Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1986-121

1986-121Kanag

Texte intégral

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTO RN EY G EN ERAL
August 22, 1986
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 86- 121
Charles A. Peckham
Rawlins County Attorney
Rawlins County Courthouse
Atwood, Kansas 67730
Re: Counties and County Officers -- County
Commissioners; Powers and Duties -- Vacancies;
Residence Requirements; Rearrangement of
Commissioner Districts
Synopsis: K.S.A. 19-202 requires each member of the board of
county commissioners to be a qualified elector and
a resident of the district within the county that
he or she represents. Such residency requirement
is a continuing, as well as a preliminary
qualification for the office. Accordingly, the
office of county commissioner automatically becomes
vacant upon the commissioner's moving to another
commissioner district, even if his or her new
residence is still located within the county in
which said commissioner was elected to serve.
Furthermore, a board of county commissioners has
the authority to rearrange its commissioner
districts by county resolution, as long as the
commissioners comply with the broad guidelines for
redistricting contained in K.S.A. 19-204 and Kansas
case law. The statute requires the board of
commissioners to divide the county into
commissioner districts which are "as compact and
equal in population as possible." Additionally,
the Kansas Supreme Court has imposed the
requirement that the integrity of the boundaries of
voting precincts be maintained. Absent an
intentional abuse of discretion, if a county
adheres to these guidelines in rearranging its
county commissioner districts, the commissioners
may re-draw the commissioner district boundary
lines as they see fit. Cited herein: K.S.A.
19-202; 19-204; 19-2608, repealed, L. 1976, ch.
129, §1; K.S.A. 1985 Supp. 77-201, as amended by L.
1986, ch. 211, §39; Gen. Stat. 1915, §2539; Kan.
Const., Art. 4, §2; Art. 5, §1.
Dear Mr. Peckham:
As Rawlins County Attorney, you request our opinion on two
questions regarding the residence requirements of county
commissioners, and the rearrangement of county commissioner
districts. Specifically, you inform us that one of the
Rawlins County Commissioners recently bought a house which
is outside his commissioner district, and that he intends to
move there in September. You inquire first whether his office
automatically becomes vacant upon his moving to another
commissioner district. Second, assuming his moving to another
district would result in a vacancy in the office, you inquire
whether the county commissioners may re-draw the
commissioner district boundary line in order to include the
new residence of the commissioner within his original
district, if the statutory requirements for equal population
are met.
In order to respond to your inquiry, it is necessary for us to
examine the statutes dealing with the powers and duties of
county commissioners. In your letter to this office, you note
that under the former K.S.A. 19-2608, it would appear that the
office would not become vacant as long as the commissioner did
not move from the county. Prior opinions of this office which
have addressed that proposition, up to but not including
Attorney General Opinion No. 79-267, were predicated on an
interpretation of K.S.A. 19-2608, and concluded that, under
the terms of that statute, a vacancy is not created on a board
of county commissioners when a commissioner changes his
residence from the district in which he was elected to another
district within the same county. However, in 1976 K.S.A.
19-2608 was repealed (L. 1976, ch. 129, §1), and the statutes
are now silent as to the effect a change of residence has on a
commissioner's continued qualification for office.
The Kansas Constitution provides at Article 4, §2:
"Not less than three county commissioners
shall be elected in each organized county
in the state, as provided by law."
County commissioners are elected pursuant to K.S.A. 19-202,
which in pertinent part provides:
"(a) The board of county commissioners of
each county - shall consist of three (3),
five (5) or seven (7) qualified electors.
"(b) One (1) county commissioner shall
reside in and represent each commissioner
district within the county." (Emphasis
added.)
The statute requires each member of the board of county
commissioners to be a qualified elector and a resident of the
district within the county that he or she represents. The
term "qualified elector" is defined in Article 5, Section 1 of
the Kansas Constitution, which provides in part:
"Every citizen of the United States who
has attained the age of eighteen years and
who resides in the voting area in which he
or she seeks to vote shall be deemed a
qualified elector."
It is clear that to be a qualified elector for the purposes of
voting at the election of county commissioners, a person must
reside in the appropriate county commissioner district. The
term "residence" is defined in K.S.A. 1985 Supp. 77-201,
twenty third, as amended by L. 1986, ch. 211, §39, which
provides:
"'Residence' means the place which is
adopted by a person as the person's place
of habitation and to which, whenever the
person is absent, the person has the
intention of returning."
The effect of residence on a county commissioner's
qualification for office was most recently considered in
Attorney General Opinions No. 76-203 and 79-267 (copies
enclosed). Opinion No. 76-203 was synopsized in part:
"Under K.S.A. 19-202, as amended by ch.
121, §2, L. 1976, a person elected to the
office of county commissioner may not
qualify and assume the duties of that
office unless and until that person
establishes residence in the commissioner
district which such person is elected to
represent." (Emphasis added.)
