Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1982-195

1982-195Kanag

Texte intégral

September 8, 1982
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 82- 195
John A. O'Leary, Jr.
State Bank Commissioner
818 Kansas
Topeka, Kansas 66612
Re: Banks and Banking -- Bank Holding Companies --
Definition of Bank Holding Company
Synopsis: The state bank commissioner has the ultimate re-
sponsibility for determining whether a violation
of the Kansas bank holding company statutes has
occurred. Such determination requires a case by
case application of these statutes to the factual
circumstances established by the commissioner.
Thus, where it is proposed that each of three
existing one-bank holding companies is to own
voting shares of a new company which will own a
national bank, the bank commissioner must deter-
mine whether any of the existing one-bank holding
companies will directly or indirectly own, control
or hold with power to vote 25% or more of the
national bank's voting shares, or will control in
any manner the election of a majority of the
directors of the national bank. If neither of
such determinations can be made, none of the
existing one-bank holding companies is a "bank
holding company," as defined in K.S.A. 9-504(a).
Cited herein: K.S.A. 9-504, 9-505a, 9-505b,
9-505c, 12 U.S.C.A. §1841, 12 C.F.R. §225.1.
Dear Commissioner O'Leary:
Your predecessor requested our opinion regarding the proposed
formation of a national bank in Garden City, Kansas, in light
of the Kansas statutes pertaining to bank holding companies
(K.S.A. 9-504 to 9-505c, inclusive). By your letter of
August 2, 1982, you expressed your desire to receive our opin-
ion on this matter, indicating your belief that the resolu-
tion of this issue "would be to the best interests of the
banking industry in Kansas."
Subsequent to the submission of this opinion request, your
predecessor was requested by this office to advise all inter-
ested parties, in particular, and the Kansas banking industry,
in general, that we would welcome the receipt of briefs or
memorandums concerning the questions of law deriving from this
request. We received four responses to this invitation, and
the briefs and memorandums submitted to us have been most
helpful in identifying the issues and in guiding our research.
As we understand the proposal in question, a new one-bank
holding company (New OBHC) will be formed, and New OBHC will
own 100% of the voting stock of the proposed national bank
(New Bank). Apparently, each of three existing one-bank
holding companies (OBHC's) will own 24.9% of New OBHC's vot-
ing stock. The remaining 25.3% of New OBHC's voting stock
will be held by various individuals, and it is our understand-
ing that certain of these individuals own and control each
of the existing OHBC's.
Because of the involvement of existing OBHC's in the forma-
tion of New OBHC, your predecessor wrote to the Comptroller
of the Currency on June 10, 1982, requesting that action be
deferred on the application for a national bank charter in
Garden City, until our office had an opportunity to advise
him as to "whether, under the laws of the State of Kansas,
commonly owned bank holding companies can cooperate in the
organization of a new bank or bank holding company under
K.S.A. 9-504 et seq." Subsequently, in requesting our opin-
ion, this was the precise question presented by your prede-
cessor for our consideration.
Before addressing this question, two preliminary comments are
appropriate. First, even though this issue arises from an
application for a national bank charter, your inquiry has
relevance to 12 U.S.C.A. §1846, which provides that the fed-
eral Bank Holding Company Act is not to be "construed as
preventing any state from exercising such powers and juris-
diction which it now has or may hereafter have with respect
to banks, bank holding companies, and subsidiaries thereof."
In Commercial Nat. Bank of Little Rock v. Board of Gov., 451
F.2d 86 (8th Cir., 1971), it was held that, by virtue of
this statute, the State of Arkansas was "free to prohibit,
by specific legislation, the formation of bank holding com-
panies." Id. at 89. Similarly, in a recent decision by the
Supreme Court of Appeals of West Virginia, it was held that
"[s]tate regulation of bank holding companies is not pre-
empted by the Federal Bank Holding Company Act, 12 U.S.C.
§1841, et seq., because Section 1846 specifically reserves
to the state the power to regulate them." (Citations and
footnotes omitted.) Sec. Nat. Bank, Etc. v. First W. Va.
Bancorp., 277 S.E.2d 613, 615 (1981). Accordingly, your
determination as State Bank Commissioner as to whether the
proposal in question is consonant with the Kansas bank hold-
ing company statutes has relevance to the federal proceedings.
