Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1985-110

1985-110Kanag

Texte intégral

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTOR NEY GENERAL
August 29, 1985
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 85- 110
Gary Hayzlett
Kearny County Commission
Kearny County Courthouse
P.O. Box 86
Lakin, Kansas 67860
Re: Constitution of the State of Kansas--
Constitutional Amendment and Revision -- Proposals
by Legislature; Approval by Electors
Synopsis: Pursuant to Article 14, Section 1 of the Kansas
Constitution, the legislature may submit a
constitutional amendment to a vote of the electors
of Kansas by means of a concurrent resolution
passed by both houses. A concurrent resolution
adopted by the legislature during the 1985 session
may be amended in the 1986 session, prior to being
submitted to the voters in November, 1986.
Alternatively, a separate concurrent resolution may
be passed as a substitute fob one earlier
approved. In either event, the same requirements
for passage must be met as were required for the
initial resolution, namely two-thirds affirmative
vote of the entire membership of both houses.
Cited herein: L. 1985, ch. 348; Kansas
Constitution, Art. 14, §1.
*
Dear Mr. Hayzlett:
As a member of the Kearney County Board of Commissioners,
you request our opinion on a question concerning the possible
amendment of 1985 House Concurrent Resolution No. 5018. That
resolution, which places the question of reclassification of
property for taxation purposes on the 1986 general election
ballot, also contains language that implements the new system
effective January 1, 1989. In that this would require all
property in the state to be reappraised within three and
one-half years at most (assuming reappraisal is begun now, and
not until after the result of the 1986 vote is known), you
express concern that the resources of the counties may not be
equal to the task. Accordingly, you inquire whether it would
be possible for the 1986 Legislature to amend the concurrent
resolution in such a way to eliminate the specific deadline
and replace it with wording that implements reclassification
upon completion of reappraisal, whenever that is achieved.
Article 14, Section 1 of the Kansas Constitution sets forth
the procedure which must be followed whenever the legislature
desires to submit a proposed constitutional amendment to the
voters of Kansas. In pertinent part, it states as follows:
"Propositions for the amendment of this
constitution may be made by concurrent
resolution originating in either house of
the legislature, and if two-thirds of
all the members elected to each house
shall approve such resolution, the same,
with the yeas and nays thereon, shall be
entered on the journal of each house. The
secretary of state shall cause such
resolution to be published in one
newspaper in each county of the state
where a newspaper is published, once a
week for five (5) consecutive weeks
immediately preceding the next election
for representatives, or preceding a
special election called by concurrent
resolution of the legislature for the
purpose of submitting constitutional
propositions. At such election, such
proposition to amend the constitution
shall be submitted either by title
generally descriptive of the contents
thereof, or by the amendment as a whole,
to the electors for their approval or
rejection. If such proposition is
submitted by title, such title shall be
specified in the concurrent resolution
making the proposition. If a majority of
the electors voting on any such amendment
shall vote for the amendment, the same
shall become a part of the
constitution." (Emphasis added.)
A reading of the above language indicates no imitation on the
power of the legislature to amend or revoke any concurrent
resolution which proposes a constitutional amendment prior to
the time such amendment s published prior to the election.
Likewise, we find nothing in the rules of either the house of
representatives (L. 1985, ch. 348, art. 21) or the senate (L.
1981, ch. 403, rule 44) which distinguishes between amendments
to bills and ordinary resolutions and amendments to concurrent
resolutions. In the absence of such language, we may look to
decisions of Kansas courts and to general authorities for any
indication that the amendment of concurrent resolutions
containing proposed constitutional amendments is prohibited.
The Prohibitory Amendment Cases, 24 Kan. 700 (1881) were
four cases that were considered together by the Kansas Supreme
Court, each of which challenged the validity of the amendment
adopting prohibition in Kansas approved in 1880. In
discussing the role of the legislature in placing a
constitutional question before the voters, the court, per
Justice David Brewer (who later was appointed to the United
States Supreme Court), held:
"Again, in constitutional changes the
popular voice is the paramount act. While
to guard against undue haste and temporary
excitement, to prevent unnecessary and
frequent appeals for constitutional