The synopsis to Opinion No. 79-267 reached a similar
conclusion, but went on to provide:
"Residence in that district must continue
throughout the term of office, and
failure of a person to maintain such
residency results in such person's
disqualification to hold the office of
county commissioner and creates a vacancy
therein." (Emphasis added.)
We agree with the conclusion reached in those two opinions,
and based upon the principles stated therein, as well as the
other previously enunciated considerations regarding
residency, it is our opinion that a person must be a resident
of the county commissioner district in which such person is
elected, in order to be qualified to serve as county
commissioner in that district. Furthermore, we believe that
such residency requirement is a continuing, as well as a
preliminary qualification for the office. See State, ex
rel., v. Stice, 186 Kan. 69 (1960); Bankers Service Life
Ins. Co. v. Sullivan, 188 Kan. 783 (1961); State v.
Bohannan, 421 P.2d 877 (1966); Phelps v. Shanahan,
210 Kan. 605 (1972). Accordingly, we conclude that the office
of county commissioner automatically becomes vacant upon the
commissioner's moving to another commissioner district, even
if his or her new residence is still located within the county
in which he or she was elected to serve.
Your second question assumes that moving to another
commissioner district would result in a vacancy in the office,
and inquires as to whether the county commissioners may
re-draw the commissioner district boundary line to include
the new residence of the commissioner within his original
district, if the statutory requirements for equal population
are met.
This particular question appears to be one of first impression
in Kansas. However, a recent Attorney General Opinion, No.
86-70, addressed the issue of whether a county has the
authority to rearrange its commissioner districts by county
resolution, thus shifting some electors from one commissioner
district to another, with the result that certain electors'
ability to vote or run for the office of county commissioner
is affected. The opinion was synopsized in part:
"The Leavenworth County Board of County
Commissioners has the authority to
rearrange its commissioner districts by
county resolution, as long as the
commissioners comply with the broad
guidelines for redistricting contained in
K.S.A. 19-204 and Kansas case law . . . ."
The opinion found that there are only two relevant factors to
be considered in determining whether the rearrangement of a
county's commissioner districts is legal. First, the
commissioners must comply with the broad guidelines for
redistricting contained in K.S.A. 19-204. That statute
provides at subsection (a):
"The board of county commissioners
shall, on the day of the organization of
the board or as soon thereafter as may be
possible, meet and divide the county into
three commissioner districts or such
number of districts as is prescribed by
resolution of the board, as compact and
equal in population as possible, and
number them, subject to alteration at
least once every three years." (Emphasis
added.)
Thus, the statute requires the board of commissioners to
divide the county into commissioner districts which are "as
compact and equal in population as possible." As stated in
the statute, the commissioner districts are subject to
rearrangement at least once every three years. In addition,
the Kansas Supreme Court has noted that, in the rearrangement
of commissioner districts, one other primary factor must be
kept in mind in addition to compactness and equality of
population. That is, in order to comply with the statutory
guidelines for redistricting, the integrity of the boundaries
of voting precincts must be maintained. Andrews v. Board of
County Commissioners, 207 Kan. 549 (1971).
The synopsis of Opinion No. 86-70 concluded:
"If a county adheres to these guidelines
in rearranging its county commissioner
districts, the fact that the redistricting
shifts some electors from one commissioner
district to another, with the result that
certain electors' ability to vote or run
for the office of county commissioner is
affected, will have no bearing on the
legality of-the-county resolution."
Opinion No. 86-70 found that a board of county commissioners
need only comply with the broad guidelines for redistricting
contained in K.S.A. 19-204 and Kansas case law, in order to
have the authority to rearrange its commissioner districts.
We agree with the conclusion reached in that opinion, and find
that, absent an intentional abuse of discretion, a board of
county commissioners may rearrange its commissioner districts
as it sees fit, as long as the broad guidelines for
redistricting are complied with. We feel this conclusion is
supported by decisions of the Kansas Supreme Court.
The State, ex rel., v. Osage County, 112 Kan. 256 (1922),
was an original proceeding in mandamus dealing with the issue
of redistricting. Plaintiffs brought suit after the board of
county commissioners acted upon the advice of the attorney
general and made an order redistricting the county. The
action, which was brought to compel a further redistricting,
was partially based on the claim that the order was
"capriciously and arbitrarily made for the purpose of
promoting the political interests of the present members of
the board." Id. at 258. In response to this allegation,
the Supreme Court of Kansas stared:
"The duty of determining how nearly the
proposed districts shall approximate
equality in population and compactness of
territory is vested in the board of county
commissioners. The real question for our
consideration is whether the order
redistricting the county was an abuse of
that discretion." State v. Osage
County, supra at 258. (Emphasis added.)
The court then quoted from Hayes v. Rogers, 24 Kan. 143, 258