This leads to our second preliminary observation.
As the a ministrative officer charged under our laws with the
administration of our banking laws and the general supervi-
sion of the banking industry in Kansas, you have the ultimate
responsibility for determining this issue and advising the
appropriate federal authorities accordingly. It is not the
prerogative of this office to usurp your authority and make
that decision. Thus, we must necessarily confine our efforts
to a consideration of questions of law, so that you might
have the benefit or our opinion as to the controlling legal
principles. Your determination, of course, will require the
application of these principles to a particular set of factual
circumstances, which we assume will be established through
investigation by your office. At this time, however, we
have no indication that you or your staff have independently
established the facts presented for our consideration. Hence,
while we must consider the legal issues presented by the pro-
posal before us, you should be cognizant that our conclusions
of law may not be appropriate to factual circumstances which
vary from those considered here. With these caveats in mind,
we turn to a consideration of the pertinent statutory require-
ments.
For purposes of the Kansas bank holding company statutes, a
"bank holding company" is defined in K.S.A. 9-504(a) as mean-
ing
"any company: (1) Which directly or indirect-
ly owns, controls, or holds with power to vote,
twenty-five percent (25%) or more of the vot-
ing shares of each of two (2) or more banks
or of a company which is or becomes a bank
holding company by virtue of this act; (2)
which controls in any manner the election of a
majority of the directors of each of two (2)
or more banks; or (3) for the benefit of whose
shareholders or members twenty-five percent
(25%) or more of the voting shares of each of
two (2) or more banks or a bank holding com-
pany is held by trustees; and for the purposes
of this act, any successor to any such company
shall be deemed to be a bank holding company
from the date as of which such predecessor
company became a bank holding company. Not-
withstanding the foregoing (A) no bank shall
be a bank holding company by virtue of its
ownership or control of shares in a fiduciary
capacity, except where such shares are held
for the benefit of the shareholders of such
bank."
Essential to an understanding of this definition is the mean-
ing of "company," which is defined in subsection (b) of that
statute to mean
"any corporation, business trust, association,
or similar organization, but shall not include:
(1) Any corporation the majority of the shares
of which are owned by the United States or by
any state; (2) any corporation or community
chest, fund, or foundation, organized and op-
erated exclusively for religious, charitable,
or educational purposes, no part of the net
earnings of which inures to the benefit of any
private shareholder or individual, and no sub-
stantial part of the activities of which is
carrying on propaganda, or otherwise attempt-
ing to influence legislation; or (3) any part-
nership."
K.S.A. 9-504 has not been amended since its enactment in 1957
(L. 1957, ch. 75, §1). From an historical perspective, this
statute was enacted a year after the Congress enacted the Bank
Holding Company Act of 1956 (see 12 U.S.C.A. §§1841 et seq.),
and the language of the definitions set forth above was sub-
stantively similar to the corresponding definitional language
of the federal act. This fact is particularly relevant to
our deliberations, because several of the legal arguments
submitted to us in opposition to the proposal under considera-
tion are predicated on administrative and case law interpre-
tations of the federal act. The arguments suggest that,
under the Bank Holding Company Act (BHCA), the existing
OBHC's would control the New Bank, thereby making each of
these OBHC's a "bank holding company" under the BHCA, be-
cause: (1) the existing OBHC's would exercise a controlling
influence over the management and policies of the New Bank;
(2) the existing OBHC's would obtain control over New Bank
through their respective officers and directors who own vot-
ing shares of New OBHC; and (3) each of the existing OBHC's
would be presumed to control the New OBHC pursuant to regula-
tions adopted by the Federal Reserve Board to implement the
BHCA, and the existing OBHC's would thereby exercise indirect
control of the New Bank.
