Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1985-134

1985-134Kanag

Texte intégral

September 27, 1985
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 85- 134
The Honorable Jack Brier
Secretary of State
State Capitol Building, 2nd Floor
Topeka, Kansas 66612
Re: Contracts and Promises -- Funeral Agreements,
Contracts and Plans; Cemetery Merchandise Contracts
-- Cemetery Merchandise; Defined
Synopsis: Under definitions contained in the Cemetery
Merchandise Act, K.S.A. 1984 Supp. 16-320 et
seq., "cemetery merchandise" is defined to
include a number of specific items of personal
property as well as "all merchandise commonly sold
or used in cemeteries." K.S.A. 1984 Supp.
16-320(a). While caskets are not specifically
mentioned, neither are they excluded (as are
certain types of real property and intangible
rights), and so are included under the general
category of "merchandise commonly sold or used in
cemeteries." Accordingly, cemetery corporations
may enter into contracts for the pre-need sale of
caskets under the terms of K.S.A. 1984 Supp. 16-320
et seq. Cited herein: K.S.A. 1984 Supp.
16-301; 16-302; 16-303; K.S.A. 16-308; K.S.A. 1984
Supp. 16-320; 16-321; 16-322; 16-329; 16-330;
16-333.
Dear Mr. Brier:
As Secretary of State for Kansas, you request our opinion on a
question concerning a provision contained in the Cemetery
Merchandise Act, K.S.A. 1984 Supp. 16-320 et As
enacted in 1982, the act provides for the pre-need sale of
items of "cemetery merchandise," as that term is defined by
K.S.A. 1984 Supp. 16-320(a). Such items may be sold on a
pre-need basis by a cemetery corporation, provided certain
specific requirements are met concerning investment of the
proceeds of the sale, record keeping, annual reporting of the
merchandise trust account, and audits by your office. As the
state official with oversight of such sales, you accordingly
seek our opinion on whether caskets fall within the scope of
the definition of cemetery merchandise contained in the act.
In 1953, K.S.A. 1984 Supp. 16-301 et seq. (the Pre-need
Funeral Law) was enacted to require anyone who sold funeral or
burial merchandise, which was not immediately delivered to the
purchaser, to deposit in trust 100% of the sales proceeds and
trust earnings. The Pre-need Funeral Law was held to apply to
burial vaults and markers by the case of State ex rel. v.
Anderson, 195 Kan. 649 (1965), and was also construed to
cover cemeteries. In 1973, however, K.S.A. 1984 Supp. 16-301
was amended to remove markers, crypts, niches, lots, spaces
and other items and intangible rights connected with graves.
Accordingly, prior to 1982, markers were subject to no trust
provisions at all, while caskets and vaults could be sold
pre-need only under the provisions of K.S.A. 1984 Supp. 16-301
et seq. or under the narrow holding of State ex rel. v.
Lakeview Gardens, Inc., 221 Kan. 211 (1976) (caskets could
be sold pre-need without trust if delivered and stored for
purchaser).
Since 1982, the Cemetery Merchandise Act has provided cemetery
corporations with a method of selling pre-need merchandise
which, while similar to that found for funeral homes at K.S.A.
1984 Supp. 16-301 et seq. is different in several
important respects. As noted above, under the provisions of
K.S.A. 1984 Supp. 16-301 et seq., "funeral or burial
merchandise" is specifically defined to include caskets
[K.S.A. 1984 Supp. 16-301]. K.S.A. 1984 Supp. 16-302 provides
that 100% of the money paid for such pre-need merchandise must
be deposited in a financial institution, while K.S.A. 1984
Supp. 16-303 prohibits any withdrawal until either the death
of the person for whom the funds were deposited or a demand
for withdrawal by the purchaser, at which time the contract
terminates. In contrast, cemetery merchandise sold pre-need
pursuant to K.S.A. 1984 Supp. 16-320 et seq. must be
funded only at 110% of the wholesale price of the item, with
the cemetery permitted to keep both the first 35% of the
amount paid on the contract and any amounts received which are
in excess of the "minimum funding requirement" (i.e. the
110% amount). K.S.A. 1984 Supp. 16-321. Further, sales made
under the Cemetery Merchandise Act are exempt from the
requirements of the Pre-Need Funeral Law. K.S.A. 1984 Supp.
16-333.
The definition of "cemetery merchandise" found at K.S.A. 1984
Supp. 16-321(a) provides the basis for your inquiry. There,
it is stated:
"'Cemetery merchandise' means burial
vaults, grave liners, grave boxes, urns,
memorials, markers, vases, memorial vases,
tombstones, lawn crypts, niches and
mausoleum spaces and all merchandise
commonly sold or used in cemeteries.
Grave lots, grave spaces; burial or
interment rights; and developed or
existing lawn crypts, mausoleum spaces or
niches are not cemetery merchandise."
(Emphasis added.)
We note that this language has existed in the statute since it
was enacted in 1982 as part of House Bill No. 2818 (L. 1982,
