Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1985-026

1985-026Kanag

Texte intégral

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL
February 27, 1985
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 85- 26
Peter Rinn
Chief Counsel
Kansas Department of Social and
Rehabilitation Services
State Office Building, 6th Floor
Topeka, Kansas 66612
Re: Infants -- Kansas Code for Care of Children -- Filing
of Petition on Referral by SRS or Other Person; Filing
by Individual -- Authority of SRS to File Child in Need
of Care Petitions
Synopsis: The Kansas Code for Care of Children allows an indivi-
dual to initiate a petition alleging a child is in
need of care, and provides that said individual may
retain legal counsel to present the case to a court
of competent jurisdiction. The Secretary of SRS or
his representative, as an individual, may file such a
petition and use the agency legal staff to present
the case. Such authority fulfills the federal statutory
mandates. The definition of abused and neglected child
as set out in the code substantially complies with the
parameters of federal law. Cited herein: K.S.A. 1984
Supp. 38-1501; 38-1502; 38-1510; 38-1529; K.S.A.
77-201 Second, Thirteenth; 42 U.S.C.A. §5101, §5102,
§5103, as amended by P.L. 98-457.
Dear Mr. Rinn:
As chief counsel to the Kansas Department of Social and
Rehabilitation Services (SRS), you request our opinion whether
certain provisions of the Kansas Code for Care of Children (the
code) (K.S.A. 1984 Supp. 38-1501 et seq.), conform with the
provisions of the Child Abuse Prevention and Treatment Act (42
U.S.C.A. §1501 et seq.). You specifically inquire as to the
authority of SRS to initiate child in need of care petitions
pursuant to the code and the adequacy of the code's definition of
child abuse and neglect.
The first question submitted concerns whether current provisions
of the code, as contained in K.S.A. 1984 Supp. 38-1501 et sea.,
allow the agency to enforce the provisions of the code by the
initiation of a petition. 42 U.S.C.A. §5103 was amended in 1984
by the Child Abuse Amendments of 1984, Public Law 98-457,
(commonly referred to as the Baby Doe Amendments), with the
addition of subsection (k). As amended, that statute reads in
pertinent part as follows:
"(b)(1) The Secretary [of Health and Human
Services], through the Center [National Center
on Child Abuse and Neglect] is authorized to
make grants to the States for the purpose of
assisting the States in developing,
strengthening, and carrying out child abuse
and neglect prevention and treatment programs.
"(2) In order for a State to qualify for
assistance under this subsection, such State
shall--
"(k) within one year after the date of the
enactment of the Child Abuse Amendments of
1984, have in place for the purpose of
responding to the reporting of medical neglect
(including instances of withholding of
medically indicated treatment from disabled
infants with life-threatening conditions),
procedures or programs, or both (within the
State child protection services system), to
provide for . . . (iii) authority, under
State law, for the State child protection
service system to pursue any legal remedies,
including the authority to initiate legal
proceedings in a court of competent
jurisdiction, as may be necessary to prevent
the withholding of medically indicated
treatment from disabled infants with
life-threatening conditions." (Emphasis
added.)
You ask whether, in light of the provisions contained in K.S.A.
1984 Supp. 38-1510, the agency can initiate legal proceedings
under K.S.A. 1984 Supp. 38-1529 and therefore be in compliance
with 42 U.S.C.A. §5103 as amended. K.S.A. 1984 Supp. 38-1510
states:
"It shall be the duty of the county or
district attorney to prepare and file the
petition alleging a child to be a child in
need of care and to appear at the hearing on
the petition and to present evidence that will
aid the court in making an appropriate
adjudication at the conclusion of the
hearing." (Emphasis added.)
K.S.A. 1984 Supp. 38-1529 reads:
"(a) Whenever the state department of social
and rehabilitation services or any other
person refers a case to the county or district
attorney for the purpose of filing a petition
alleging that a child is a child in need of
care, the county or district attorney shall
review the facts and recommendations of the
department and any other evidence available
and make a determination whether or not the
circumstances warrant the filing of the
petition.
"(b) Any individual may file a petition
alleging a child is a child in need of care
and the individual may be represented by the
individual's own attorney in the presentation
of the case. (Emphasis added.)
In arriving at an answer to your question, it is first necessary
to determine the intent of the legislation as to who may file
petitions under this code and the meaning of the term
"individual." Initially, it would appear that K.S.A. 1984 Supp.
38-1510 and 38-1529 are in conflict with one another. Therefore,
the legislative history should be examined. Southeast Kansas
Landowners Ass'n v. Kansas Turnpike Authority, 224 Kan. 357
(1978). In reviewing the comments made by the Kansas Judicial
Council in the re-write of the code in 1981, we find that the
above-named statutes reincorporated K.S.A. 1980 Supp. 38-815c
and 38-816 (repealed, L. 1982, ch. 182). These earlier
provisions placed a duty on the county and district attorneys to
present a prefiling determination to the court, which then
decided whether to procede. The new code provisions leave that
determination to the prosecutor. The 1981 Judicial Council
Bulletin Comments state:
"This section replaces K.S.A. 1980 Supp.
38-816 and removes the court from the making
