Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1983-089

1983-089Kanag

Texte intégral

June 13, 1983
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 83 - 89
The Honorable Steven A. Ediger
Representative, One Hundred-Fourth District
716 East 14th Street Terrace
Hutchinson, Kansas 67501
Re: Counties and County Officers -- Planning and
Zoning -- Subdivision of Land; Reasonableness of
Regulations
Synopsis: Pursuant to K.S.A. 19-2918b, the board of county
commissioners and the governing body of any city
within the county may establish a joint committee
for subdivision regulation. The committee is em-
powered to adopt regulations governing the subdi-
vision of land within the area subject to the
jurisdiction of both the city and the county.
Such regulations may provide for, among other
things, the location and width of streets. Pro-
vided a regulation requiring the dedication of
land for future improvements to an existing, ad-
joining highway is reasonable, it is a legitimate
exercise of the police power granted to counties
and cities in the area of land use and development,
and is not a taking of property without just com-
pensation. Cited herein: K.S.A. 19-2918, 19-2918b,
19-2918c.
Dear Representative Ediger:
As State Representative for the 104th District, which includes
a portion of the City of Hutchinson, Kansas, you request our
opinion on a question concerning a subdivision regulation and
its effect on a landowner. Specifically, you inform us that
a constituent who owns land in Reno County outside the city
has been informed that he must dedicate a 20-foot strip of
land adjacent to K-96 Highway before the subdivision plat
will be approved. You wish to know whether such a dedication
requirement is authorized by existing Kansas statutes and,
if so, whether the effect of the regulation here is so un-
reasonable as to constitute a taking of private property
without due compensation. You further inform us that the
strip in question contains a number of evergreen trees, and
that the property itself is located well outside the city
limits of Hutchinson.
Initially, it should be said that the area of subdivision
regulation involves a close relationship between planning,
zoning and platting. Hudson Oil Co. v. City of Wichita, 193
Kan. 623, 628 (1964). Prior to 1965, the state of the law
in these areas evinced confusion. City of Salina v. Jaggers,
228 Kan. 155 (1980). In that year, the legislature took steps
to coordinate the development of subdivisions, especially in
unincorporated areas of a county located near a city. It did
so by enacting what are now K.S.A. 19-2918, 19-2918b and
19-2918c, which set forth the procedure for creating a joint
subdivision regulation committee, its powers, and the nature
and extent of regulations it could adopt concerning subdivi-
sion of land. In that each of these statutes is of relevance
here, their pertinent provisions should be examined.
K.S.A. 19-2918b attempts to deal with situations in which
both the county and a city therein have an interest in regu-
lating development through subdivision of tracts of land.
In part, it states:
"If the area designated by the board of county
commissioners shall include lands lying within
any area designated and governed by the regu-
lations of any city, a copy of the resolution
of the board of county commissioners shall be
certified to the governing body of said city
or if at any time subsequent to the adoption
of regulations governing the subdivision of
land by the county, the governing body of any
city shall by resolution designate an area
for such purposes which shall include lands
lying within the area designated and governed
by regulations of the county, the governing
body of such city shall certify a copy of such
resolution to the board of county commissioners
and regulations governing the subdivision of
land within the area designated by the city
shall be adopted and administered in the man-
ner hereinafter provided. Within sixty (60)
days after the date of the certification of
said resolution by the board of county commis-
sioners or the governing body of the city
there shall be established by joint resolution,
of said board of commissioners and governing
body, a joint committee for subdivision regula-
tion which shall be composed of three (3) mem-
bers of the county planning board and three
(3) members of the city planning commission
to be appointed by the chairmen of such board
and commission and one (1) member to be se-
lected by the six (6) members. Such joint
committee shall have such authority as is pro-
vided by law for county planning boards and
city planning commissions relating to the
adoption and administration of regulations
governing the subdivision of land within the
area of joint designation." (Emphasis added.)
K.S.A. 19-2918 contains the procedure for the adoption of
such subdivision regulations, as well as the areas which may
be covered and provides in pertinent part thus:
"The planning board may adopt regulations gov-
erning the subdivision of land within that
portion of the unincorporated area of the
county, and the incorporated area of any city
upon the written request by resolution of the
governing body of such city, when the same
shall have been designated by resolution of
the board of county commissioners for that
purpose. No such regulations or changes or
amendments thereto adopted by a county plan-
ning board shall become effective unless and
until the same has been submitted to and ap-
proved by the board of county commissioners
and no such regulations or changes or amend-
ments thereto adopted by a joint committee as
hereinafter provided shall become effective
unless and until the same has been submitted
to and approved by both the board of county
commissioners and the governing body of the
city. Such regulations may provide for the
location and width of streets, building lines,
open spaces for traffic, utilities, access for
fire-fighting apparatus, recreation, light,
and air, for the avoidance of congestion of
population, including minimum width and area
of lots and for flood protection and flood-
plain regulations. . . ." (Emphasis added.)
Lastly, K.S.A. 19-2918c sets forth the impact of the subdivi-
sion regulations on a landowner who wishes to develop his or
her property.
"Whenever regulations governing the subdivi-
sion of land shall have been adopted under
