Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1986-095

1986-095Kanag

Texte intégral

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
AT TORNEY GENERAL June 30, 1986
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 86- 95
The Honorable Henry M. Helgerson, Jr.
State Representative, Eighty-Sixth District
4009 Hammond Drive
Wichita, Kansas 67218
Re: Automobiles and Other Vehicles--Miscellaneous
Provisions--Kansas Safety Belt Use Act
Synopsis: The purpose of the Safety Belt Use Act is to
educate rather than punish. However, law
enforcement officers should not be constrained
from enforcing the act within the bounds of its
provisions. When an officer can articulate facts
which would lead a cautious person to believe
that a violation has occurred, a citation may
then issue. Drivers are not to be cited for
violations committed by passengers. Any person
10 or more years of age may be held responsible
for failure to fasten their safety belt. Cited
herein: K.S.A. 1985 Supp. 8-1344; 8-1345;
K.S.A. 8-2101; K.S.A. 1985 Supp. 21-3105; 38-
1602, K.S.A. 41-2719; L. 1986, ch. 35, §§3, 4.
Dear Representative Helgerson:
You have requested our opinion regarding the Kansas Safety
Belt Use Act, L. 1986, ch. 35. Specifically, you inquire
into matters pertaining to citation procedures as well as a
driver's responsibility for violations of the act committed
by his passenger(s).
In response to your query regarding what observations an
officer must make before issuing a citation, we note that
enforcement must reflect the act's legislative history and
purpose. The Kansas Safety Belt Use Act originated as S.B.
520, died in house committee, and was reintroduced as H.B.
3160, with amendments not pertinent to your inquiry. The
purpose of the law is to educate rather than punish
motorists. Bob W. Storey, proponent of S.B. 520 and
representing Traffic Safety Now, a non-profit corporation,
testified in the Committee on Transportation and Utility
hearings:
"Bear in mind here that the purpose of
this law is not to punish people for not
wearing safety belts, but to make them
aware of the importance of a safety-
belt law, and to educate adults and
minors to use their safety belts at all
times while operating a vehicle."
Comm. Trans. and Util., minutes,
February 13, 1986, Att. 1, p.8.
This legislative purpose is evident in the provisions of the
law as enacted. The secretary of transportation is to
initiate an educational program to encourage safety belt
usage. L. 1986, ch. 35, §3(c). Also, the enforcement
procedures of the act are secondary to other offenses. L.
1986, ch. 35, §3(e) states in relevant part:
"Law enforcement officers shall not stop
drivers for violations of this act in the
absence of another violation of law."
This section further provides that a citation must be issued
for the primary violation before a citation for violating the
safety belt use act may be issued. This legislative purpose
of educating motorists to use safety belts should be taken
into consideration by law enforcement officers.
A violation of the act occurs when a front seat occupant of
a passenger vehicle which was manufactured with safety belts
fails to have a safety belt properly fastened about the
person's body at all times while the vehicle is in motion.
L. 1986, ch. 35, §3(a). Until July 1, 1987, officers are
to issue warning citations for violations of the act. After
that date, violators are subject to fines of up to $10
including court costs.
It is our opinion that a citation may be issued in the
officer's discretion when facts can be articulated which
would lead a reasonable and prudent person to believe that an
occupant was in violation of the act. Your concern regarding
motorists who buckle up or unbuckle prior to an officer
approaching the vehicle can only be dealt with on a case-by-
case basis. Controversies of whether or not the person was
wearing the safety belt while the vehicle was in motion
become questions of fact. In short, law enforcement officers
should not be constrained from issuing citations within the
provisions of the act.
You have also requested our opinion regarding to whom a
citation is to be issued when a passenger is in violation of
the act. There is no question that a passenger may be issued
a citation for failing to have a safety belt properly
fastened about the body while the vehicle is in motion. The
statute provides in relevant part:
"[P]ersons violating subsection (a) of
section 3 shall be fined not more than
$10 including court costs." L. 1986,
ch. 35, §4(a)(2).
A more difficult question arises, however, in determining
whether or not a driver is also responsible for a passenger's
violation. Applying rules of strict construction, there is
no statutory authority for issuing citations to drivers for
passengers' violations of the act. In State v. Thompson,
