Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1986-060

1986-060Kanag

Texte intégral

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL April 22, 1986
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 86- 60
The Honorable Wint Winter, Jr.
State Senator, Second District
Capitol Building, Room 120-S
Topeka, Kansas 66612
Re: Corporations -- Miscellaneous Provisions --
Reservation of Exclusive Right to Corporate Name;
Reservation of the Name "Kansas, Inc."
Synopsis: Reservation of the name "Kansas, Inc." for a
corporate name does not preclude the legislature
from using this name in 1986 House Bill No. 2960.
K.S.A. 17-7402 prevents other corporations from
registering with the Secretary of State under names
that have been reserved. The fact that Kansas,
Inc. has been reserved as the official name of a
future corporation is of no consequence because the
entity created by H.B. 2960 is in fact an agency of
the state and is not required to register as a
corporation. In addition, corporate name
reservation does not prevent another entity from
using that name outside its official registration.
Furthermore, the right to the name "Kansas," used
alone without any descriptive words, belongs to the
people of the state. A private corporation,
therefore, cannot adopt the name "Kansas, Inc." as
such use would be in derogation of existing public
rights to that name. Cited herein: K.S.A. 1985
Supp. 17-6002; K.S.A. 17-7402.
Dear Senator Winter:
You have requested our opinion regarding the reservation of
the exclusive right to the proposed corporate name "Kansas,
Inc." You ask whether the attempt to reserve this name for a
future corporation precludes the use of that name by the
Kansas Legislature in 1986 House Bill No. 2960.
K.S.A. 17-7402 provides, in pertinent part, as follows:
"The exclusive right to the use of a
corporate name may be reserved by: (a)
Any person intending to organize a
corporation under this act;
"The reservation shall be made by filing
with the secretary of state an application
to reserve a specific corporate name,
executed by the applicant. If the
secretary of state finds that the name is
available for corporate use, he shall
reserve the same for the exclusive use of
the applicant for a period of one hundred
twenty (120) days.
"The right to exclusive use of a specified
corporate name, so reserved, may be
transferred to any other person or
corporation by filing in the office of the
secretary of state, a notice of such
transfer, executed by the applicant for
whom the name was reserved, and specifying
the name and address of the transferee."
You inform us that on April 1, 1986, a member of the Kansas
House of Representatives filed an application with the
Secretary of State reserving the name "Kansas, Inc." The
state representative, an attorney, apparently made the filing
on behalf of a client.
Introduced on February 12, 1986, House Bill No. 2960 is one
among several pieces of legislation concerning economic
development still pending before the legislature. This bill
is presently in a conference committee. House Bill No. 2960
was first amended by the House Committee on Ways and Means to
reflect the recommendations of the Joint Legislative
Commission on Economic Development to create an entity to
replace the existing advisory commission to the Department of
Economic Development. The entity created by the proposed
legislation is to be "a body politic and corporate." (1986
H.B. 2960, Sec. 2.) The bill also states that the entity
constitutes "a public instrumentality and the exercise of the
authority and powers confined by this act shall be deemed and
held to be the performance of an essential governmental
function." (1986 H.B. 2960, Sec. 2.)
According to the Legislative Research Department, the intent
of the Joint Commission was to create a quasi-public
corporation similar to the Kansas Turnpike Authority. The
name of the entity was originally proposed as "Kansas, Inc.,"
but was changed by amendment of the Senate on final action
when it was learned that the name had been reserved for use as
a corporate name.
The Kansas statutes governing formation of a corporation,
including corporate name reservation, are patterned after the
Model Business Corporations Act. 1 Model Business
Corporations Act Annotated §1.01, p. 5 (3rd ed. 1985).
When an application for reservation of a particular name is
filed pursuant to K.S.A. 17-7402, the applicant has the right
to exclusive use of that name for 120 days, provided that the
secretary of state determines that the name is available for
corporate use. The duty imposed on the secretary of state is
ministerial in nature; if no other corporate entity is
registered by the submitted name, the applicant is
automatically granted exclusive use of that name. 18A
Am.Jur.2d Corporations §281, p. 194. "Exclusive use" means
that for that time period no other entity can register under
the name reserved by the applicant. The purpose of allowing a
proposed corporation to reserve a name has been stated as
follows:
"The 'reservation; of a corporate name is
basically a device to simplify the
formation of a new corporation . . . . By
reserving a name, the persons considering
the formation . . . of [a] corporation can
order stationery, prepare documents, etc.
on the assumption that the reserved name
will be available." 1 Model Business
Corporations Act Annotated §4.02, p. 259
(3d ed. 1985).
The articles of incorporation of a proposed corporation must
include the information specified in K.S.A. 1985 Supp. 17-
6002. This statute imposes two requirements on the selection
of a corporate name: (1) the name must include one of the
words listed under the subsection, and (2) the name must be
distinguishable from the names of other corporations and
partnerships organized, reserved, or registered with the
state. K.S.A. 1985 Supp. 17-6002(a)(1).
The requirement under the Model Act and K.S.A. 1985 Supp.
17-6002(a)(1) that the name of the corporation stated in the
articles of incorporation be sufficiently distinctive is only
to ensure that the new corporation can be distinguished from
other corporations upon the records of the Secretary of
State. The corporation code, therefore, does not affect
common law rights to the use of the name.
"The general business corporation statute
should not be a partial substitute for a