(1880):
"'The statute gives the commissioners full
power to make the change . . . . Large
powers are in this respect intrusted to
them, as well as an almost unlimited
discretion.'" (Emphasis added.)
In dealing with the specific contention that the board acted
from personal and selfish motives in making the order and
redistricting the county in order to secure the reelection of
one of its members, the court stated:
"Commissioner districts are created merely
to define the territory from which the
voters are to select commissioners; they
have no functions to perform as
governmental agencies . . . . It is
within the power of the board to alter the
lines of a township at any time and
without a petition asking such action."
Hayes, supra at 263. (Emphasis added.)
The court concluded that the board of county commissioners was
authorized to rearrange the county's commissioner districts
even for purely political purposes, as long as the statutory
requirements of "as compact and equal in population as
possible" were met. ( Citing Gen. Stat. 1915, §2539.)
Accordingly, it would not issue the writ of mandamus to
control the discretion vested in the board, absent proof by
the plaintiff of an intentional abuse of discretion.
The most recent case in which the Kansas Supreme Court dealt
with the issue of redistricting was the 1971 case of Andrews
v. Board of County Commissioners, 207 Kan. 547. In that
case, appellants' claims on appeal were first, that the
statutory requirements as to compactness and equality of
population had not been met, and second, that the commissioner
districts were gerrymandered to prevent the citizens of
Arkansas City from electing more than one county commissioner.
In dealing with the first claim, the court emphasized that
what has been declared as the policy of the federal courts
regarding reapportionment (i.e. "one man, one vote"), has
long been recognized as the policy of the state courts, via
K.S.A. 19-204. That is, when called upon, the Kansas courts
have consistently enforced the requirement of the statute that
each county be rearranged into commissioner districts which
are "as compact and equal in population as possible." This
decision reiterated the court's long-standing policy that
county commissioner districts can divide a city and still meet
the statutory requirement of compactness. Furthermore, in
order to comply with the statutory guidelines for
redistricting, the court stated it must consider not only the
requirement of compactness, but also the requirement that the
integrity of the boundaries of voting precincts be maintained.
In examining the charges of gerrymandering, the court stated:
"In the absence of evidence of improper
motives on their part(,) a plan which
meets the statutory requirements of
compactness and equality of population
without violating the integrity of voting
precincts should be approved, for no abuse
of discretion on the part of the board can
be presumed." Andrews, supra at 554.
The court emphasized that abuse of discretion must always be
clearly established by those attacking the results of
discretionary action of a governing body in order to establish
the unreasonableness of the action. [Bodine v. City of
Overland Park, 198 Kan. 371 (1967); Creten v. Board of
County Commissioners, 204 Kan. 782 (1970):i. Taking into
consideration its previous conclusions as to the compactness
and equality of population in the commissioner districts, the
court found the claim of gerrymandering to be without
substantial merit.
In the absence of evidence of improper motives on the part of
county commissioners, the Supreme Court of Kansas has
consistently refused to interfere with the discretion vested
in the board by the legislature to determine how boundary
lines for county commissioner districts shall be drawn. In
our opinion, the question of whether there has been an abuse
of discretion can only be determined by a court of law. In
that no abuse of discretion on the part of the board can be
presumed, we believe that a county plan for redistricting
which meets the statutory requirements of compactness and
equality of population, and which allows the integrity of the
boundaries of voting precincts to be maintained, should be
allowed to stand.
In summary, K.S.A. 19-202 requires each member of the board of
county commissioners to be a qualified elector and a resident
of the district within the county that he or she represents.
Such residency requirement is a continuing, as well as a
preliminary qualification for the office. Accordingly, the
office of county commissioner automatically becomes vacant
upon the commissioner's moving to another commissioner
district, even if his or her new residence is still located
within the county in which said commissioner was elected to
serve.
Furthermore, a board of county commissioners has the authority
to rearrange its commissioner districts by county resolution,
as long as the commissioners comply with the broad guidelines
for redistricting contained in K.S.A. 19-204 and Kansas case
law. The statute requires the board of commissioners to
divide the county into commissioner districts which are "as
compact and equal in population as possible." Additionally,
the Kansas Supreme Court has imposed the requirement that the
integrity of the boundaries of voting precincts be
maintained. Absent an intentional abuse of discretion, if a
county adheres to these guidelines in rearranging its county
commissioner districts, the commissioners may re-draw the
commissioner district boundary lines as they see fit.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF KANSAS
Barbara P. Allen
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:JLM:BPA:crw

Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude

Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.