Without in any way commenting upon the validity of these argu-
ments, insofar as they reflect interpretations of federal law,
we do not find such interpretations persuasive to a determina-
tion of the question presented for our review. However, be-
fore considering the factors which have prompted this conclu-
sion, it should be recognized that federal law does not pro-
hibit bank holding companies. It requires, instead, that a
company must receive the approval of the Federal Reserve Board
before it may operate as a bank holding company, and it also
imposes limitations on the activities of a bank holding com-
pany. By contrast, K.S.A. 9-505a prohibits any bank holding
company, as defined in K.S.A. 9-504, from being organized or
transacting business in the state of Kansas after March 21,
1974. While this distinction considered by itself does not
preclude the application of federal law interpretations to
the Kansas law, it does reflect distinctly different regisla-
tive philosophies underlying the two acts.
It is within this context we have considered these interpre-
tations of federal law, which have been urged upon us on the
theory that the language of the state and federal laws are
"nearly identical." However, it is our judgment that the
necessary similarity in language does not exist and the fed-
eral law interpretations are not appropriate to a resolution
of this matter, because of the pertinent dissimilarities
which exist between the Kansas and federal statutes.
The federal definition of "bank holding company" appears in
subsection (a) of 12 U.S.C.A. §1841 and reads in pertinent
part, as follows:
"(a)(1) Except as provided in paragraph (5)
of this subsection, 'bank holding company'
means any company which has control over any
bank or over any company that is or becomes
a bank holding company by virtue of this chap-
ter.
"(2) Any company has control over a bank or
over any company if --
"(A) the company directly or indirectly or
acting through one or more other persons owns,
controls, or has power to vote 25 per centum
or more of any class of voting securities of
the bank or company;
"(B) the company controls in any manner the
election of a majority of the directors or
trustees of the bank or company; or
"(C) the Board determines, after notice and
opportunity for hearing, that the company di-
rectly or indirectly exercises a controlling
influence over the management or policies of
the bank or company.
"(3) For the purposes of any proceeding under
paragraph (2)(C) of this subsection, there is
a presumption that any company which directly
or indirectly owns, controls, or has power to
vote less than 5 per centum of any class of
voting securities of a given bank or company
does not have control over that bank or com-
pany.
"(4) In any administrative or judicial pro-
ceeding under this chapter, other than a pro-
ceeding under paragraph (2)(C) of this subsec-
tion, a company may not be held to have had
control over any given bank or company at any
given time unless that company, at the time
in question, directly or indirectly owned,
controlled, or had power to vote 5 per centum
or more of any class of voting securities of
the bank or company, or had already been found
to have control in a proceeding under para
graph (2)(C)." (Emphasis added.)
Similarly, "company" is defined in §1841(b) as meaning
"any corporation, partnership, business trust,
association, or similar organization, or any
other trust unless by its terms it must term-
inate within twenty-five years or not later
than twenty-one years and ten months after the
death of individuals living on the effective
date of the trust, but shall not include any
corporation the majority of the shares of
which are owned by the United States or by any
State. 'Company covered in 1970' means a com-
pany which becomes a bank holding company as a
result of the enactment of the Bank Holding
Company Act Amendments of 1970 and which would
have been a bank holding company on June 30,
1968, if those amendments had been enacted on
that date."
As previously noted, the definition of "bank holding company"
in K.S.A. 9-504 was substantially the same as the correspond-
ing definition in the BHCA of 1956. Now, however, as a re-
sult of amendments made to the BHCA in 1966 (P.L. 89-485) and
1970 (P.L. 91-607), there are important differences, some of
which are reflected by the emphasized language in the above-
quoted provisions of §1841(a). In paragraph (2)(A) of the
federal definition, it is now provided that a company is
deemed to have control over a bank or over any company if
such company, "acting through one or more other persons owns,
controls, or has power to vote 25 per centum or more of any
class of voting securities of the bank or company." (Emphasis
added.) No comparable provision is included in K.S.A.
9-504(a). Hence, we find no basis for applying judicial or
administrative interpretations of this distinctive federal
requirement in construing the Kansas statute.
Further, §1841(a)(2)(C) provides that a company has "control"
over a bank or over any company where the Federal Reserve
Board finds "that the company directly or indirectly exer-
cises a controlling influence over the management or policies
of the bank or company." Again, there is no comparable pro-
vision in the Kansas definition. Whereas the Kansas defini-
tion is predicated, in part, on a finding that a company
exercises "control" over the requisite voting shares of two
or more banks, or over the election of their boards of direc-
tors, the threshold for the federal definition is "control
over a bank," with the specific recognition that such control
may be evidenced by the exercise of a "controlling influence
over the management or policies of the bank." Thus, we think
it inappropriate to apply to the Kansas statute any interpre-
tations of the federal definition which depend upon this pro-
vision of §1841 for their efficacy.
