Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1986-066

1986-066Kanag

Texte intégral

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL
May 2, 1986
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 86- 66
Marvin S. Steinert
Commissioner
Savings and Loan Department
503 Kansas Avenue, Room 220
Topeka, Kansas 66603
Re: Corporations -- Savings and Loan; Miscellaneous --
Effect of Repeal of K.S.A. 17-5815 Upon Claimants
of an Insolvent Savings and Loan Association
Synopsis: Since K.S.A. 17-5815 was repealed in 1983, before
any distributions were made to any of the priority
3 or 4 claimants the statute had spoken to, K.S.A.
17-5815, as repealed, is construed neither
prospectively nor retrospectively in this fact
situation. In absence of any state law on this
point, federal law dictates priority status to all
category 3 and 4 claimants of this insolvent
savings and loan association in receivership.
Cited herein: K.S.A. 17-5815, as repealed by L.
1983, ch. 86, §5; 17-5824; 12 C.F.R. 569a.7(a)(1)
through (4); 1983 Senate Bill No. 55.
Dear Commissioner Steinert:
As Savings and Loan Commissioner for the State of Kansas, you
request our opinion on a question concerning the effect of
K.S.A. 17-5815, and its 1983 repeal, upon general unsecured
creditors and savings and checking account depositors and the
F.S.L.I.C. Specifically, you inquire whether the repealed
statute should be construed prospectively or retrospectively.
K.S.A. 17-5815 concerned priority of shares and savings
deposits upon liquidation, stating:
"Shares of an association and savings
deposits of a deposit association will, in
the event of voluntary or involuntary
liquidation, dissolution or winding up of
an association or a deposit association,
or in the event of any other situation in
which the priority of such savings
deposits or shares is in controversy,
have, to the extent of their withdrawable
value, the same priority as general
creditors of the association not having
priority over other general creditors of
the association." (Emphasis added.)
The Kansas Legislature later enacted K.S.A. 17-5824, effective
1980, which provides in part:
"Every savings and loan association
organized and operating under the laws of
the state of Kansas shall, on and after
June 30, 1980, insure the shares or
deposits of each shareholder or depositor
of such association with the federal
savings and loan insurance corporation or
with an insurer approved by the state
commissioner of insurance for such
purposes as hereinafter provided . . •
The enactment of K.S.A. 17-5824 rendered K.S.A. 17-5815
surplusage, in that the depositors under K.S.A. 17-5815 were
now fully insured and no longer had to "stand in line" with
general creditors during a defunct savings and loan
receivership. Accordingly, the 1983 Kansas Legislature, with
Senate Bill No. 55, repealed K.S.A. 17-5815 in a "clean-up"
addendum to the body of the bill itself. A reading of the
bill, as well as the minutes of the March 17, 1983 meeting of
the House Committee on Commercial and Finance Institutions,
reveals no legislative intent or remarks whatsoever pertaining
to K.S.A. 17-5815, lending further credence to the surplusage
status of K.S.A. 17-5815 after 1980 and its subsequent 1983
"clean-up."
A statute, in absence of clear legislative expression to the
contrary, is presumed to operate prospectively. Ohio
Casualty Insurance Company v. State Farm Automobile Insurance
Company, 601 F. Supp. 345 (D. Kan. 1985). However, purely
procedural statutes which do not affect substantive rights are
ordinarily given retrospective application. Tew v. City of
Topeka Police and Fire Civil Service Commission, 237 Kan. 96
(1985).
In the instant case, however, neither retrospective nor
prospective application of K.S.A. 17-5815 applies.
Retrospectively, no distributions were made to priority 3 or 4
claimants before the 1983 repeal of K.S.A. 17-5815 (which
statute placed category 3 and 4 claimants on the "same
priority"). There is of course no prospective application of
a repealed statute, especially when no substantive rights have
vested in any affected parties.
No money was distributed to priority 3 or 4 claimants prior to
repeal of the state statute that prioritized their status.
Money distributions first occurred in 1985, when applicable
law placed priority 3 claimants ahead of priority 4
claimants. Whether any moneys had been distributed to
priority 1 or 2 claimants is irrelevant, as K.S.A. 17-5815
addressed only priority 3 and 4 claimants.
To analogize, the "bowl of spaghetti" never reached the end of
the table that claimants 3 and 4 were seated at before their
chairs were moved. Had claimants 3 or 4 had one "forkful of
money" when they were of the "same priority" per K.S.A. 17-
5815, their status would have been substantively vested, and
"same priority" would have dictated their shares of monetary
distribution. However, their "chairs" were moved from "side-
by-side" to "claimant 3 seated before claimant 4" by the time
the money was distributed to them in 1985. Claimant 3 now
"dishes up" at 100 cents on the dollar, with claimant 4
getting the remainder of the money, per federal law as
outlined below.
Since the applicable state law has been repealed, federal
rules dictate claim prioritization as follows:
"(a) Claims against the receivership,
except for claims specified in paragraphs
(b), (c), and (d) of this section shall
have the following order of priority:
"(1) All costs, expenses, and debts of the
receivership incurred on or after the date
of the appointment of the Receiver;
"(2) All claims of creditors, including
contractual claims for interest to the
date of payment, to the extent that under
the laws of the State in which the
principal office of the institution in
receivership is located such creditor
claims are secured by, or constitute a
lien on, assets or property of any kind of
the institution in receivership;
"(3) All claims of general creditors,
and the unsecured portion of any creditor
obligation under subparagraph (2) of this
paragraph, valid as such under the laws of
the State in which home office of the
institution in receivership is located,
including contractual claims for interest
to the date of default;
"(4) All claims of holders of checking
and savings accounts, and/or the Federal
Savings and Loan Insurance Corporation to
the extent it has paid insurance to
holders of such accounts, which under the
laws of the State in which the principal
office of the institution in receivership
is located are given a priority for
liquidation purposes over other classes of
such accounts; except that whenever under
the laws of the State in which the
principal office of the institution in
receivership is located such claims are
treated on a parity with general creditor
obligations upon the liquidation of the
institution, such claims will be treated
as general creditor obligations under
subparagraph (3) of this paragraph;" 12
C.F.R. 569a 7(a)(1)-(4). (Emphasis added.)
Thus, since K.S.A. 17-5815 was repealed in 1983, before any
distributions were made to any of the priority 3 or 4
claimants the statute had spoken to, K.S.A. 17-5815, as
repealed, is construed neither prospectively nor
retrospectively in this fact situation. In absence of any
state law on this point, federal law dictates priority status
to all category 3 and 4 claimants of this insolvent savings
and loan association in receivership.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF KANSAS
Thomas Lietz
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:JLM:TL:crw

Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude

Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.