
state, or any department, agency or
authority of the state, any city, school
district, or other political subdivision
or municipality or public corporation
and any instrumentality thereof, under
any contract of service, express or
implied, . . . ." (Emphasis added.)
Opinion No. 82-213 noted that the above definition looks to
the existence of a "contract of service" between the employer
and employee, which must exist before the other provisions of
the Act come into play. Dorst v. City of Chanute,
supra; Gaston v. San Ore Construction Co., 206 Kan. 254
(1970). The opinion found that any agreement made by a
convicted violator is with the court or prosecuting attorney
and not the entity which receives the benefit of the service.
Thus, the recipient of community service makes no agreement
with the offender as to compensation, length of time to be
served, deadline for completion or consequences of failure to
perform assigned tasks of community service work. Likewise,
in performing such work, an offender receives no compensation,
but rather fulfills a condition of his or her sentence from
the district or municipal court. Accordingly, Opinion No.
82-213 concluded that since no "contract of service" exists
between the person performing community service work and the
entity receiving community service work, the person performing
the service is not a workman, employee or worker under K.S.A.
44-508(b), and is thus not covered by the terms of the
Workmen's Compensation Act.
In 1986, the Kansas legislature changed the definition of
"employer" and "workman, employee or worker" under the
Workmen's Compensation Act, by amending K.S.A. 1985 Supp.
44-508(a) and (b). L. 1986, ch. 189, §1 now reads as follows:
"As used in the workmen's compensation act:
"(a) 'Employer' includes . . . (3) for
the purposes of community service work,
the entity for which the community service
work is being performed and the
governmental agency which assigned the
community service work, if any, if either
such entity or such governmental agency
has filed a written statement of election
with the director to accept the provisions
under the workmen's compensation act for
persons performing community service work
and in such case such entity and such
governmental agency shall be deemed to be
the joint employer of the person
performing the community service work and
both shall have the rights, liabilities
and immunities provided under the
workmen's compensation act for an employer
with regard to the community service work,
except that the liability for providing
benefits shall be imposed only on the
party which filed such election with the
director, or on both if both parties have
filed such election with the director;
for purposes of community service work,
'governmental agency' shall not include
any court or any officer or employee
thereof and any case where there is deemed
to be a 'joint employer' shall not be
construed to be a case of dual or multiple
employment.
"(b) 'Workman' or 'employee' or 'worker'
means any person who has entered into the
employment of or works under any contract
of service or apprenticeship with an
employer. Such terms shall include but
not be limited to: . . . persons
performing community service work, but
only to the extent and during such periods
as they are performing community service
work and if an election has been filed an
election to extend coverage to such
persons." (Emphasis added.)
As noted previously, Attorney General Opinion No. 82-213
concluded that offenders sentenced to community service work
were not employees of the county, and were therefore not
covered by the Workmen's Compensation Act. Taking into
consideration the 1986 amendment to K.S.A. 1985 Supp. 44-508,
you inquire whether the statute was specifically changed to
cover individuals performing community service work.
While Kansas courts have yet to interpret K.S.A. 1985 Supp.
44-508, as amended, in our opinion the clear purpose of the
amendment is to allow offenders sentenced or assigned to
community service work to be covered by workers' compensation
during the time they are performing work.
Section 1, subsection (a) broadens the definition of employer,
as used in the Workmen's Compensation Act, to include the
entity for which community service work is being performed and
the governmental agency which assigned the community service
work, if either has filed for an election to be covered under
workers' compensation. In addition, the new language provides
that both the entity receiving community service work and the
entity assigning community service work shall be joint
employers under the statute, if either has filed for the
workers' compensation election. Further, both entities have
the rights, liabilities and immunities provided under the Act
for an employer with regard to community service work, except
that liability for providing workers' compensation benefits
shall be imposed only on the party that so elects. If both
parties file an election, both will be charged with
liability. Finally, the court and its employees or officers
will not be considered a governmental agency for purposes of
community service work.
Section 1, subsection (b) likewise broadens the definition of
"workman, employee or worker." The new language specifically
states that under the Workmen's Compensation Act, the term
employee can mean persons performing community service work.
The amendment imposes limitations that a person assigned to
community service is only an employee while he or she is
performing the service. Further, the employer, as defined in
section 1, subsection (a), must have filed an election to
extend workers' compensation coverage to such person before he
or she can become an employee under the Act.
In addition to the plain language of the statute, we refer to
the Supplemental Note on 1986 House Bill No. 2891 to determine
legislative intent. The note provides:
"H.B. 2891 amends the Workers'
Compensation Law to allow offenders
sentenced or assigned to community service
work to be covered, during the time they
are performing work, by workers
compensation if either or both the
entity(ies) receiving the benefit of the
community service work or the state agency
assigning the community service work has
elected to come under the provisions of
the Workers' Compensation Act."
The note also indicates that spokespersons from the state
AFL/CIO and the division of Workers' Compensation
testified in support of extending coverage to include
offenders sentenced to community service.
Based on our analysis of the plain language of K.S.A. 1985
Supp. 44-508, as amended by L. 1986, ch. 189, §1, plus a
reading of the supplemental note on 1986 House Bill No. 2891,
it is our opinion that the statute was specifically changed in
1986 to cover individuals performing community service work.
In that K.S.A. 1985 Supp. 44-508, as amended, specifically
includes persons performing community service work within the
definition of "workman, employee or worker," we withdraw
Attorney General Opinion No. 82-213, which concluded such a
person is not a workman, employee or worker under the terms of
the Workmen's Compensation Act prior to its amendment.
In summary, K.S.A. 1985 Supp. 44-508, as amended by L. 1986,
ch. 189, §1, broadens the definition of "employer," and
"workman, employee or worker" for purposes of community
service work. This amendment to the Workmen's Compensation
Act allows offenders sentenced or assigned to community
service work to be covered by workers' compensation, during
the time they are performing community service work, if the
entity(ies) receiving or assigning such work so elect(s).
This opinion withdraws Attorney General Opinion No. 82-213,
which is inconsistent with this conclusion.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF KANSAS
Barbara P. Allen
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:JLM:BPA:crw

Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude

Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.