Finally, we note that there are no counterparts in K.S.A.
9-504 to subsections (a)(3) and (a)(4) of §1841. These sub-
sections establish a threshold for determining whether a
company controls a bank or another company by virtue of its
ownership, control or holding with power to vote any class
of voting securities of the bank or such other company. The
threshold so established is 5% of such class of voting securi-
ties. In furtherance of these provisions, and in pursuance of
its authority in 12 U.S.C.A. §1844(b) "to issue such regula-
tions . . . as may be necessary to enable it to administer and
carry out the purposes" of the BHCA, the Federal Reserve Board
has established in 12 C.F.R. §225.2(b) certain rebuttable pre-
sumptions of control. These presumptions are predicated, in
part, on a company's ownership, control or power to vote more
than 5% of any class of voting securities of a bank or another
company. However, we find no basis for extending these pre-
sumptions to a company that is being measured against K.S.A.
9-504(a) to determine if it is a bank holding company.
Accordingly, in our judgment, the arguments previously noted
which are based on the judicial and administrative interpre-
tations of distinctive federal requirements are not persua-
sive in construing the Kansas bank holding company statutes.
Thus, in the absence of any Kansas case law precisely on
point, we are constrained to construe our statutes in the
light of established rules of statutory interpretation.
As noted in Southeast Kansas Landowners Ass'n v. Kansas Turn-
pike Auth., 224 Kan. 357 (1978):
"The fundamental rule of statutory construction,
to which all others are subordinate, is that
the purpose and intent of the legislature
governs when that intent can be ascertained
from the statutes. Easom v. Farmers Insurance
Co., 221 Kan. 415, Syl. 2, 560 P.2d 117 (1977);
Thomas County Taxpayers Ass'n v. Finney, 223
Kan. 434, 573 P.2d 1073 (1978); Brinkmever v.
City of Wichita, 223 Kan. 393, 573 P.2d 1044
(1978)." 224 Kan. at 367.
The Court also has provided guidance in ascertaining the leg-
islature's intent, and we believe the following statement of
the Court to be of relevance here:
"A primary rule for the construction of a
statute is to find the legislative intent
from its language, and where the language
used is plain and unambiguous and also appro-
priate to the obvious purpose the court should
follow the intent as expressed by the words
used and is not warranted in looking beyond
them in search of some other legislative pur-
pose or extending the meaning beyond the plain
terms of the Act. (Alter v. Johnson, 127 Kan.
443, 273 Pac. 474; Hand v. Board of Education,
193 Kan. 460, 426 P.2d 124; City of Overland
Park v. Nikias, 209 Kan. 643, 498 P.2d 56;
Hunter v. Haun, 210 Kan. 11, 499 P.2d 1087.)"
City of Kiowa v. Central Telephone & Utilities
Corporation, 213 Kan. 169, 176 (1973).
Of similar import is the Court's pronouncement in Lakeview
Gardens, Inc. v. State, ex rel. Schneider, 221 Kan. 211 (1976):
"[T]his court must ascertain and give effect
to the intent of the legislature. In so doing
we must consider the language of the statute;
its words are to be understood in their plain
and ordinary sense. (Hunter v. Haun, 210 Kan.
11, 13, 499 P.2d 1087; Roda v. Williams, 195
Kan. 507, 511, 407 P.2d 471.) When a statute
is plain and unambiguous this court must give
effect to the intention of the legislature as
expressed rather than determine what the law
should or should not be. (Amoco Production
Co. v. Armold, Director of Taxation, 213 Kan.
636, 647, 518 P.2d 453; Jolly v. Kansas Public
Employees Retirement System, 214 Kan. 200,
204, 519 P.2d 1391.)" 221 Kan. at 214.