general assumed name, unfair competition,
or antifraud statute. As a result, the
Model Act does not restrict the power of a
corporation to adopt or use an assumed or
fictitious name with the same freedom as
an individual or impose a requirement that
an 'official' name not be 'deceptively
similar' to another corporate name . . . .
Principles of unfair competition, not the
business corporation act, provide the
limits on the competitive use of similar
names." 1 Model Business Corporations
Act Annotated §4.01, p. 242 (3d ed.
1985). (Emphasis added.)
Case law, primarily in the area of trademark law, has firmly
established the following principle:
"[I]ncorporation under a specified name
in a state does not give the new company
the right to use that name in that state
or anywhere else, in derogation of the
existing rights of other parties." George
Gottlieb, "Corporate Name Clearance -
Potential Trademark Trouble Spot," The
Business Lawyer, Vol. 33 p. 2263, July
1978.
Thus, the fact of incorporation under a given name is not the
equivalent of the right to use that name. Reservation of a
corporate name only precludes other entities from registering
with the state under that name.
1986 House Bill No. 2960, as amended, would create an
organization for the purpose of performing "essential
governmental function[s]." (1986 H.B. 2960, Sec. 2.) Even
though the name has been reserved for corporate use, it is our
opinion that the legislature is not precluded from naming the
proposed entity "Kansas, Inc." K.S.A. 17-7402 prevents
other corporations from registering with the secretary of
state under names that have been reserved. The entity created
by H.B. 2960 is referred to as a "quasi-public corporation."
This proposed entity, however, is not organized pursuant to
the corporation statutes but is in fact an agency of the state
created by a legislative act. Reservation of the name
"Kansas, Inc." is of no consequence as the entity created by
H.B. 2960 is not required to be registered with the Secretary
of State. Also, name reservation of a proposed corporation
does not prevent another entity from using that name, only
from registering under it. Furthermore, as will be discussed
below, a private corporation cannot use a name in derogation
of existing public rights to that name.
In addition to statutory requirements governing incorporation,
the courts have recognized common-law restrictions on the
selection of a corporate name. For example, it has been held
that "a corporation should not be permitted to adopt a name
which all citizens are untitled to use . . . ." 18 C.J.S.
Corporations §167a, p. 563. In In re We Americans, Inc., 2
N.Y.S.2d 235 (1938), a certificate of incorporation was
submitted for approval by six private citizens who wished to
incorporate an organization under the name "We Americans,
Inc." In disapproving the name, the court stated:
"All the citizens of these United States
are entitled to the use of the term 'We
Americans' and no group should be
permitted to incorporate it as their
exclusive designation." Id. at 236.
For the same reasons, the court in Application of Williams,
95 N.Y.S.2d 177 (1950), did not allow the name "Americans
against Communism" to be used for a proposed corporation.
All persons part of a large group designated by a broad term
such as "Americans" or "Kansas" should have the right to use
that term. Therefore, a corporation formed by one person or a
small group of private citizens should not be permitted to
adopt the name "Kansas, Inc." as its official designation.
Another recognized common-law restriction is that in adopting
a name a corporation cannot "appropriate to its exclusive use
geographical words . . . which anyone may lawfully use
. . . ." 18 C.J.S. Corporations §167 c(1), p. 564. See 18A
Am.Jur.2d Corporations §294, p. 206; 1 Thompson on
Corporations §89, pp. 103-04. The word "Kansas" was
officially proclaimed 125 years ago to designate a particular
geographical area as the thirty-fourth state of the United
States. It would follow, then, that the word Kansas should
not be appropriated by a private corporation for its exclusive
use.
Proposed corporate names have also been disapproved on the
basis that the name would cause confusion and mislead the
public. For example, in In re New York State Voters League,
157 N.Y.S. 2d 210 (1956), the court refused to approve the
name "New York State Voters League, Inc." because the
impression was given that the private organization was an
official function and arm of the state. See In re World's
Fair Information & Service Club, Inc., 297 N.Y.S. 922
(1937).
Many corporations registered in this state contain the word
"Kansas" as one of the words in their official corporate
name. The other descriptive words in their title
distinguishes the particular corporation from others listed in
the records of the secretary of state. Used alone, "Kansas"
names a state -- a specific governmental unit and particular
political subdivision. The right to use the name Kansas is a
prior right which belongs to the people of this state and
therefore should not be permitted to be used as the official
name of a private corporation.
In conclusion, it is our opinion that reservation of the name
"Kansas, Inc." for a corporate name does not preclude the
legislature from using this name in 1986 House Bill No. 2960.
K.S.A. 17-7402 prevents other corporations from registering
with the Secretary of State under names that have been
reserved. The fact that Kansas, Inc. has been reserved as the
official name of a future corporation is of no consequence
because the entity created by H.B. 2960 is in fact an agency
of the state and is not required to register as a
corporation. In addition, corporate name reservation does not
prevent another entity from using that name outside its
official registration. Furthermore, the right to the name
"Kansas," used alone without any descriptive words, belongs to
the people of the state. A private corporation, therefore,
cannot adopt the name "Kansas, Inc." as such use would be in
derogation of existing public rights to that name.
Very truly yours
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF KANSAS
Rita L. Noll
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:JLM:RLN:crw

Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude

Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.