Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1985-166

1985-166Kanag

Texte intégral

November 27, 1985
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 85- 166
The Honorable Don Montgomery
State Senator, Twenty-First District
1218 Main
Sabetha, Kansas 66534
Re: Cities and Municipalities--General Provisions--
Annexation of Lands Located in Water Districts;
Title to Facilities; Agreement; Compensation
Synopsis: While K.S.A. 12-527 prescribes no time limit
within which a city must purchase rural water
district lines and facilities located upon land
annexed by the city, such purchase must be ac-
complished within a reasonable time following
annexation. The reasonableness of the time within
which a city proposes to consumate such a purchase
is a question of fact to be ascertained in light
of all facts and circumstances. Additionally,
a city is not liable for severance damages in
acquiring title to rural water district lines
and facilities under the provisions of K.S.A.
12-527. Cited herein: K.S.A. 12-527; 26-504.
Dear Senator Montgomery:
You request our interpretation of K.S.A. 12-527. That statute
prescribes a procedure for the transfer of rural water district
facilities located upon land annexed by a city, and provides as
follows:
"Whenever a city shall annex lands located
within a rural water district organized
pursuant to the provisions of K.S.A. 82a-612
et seq., title to all facilities used for the
transportation or utilization of water
belonging to the water district shall vest in
or become the property of the city upon
payment by the city to the water district of
the value of such property, as agreed by the
governing body of the city and the board of
directors of the district, or if such
agreement is not made, then as determined by
the city: Provided, That the board of
directors of any such district may bring an
action in the district court to determine the
reasonableness of the amount of compensation
fixed and determined by any such city. The
governing body of the city and board of
directors of the district may provide, on such
terms as may be agreed, that water
transmission facilities owned by the district
and located within the city may be retained by
the district for the purpose of transporting
water to customers outside the city. In
addition to compensation for such physical
facilities the city may pay to the water
district an amount equal to that portion of
outstanding indebtedness of the district which
is properly attributable to the portion of the
water district annexed by the city."
You first inquire as to whether there is "a reasonable length of
time in which existing rural water district facilities and lines
should be purchased by the annexing city." In this regard, while
it is clear that the water lines and facilities are ultimately to
be purchased by the annexing city (except where there is an
agreement that water transmission facilities owned by the
district and located within the city are retained by the district
for the purpose of transporting water to customers outside the
city), the statute does not prescribe the period of time within
which the purchase is to be made.
Under these circumstances, it is our opinion that the "reasonable
time rule" is applicable. That rule is as follows:
"Where no time has been fixed for the
performance of an act to be done, the law
implies that performance is to be accomplished
within a reasonable time." Singer Company v.
Makad, Inc., 213 Kan. 725, Syl. ¶7 (1974).
Moreover, "[w]hat constitutes a reasonable time depends on the
facts and circumstances of the particular case." (Id. at Syl.
¶8). Accordingly, the purchase mandated by K.S.A. 12-527 could
be deferred indefinitely if such course of action was reasonable
under the particular facts and circumstances.
You next ask whether the long-term viability of the remainder of
the water district should be a factor in determining the value of
the annexed water lines, i.e. if remaining patrons cannot, at
reasonable rates, support the water plant operation should this
be a factor in determining the value of the annexed lines. In
this regard, we note that courts in other jurisdictions have
awarded severance damages in eminent domain proceedings where
only part of a public utility system is taken. [See 27 Am.Jur.2d
Eminent Domain §340; Puget Sound Power & Light Co. v. City of
Puyallup, 51 F.2d 688, 697 (9th Cir. 1931); Brunswick & T.
Water Dist. v. Maine Water Co., 59 A. 537, 542 (Me. 1904).)
Further, while no Kansas cases have applied the language of
K.S.A. 26-504(d)(4), that paragraph would appear to allow the
use of the remaining property to be considered in determining an
award in an eminent domain proceeding. However, under the plain and
unambiguous provisions of K.S.A. 12-527, a city must pay a rural
water district only for the value of the physical facilities
actually acquired, and has the option of paying an additional
amount equal to that portion of the outstanding indebtedness of
the district which is properly attributable to the portion of the
water district annexed by the city. Accordingly, in our opinion
a city is not liable for severance damages in acquiring title to
rural water district lines and facilities under the provisions of
K.S.A. 12-527 as they presently read.
In summary, it is our opinion that while K.S.A. 12-527
prescribes no time limit within which a city must purchase rural
water district lines and facilities located upon land annexed by
the city, such purchase must be accomplished within a reasonable
time following annexation. The reasonableness of the time within
which a city proposes to consumate such a purchase is a question
of fact to be ascertained in light of all facts and circumstances.
Additionally, a city is not liable for severance damages in
acquiring title to rural water district lines and facilities
under the provisions of K.S.A. 12-527.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHA
Attorney General of Kansas
Terrence R. Hearshman
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:JSS:TRH:jm

Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude

Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.