Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1982-179

1982-179Kanag

Texte intégral

August 19, 1982
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 82-179
C. W. Naab
Mayor of Nickerson
P. 0. Box 32
Nickerson, Kansas 67561
Re: Cities and Municipalities -- Cemeteries -- Care
and Control; Police Power to Relocate Remains From
Mausoleum
Synopsis: A city which operates a cemetery pursuant to the
provisions of K.S.A. 12-1401 et seq. has full power
to make and enforce all necessary rules and regu-
lations pertaining to the care of such cemetery.
This grant of power includes the ability to remove
and reinter remains which are contained in a mauso-
leum that has become structurally unsound. In
order to avoid potential liability, notice should
be provided if possible to relatives of those per-
sons whose remains are so transferred. However,
a city is not required to obtain such relatives'
consent prior to effecting such removal and rein-
terment. Cited herein: K.S.A. 12-1402, 17-1326.
Dear Mr. Naab:
As Mayor of the City of Nickerson, Kansas, you request our
opinion on a matter which concerns the city cemetery. Speci-
fically, you inform us that Wildmead Cemetery contains a
mausoleum which was constructed of cement by a local resident
in the 1920's. The structure, which contains the remains of
the builder and his wife, is now in a condition of deterior-
ation (due to failure of the building materials) such that
repairs cannot practically be made. You inquire what steps
the city is required to take in removing and reinterring the
6remains prior to demolition of the mausoleum.
In examining the statutes of this state, it does not appear
that any specific act of the legislature has addressed this
particular question. While K.S.A. 17-1324 through 17-1327
concern the sealing of defective mausoleums and the reinter-
ment of bodies contained therein, the basis for such action
lies in potential health problems which may be created. Addi-
tionally, the authority to act is given to the secretary of
health and environment, not the city or county in which the
cemetery is located. K.S.A. 17-1326. However, given the pre-
sence of other, more general stautes, we believe the inappli-
cability of these statutes is not crucial.
Specifically, K.S.A. 12-1402 vests a city which operates a
cemetery with "full power to make and enforce all necessary
rules and regulations pertaining to the custody, control and
care of the cemetery." The above statute is in effect a codi-
fication of the common law authority of a governmental body
to exercise its police power over a cemetery. As noted in a
prior case dealing with cemeteries, State ex rel. Stephan v.
Lane, 228 Kan. 379, 392 (1980):
"The police power is wide in its scope and
gives the governmental body broad powers to
enact laws to promote the health, morals, se-
curity, and welfare of the people. Broad dis-
cretion is vested in the governing body to
determine for itself what is deleterious to
health, morals, or is inimical to public wel-
fare. However, the governing body does not
possess plenary power to pass legislation
that is arbitrary, oppressive, or so caprici-
ous that it has no reasonable basis." (Cita-
tion omitted.)
Other jurisdictions have also recognized that the police
power can be used to protect the public health and welfare
[Arlington Cemetery Corp. v. Bindig, 212 Ga. 298, 95 S.E.2d
378 (1947)], the public policy of protecting cemeteries
against desecration [Eden Memorial Park Assn. v. Superior
Ct., 189 Cal.App.2d 421, 11 Cal.Rptr. 186 (1961)], the need
to maintain cemeteries in proper condition and appearance
[Killian v. Brith Shalom Congregation, 154 S.W.2d 387 (Mo.
1941)] and the safety of those visiting the graves of rela-
tives or friends. [Cedar Hill Cemetery v. Ball, 78 F.2d 220
(D.C. Cir. 1935).]
In light of the above, it is our opinion that the city may
take whatever steps are reasonable to remedy the present
situation at Wildmead Cemetery. The broad grant of police
power authority which cities possess with regard to cemeteries
,(State ex rel. Stephan v. Lane, supra) would allow Nickerson
remove the crumbling structure with or without the consent
of the heirs of those who first erected it. This is not to
say, however, that no consideration should be had for the
sensibilities and feelings of the interested relatives. To
avoid any potential liability in tort for the handling of the
remains [see, e.g. Hamilton v. Individual Mausoleum Co., 149
Kan. 216 (1939)], reasonable efforts to notify the next of
kin should be taken, as in fact you advise they already have.
While exact details can be worked out at that time, a reinter-
ment that resembles that initially had (i.e. two graves with
two caskets, with each name identified on a marker) would
avoid potential charges of arbitrary, capricious or unreason-
able conduct on the part of the city, which will bear the
cost of all removal and reinterment work.
In conclusion, a city winch operates a cemetery pursuant to
the provisions of K.S.A. 12-1401 et seq. has full power to
make and enforce all necessary rules and regulations pertain-
ing to the care of such cemetery. This grant of power includes
the ability to remove and reinter remains which are contained
in a mausoleum that has become structurally unsound. In order
to avoid potential liability, notice should be provided if
possible to relatives of those persons whose remains are so
transferred. However, a city is not required to obtain such
relatives' consent prior to effecting such removal and reinter-
ment.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT 'IT:- STEPHAN
Attorney General of Kansas
Jeffrey S. Southard
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:BJS:JSS:hle

Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude

Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.