Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1983-165

1983-165Kanag

Texte intégral

November 14, 1983
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 83- 165
Thomas J. Kennedy
Director
Alcoholic Beverage Control Division
Kansas Department of Revenue
700 Jackson Street, 2nd Floor
Topeka, Kansas 66603
Re: Intoxicating Liquors and Beverages -- Licensing
and Regulation of Clubs -- Eligible Parties;
Limited Partnerships
Synopsis: K.S.A. 41-2623(e) requires that all the members
of a partnership be individually qualified to ob-
tain a license before the partnership itself can
secure a license. However, subsection (f) of the
same statute exempts stockholders of a corporation
who own 5% or less of the corporate stock from any
requirements. In that the limited partners of a
partnership organized under K.S.A. 56-122 et seq.
(the Kansas Limited Partnership Act) have the
attributes of shareholders in a corporation rather
than partners in a general partnership, the re-
quirements of subsection (f) of K.S.A. 41-2623
should be applied as to such partners in the grant-
ing of a license to a limited partnership. Cited
herein: K.S.A. 41-2623, 56-125, 56-126, 56 - 128,
56-131.
* *
Dear Mr. Kennedy:
As Director of the Alcoholic Beverage Control Division of
the Kansas Department of Revenue, you request our opinion
on a question concerning the licensing of private clubs under
K.S.A. 41-2601, et seq. Specifically, you inquire regarding
the treatment of limited partnerships which seek a private
club license under K.S.A. 41-2623. Under this statute, dif-
ferent standards exist for determining the eligibility of
partnerships and corporations for such licenses. Since a
limited partnership has attributes of both a partnership and
a corporation, you inquire as to which procedure should be
followed in determining its eligibility.
As you note, K.S.A. 41-2623 sets forth the basic qualifica-
tions for those persons who wish to obtain a Class "B" pri-
vate club license (Class "A" licenses are available to only
a limited number of entities and are not-for-profit, and so
do not enter into either your inquiry or this opinion).
You paraphrase the requirements of K.S.A. 41-2623 as follows:
"1. Residence in the same county as the club
premises, both currently and for one (1) year
preceding the date of the application;
"2. Residence in Kansas for at least five
(5) years preceding the date of the applica-
tion;
"3. No beneficial interest in any other club
or in any other aspect of the liquor business
(with certain exceptions); and
"4. Other requirements common to all classes
of liquor licenses."
K.S.A. 41-2623(3) states that a "copartnership" cannot obtain
a license unless all of the partners are qualified as indi-
viduals. K.S.A. 41-2623(f) exempts all officers, directors,
managers and stockholders of any Kansas corporation from the
residence and citizenship requirements [the latter is found in
K.S.A. 41-311(a)], and by implication exempts any stockholder
who owns five percent or less of the common or preferred stock
from all requirements.
Kansas has adopted the provisions of the Uniform Limited Part-
nership Act, K.S.A. 56-122 et seq., which set forth the steps
which must be taken to establish and maintain a limited part-
nership. Like a corporation, a limited partnership is
strictly a creation of statute, and so differs from a general
partnership which has its roots in common law. State v.
Williams, 196 Kan. 274 (1966). The role of the limited part-
ner is strictly limited by the Act, which provides variously
that: A limited partner cannot contribute services, only
cash or other property (K.S.A. 56-125); a limited partner's
surname may not appear in the partnership's name (K.S.A. 56-126);
and the rights of a limited partner are the same as those of
a general partner only as to access to partnership books and
financial affairs, and in the area of dissolution. (K.S.A.
56-131). By implication, a limited partner cannot become
involved in the business affairs of the partnership without
sacrificing the protection from liability which such status
otherwise confers. See, e.g., Columbia Land and Cattle Co.
v. Daly, 46 Kan. 504 (1891); K.S.A. 56-128.
In view of the above differences between a general and a
limited partner, courts have tended to view limited partners
in a different light. In Ruzicka v. Rager, 305 N.Y. 191, 111
N.E.2d 878, 39 ALR 2d 288 (1953), the court stated:
"Statutes permitting limited partnerships are
intended to encourage investment in business
enterprise by affording to a limited partner
a position analogous to that of a corporate
shareholder. Due to the quasi-corporate as-
pects of a limited partnership and the quasi-
shareholder status of a limited partner in
that his liability is restricted to the amount
of his investment and his voice in partnership
affairs is negligible, it seems proper that
in a suit by a limited partnership, the indi-
vidual partners, whether general or limited,
ought not to be subject to counterclaims
against them upon causes of action unrelated
to partnership affairs." 39 A.L.R. 2d at 293.
A more detailed discussion of the legal status of a limited
partner is found in Klebanow v. New York Produce Exchange,
344 F.2d 294 (2nd Cir. 1965), where at page 297 the court
found as follows:
"A limited partner, barred from using his name
in the firm title, said to lack 'property
rights' in partnership assets, and presumed
to have priority over other partners in the
distribution of assets, does have some resem-
blance to a creditor. (Citations omitted.)
"However, in the main, a limited partner is
more like a shareholder, often expecting a
share of the profits, subordinated to general
creditors, having some control over direction
of the enterprise by his veto on the admis-
sion of new partners, and able to examine
books and 'have on demand true and full in-
formation of all things affecting the part-
nership * *' See N.Y. Partnership Law §§
98,99,112. That the limited partner is im-
mune to personal liability for partnership
debts save for his original investment, is
not thought to be an 'owner' of partnership
property, and does not manage the business
may distinguish him from general partners
but strengthens his resemblance to the stock-
holder; and even as to his preference in
dissolution, he resembles the preferred stock-
holder."
See also Lynn v. Cohen, 359 F. Supp. 565 (S.D.N.Y. 1973), 60
Am.Jur.2d Partnership, §371 (1972).
In view of the above authorities, it is our conclusion that
a limited partner should be treated as a corporate share-
holder, and not as a general partner, for the purposes of
licensure under K.S.A. 41-2623. A limited partner's relation-
ship to the business which is run by the partnership is as
remote as that of a stockholder in a corporation, i.e., he
or she is entitled to a share of the proceeds, but has no
actual control of the operations. To treat each limited
partner as a general partner, and so require them to meet
the requirements of K.S.A. 41-2623, would be a distortion
of the legal realities which are present in a limited part-
nership. Therefore, any limited partner who has an invest-
ment equal to five percent or less of the partnership may
be treated as would a stockholder with such an interest
under K.S.A. 41-2623(f). Holders of more than five percent
interest should be subject to the residency and citizenship
requirements, as are stockholders who own interests of this
size.
In conclusion, K.S.A. 41-2623(e) requires that all the mem-
bers of a partnership be individually qualified to obtain a
license before the partnership itself can secure a license.
However, subsection (f) of the same statute exempts stock-
holders of a corporation who own 5% or less of the corporate
stock from any requirements. In that the limited partners
of a partnership organized under K.S.A. 56-122 et seq. (the
Kansas Limited Partnership Act) have the attributes of share-
holders in a corporation rather than partners in a general
partnership, the requirements of subsection (f) of K.S.A.
41-2623 should be applied as to such partners in the granting
of a license to a limited partnership.
Very truly yours,
ROBERTT.STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF KANSAS
JeffreyS.	Southard
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:BJS:JSS:hle

Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude

Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.