Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1986-123

1986-123Kanag

Texte intégral

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL.
August 27, 1986
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 86-123
The Honorable Edward F. Reilly, Jr.
State Senator, Third District
430 Delaware, Box 9
Leavenworth, Kansas 66048
Re: Contracts and Promises--Funeral and Cemetery
Merchandise Agreements, Contracts and
Plans--Counselor's Commission
Synopsis: K.S.A. 1985 Supp. 16-301 regulates the payment
for funeral services and burial merchandise before
they are actually needed and received. It does not
preclude the contracting and payment for consulting
services which are rendered immediately. Thus, a
seller of merchandise or services is free to
immediately deliver consulting or planning
services, and receive payment in a lump sum or by
installments, notwithstanding the provisions of
K.S.A. 16-301 et seq., if a separate contract
is entered into providing for those services, and
for payment. Cited herein: K.S.A. 1985 Supp.
16-301; 16-320 et seq.; 16-321.
* *
Dear Senator Reilly:
You request our opinion regarding the applicability of K.S.A.
16-301 et seq. to a "counselor's commission" charged by
some sellers of funeral services and burial merchandise. An
explanation of the counselor's commission appears in your
request letter as follows:
"[The] amount is not considered to be part
of the payment for services or merchandise
required to be furnished by the funeral
home. The commission is designated as
nonrefundable and moneys paid under the
contract are to be credited to payment of
this commission prior to being credited to
the cost [of] services to be provided
under the contract."
It appears that the counselor's commission is for services
rendered immediately rather than at some time in the future.
This is an assumption upon which we base this opinion.
K.S.A. 1985 Supp. 16-301 provides, in part, as follows:
"Any agreement, contract or plan
requiring the payment of money in a lump
sum or installments which is made or
entered into with any person, association,
partnership, firm or corporation for the
final disposition of a dead human body, or
for funeral or burial services, or for
the furnishing of personal property or
funeral or burial merchandise, wherein
the delivery of the personal property or
the funeral or burial merchandise or the
furnishing of professional services by a
funeral director or embalmer is not
immediately required, is hereby declared
to be against public policy and void,
unless all money paid thereunder shall be
deposited in a bank, trust company or
savings and loan association which is
authorized to do business in this state
and insured by a federal agency, or
invested in a credit union which is
insured with an insurer or guarantee
corporation as required under K.S.A.
17-2246, and amendments thereto, all as
herein provided, and subject to the terms
of an agreement for the benefit of the
purchaser of the agreement, contract or
plan. . . ." (Emphasis added.)
The purpose of this statute was enunciated by the Kansas
Supreme Court in Lakeview Gardens, Inc. v. State, ex rel.
Schneider, 221 Kan. 211, 215 (1976):
"The concern of the legislature expressed
by this statute emanated from the
possibility for fraud which can arise from
sales of burial merchandise to young
persons where the purchase price is
collected long in advance of any actual
need for such merchandise. Because of the
time lag between the time of bargaining
and the time of performance requiring
delivery of the merchandise there are
hazards not present in ordinary retail
sales. Not only do such sales present
opportunities for fraud and deceit but
delivery of the merchandise may become
impossible of performance when a seller
has suffered economic woes and has gone
out of business. The purpose of requiring
that purchase price payments be held in
trust is to assure those who purchase
preneed caskets and burial merchandise
that they will have either the benefit of
their purchase, the merchandise, or their
money back at the time the need for the
merchandise occurs.
"The legislature did not restrict all
sales of caskets. It is only those sales
wherein the delivery of the casket is not
immediately required that fall within the
restriction. An intent to restrict all
preneed contracts for the sale of
caskets could have been clearly expressed
without reference to delivery, if such was
the intent of the legislature."
The court narrowed its discussion to the sale of caskets
(burial merchandise) because the facts before the court
specifically involved the sale of caskets. However, at the
time this case was decided K.S.A. 16-301 read virtually the
same as it does currently, providing that money paid for the