the provisions of this act, the owner or own-
ers of any land located within the area gov-
erned by such regulations, subdividing the
same into lots and blocks or tracts or parcels,
for the purpose of laying out any subdivision,
suburban lots, building lots, tracts or par-
cels or the owner of any land establishing any
street, alley, park or other property intended
for public use or for the use of purchasers or
owners of lots, tracts or parcels of land
fronting thereon or adjacent thereto, shall
cause a plat to be made which shall accurately
describe the subdivision, lots, tracts or par-
cels of land giving the location and dimen-
sions thereof or the location and dimensions
of all streets, alleys, parks or other pro-
perties intended to be dedicated to public
use or for the use of purchasers or owners
of lots, tracts or parcels of land fronting
thereon or adjacent thereto and every such
plat shall be duly acknowledged by the owner
or owners thereof. All such plats shall be
submitted to the county planning board or to
the joint committee for subdivision regula-
tion if such has been formed, which shall de-
termine if the same conforms to the provisions
of the subdivision regulations . . . ." (Em-
phasis added.)
Given the above statutory framework, it remains to examine
the particular regulation involved here. As adopted by the
Hutchinson-Reno County Joint Subdivision Committee, and sub-
sequently approved by both the county commission and the
city commission, the regulation at issue requires that a
principal rural arterial street have a minimum right-of-way
of 100 feet. K-96 Highway, which abuts the constituent's
property on one side, is classified as such a street. At
present, K-96 has a 60 foot right-of-way. The 20 feet re-
quired for dedication by the landowner-developer is accord-
ingly half of the amount needed to meet the minimum standard
set forth by the regulation. Despite a request for a vari-
ance, the joint committee required the dedication to be made
as a condition for obtaining a plat. Factors presented by
the Reno County Public Works Department for the committee's
consideration included the need for such right-of-way in the
future. Potential development could necessitate the addition
of more lanes, a frontage road, and bicycle lanes, as well as
providing for uses such as a bus stop. While there are trees
in the 20 foot strip, the lots themselves, being over 350 feet
deep, are not greatly reduced in size by the proposed dedica-
tion.
As noted by numerous Kansas decisions, land use restrictions
are grounded in the authority of the state and (through dele-
gation) cities and counties to protect the public health,
safety and welfare. City of Douglass v. Tri-Co. Fertilizer,
Inc., 214 Kan. 154 (1974), Grigsby v. Mitchum, 191 Kan. 293
(1963). While broad discretion is vested in the governing
body to determine what is deleterious to health, morals or
the general welfare, it does not have the power to impose
restrictions that are so arbitrary, oppressive or capricious
as to have no reasonable basis. State ex rel. Stephan v. Lane,
228 Kan. 379 (1980). The mark of unreasonable action by
zoning authorities is "when the action is so arbitrary it
can be said it was taken without regard to the benefit or
harm involved to the community at large including all inter-
ested parties and was so wide of the mark its unreasonableness
lies outside the realm of fair debate." Gaslight Villa, Inc.
v. City of Lansing, 213 Kan. 862, Syl. ¶3 (1974). Of course,
as is the case in other fields of the law, the determination
of what is reasonable in a land use dispute has troubled trial
and appellate courts alike. Golden v. City of Overland Park,
224 Kan. 591 (1978).
As a general rule, when in doubt courts have deferred to the
determination of the governing body who passed the regulation
as to its reasonableness. It has been repeatedly said that
a court may not substitute its judgment for that of a city
or county [Hukle v. City of Kansas City, 212 Kan. 627 (1962)],
and will not declare the action unreasonable unless clearly
compelled to do so by the evidence. Arkenberg v. City of
Topeka, 197 Kan. 731 (1966). Should the regulation be found
to be unreasonable, the governing body may still act, but
under the more restrictive procedures of eminent domain,
whereby the taking must be compensated. Smith v. State High-
way Commission, 185 Kan. 445 (1959).
In our opinion, it cannot be concluded here that the right-
of-way requirement is so arbitrary, oppressive or capricious
as to be without reasonable basis. Given the nature of the
road involved (a state highway) and the distance from the
Hutchinson city limits (between 2 and 3 miles), the potential
for further development is not merely theoretical. The con-
siderations for the dedication of the additional land are
valid ones, and the statute (K.S.A. 19-2918) specifically
allows for regulations governing the location and width of
streets, with nothing said about whether the streets must be
new or existing. Since any development in the subdivided
property will contribute in part to heavier traffic on the
highway, the requirement that a portion of land be dedicated
for future improvements has a rational basis. While the need
at this time for such action can be debated, such issues are
not for the courts but for the legislature. State ex rel.
Stephan v. Lane, supra, at 392.
In conclusion, pursuant to K.S.A. 19-2918b, the board of
county commissioners and the governing body of any city within
the county may establish a joint committee for subdivision
regulation. The committee is empowered to adopt regulations
governing the subdivision of land within the area subject
to the jurisdiction of both the city and the county. Such
regulations may provide for, among other things, the location
and width of streets. Provided a regulation requiring the
dedication of land for future improvements to an existing,
adjoining highway is reasonable, it is a legitimate exercise
of the police power granted to counties and cities in the
area of land use and development, and is not a taking of
property without just compensation.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
Attorney General of Kansas
Jeffrey S. Southard
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:BJS:JSS:hle

Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude

Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.