Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1986-143

1986-143Kanag

Texte intégral

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENER AL October 7, 1986
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 86- 143
The Honorable Robert F. Bennett
Johnson County Bank Building, 2nd Floor
5100 West 95th Street
Prairie Village, Kansas 66207
Re: State Departments; Public Officers and Employees --
Public Officers and Employees; Open Public Meetings
-- Attendance at Executive Sessions
Synopsis: Only the members of a public body have the right to
attend closed meetings of that body. Members of
the five advisory boards in Unified School District
No. 512, therefore, do not have the right to attend
executive sessions held by the board of education.
Advisory board members may attend such executive
- .':sessions upon invitation by the board of education
to prodeliberationsbody or participate
in its deliberationsinformation to attend merely as
observers to gather informaK.S.to aid them in
recommendations. Cited hereinK.S.A. 1985985
72-8121; 72-8122; 72-8123; 72-8134
K.S.A.41985 Supp. 75-4318; K.S.A.
• CcV
_- Ue:atDear	.Governor	,GDI:ipxnorBennett:
As chief legal counsel for the Johnson county school system,
Unified School District (U.S.D.) No. 512, you ask our opinion
concerning the Kansas Open Meetings Act (KOMA), K.S.A. 75-4317
et seq. Specifically, you ask whether members of the
district's advisory boards have the right to attend executive
sessions held by the board of education.
U.S.D. No. 512 was formed under a special act, K.S.A. 72-8121
et seq., which unifies five member districts. A
seven-member board of education governs the district.
K.S.A. 72-8122; 72-8123; 72-8205. K.S.A. 72-8134(a) provides
that each member district shall have a five-member advisory
board elected by the school patrons residing in that
district. The purpose of the five advisory boards is stated
as follows:
"The advisory board of each member
district shall serve to provide liaison
between the citizens of the member
district and the board of education of the
unified school district. Each advisory
board shall be responsible to make
recommendations to the board of education
on all matters relating to education
. . . . On or before December 1 of each
year each advisory board shall adopt its
recommendations with respect to curricula
and shall submit the same to the board of
education of the unified school district.
On or before February 1 of each year each
advisory board shall make its recommen-
dations on personnel and submit the same
to such board of education. Each advisory
board shall meet at least monthly at a
time and place determined by it . . . ."
K.S.A. 72-8134(b).
You inform us that a member of an advisory board wishes to be
admitted to lawfully closed meetings of the board of
education. It is contended that, since they are obligated by
law to make recommendations on all matters relating to
education, advisory board members hate the right to attend
executive sessions. The advisory board member maintains that
advisory boards are precluded from making proper
recommendations unless board members are privy to all
discussions had by the board of education in executive
sessions. It is also argued that advisory board members are
entitled to participate in closed meeting discussions and to
make recommendations to the board at that time.
Under the KOMA, meetings of public bodies must be open to the
public. K.S.A. 1985 Supp. 75-4318(b) lists six subjects
which the public body may discuss in private. These
exceptions to the open meetings principle "are founded on a
determination that the business conducted by the body is such
that the interests served by maintaining secrecy are more
important than those promoted by informing the public." Note,
Open Meetings Statutes: The Press Fights for the "Right to
Know", 75 Harv. L. Rev. 1199, 1206 (1962). The KOMA
states that "[u]pon formal motion made, seconded and
carried, all bodies and agencies subject to this act may
recess . . . for closed or executive meetings." K.S.A.
75-4319(a). The only persons who have the right to attend
executive sessions are the members of that particular public
body. Meetings of the advisory boards are subject to the
KOMA. See K.S.A. 1985 Supp. 75-4318. Members of the
advisory boards, however, are not members of the U.S.D. No.
512 board of education and thus have no right to attend
executive sessions held by the board of education.
We also note that advisory boards do not have the right to
make their recommendations in closed meetings. An executive
session may be called for this purpose if the subject of a
particular recommendation is listed in K.S.A. 75-4319(b). In
addition, it is not mandatory that these six subjects be
discussed behind closed doors. Only the board of education
may call an executive session of its body or it may choose to
discuss these subjects in the open meeting.
The open meetings law does not specifically state who may
attend closed meetings. At least two of the six subjects
authorized for discussion in executive session imply the
presence of persons other than members of the body. K.S.A.
75-4319(b)(2) (consultation with an attorney); K.S.A.
75-4319(b)(3) (matters relating to employer-employee
negotiations). In Attorney General Opinion No. 80-43 we
stated:
"So long as the procedural requirements of
that section are followed, the board may
include in its discussions in executive
session those persons selected by the
'board to be present. See Blum v. Board
of Zoning Appeals of North Hempstead,
149 N.Y.S. 2d 5, 8, 1 Misc. 2d 668
(1956), Thomas v. Board of Trustees, 215
N.E. 2d 434, 436, 5 Ohio App.2d 365
(1966)." Id. at 3.
Both cases cited therein defined an executive session as "one
from which the public is excluded and at which only such
selected persons as the board may invite are permitted to be
present."
In Attorney General Opinion.No. 82-176 we were asked whether a
school board's practice of permitting members of the news
media to be present during executive sessions was lawful. In
concluding that this practice was contrary to the spirit and
intent of the KOMA, we discussed which persons may properly
attend executive sessions.
"We think the statute [K.S.A. 75-4319]
generally permits public bodies to conduct
executive sessions as they see fit. Such
discretion to admit others is both
required and necessary in some instances
to facilitate the deliberations of the
body. This commonly occurs when the
non-members are persons who are
providing information to, and
participating in discussions with, the
members of the government bodies . . . .
However, we do not think the Act grants
unbridled discretion in this regard.
"In our judgment, the Act does not allow
persons to attend executive sessions
_merely as observers. In such a role, the
interests of the person or persons in
attendance is indistinguishable from those
of any other member of the public. Under
such circumstances, persons are not
admitted to the meeting to aid the
governing body in its deliberations.
Hence, the admission of some observers at
the exclusion of others transforms the
so-called executive session into a meeting
at which the public should have access.
"Therefore in our opinion, a public body
subject to the Kansas Open Meetings Act
may not permit individuals or special
interest groups, including members of the
media, to attend executive sessions as
mere observers while excluding the public
generally. Individuals may attend
executive sessions of government bodies
.subject to the Act upon invitation where
such persons are present to provide
information to the body or participate in
its deliberations but may not attend
merely as observers." Id. at 4, 5.
In conclusion, it is our opinion that only the members of a
public body have the right to attend closed meetings of that
body. Members of the five advisory boards in U.S.D. No. 512,
therefore, do not have the right to attend executive sessions
held by the board - of education. Advisory board members may
attend such executive sessions upon invitation by the board of
education to provide information to the body or participate in
its deliberations, but may not attend merely as observers to
gather information to aid them in making recommendations.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF KANSAS
Rita L. Noll
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:JLM:RLN:crw
4 4

Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude

Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.