Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1986-027

1986-027Kanag

Texte intégral

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL
February 28, 1986
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 86-27
Thomas D. Borniger
Curfman, Harris, Stallings & Snow
Suite 800, First National Bank Building
Wichita, Kansas 67202-3391
Re: Waters and Watercourses--Rural Water Districts--
Construction of Works; Revenue Bonds
Synopsis: K.S.A. 82a-625 provides that revenue bonds issued
by a rural water district pursuant to the authority
granted therein "shall be exempt from taxation."
Kansas state income and inheritance taxes are
included in the exemption granted by this statutory
language. Cited herein: K.S.A. 32-607; 68-2013;
68-2041; 74-4522; 76-6a22; 82a-625; L. 1957, ch. 450.
Dear Mr. Borniger:
As general counsel for Rural Water District Nos. 1, 2, 3 and 4
in Sedgwick County, Kansas, you have requested an opinion
interpreting K.S.A. 82a-625. That statute, which concerns a
rural water district's authority to issue revenue bonds provides:
"The board of directors of any district as
provided shall have power to cause to be
constructed within such district such works as
are authorized by this act and to issue
revenue bonds therefor, which shall be exempt
from taxation. Such bonds shall be
self-liquidating out of the revenue to be
derived by the district for its services and
facilities, shall bear interest at not more
than the maximum rate of interest prescribed
by K.S.A. 10-1009 and shall be issued under
such provisions and conditions as the board
shall determine." (Emphasis added.)
You raise the following question: "Are revenue bonds issued
pursuant to K.S.A. 82a-625 exempt from Kansas state income and
inheritance taxes?" It is our opinion that the language of K.S.A.
82a-625 which provides that revenue bonds "shall be exempt from
taxation" is sufficiently broad to exempt such bonds from Kansas
income and inheritance taxes.
This conclusion is based upon certain fundamental rules of
statutory construction; some of which are distinctly applicable
to statutes concerning taxes. It is, of course, the primary rule
of statutory construction that the intent of the legislature,
when it may be ascertained, governs interpretation of statutes.
State v. Sexton, 232 Kan. 539 (1983). The specific rule in
Kansas concerning tax exemption statutes provides that such
statutes are to be strictly construed in favor of imposing a tax
and against the allowance of an exemption for one who does not
clearly qualify. Director of Taxation v. Kansas Krude Oil
Reclaiming Co., 236 Kan. 450, 454 (1984); Board of Park Commr's,
City of Wichita v. State ex rel., 212 Kan. 716, 717 (1973).
These cases, however, generally concern tax exemption statutes in
which a factual question is presented concerning whether an
individual or organization qualifies for a particular exemption.
K.S.A. 82a-625 does not raise such factual concerns. It
unambiguously provides that revenue bonds issued pursuant to its
terms "shall be exempt from taxation." As noted in the Kansas
Krude Oil Reclaiming Co. case cited above:
"The rule of strict construction means that
ordinary words are to be given their ordinary
meaning. Such a statute should not be so read
as to add that which is not readily found
therein or to read out what as a matter of
ordinary English language is in it. (citations
omitted)." 236 Kan. at 455.
Utilizing these guidelines, we can only conclude that "as a matter
of ordinary English" K.S.A. 82a-625 means exactly what it says, i.e.
revenue bonds issued pursuant to its authority are "exempt from
taxation." The term "taxation" in this case is not limited by the
terms or context of the statute. We cannot reasonably infer from
terms or context of the statute. We cannot reasonably infer from
the "ordinary" words used any intention on the part of the
legislature to restrict the scope of the exemption to exclude
income and inheritance taxes.
The word "exempt" has a plain and common meaning which, when
applied to taxation, means "freedom from the burden of enforced
contributions to the expense and maintenance of government, or an
immunity from a general tax." See William Clairmont, Inc. v.
State, 261 N.W. 2d 780, 784 (N.D.2d 1978); Kroger Co. v.
Schneider, 223 N.E.2d 606, 610 (Ohio 1977).
Similarly, the term "taxation", as used in K.S.A. 82a-625, must
be understood in its ordinary sense to refer generally to the
imposition of charges or contributions in a system designed to
raise the revenue necessary to support government. In this
general sense the term certainly includes the imposition of
income and inheritance taxes. To read the term in more limited
sense would require us to presume a legislative intent which is
not evidenced by the unambiguous language of K.S.A. 82a-625.
The legislature has chosen to grant a more limited tax exemption
for other bonds issued under Kansas statutes. In those instances
the statutory language employed clearly states the scope of the
exemption and specifies its limitations, e.g., K.S.A. 76-6a22
(revenue bonds issued by colleges and universities.); K.S.A.
74-4522 (state parks); K.S.A. 68-2013 and 68-2041 (Kansas
Turnpike and highway bonds); K.S.A. 32-607 (state fish hatchery
revenue bonds). We note that K.S.A. 42-388b employs language
similar to K.S.A. 82a-625 in declaring bonds issued by certain
irrigation districts to be "tax-exempt." Our research on this
statute does not reveal any interpretation of K.S.A. 42-388b
contrary to the conclusions we have reached regarding K.S.A.
82a-625.
It is clear from the statutes cited above that if the legislature
intended to limit the scope of the tax exemption granted to bonds
it could so provide in specific and unambiguous terms. In the
case of K.S.A. 82a-625, the legislature did not choose to employ
such language, providing instead for an exemption in a general
sense by stating that the bonds shall be exempt from taxation.
Under these circumstances, and given the rules of construction
which control here, we can only conclude that the words "exempt
from taxation" as used in K.S.A. 82a-625 include Kansas state
income and inheritance taxes. Thus, in our opinion, bonds issued
pursuant to the statute are exempt from Kansas state income and
inheritance taxes.
We note that this language has appeared unchanged in the statute
since its enactment in 1957. The 1957 bill providing for the
establishment and powers of rural water districts also contained
the following preamble declaring the purpose of the legislation.
"WHEREAS, It is recognized that the wastage
and inadequate utilization of water resources
within this state resulting from inadequate
facilities for water storage, transportation
and utilization contribute to: The
destruction of natural resources, injuries to
public health and lands, droughts, periodic
floods, crop failures, decline in standards of
living, and excessive dependence upon public
relief, and thereby menace the welfare of the
citizens of the state of Kansas; and
"WHEREAS, The 83rd congress of the United
States of America has recognized that the
wastage and inadequate utilization of said
water resources on a national level have a
similar undesirable effect on the national
public health, economy and welfare and
therefore enacted public law 597, which
authorized the United States secretary of
agriculture to: Enter into agreements with
state agencies and private persons; furnish
financial or other aid and assistance; and,
insure loans for the purpose of encouraging
various water conserving, utilization and
drainage facility improvement projects: Now,
therefore," L. 1957, ch. 450.
As the preamble makes clear, the legislation is designed to
accomplish a public purpose and to further the public welfare.
The revenue bonds provided for by K.S.A. 82a-625 are a source of
revenue for the legislature's plan to remedy the problems
discussed in the preamble to the act. Obviously, the exemption
of the bonds from state taxation will make the bonds more
marketable and promote the realization of this plan. The Kansas
supreme court has approved a similar exemption for revenue bonds
issued by the state board of regents. See State, ex rel. v.
Board of Regents, 167 Kan. 587, 596-597 (1949).
It is our opinion therefore, that K.S.A. 82a-625 provides that
revenue bonds issued pursuant to its terms are exempt from Kansas
income and inheritance taxes.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
Attorney General of Kansas
Mary F. Carson
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:JSS:MFC:jm

Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude

Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.