Admittedly, the Kansas bank holding company statutes are
less than artfully drawn. They contain meaningless surplus-
ages, circuitous usage of defined terms and erroneous dupli-
cations of the corresponding federal statutes. The defective
draftsmanship of these statutes was noted in several of the
briefs submitted on this proposal, and the overriding, con-
textual ambiguity of the entire act was called to the legis-
lature's attention in 1974 by conferees who testified
regarding the enactment of K.S.A. 9-505a, 9-505b and 9-505c.
(See, e.g., Minutes of House Committee on Commercial and
Financial Institutions, March 4, 1974.)
However, even conceding the careless and inattentive drafting
of these statutes, it is our judgment there is no ambiguity
in the definitional requirements pertinent to our considera-
tion, at least to the extent that we find no legislative in-
tent to circumscribe the type of arrangement considered here
by the definition of "bank holding company" in K.S.A. 9-504(a).
Such conclusion, of course, obviates the necessity of con-
sidering the succeeding sections which proscribe the activities
of a bank holding company.
As is necessary in resolving most legal issues, it is the
application of the pertinent law to the facts provided us
which has prompted our conclusion. To briefly reiterate
these facts, each of the existing OBHC's involved is owned
and controlled by substantially the same individuals (here-
after referred to as "Organizers"), and collectively these
existing OBHC's own 74.7% of the voting shares of the New
OBHC. In addition, the Organizers collectively own 25.3% of
the voting shares of the New OBHC.
Before proceeding, it is important to again note that we have
no indication that you or your staff have conducted an inde-
pendent verification of these facts. Hence, our considera-
tion of this matter has necessarily been predicated on the
assumption that these are, in actuality, all of the essential
facts. We have been provided no information, for example,
to indicate that any of the existing OBHC's is a party to a
stockholders' agreement, voting trust or other voting agree-
ment regarding the voting shares of New OBHC. Nor have we
any indication that there is any oral or written agreement
or arrangement which would provide for the horizontal inte-
gration of two or more of the existing OBHC's. Obviously,
should you find through independent investigation that any
of these agreements or arrangements exist, it may well justify
a conclusion by you that the organizational structure created
thereby creates a bank holding company. However, in the
absence of any indication as to the existence of any such
agreement or arrangements, we have premised our opinion on
the assumption that the organizational scheme outlined above
constitutes the facts essential to our conclusion.
Under this set of facts, there can be no serious question that,
by virtue of their ownership of each of the existing OBHC's,
as well as their ownership of voting shares of the New OBHC,
the Organizers will control not only the New OBHC, but also
will control the operation of the New Bank, since it is to
be wholly owned by the New OBHC.
We find nothing inappropriate that the Organizers own and
control a multiplicity of one-bank holding companies and, as
a consequence thereof, control the operation of a correspond-
ing number of banks. It must be recognized that a "bank
holding company" must be a "company," as defined by K.S.A.
9-504(b), i.e., it must be a "corporation, business trust,
association, or similar organization." Clearly, then, a person
acting in his or her individual capacity and on his or her
own behalf is not a company and, as a consequence, cannot be
a bank holding company. Moreover, paragraph (3) of K.S.A.
9-504(b) specifically excludes a partnership from the defini-
tion of "company." Hence, even if the Organizers were to
form a partnership for the purpose of owning and controlling
the various one-bank holding companies, it would not render
such arrangement a bank holding company within the meaning
of K.S.A. 9-504(a).
Here, it is appropriate to observe that this is no longer the
case under the federal act, since the Bank Holding Company
Act Amendments of 1970 effected a redefinition of "company"
in 12 U.S.C.A. §1841(b), so as to include partnerships. The
exemption of partnerships from the definition of "company"
in the BHCA of 1956 was explained by the U.S. Senate Committee
on Banking and Currency in its report (Senate Report No. 1095)
of
of
its consideration of the legislation which
1956, as follows:
became the BHCA
"The third exemption from the definition of
'company' is granted to any partnership be-
cause the attributes of a partnership are simi-
lar to those presented by an individual in the
sense that neither has perpetual duration. As
the individual's personal control of business
activities ceases with his death, any business
control exercised by a partnership will like-
wise terminate upon the death of either part-
ner. Usually, the death of an individual who
controls banks is accompanied by a diffusion
of ownership of such banks.
