Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1985-162

1985-162Kanag

Texte intégral

November 25, 1985
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 85- 162
The Honorable Homer E. Jarchow
State Representative, Ninety-Fifth District
2121 West Douglas
Wichita, Kansas 67213
Re: Kansas Constitution--Finance and Taxation--Uniform
and Equal Rate of Assessment and Taxation
Taxation--Merchants--Inventory of Merchant; Listing
for Taxation; Fair Market Value in Money
Synopsis: Based upon the Kansas Supreme Court's differentiation
of "permissible" and "impermissible" partial exemptions,
and the legislative history of 1971 Senate Bill No. 28,
it cannot be concluded as a matter of law that the
portion of K.S.A. 79-100lb which provides for a maximum
40% reduction in the fair market value of property held
as inventory by a merchant is prohibited by Article 11,
Section 1 of the Kansas Constitution. Cited herein:
K.S.A. 79-1001a, 79-1001b, 79-1004a; Kan. Const., Art. 11,
§1.
*
Dear Representative Jarchow:
You request our opinion concerning the constitutional validity of
K.S.A. 79-1001a and 79-1001b. The former statute provides that,
for purposes of property taxation, the fair market value of
personal property held by a merchant shall be:
"an amount equal to the average of the fair
market value in money of the personal property
held as inventory within the state of Kansas
for sale by such merchant during his tax year
(as established for reporting for federal
income tax purposes) next preceding the time of
filing the statement of personal property."
(Emphasis added.)
K.S.A. 79-100lb prescribes the following formula for determining
"the average of the fair market value" of merchant's inventory:
"The average of the fair market value of the
personal property held as inventory for sale
by a merchant during the preceding tax year,
as established for reporting for federal
income tax purposes, shall be determined in
the following manner:
"(a) Add the fair market value of personal
property held as beginning inventory by such
merchant on the first day of such tax year, as
reported for federal income tax purposes for
such year, to the fair market value of personal
property not reflected in such beginning
inventory which is consigned to and held for
sale by such merchant on such date;
"(b) add to the amount computed in subsection
(a) the fair market value of personal property
held as ending inventory by such merchant on
the last day of such tax year, as reported for
federal income tax purposes for such year and
the fair market value of personal property not
reflected in such ending inventory which is
consigned to and held for sale by such
merchant on such date;
"(c) divide the amount computed under
subsection (b) by two. If any merchant
establishes by means of actual inventories
taken throughout such tax year and reflected
in the records of such merchant's business
that the average of the fair market value of
inventory computed in the manner hereinbefore
provided does not reflect the true average of
the fair market value of property held as
inventory during such tax year, the average of
the fair market of property held as inventory
by such merchant shall be computed by
averaging the fair market value of property
included in the actual inventories taken by
such merchant during such year; and
"(d) subtract from the average of the fair
market value of property held as inventory, as
computed under subsection (c), the operating
and administrative costs and expenses of the
business for which such inventory is listed
and reported, including overhead and
obsolescence or depreciation in value not
reflected in determining the value of
inventory under the provisions of subsections
(a), (b) and (c), not exceeding an amount
equal to 40% of the average value of the
inventory of such business as determined
under the provisions of subsection (c)."
You question whether the underscored provisions in the
above-quoted statute, which provide for a reduction in the fair
market value of merchants inventory for operating and
administrative costs and expenses of the business (not exceeding
40% of the average value of the inventory), violate Article 11,
Section 1 of the Kansas Constitution. That constitutional
provision, in part relevant to your inquiry, states: "The
legislature shall provide for a uniform and equal rate of
assessment and taxation."
A determination of the validity of K.S.A. 79-100lb under the
uniform and equal clause of the Kansas Constitution requires a
consideration of two recent cases dealing with partial exemptions
from property tax. In State ex rel. Stephan v. Martin, 227
Kan. 456 (1980), the Kansas Supreme Court found that a provision
reducing the appraised valuation of certain farm machinery and
equipment was a partial exemption from taxation, and intimated
that partial exemptions were unconstitutional. (See Kansas
Attorney General Opinion No. 82-234.) However, in Von Ruden v.
Miller, 231 Kan. 1 (1982) the court modified its position on
partial exemptions, and indicated that such an exemption is
permissible under Article 11, Section 1 so long as the exemption
is "based on a purpose promoting the general welfare" and is not
merely "for the purpose of benefiting a particular class of
persons." (See 231 Kan. at 15; Kansas Attorney General Opinion
No. 82-234.) As the maximum 40% reduction in fair market value
provided for in K.S.A. 79-100lb constitutes a partial exemption
under the court's analysis in Martin, supra, it is necessary to
consider the purpose of the exemption in order to determine its
validity under Article 11, Section 1.
K.S.A. 79-1001a and 79-100lb were enacted in 1971 as part of
Senate Bill No. 28 (L. 1971, ch. 296), which bill was the
culmination of several years of legislative study of problems
associated with assessing merchants' inventories. Prior to 1971,
there was no deduction for operating and administrative expenses,
and studies indicated that there was a low degree of compliance
with the requirement of assessing merchants inventory at 30% of
value. [See Final Report of the Joint Interim Committee on the
State Tax Structure, Vol. I, p. 56 (January, 1970)]. Spokesmen
for various trade associations testified that full enforcement of
the existing law in valuing merchants inventory "would make it
impossible for many firms to remain in business." (Id. at 57.)
Additionally, it was noted that under existing statutes there was
no check on the degree of compliance by merchants in reporting
their inventories, and that tax officials were forced to accept
the merchant's word. (See 1969 Journal of the Kansas Senate at
120.)
After considering 8 possible legislative solutions to problems
associated with assessing merchants' inventory, the committee
recommended a plan which included the maximum 40% reduction in
fair market value prescribed by K.S.A. 79-100lb, and the
requirement incorporated in K.S.A. 79-1004a that merchants
include in their statement of property a copy of the inventory
portion of their federal income tax return. (See 1971 Journal of
the Kansas Senate at 78.) Evidence before the committee indicated
that the proposed plan would result in a substantial increase in
taxes on inventories paid by most classes of retail business:
"[D]ata from a survey conducted by the County
Attorney of Johnson County in 1969 indicates
that, if such data is representative of the
situation in most counties, reasonable
compliance with the proposed basis for valuing
inventories of merchants, even if the 40%
deduction were taken in all cases, probably
would result in a substantial increase in
taxes on inventories paid by most classes of
retail business." (1971 Journal of the Kansas
Senate at 78.) (Emphasis added.)
The legislative history summarized above suggests that the
partial exemption prescribed by K.S.A. 79-100lb is "based on a
purpose promoting the general welfare." Specifically, in our
judgment the legislature found that such an exemption was needed
to prevent numerous business failures and other adverse
consequences for an important segment of the Kansas economy.
Additionally, it can hardly be said that 1971 Senate Bill No. 28
was enacted merely for the purpose of benefiting merchants, since
the only evidence before the Joint Tax Study Committee was that
the bill "would result in a substantial increase in taxes on
inventories paid by most classes of retail business."
In summary, it is our opinion that based upon the Kansas Supreme
Court's differentiation of "permissible" and "impermissible"
partial exemptions, and the legislative history of 1971 Senate
Bill No. 28, it cannot be concluded, as a matter of law, that
the portion of K.S.A. 79-100lb which provides for a maximum 40%
reduction in the fair market value of property held as inventory
by a merchant is prohibited by Article 11, Section 1 of the
Kansas Constitution.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
Attorney General of Kansas
Terrence R. Hearshman
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:JSS:TRH:jm

Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude

Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.