237 Kan. 562 (1985), it was noted that in strictly
construing penal statutes, "[t]he statute should not be read
to add that which is not readily found therein or to read out
what, as a matter of ordinary English language, is contained
therein." 237 Kan. at 566.
In State v. Erbacher, 8 Kan. App.2d 169 (1982), it
was held that a passenger, as well as a driver, could be
found guilty for violations of the Open Container of Cereal
Malt Beverage Law, K.S.A. 41-2719. The court construed the
language "no person shall transport" to be broad enough to
include passengers. Using the rules of strict construction,
it was stated that "ordinary words are to be given their
ordinary meaning; it does not permit or justify a disregard
of manifest legislative intention appearing from plain and
unambiguous language." (Emphasis added.) 8 Kan. App.2d
at 170. In K.S.A. 41-2719, there was a manifest legislative
intent to prohibit the presence of open containers as an
indirect method of preventing intoxication of drivers. 8
Kan. App.2d at 170.
Conversely, the terms of the Safety Belt Use Act do not
indicate a manifest legislative intent that drivers should be
responsible for passengers' violations. We do not believe
that the terms are broad enough to offer such a
construction. In unambiguous terms, a violation occurs when
an occupant fails to have a safety belt properly fastened.
Persons who violate the act, i.e. those who fail to have a
safety belt properly fastened, shall be fined.
No doubt, the legislature could have required that drivers
ensure passengers' compliance with the act . For example,
the Uniform Act Regulating Traffic, K.S.A. 8-2101 et
seq., plainly permits an imputation of guilt to another:
"Every person who . . . permits or
directs another to violate any provision
of this act is likewise guilty of such
offense." K.S.A. 8-2101.
However, the Safety Belt Use Act lacks the unequivocal
language contained in the Uniform Act Regulating Traffic. In
our opinion, for the reasons stated herein, drivers may not
be issued citations for violations committed by passengers.
You have further queried whether the age of the passenger
violator has an affect on who receives the citation.
Consistent with our opinion that drivers are not responsible
for violations of passengers, it is also our opinion that
there is no manifest legislative intent to make adults
responsible for violations committed by minors. The Safety
Belt Use Act lacks the statutory language and manifest intent
of the Child Passenger Safety Act, K.S.A. 1985 Supp. 8-1344
et seq. which provides:
"It shall be unlawful for any parent or
legal guardian of a child under the age
of four years to violate the provisions
of K.S.A. 8-1344, and amendments thereto
[which requires the use of an approved
child restraint when transporting such
child in the front seat area], and upon
conviction shall be punishable by fine of
$10 per occurrence." K.S.A. 1985 Supp.
8-1345.
The Safety Belt Use Act does apply, however, to minors who
are 10 years of age and older. K.S.A. 1985 Supp. 21-3105
provides that crimes which are not felonies or traffic
infractions listed in K.S.A. 1984 Supp. 8-2118(c) are
misdemeanors. In that a violation of the Safety Belt Use Act
is not a felony nor listed in K.S.A. 1984 Supp. 8-2118(c)
as a traffic infraction, such a violation is a misdemeanor.
The Kansas Juvenile Offenders Code [K.S.A. 1985 Supp. 38-
1601 et seq.] defines "juvenile offender" as a juvenile
who commits a misdemeanor [K.S.A. 1985 Supp. 38-1602(b)]
but does not include a person who is 14 or more years of age
and who commits a traffic offense in violation of chapter 8
of the Kansas Statutes Annotated [K.S.A. 1985 Supp. 38-
1602(b)(1).] A juvenile is defined in K.S.A. 1985 Supp. 38-
1602(a) as a person 10 or more years of age. K.S.A. 1985
Supp. 8-2117 authorizes a court of competent jurisdiction
to adjudicate persons 14 or more years of age who have
committed traffic offenses. Therefore, persons who are 10
years of age or older but less than 14 years of age are to be
prosecuted under the Kansas Juvenile Offenders Code, and
persons 14 years or older are to be prosecuted in a court of
competent jurisdiction.
In conclusion, we are of the opinion that law enforcement
officers may issue a citation when facts can be articulated
which lead a cautious person to believe that a violation of
the act has occurred. Drivers are not to be cited for
violations committed by passengers. In addition, any person
10 or more years of age may be held responsible for failure
to fasten their safety belt.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
Attorney General of Kansas
Julene L. Miller
Deputy Attorney General
RTS:JLM:jm

Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude

Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.