"By way of contrast, corporations and similar
organizations may have perpetual existence.
The death of any individual member of a cor-
poration has no effect upon continued control
of banks by the corporation. This bill is de-
signed to bring under control those types of
entities that may be used as media for acquir-
ing and maintaining in perpetuity management
and control of bank shares or assets." 2 U.S.
Code Cong. & Ad. News (1956), 2486.
The foregoing explanation, particularly the emphasized por-
tion thereof, provides insight as to the congressional intent
underlying the BHCA of 1956. This act was not intended to
circumscribe individuals who own or control several banks.
It was designed to provide safeguards "against undue
concentration of control of banking activities" (Id. at 2482) in
those business entities "that may be used as media for acquir-
ing and maintaining in perpetuity management and control of
bank shares or assets." Id. at 2486. Since the Kansas bank
holding company statutes were patterned after the BHCA of
1956, we think it appropriate to attribute a similar intent
to the Kansas Legislature.
Thus, even though the organizational scheme considered here
may, in fact, be a unitary operation as a result of the con-
trol exercised by the Organizers over all of the corporate
entities involved, such operation is not proscribed by our
statutes unless it results in one or more of the corporate
entities becoming a "bank holding company," as defined in
K.S.A. 9-504(a).
The facts presented suggest only two possibilities that the
proposed organizational scheme causes one or more of the
existing OBHC's to become multi-bank holding companies, i.e.,
under these facts, any of the existing OBHC's can be regarded
as a "bank holding company" only if it (1) directly or in-
directly owns, controls or holds with power to vote 25% or
more of the voting shares of each of two or more banks or
(2) controls in any manner the election of a majority of the
directors of each of two or more banks.
With regard to the first possibility, the question of "direct"
ownership or control involves, in our judgment, a considera-
tion of the percentage of New Bank's voting shares which are
owned by an existing OBHC, or which are controlled through
an agreement or other arrangement with other owners of such
shares. The facts presented to us, or course, indicate that
New OBHC will own all of New Bank's voting shares. However,
if you should find that an existing OBHC will, in fact, own
25% or more of such shares, or if you find that, through an
agreement or other arrangement with New OBHC, an existing
OBHC will control 25% or more of such shares, either such
finding would, in our opinion, justify your conclusion that
such existing OBHC would be a bank holding company under our
statute.
On the other hand, if you find that, in fact, New OBHC will
own all of New Bank's voting shares and that there is no
agreement or other arrangement which vests control of 25% or
more of such shares in any of the existing OBHC's, the ques-
tion arises as to whether an existing OBHC "indirectly" owns
or controls 25% or more of these shares. Thus, it is appro-
priate for you to consider the relationship of each of the
existing OBHC's to New OBHC. For example, if the New OBHC is
found to be a subsidiary of any of the existing OBHC's, we
think it appropriate for you to find that the existing OBHC'
exercises some measure of indirect ownership or control over
the voting shares of New Bank that are owned by New OBHC.
Here, we note that K.S.A. 9-504 defines "subsidiary," as
follows:
"(d) 'Subsidiary,' with respect to a specified
bank holding company, means: (1) Any company
twenty-five percent (25%) or more of whose vot-
ing shares (excluding shares owned by the
United States or by any company wholly owned
by the United States) is owned or controlled
by such bank holding company; (2) any company
the election of a majority of whose directors
is controlled in any manner by such bank hold-
ing company; or (3) any company twenty-five
percent (25%) or more of whose voting shares
are held by trustees for the benefit of the
shareholders or members of such bank holding
company."
The problem with utilizing this definition to determine the
existence of a bank holding company is obvious. It is pre-
dicated on the presumed existence of a parent corporation
which meets the definitional requirements of a "bank holding
company." It has apparent relevance only to those provisions
of the Kansas bank holding company statutes which circumscribe
the activities of subsidiaries of bank holding companies. To
apply this definition to the relationship existing between
the New OBHC and any of the existing OBHC's for the purpose
of determining whether any such existing OBHC is a "bank hold-
ing company" would be circuitous, at best.
Thus, in the absence of an appropriate definition in K.S.A.
9-504, we note that the commonly accepted definition of a sub-
sidiary corporation is one in which another corporation owns
at least a majority of the shares, and thus has control.