of prefiling determinations, except in limited
circumstances covered in subsection (c) of
this section. This is consistent with the
policy of the Committee to maintain the
impartiality of the court.
"Subsection (a) places the duty of determining
whether or not a petition should be filed with
the county or district attorney.
"Subsection (b) provides for the possibility
of an individual filing a petition and
proceeding with retained counsel.
"Subsection (c) deals with the contingency of
an individual filing the petition, but
requesting the county or district attorney to
present the case." (Emphasis added.) Comments
to Section 1529, Judicial Council Bulletin, p.
29, 30, June, 1981.
Although the final version is somewhat different from the
proposed language, it is apparent that the intent of K.S.A.
38-1529, as well as 38-1510, was to remove the need for a
court to make a pre-filing determination. See Comments, supra,
p. 17.
A general rule of statutory construction is that all the
provisions in an act must be read in pari materia
[Claflin v. Walsh, 212 Kan. 1 (1973)], and, if possible,
construed to be consistent. Capital Services, Inc. v. Dahlinger
Pontiac-Cadillac, 232 Kan. 419 (1983). As it would be
inconsistent to give an individual an opportunity to file a
petition, then limit enforcement only to county and district
attorneys, we can only conclude that the intent of the drafters
was to place an affirmative duty on county and district attorneys
to review and prosecute child abuse violations, not to make
enforcement an exclusive function of prosecutors only. For
further support, see In re Hamlett, 2 Kan.App.2nd 642 (1978).
Further, we note that code violations are civil, not criminal,
in nature. K.S.A. 1984 Supp. 38-1501.
As it is our opinion that an "individual" has the authority to
initiate petitions for enforcement of the code under K.S.A. 1984
Supp. 38-1529(b), we must now determine whether SRS would be
able to do so. Another rule of statutory construction is that
words be given their ordinary and usual meaning. K.S.A.
77-221 Second, "Individual" is defined: "as a noun, this
term denotes a single person as distinguished from a group or
class, and also, very commonly, a private or natural person as
distinguished from a partnership, corporation or association
. . ." Black's Law Dictionary Revised Fourth Edition, p. 913
(1968). Based upon the use of the word "individual," as opposed
to "person," which is defined to include corporations (K.S.A.
77-201, Thirteenth), we must conclude that the drafters meant one
human being. Accordingly, as an agency SRS could not file an
action under K.S.A. 1984 Supp. 38-1529(b).
However, this result is not dispositive of the question, for
the federal statute in question only requires that the agency be
able to enforce the code provisions. We have been able to find
no language that would prohibit an individual, connected with the
agency, such as Dr. Harder or a case worker, from initiating an
action. Therefore, since the secretary or his designated
representative, could bring an action as an individual, the
agency would be able to enforce the code and thereby be in
compliance with 42 U.S.C.A. §5103(k).
Your second question concerns Kansas statutory definition of
child abuse and neglect and its similarity to federal law.
42 U.S.C.A. §5102 defines child abuse and neglect as follows:
"The physical or mental injury, sexual abuse
or exploitation, negligent treatment, or
maltreatment of a child under the age of
eighteen, or the age specified by the child
protection laws of the State in question, by a
person who is responsible for the child's
health or welfare under circumstances which
indicate that the child's health or welfare is
harmed or threatened thereby, as determined in
accordance with regulations prescribed by the
Secretary."
K.S.A. 1984 Supp. 38-1502(b) defines "physical mental or
emotional abuse or neglect" as:
"The infliction of physical, mental or
emotional injury or the causing of a
deterioration of a child and may include, but
shall not be limited to, failing to maintain
reasonable care and treatment, negligent
treatment or maltreatment or exploiting a
child to the extent that the child's health or
emotional well-being is endangered."
Although the definitions and terminology are different between
the two statutes, we feel that there is sufficient similarity in
the two to include the same types of situations. For example,
both statutes speak to both physical and mental injury, negligent
treatment, maltreatment and exploitation. Also, it is enough
that the child's health or well-being is endangered or threatened,
without actual harm having to be shown. In light of these
similarities, we have little hesitancy in concluding that the
parameters of K.S.A. 1984 Supp. 38-1502 fit within the
guidelines of 42 U.S.C.A. §5102.
In conclusion, we are of the opinion that the Kansas Code for
Care of Children allows an "individual" to initiate a petition
alleging a child is a child in need of care, and provides that
said individual may retain legal counsel to present the case to a
court of competent jurisdiction. The Secretary of SRS or his
representative, as an individual, may file such a petition and use
the agency's legal staff to present the case. Such authority
fulfills the federal statutory mandates. In addition, the
definition of abused and neglected child as set out in the code
substantially complies with the parameters of the federal law.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF KANSAS
Matthew W. Boddington
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:JSS:MWB:crw

Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude

Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.