Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1983-180

1983-180Kanag

Texte intégral

December 15, 1983
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 83 - 180
John Horst
Caney City Attorney
Caney, Kansas 67333
Re: Automobiles and Other Vehicles--Act Regulating
Traffic; Rules of the Road--Overtaking and Passing
School Buses
Schools--Transportation of Students--Transportation
Routes
Synopsis: Local boards of education are not required to provide
school bus loading areas which allow school buses
to be stopped entirely off the roadway portion of
all city streets.
In addition, while K.S.A. 8-1556(b) and Section 81
of Article 12 of the Uniform Standard Traffic
Ordinance for Kansas Cities prohibit a school bus
driver from activating the flashing warning signal
lamps on the bus when the bus is stopped entirely
off the roadway in designated school bus loading
areas, the same subsections of law expressly autho-
rize those lamps to be activated when the bus is
stopped on a roadway to receive or discharge students.
Finally, an area on and along a city street, which
is part of the roadway of the street, continues to be
a part of the roadway, although the area is posted
as a no parking zone. The stopping of a school
bus on this portion of a city street to receive
or discharge children has no effect on the school
bus driver's authority to activate the flashing
warning signal lamps on the bus. Cited herein:
K.S.A. 8-1459, 8-1556, K.S.A. 72-8301, K.A.R. 1983
Supp. 36-13-33, Kan. Const., Art. 6, S5.
Dear Mr. Horst:
At the direction of the governing body of the city of Caney,
you seek our opinion on a number of questions concerning the
stopping of school buses at the local elementary school to
receive or discharge students. Specifically, you inquire whether
the school bus drivers may activate the flashing warning signal
lamps on the buses while children are entering or departing the
buses at the elementary school; whether a portion of the road-
way of the city street upon which school buses stop to load
and unload children, which is posted as a "no parking zone"
during school hours, should be considered an area "off the
roadway" under K.S.A. 8-1556 and its counterpart, Article 12,
Section 81 of the Uniform Standard Traffic Ordinances for Kansas
Cities, which has been adopted by the city of Caney; and, finally,
whether the local school board is required to provide a school
bus loading area for children, which allows buses to be stopped
entirely off the roadway portion of all city streets.
In correspondence sent to our office, including photographs
of the four streets which bound the property on which the
elementary school is located, there is much discussion as to
that which the board of education could do concerning the place
at which the buses stop and the manner in which children are
transported by the school district. This information, however,
involves policy questions and is not germane to the legal issues
presented by your inquiry.
Neither state or local law enforcement officers, private citizens,
nor anyone else [except the governing body of a city which may
enact reasonable local ordinances controlling the use of city
streets], has the authority to compel the local board of education
to adopt any prescribed point at the school location as the point
at which children are to enter or depart school buses, or to
dictate to the board of education the procedures by which the
school district should provide transportation for children of
the school district. These matters, by state law, are under the
control, and are left to the sound discretion, of the locally-
elected board of education. See Kan. Const., Art. 6, Sec. 5 and
K.S.A. 72-8301 et seq.
This leads to a discussion of your inquiry concerning whether
the local school board must provide a school bus loading area
which is entirely off the roadway portion of all city streets.
This question, along with the others you pose, arises from the
provisions of K.S.A. 8-1556 and Article 12, Section 81 of the
Uniform Standard Traffic Ordinances for Kansas Cities (USTO).
The statute provides, in part:
"(a) The driver of a vehicle meeting or
overtaking from either direction any
school bus stopped on the highway shall
stop before reaching such school bus
when there is in operation on said school
bus the flashing red lights specified in
subsection (a) of K.S.A. 8-1730, and said
driver shall not proceed until such school
bus resumes motion or said driver is signaled
by the school bus driver to proceed or the
flashing red lights and the stop signal
arm are no longer actuated.
"(b) Every school bus shall be equipped
with red visual signals meeting the require-
ments of subsection (a) of K.S.A. 8-1730,
which may be actuated by the driver of said
school bus whenever but only whenever such,
vehicle is stopped on the highway for the
purpose of receiving or discharging school
children. A school bus driver shall not
actuate said special visual signals:
"(1) At intersections or other places
where traffic is controlled by traffic-
control signals or police officers; or
"(2) In designated school bus loading areas
where the bus is entirely off the roadway."
(Emphasis added.)
The ordinance contains the same provisions as the statute which
are emphasized above.
Our attention has not been called to any requirement of law, and
we find none, which mandates that "school bus loading areas,"
sufficiently large to permit school buses to be stopped "entirely
off the roadway," be designated. The above-quoted statute and
the provisions of the local ordinance merely prescribe what shall
be done if such an area has been designated. They do not require
the designation of such an area. Moreover, K.A.R. 1983 Supp.
36-13-33(a)(1) merely prescribes that the "loading and unloading
of students onto and off of school buses shall be conducted off
the roadway, highway or street, in an area way from vehicular
traffic, whenever possible." (Emphasis added.) Of course, this
direction to school bus drivers does not impose a duty upon any
local board of education. Thus, finding no requirement of law
mandating such action, we conclude that a local board of education
is not required to designate a school bus loading area, sufficient
in size to permit a school bus to be stopped entirely off the road-
way portion of all city streets.
Turning, now, to your inquiry about whether the posting of an
area along a city street, which street, from curb to curb, is
a roadway, as a no parking zone during school hours renders that
area to be "off the roadway," we fail to see how the mere posting
of such an area as a no parking zone could possibly render that
area to not continue to be a part of the roadway. A "roadway"
is defined in K.S.A. 8-1459 as "that portion of a highway improved,
designed or ordinarily used for vehicular travel, exclusive of the
berm or shoulder." Thus, if a portion of a highway is improved,
designed or ordinarily used for vehicular travel, it is a roadway.
That parking on a roadway is prohibited during a certain period
of time does not effect its status as a roadway.
Thus, in response to your inquiry, we conclude that an area on
and along a city street which is part of the roadway of the
street continues to be a part of the roadway, although the area
is posted as a no parking zone.
Your final inquiry is whether school bus drivers may activate
the flashing warning signal lamps on the buses while children
are entering or departing the school buses at the elementary
school located in Caney. You inform us that the school buses
of your local school district, while receiving and discharging
children at the elementary school, are stopped on Taylor Street
in the city of Caney. It also appears that the entire width
of Taylor Street is improved, designed and ordinarily used for
vehicular traffic. Given these facts, we have no hesitancy in
concluding that, under the provisions of K.S.A. 8-1556(b) and
Section 81 of Chapter 12 of the USTO, quoted-above, the school
bus drivers may take the action mentioned above.
In summary, it is our opinion that local boards of education are
not required to provide school bus loading areas which allow
school buses to be stopped entirely off the roadway portion of
all city streets.
In addition, while K.S.A. 8-1556(b) and Section 81 of Article 12
of the Uniform Standard Traffic Ordinances for Kansas Cities
prohibit a school bus driver from activating the flashing warning
signal lamps on the bus when the bus is stopped entirely off the
roadway in designated school bus loading areas, the same subsections
of law expressly authorize those lamps to be activated when the
bus is stopped on a roadway to receive or discharge students.
Finally, an area on and along a city street which is part of
the roadway of the street continues to be a part of the roadway,
although the area is posted as a no parking zone. The stopping
of a school bus on this portion of a city street to receive or
discharge children has no effect on the school bus driver's
authority to activate the flashing warning signal lamps on the
bus.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
Attorney General of Kansas
Rodney J. Bieker
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:BJS:RJB:jm

Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude

Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.