furnishing of professional services by a funeral director or
embalmer which are not immediately required, is to be placed
in deposit for future use. Thus, the reasoning of the court
applies equally to both the rendering of services and the
delivery of merchandise. The court in Lakeview, supra,
held that the cemetery corporation's contracts for the sale of
caskets did not fall within the purview of K.S.A. 16-301
because the caskets were delivered, albeit constructively,
immediately upon execution of the sale contract.
The same analysis may be used in the present inquiry. A
separate contract for consulting services contemplates the
immediate furnishing of such services. Thus, in light of
Lakeview, supra, the immediate furnishing of professional
planning services would render inapplicable the trust
requirements of K.S.A. 1985 Supp. 16-301. Conversely, any
services to be rendered by the seller in the future are
subject to the provisions of K.S.A. 1985 Supp. 16-301, and
moneys paid pursuant to contracts for such services are to be
placed in trust until those services are furnished.
This conclusion is not intended to allow the pre-need
sellers to circumvent the trust provisions of K.S.A. 16-301
et seq. You specifically ask whether the addition of
the counselor's commission to the cost of a pre-need contract
is permissible under K.S.A. 16-301 et seq. In our
judgment, it is permissible if all money paid under the
pre-need contract is deposited in trust.
K.S.A. 1985 Supp. 16-301 provides that any agreement,
contract or plan for burial merchandise or services to be
delivered in the future is void unless all money paid
thereunder is placed in trust. If the counselor's commission
is made a part of the pre-need contract, agreement or plan
which is covered by K.S.A. 16-301 et seq., then it is part
of "all money" paid under the contract, agreement or plan
which must be deposited. It is our opinion, therefore, that
sellers may require immediate payment or installment payments
for those counseling services immediately rendered, but this
may not be done in the pre-need contract, unless all money
is deposited in trust. For the seller to avoid trust
depositing of the counseling or planning fees, there would
have to be separate contracts, one for the services furnished
and merchandise delivered immediately, and one for the
services and merchandise to be delivered in the future. In
addition, if a pre-need contract covered by K.S.A. 16-301
et seq. provides for a credit or reduced price on the
total cost based on the payment of a separate counselor's
commission, the commission may again become part of the
"agreement, contract or plan" causing the counselor's
commission to be subject to the trusting requirements.
You further ask whether, if this charge is deemed permissible,
there is any limitation on the amount that may be charged.
None of the statutory language in K.S.A. 16-301 et seq.
restricts the amount which may be charged for funeral or
burial services and merchandise; nor do Kansas statutes
restrict charges for before-need or at-need professional
services and consulting. Thus, contract and consumer
protection laws, as well as ethical considerations, would have
to be applied, through a case-by-case analysis, to determine
whether prices charged were exorbitant or unconscionable.
Your final question is what difference there is between a
charge for immediate counseling services and the amount
cemetery corporations are allowed to retain prior to beginning
to trust funds under the provisions of K.S.A. 1985 Supp.
16-321(b). There is no statutory connection between the
provisions of K.S.A. 16-320 et seq., which provide for
trust arrangements for the sale of cemetery merchandise to be
delivered in the future, and the immediate furnishing of
counseling by a pre-need seller.
In conclusion, K.S.A. 1985 Supp. 16-301 regulates the payment
for funeral services and merchandise before they are actually
needed and received. It does not preclude the contracting and
payment for consulting services which are rendered
immediately. Thus, a pre-need seller is free to immediately
deliver those services, and receive payment in a lump sum or
by installment, notwithstanding the provisions of K.S.A.
16-301 et seq., if a separate contract is entered into
providing for those services, and for payment. If the payment
for consulting services is made part of the pre-need
contract, then all money paid thereunder must be deposited in
trust.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
Attorney General of Kansas
JuleneL.Miller
Deputy Attorney General
RTS:JLM:jm

Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude

Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.