Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1986-006

1986-006Kanag

Texte intégral

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL January 21, 1986
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 86- 6
The Honorable Susan Roenbaugh
State Representative, 114th District
Capitol Building, 181-W
Topeka, Kansas 66612
Re: Counties and County Officers -- County
Commissioners; Powers and Duties -- Eligibility to
Office of Commissioner
Synopsis: A county Commissioner is not precluded from holding
a concurrent position as property appraiser with
the Division of Property Valuation. Since a
property appraiser is not a "public officer," such
employment would not result in a situation
prohibited by K.S.A. 19-205. Cited herein: K.S.A.
19-205; 21-3110.
Dear Representative Roenbaugh:
As state representative for the 114th District of the House
of Representatives, you request our opinion as to whether
certain state employment would result in a holding of offices
which is prohibited by K.S.A. 19-205. Specifically, you
inquire as to whether a county commissioner can be employed as
a property appraiser by the Division of Property Valuation.
You inform us that the position would involve supervising
county reappraisal efforts in a multi-county area, but would
not involve the home county of the county commissioner.
K.S.A. 19-205 deals with eligibility to the office of county
commissioner, and states:
"No person holding any state, county,
township or city office shall be
eligible to the office of county
commissioner in any county in this
state." (Emphasis added.)
Thus, the issue presented is whether a property appraiser for
the Division of Property Valuation is a state officer.
Several Kansas Supreme Court cases have addressed the issue of
how to distinguish a public office from a public employee. In
Sowers v. Wells, 150 Kan. 630 (1939), the Court was asked
what is a public office and who is a public officer? 150 Kan.
at 633. In response, the Court answered:
"While the authorities are not in complete
harmony in defining the term 'public
office,' or 'public officer,' it
universally has been held that the right
to exercise some definite portion of
sovereign power constitutes an
indispensable attribute of 'public
office.'" 150 Kan. at 633.
See also Steere v. Cupp, 226 Kan. 566, 572 (1979). Two
years before Sowers, the Supreme Court of Kansas in Miller
v. Ottawa County Comm'rs, 146 Kan. 481, 485 (1937),
observed:
. . as a general rule . . . a position
is a public office when it is created by
law, with duties cast on the incumbent
which involve an exercise of the sovereign
power and in the performance of which the
public is concerned, and which also are
continuing in their nature and not
occasional or intermittent; while a public
employment, on the other hand, is a
position which lacks one or more of the
foregoing elements."
Further, the Court stated:
"The distinction between an officer and an
employee is that the responsibility for
results is upon one and not upon the
other. There is also upon an officer the
power of direction, supervision and
control." Miller, supra at 484.
Thus, the Court distinguished a public officer from a public
employee on the basis of the responsibility of each. A public
officer has responsibility for results, while an employee is
subordinate to the legal authority of another. The Kansas
Court has also described a public Office as a public trust
which the incumbent holds for a term and tenure prescribed by
law. State ex rel. v. Rose, 74 Kan. 262, 267 (1906).
In addition to Kansas case law, general legal authority and
Kansas statutes provide assistance in determining when the
nature and duties of a position require it to be deemed a
public office rather than public employment. The Miller
court quoted language from 53 A.L.R. 595 in describing a
public office:
"'It may be stated, as a general rule
deducible from the cases discussing the
question, that a position is a public
office when it is created by law, with
duties cast on the incumbent which involve
an exercise of some portion of the
sovereign power and in the performance of
which the public is concerned, and which
also are continuing in their nature and
not occasional or intermittent; while a
public employment, on the other hand, is a
position which lacks one or more of the
foregoing elements.'" 146 Kan. at 485.
A public officer is defined in 63 Am.Jur.2d, Public Officers
and Employees §1, p. 625, as such:
"A public officer is such an officer as is
required by law to be elected or
appointed, who has a designation or title
given him by law, and who exercises
functions concerning the public, assigned
to him by law. The duties of such officer
do not arise out of contract or depend for
their duration or extent upon the terms of
a contract."
Although contained in the criminal code, K.S.A. 21-3110
provides additional insight into the distinction between a
public employee and a public officer. The statute states in
relevant part:
"(18) 'Public employee' is a person
employed by or acting for the state or by
or for a county, municipality or other
subdivision or governmental
instrumentality of the state for the
purpose of exercising their respective
powers and performing their respective
duties, and who is not a 'public officer.'
"(19) 'Public officer' includes the
following, whether elected or appointed:
"(a) An executive or administrative
officer of the state, or a county;
municipality or other subdivision or
governmental instrumentality of or within
the state.
"(b) A member of the legislature or of a
governing board of a county, municipality,
or other subdivision of or within the
state.
"(c) A judicial officer, which shall
include a judge of the district court,
juror, master or any other person
appointed by a judge or court to hear or
determine a cause or controversy.
"(d) A hearing officer, which shall
include any person authorized by law or
private agreement, to hear or determine a
cause or controversy and who is not a
judicial officer.
"(e) A law enforcement officer.
"(f) Any other person exercising the
functions of a public officer under color
of right."
In applying the foregoing principles and statutes to your
inquiry, it is our opinion that a property appraiser does not
hold a public office, but rather is a public employee. An
appraiser's duties do not involve the exercise of any amount
of sovereign power. Further, an appraiser is not ultimately
responsible for his acts; rather, the Division of Property
Valuation supervises and directs each appraiser as an
employee, and is ultimately responsible for the results of any
acts he or she might perform. In addition, we note that an
appraiser has no definite term and tenure prescribed by
statute; rather, his work is intermittent depending upon the
demand for his services.
For these reasons, it is our opinion that a county
commissioner is not precluded from holding a concurrent
position as property appraiser with the Division of Property
Valuation. Since a property appraiser is not a "public
officer," such employment would not result in an incompatible
dual office holding which is prohibited by K.S.A. 19-205. The
fact the commissioner would not he performing appraisal duties
in his home county is immaterial, as the issue is solely
determined by whether a property appraiser is defined as a
public officer or a public employee.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF KANSAS
Barbara P. Allen
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:JSS:BPA:crw

Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude

Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.