Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1985-170

1985-170Kanag

Texte intégral

December 12, 1985
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION 85- 170
The Honorable Marvin L. Littlejohn
State Representative, 119th District
14 Southwest Second
Phillipsburg, Kansas 67661
Re: Public Health -- Hospitals and Other Facilities --
Moratorium on Modifications; Consolidation of
Adjacent Hospital and Nursing Home
Synopsis: A consolidation of a nursing home and hospital by
converting the nursing home into a long-term care
unit of the hospital is an alteration which
increases the licensed bed capacity of the
hospital. Such a consolidation is prohibited under
L. 1985, Ch. 204. Cited herein: L. 1985, Ch. 204.
Dear Representative Littlejohn:
As Representative of the 119th District, you request our
opinion concerning 1985 House Bill No. 2627. You advise that
Wichita County Hospital and the Golden Acres Nursing Home wish
to consolidate as one functional unit by making the nursing
home a long-term care unit of the hospital. The two
facilities are physically attached and are currently separated
only by a common set of swinging doors. You inquire whether
this bill prohibits such consolidation.
1985 House Bill No. 2627, now at L. 1985, Ch. 204, imposes a
one-year moratorium on the construction of new general or
special hospitals and certain other actions which increase the
licensed bed capacity of existing hospitals. For purposes of
this opinion, the heart of the bill is found in Section 2
which states in pertinent part as follows:
"The following construction or
modifications shall not be commenced prior
to July 1, 1986:
"(a) Any erections, building, alteration,
reconstruction, modernization,
improvement, extension, lease or other
acquisition by or on behalf of a hospital
that increases the licensed bed capacity
of a hospital or relocates hospital beds
from one physical facility or site to
another;"
It .is clear that the proposed consolidation of the hospital
and nursing home would be a modification that would increase
the licensed bed capacity of the hospital. The hospital,
which currently has 13 licensed beds, would increase its
licensed bed capacity by 30 by consolidation with the nursing
home. The issue raised is whether such a modification, which
requires no physical change in existing structures,
constitutes an "erection, building alteration, reconstruction,
modernization, improvement, extension, lease or other
acquisition" by or on behalf of the hospital.
Clearly, the proposed consolidation does not entail an
"erection," "building," "reconstruction," or "lease." In
determining whether such consolidation is an "alteration,"
"modernization," "improvement," or "acquisition" other than a
lease, we look to the commonly understood meaning of those
terms. See, e.g. Appeal of Armed Forces Co-op Insuring
Assn., 5 Kan.App.2d 787 (1981).
The following denotation of the root verbs of those terms are
found in Webster's Third New International Dictionary
(unabridged edition, 1968):
"alter" - "to cause to become different in some
particular characteristic without changing into something
else";
"modernize" - "to make modern";
"improve" - "to make greater in amount or degree" or "to
enhance in value or quality"; and,
"acquire" - "to come into possession, control, or power
of disposal of."
In our judgment, the proposed consolidation of the hospital
and nursing home constitutes an "alteration," "improvement,"
or non-lease "acquisition" by or on behalf of the hospital.
Indeed, it is difficult to conceive of an action which would
result in an increase in the licensed bed capacity of a
hospital which would not be included within the broad terms
chosen by the legislature. It appears that the legislature
intended to prohibit any action which would result in an
increase of the licensed bed capacity of a hospital, unless
such action falls within the express exceptions listed in
Section 3 of the Act. See Attorney General Opinion No.
85-115, copy enclosed. This interpretation is consistent with
the legislation's purpose of preventing unnecessary
duplication or expansion of health facilities, thereby
preventing (at least in part) higher medical costs resulting
from such duplication or expansion.
Although 1985 House Bill No. 2627 prohibits consolidation of
the hospital and nursing home by means which would result in
an increase in the licensed bed capacity of the hospital, the
general goal of reducing costs without sacrificing needed
services may be achieved by any other legal means. Further,
we note that the act by its own terms expires on July 1, 1986.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF KANSAS
Kathryn Gardner
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:JSS:KG:crw

Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude

Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.