Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1982-226

1982-226Kanag

Texte intégral

October 21, 1982
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 82- 226
Mr. Nick Tomasic
District Attorney
29th Judicial District
Wyandotte County Courthouse
Kansas City, Kansas 66101
Re: Crimes and Punishments -- Identification and Detec-
tion of Crimes and Criminals -- Records of Felony
Offenses
Laws, Journals and Public Information -- Records
Open to Public -- Records of Felony Offenses
Synopsis: K.S.A. 21-2501a(a) requires that law enforcement
agencies maintain permanent records of specified
crimes "on forms approved by the attorney general."
Such forms, therefore, constitute the records
which are required to be maintained, and all in-
formation required by these forms is included in
such records. Unless such records contain infor-
mation which is made confidential by law or by
directive authorized by law, all information con-
tained in such records is available for public
inspection under the Public Records Act (K.S.A.
45-201 et seq.). If these records contain such
confidential information, the law enforcement
agency having custody of the records has a duty
to make available for public inspection all dis-
closable portions of the records in a way which
protects the confidentiality of the nondisclosable
information. Cited herein: K.S.A. 21-2501a,
45-201.
Dear Mr. Tomasic:
You have inquired as to what information is required by law
to be included in the permanent record which must be kept and
maintained by law enforcement agencies pursuant to K.S.A.
21-2501a. In addition, you inquire as to what portion of the
record maintained in accordance with K.S.A. 21-2501a must be
open to public inspection pursuant to K.S.A. 45-201(a).
Subsection (a) of K.S.A. 21-2501a provides as follows:
"All law enforcement agencies having respon-
sibility for law enforcement in any political
subdivision of the state shall maintain, on
forms approved by the attorney general, a per-
manent record of all felony offenses reported
or known to have been committed within their
respective jurisdictions, and of all misde-
meanors or other offenses which involve the
violation of the uniform controlled substances
act." (Emphasis added.)
From the foregoing, it is apparent that permanent records of
the specified crimes must be maintained "on forms approved
by the attorney general." Accordingly, in response to your
first question, it is our opinion that the completed forms
constitute the records which must be maintained by law enforce-
ment agencies under this statute. Hence, all information re-
quired by these forms is included in such records.
As to your second inquiry, K.S.A. 45-201(a) states:
"All official public records of the state,
counties, municipalities, townships, school
districts, commissions, agencies and legisla-
tive bodies, which records by law are required
to be kept and maintained, except those of
the district court concerning proceedings pur-
suant to the juvenile code which shall be open
unless specifically closed by the judge or by
law, adoption records, records of the birth
of illegitimate children, and records speci-
fically closed by law or by directive autho-
rized by law, shall at all times be open for
a personal inspection by any citizen, and
those in charge of such records shall not re-
fuse this priviledge to any citizen."
This statute has been considered by the Kansas Supreme Court
on a number of occasions. Several of these cases have rele-
vance to your inquiry. In Atchison, T. & S.F. Rly. Co. v.
Commission on Civil Rights, 215 Kan. 911 (1974), it was held
that "45-201 applies only to public records which are required
by law to be kept and maintained." (Emphasis by the Court.)
Id. at 919. Subsequently, in Stephens v. Van Arsdale, 227
Kan. 676 (1980), the Court construed the scope of 45-201, as
follows: "Simply stated, that statute requires all official
public records to be open unless either closed by the judge
or by some statute." Id. at 686. This conclusion was affirmed,
in effect, by State ex rel. Stephan v. Harder, 230 Kan. 573
(1982), wherein the Court found that K.S.A. 45-201 "excepts
from public disclosure records which are specifically closed
by law or by directive authorized by law." Id. at 584.
Harder also contains the most comprehensive statement as to
the legislative purpose underlying the Public Records Act
(K.S.A. 45-201 et seq.). There, the Court stated:
"The purpose of the legislature is exceedingly
clear: To subject to public view and scrutiny
all of those records which the law requires
public officials to keep. Sunshine is the
strongest antiseptic -- its rays may penetrate
areas previously closed. The legislature must
have so intended when it enacted this legis-
lation. This is not to say that all documents
in public offices are open to inspection; only
those required by law to be kept and maintained
must be made available. The latter, however,
must be open for inspection under penalty of
the law." (Emphasis by Court.) 230 Kan. at
580-581.
We also note that in Van Arsdale, supra, the Court found that
public access to public records is originally based in the
common law. 227 Kan. at 686. Thus, it was argued in Harder,
supra, that the duty, under common law, of a person seeking
to examine public records to show proper "motives" and
"reasons" should apply under K.S.A. 45-201, as well, so as
to vest in a custodian of public records the discretion to
close such records to public scrutiny. The Court rejected
that argument, holding that Van Arsdale "does not stand as
authority for an agency director to determine whether . . .
records should be open to public inspection." 230 Kan. at
584. The Court concluded that:
"The Kansas act places no burden on the public
to show a need to inspect, and requires no
particular motives or reasons for inspection.
It declares that all legally required records
'shall . . . be open for a personal inspection
by any citizen . . . .' It gives the custodian
no discretion and no choice; it imposes a duty
upon the custodian, and subjects him or her to
stringent penalties for noncompliance. We
hold that the common-law restrictions on pub-
lic access to open records are inapplicable
under the Kansas public records inspection
act." Id. at 585.
Finally, one of the issues in Harder was the public's right
to inspect public records containing both confidential and
non-confidential information, and we think the following
statement of the Court regarding this issue has pertinence
here:
"We have seen that the information requested
exists as a part of official public records
which are by law required to be kept and main-
tained. The same records, however, contain
information which is by law confidential and
may not be released. We think it is far more
consistent with the purpose of the Kansas pub-
lic records inspection act to interpret that
act as we now do. We hold that the act im-
plies a duty upon the agency to delete confi-
dential and nondisclosable information from
that which may be disclosed, and thus to carry
out the act's purpose of making available for
public inspection all disclosable parts of the
public record. Were this not so, any record
which an agency is required by law to keep
could be rendered inaccessible to public scru-
tiny by including confidential material there-
in." Id. at 583.
Therefore, in light of K.S.A. 45-201 and the foregoing judi-
cial interpretations thereof, we have concluded that: (1)
The permanent records required to be maintained on forms
approved by the Attorney General under K.S.A. 21-2501a(a) by
a law enforcement agency of any of the governmental entities
specified in K.S.A. 45-201(a), are subject to public inspec-
tion under the Public Records Act (K.S.A. 45-201 et seq.);
(2) a law enforcement agency has no discretion as to the dis-
closure of such records; (3) unless such records contain in-
formation which is made confidential by law or by directive
authorized by law, all information contained in such records
is available for public inspection; and (4) if these records
contain such confidential information, the law enforcement
agency has a duty to make available for public inspection
all disclosable portions of the records in a way which pro-
tects the confidentiality of the nondisclosable information.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF KANSAS
W. 'Robert Alderson
First Deputy Attorney General
RTS:WRA:hle

Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude

Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.