ch. 96, §1). Prior to action by the House Local Government
Committee, the word "similar" appeared in the underscored
portion where the word "all" now appears. This action was
taken by the House committee, and was not altered during the
bill's subsequent passage through the legislature.
It should also be noted that while caskets are not mentioned
in the list of items which are defined as cemetery
merchandise, the items which are specifically excluded are
all either interests in real estate or intangible rights. In
this respect, the definition is similar'to a provision found
in the Pre-need Funeral Law at K.S.A. 1984 Supp. 16-301, where
certain items are specifically included (caskets and vaults)
while others are specifically excluded (tombstones, lots,
crypts, etc.). Unfortunately for the purposes of statutory
construction, while some items are excluded by both acts (such
as grave lots, spaces, niches), others are included in both
(vaults), with both acts containing general "catch-all"
provisions which arguably may contain other items which are
not specifically enumerated.
Since caskets are not specifically included or excluded by
K.S.A. 1984 Supp. 16-321(a), we are faced with determining
whether they are "merchandise commonly sold or used in
cemeteries." By inserting this phrase, the legislature has
indicated that there are items not specifically set forth
which are nonetheless to be considered as cemetery
merchandise. While it may be argued that caskets are not
commonly "sold" by cemeteries, caskets are universally "used"
in cemeteries, and the statute by its terms does not restrict
the source of the caskets to funeral directors, cemetery
owners or anyone else.
The fundamental purpose of statutory construction is to
determine and give effect to the intent of the legislature,
when that intent can be determined from the language of the
statute. Szoboszlay v. Glessner, 233 Kan. 475 (1983).
In our opinion, both K.S.A. 1984 Supp. 16-301 et seq., and
K.S.A. 1984 Supp. 16-320 et seq., indicate an intent to be
inclusive in their scope and application. As noted above,
K.S.A. 1984 Supp. 16-321(a) defines "cemetery merchandise" to
include "all merchandise commonly sold or used in
cemeteries." K.S.A. 1984 Supp. 16-301 likewise states that
"funeral or burial merchandise" includes certain enumerated
items, plus "all other articles of merchandise incidental to a
funeral service." Kansas courts have held as a matter of
course that where statutes contain an enumeration of certain
things to which the act applies and also a general expression
concerning application of the act, the general expression may
be given effect if the context shows that the enumeration was
not intended to be exclusive. Kansas Commission on Civil
Rights v. Sears, Roebuck and Company, 216 Kan. 306 (1975);
Johnson v. General Motors Corporation, 199 Kan. 720 (1967).
Such is the case in both of the acts in question here, where
the legislature set forth a list of items and included a
general statement as well.
As a result of the statutory framework now in place, a
consumer may purchase a casket on a pre-need basis from
either a funeral home or a cemetery, although the requirements
placed on the two businesses are different. In examining the
legislative history behind K.S.A. 1984 Supp. 16-320 et
seq., we have been unable to determine why a distinction was
made between funeral homes and cemeteries regarding sales of
the same item, including both vaults and caskets. However,
like a court, it is not the function of this office to
question the propriety, wisdom or necessity of otherwise valid
legislative acts, since it is the legislature and the
legislature alone which determines whether a statute is in the
public interest. City of Baxter Springs v. Bryant, 226
Kan. 383, 386 (1979). Creating parity between the two
industries is clearly a policy decision which is in the hands
of the legislature. In any event, the public is protected
through the trust mechanism under either act.
In conclusion, under definitions contained in the Cemetery
Merchandise Act, K.S.A. 1984 Supp. 16-320 et seq.,
"cemetery merchandise" is defined to include a number of
specific items of personal property as well as "all
merchandise commonly sold or used in cemeteries." K.S.A. 1984
Supp. 16-320(a). While caskets are not specifically
mentioned, neither are they excluded (as are certain types of
real property and intangible rights), and so are included
under the general category of "merchandise commonly sold or
used in cemeteries." Accordingly, cemetery corporations may
enter into contracts for the prepaid sale of caskets under the
terms of K.S.A. 1984 Supp. 16-320 et seq.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF KANSAS
JeffreyS.	Southard
Deputy Attorney General
RTS:JSS:crw

Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude

Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.