Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1986-090

1986-090Kanag

Texte intégral

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL. June 17, 1986
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 86- 90
Greg A. Bengtson
City Attorney
129 S. 8th, P.O. Box 380
Salina, Kansas 67402-0380
Re: Constitution of the State of Kansas--
Corporations--Cities' Powers of Home Rule
Synopsis: An ordinance which authorizes a local human
relations commission to award compensatory and
punitive damages in a discrimination case is
incidental to effectuation of a public purpose,
i.e. the elimination of discrimination within a
community, and constitutes a valid exercise of city
home rule powers. While a local human relations
commission lacks standing in district court to
enforce such an award, a victim of discrimination
may file suit for enforcement in district court.
Cited herein: K.S.A. 1985 Supp. 44-1005; K.S.A.
44-1011; 60-217; K.S.A. 1985 Supp. 60-2101(d);
Kan. Const., Art. 12, .55.
Dear Mr. Bengtson:
You request our opinion concerning enforcement of an order of
the Salina Human Relations Commission which awards monetary
damages in a discrimination case. You indicate that Salina
Code Section 13-58(13) confers authority on the Human
Relations Commission to award such damages, and that in a
recent case the Commission made such an award to the
complainant. However, the respondent has refused to comply
with the order, and you pose several questions concerning
enforcement of it.
You first ask whether the Salina Human Relations Commission
can pursue a lawsuit in Saline County District Court seeking
to enforce the order. In this regard, we note that it is a
well settled principle that municipalities may, in the
exercise of their home rule power as provided by Kan.
Const., Art. 12, §5, establish human relations agencies.
Hutchinson Human Relations Comm. v. Midland Credit
Management, Inc., 213 Kan. 308, 313 (1973). State
provisions, establishing the Kansas Commission on Civil Rights
(K.C.C.R.) which in effect are parallel to many local civil
rights ordinances, are not preemptive. 213 Kan. at 315. It
is also clear that a local commission may bring an action in
district court for specific performance of a conciliation
agreement. H.H.R.C. v. Midland, supra.
However, while K.S.A. 1985 Supp. 60-2101(d) confers
authority on district courts to hear appeals of final orders
made by municipal agencies, and K.S.A. 44-1011 confers
authority on the K.C.C.R. to file suit in district court to
enforce its final orders [including awards of damages for
pain, suffering and humiliation not exceeding $2000 (see
K.S.A. 1985 Supp. 44-1005(d)], no statute confers standing
on a local human relations agency to file suit to enforce an
award of monetary damages entered by the agency in a
discrimination case. In this regard, K.S.A. 60-217 provides
that every action shall be prosecuted in the name of the real
party in interest, and the Kansas Supreme Court has indicated
that a local commission does not have standing to file suit
for monetary damages:
"We do not view the Commission as being an
aggrieved person in the context of this
case, or in the sense of having suffered
an injury or wrong compensable in
dollars. It is difficult for us to
conjure up a basis for monetary damages so
far as the Commission is concerned, and
its counsel was unable, at oral argument,
to assist us greatly in this respect."
H.H.R.C. v. Midland, supra at 316.
Accordingly, it is our opinion that a local human relations
commission lacks standing to enforce an award of monetary
damages which it has entered in favor of a complainant in a
discrimination case.
You next ask whether amendment of the Salina Code to include
a provision similar to K.S.A. 44-1011 would provide a means of
enforcement of the Human Relations Commission Order. In this
regard, it is our opinion that the rules of standing
prescribed by K.S.A. 60-217 may be modified only by enactments
of the state legislature; cities, even in the exercise of
their extensive home rule powers, lack authority to legislate
on the subject of standing in district court, as such is not a
matter of local concern within the meaning of Article 12,
Section 5 of the Kansas Constitution.
Your final question is "whether Salina Code Section 13-
58(13) authorizing the Salina Human Relations Commission to
award compensatory and punitive damages represents an
enforceable exercise of home rule powers." In response, we
note that while the Kansas Supreme Court has not spoken on
this issue, it has been addressed by Professor Barkley Clark
in the comprehensive article State Control of Local
Government in Kansas: Special Legislation and Home Rule, 20
Kan. L. Rev. 631, 676. In that article, Professor Clark
indicates that the "local affairs and government" language of
the home rule amendment could be invoked to limit some
municipal attempts to enact "private law" (i.e. ordinances
which regulate private legal relationships). However, he also
states that if an ordinance's "impact on 'private' law is
merely incidental to effectuation of a public purpose, it
might well stand." Id. In our judgment, an ordinance which
authorizes a local human relations commission to award
compensatory and punitive damages in a discrimination case is
incidental to effectuation of a public purpose, i.e. the
elimination of discrimination within a community, and
constitutes a valid exercise of city home rule powers.
However, as indicated above, in the event the respondent
refuses to comply with an order awarding damages (and does not
appeal the order to district court), the rules of standing
require that the complainant, not the local human relations
commission, enforce the award in district court.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
Attorney General of Kansas
Terrence R. Hearshman
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:JLM:TRH:jm

Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude

Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.