See, e.g., Black's Law Dictionary (Rev. 4th Ed.). D. 159A-
and 40 Words and Phrases, "Subsidiary Corporation," p. . 748.
In our opinion, it is appropriate for you to measure the
relationship between New OBHC and the existing OBHC's against
this standard. We also note that, under appropriate circum-
stances, ownership of less than a majority of a corporation's
shares will permit control of that corporation, i.e., will
permit control over the election of a majority of the corpora-
tion's board of directors. Thus, should you find that, even
though each of the existing OBHC's owns less than 25% of New
OBHC's voting shares, through an agreement or other arrange-
ment which, for example, either affects the horizontal inte-
gration of the existing OBHC's or vests in one or more of
the existing OBHC's control over the voting shares of New
OBHC held by the Organizers, you may well conclude that an
existing OHBC controls the New OBHC and thereby indirectly
controls 25% or more of New Bank's voting shares. Of -course,
the question of control is a factual issue which, in the
absence of statutory guidelines, is properly left to your
sound discretion for resolution.
It requires no discussion or citation of authority to note
that the stockholders of a corporation are the owners of that
corporation and, by virtue of their authority to select its
board of directors, they exercise ultimate control over the
operation of the corporation. Of course, corporations exist
by legislative grace, and the activities of corporations and
their officers, directors and stockholders are subject to
appropriate legislative regulation. Accordingly, we recog-
nize the potential power of the legislature to limit the
amount of stock that the officers, directors or stockholders
of one banking corporation may own in another banking corpora-
tion, or to create certain presumptions of control deriving
from such ownership of stock. However, there are no such
limitations or presumptions either expressly or impliedly
contained in the pertinent Kansas statutes, and absent any
such statutory requirement, we are aware of no general legal
principle which would impute to a corporation the control
over its stockholders' ownership of stock in another corpora-
tion. Hence, we are unable to conclude as a matter of law
that any of the existing OBHC's will exercise control over
the voting shares of the New OBHC to be held by the Organizers
or, for that matter, over the shares held by the Organizers
in each of the other existing OBHC's. However, as we have
previously noted, whether such control exists in actuality
is a factual issue to be resolved through investigation and
the exercise of your discretion and judgment in light of the
facts as you determine them.
Thus, whether any of the existing OBHC's will exercise con-
trol over the voting shares of the New OBHC to be held by
the Organizers, or over the shares held by the Organizers
in each of the other existing OBHC's, becomes a question of
fact. To answer this question in the affirmative would re-
quire a finding that the Organizers, as shareholders, officers
and directors of each of the existing OBHC's, are acting
on behalf of the existing OBHC's and not on their own be-
half.
We also have no basis for concluding, as a matter of law,
that any of the existing OBHC's will be able to control in
any manner the election of a majority of the directors of
each of two or more banks. The directors of New Bank will
be elected by its shareholders. Thus, in order to find that
an existing OBHC controls in any manner the election of a
majority of these directors, you must conclude that such
existing OBHC directly or indirectly owns or controls or
holds with power to vote such voting shares of New Bank as
are necessary to elect such majority of directors. Here,
again, this is a question involving the same factual con-
siderations noted above, and for the reasons previously
stated, such question must be left for your resolution in
accordance with the statutory interpretations and legal prin-
ciples enunciated herein.
In summary, therefore, it is our opinion that the state bank
commissioner has the ultimate responsibility for determining
whether a violation of the Kansas bank holding company statutes
has occurred. Such determination requires a case by case
application of these statutes to the factual circumstances
established by the commissioner. Thus, where it is proposed
that each of three existing one-bank holding companies is to
own voting shares of a new company which will own a national
bank, the bank commissioner must determine whether any of
the existing one-bank holding companies will directly or
indirectly own, control or hold with power to vote 25% or
more of the national bank's voting shares, or will control
in any manner the election of a majority of the directors of
the national bank. If neither of such determinations can
be made, none of the existing one-bank holding companies is
a "bank holding company," as defined in K.S.A. 9-504(a).
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF KANSAS
W. Robert Alderson
First Deputy Attorney General
RTS:WRA:hle

Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude

Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.