amendments, the assent of two-thirds of
the legislature is prescribed as a
condition precedent, yet after all, that
which determines constitutional changes is
the popular will. This is a government by
the people, and whenever the clear voice
of the people is heard, legislatures and
courts must obey. True, a popular vote
without previous legislative sanction must
be disregarded. There is no certainty
that all who could would take part in such
a vote, or that they who did, all realize
that it was a final action. It lacks the
sanction of law, is a disregard of
constitutional methods and limitations,
and should be taken as a request for a
change, rather than as a change itself.
But notwithstanding this, legislative
action is simply a determination to submit
the question to popular decision. It is
in no sense final. No number of
legislatures and no amount of legislative
action can change the fundamental law.
This was made by the people, who alone can
change it. The action of the legislature
in respect to constitutional changes is
something like the action of a committee
of the legislature in respect to the
legislative disposition of a bill. It
presents, it recommends, but it does not
decide. And who ever thought of
declaring a law invalid by reason of any
irregularities in the proceedings of the
committee which first passed upon it? It
is the legislative action which is
considered in determining whether the law
has been constitutionally passed; and it
is the popular action which is principally
to be considered in determining whether a
constitutional amendment has been
adopted." 24 Kan. at 711-712." (Emphasis
added.)
The court further discussed the argument that the amendment
was defective due to procedural flaws in the way the matter
had been adopted by the legislature. In noting that nearly
two years had passed between the time the concurrent
resolution had been adopted and the vote held, the court
determined that if objections had been raised before the
popular vote, "the legislature could have been easily
convened, and the defect remedied." 24 Kan. at 720. Implicit
in both this language and that quoted above is the assumption
that the legislature may alter a concurrent resolution
containing a constitutional change prior to its submission to
the voters.
In a later case, the authority of the legislature to revise
previously passed concurrent resolutions was made more
specific. The decision of State ex rel. v. Shanahan, 183
Kan. 464 (1958) discussed several challenges to the submission
of an amendment to the voters in 1958 which had been approved
by the legislature in the proceeding year. One of the
challenges concerned a procedural point, namely that the
concurrent resolution had not been properly entered in the
journal of the senate after being initially approved in the
house. At oral argument, this objection was abandoned by the
plaintiff, Attorney General John Anderson, in that the 1958
special session of the legislature had corrected the defect
following the filing of the suit. The ability of the
legislature to amend a previously-passed concurrent
resolution was again not questioned. See also State ex rel.
v. Sessions, 87 Kan. 497, 501 (1912) ("The right [of the
legislature] to determine what form a proposed amendment on a
particular subject shall take implies the right to reject a
proposal submitted at a former session, and this implies the
right to control absolutely the matter of amendment to be
submitted at the ensuing election.")
General authorities are also unanimous in concluding that a
state legislature may alter or repeal a concurrent resolution
containing a proposed constitutional change prior to the time
that such question is presented for a popular vote. 16 C.J.S.
Constitutional Law §11, p. 52 (1984) states:
"Prior to ratification by the people, a
proposed legislative amendment is of no
effect whatever, . . ., and it may be
amended before submission for ratification.
"The legislature may reconsider its action
on a constitutional amendment, and it may
recall its bill proposing a constitutional
amendment, from a state official for
further consideration and amendment, while
it is still in session."
16 Am.Jur.2d Constitutional Law §38, p. 354 (1979) is in
accord.
Accordingly, it is our opinion that the 1986 session of the
Kansas Legislature is free to either amend the provisions of
1985 House Concurrent Resolution No. 5018 in any fashion it
desires, to revoke the resolution and replace it with another
dealing with the same subject, or to remove the question
entirely from consideration by the voters in the general
election in 1986. Under any of these possible options, the
same vote will be needed as was originally required for
passage of the resolution (two-thirds of the total
membership of both houses of the legislature).
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF KANSAS
JeffreyS.Southard
Deputy Attorney General
RTS:JSS:crw

Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude

Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.