Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1982-168

1982-168Kanag

Texte intégral

August 9, 1982
ATIORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 82-16 8
Mr. David K. Martin
P.O. Box 10
The Tower Building
200 South Chestnut
Olathe, Kansas 66061
Re: Criminal Procedure -- Search and Seizure --
Custody and Disposition of Seized Property
Cities, Second Class -- Sale of Firearms
Found and Unclaimed or Used as Evidence in
Municipal Court -- Disposition of Proceeds
Synopsis: Firearms seized as evidence for use in district courts
may be sold, at the court's discretion, and the proceeds
shall be paid to the state treasurer.
In cities of the second class which have elected to
establish police and fire department pension funds
as authorized by K.S.A. 1981 Supp. 14-10a02, firearms
seized for use as evidence and firearms which are
found and unclaimed may be sold and the proceeds
paid into the pension funds. However, pursuant to the
constitutional grant of home rule power, such cities
may modify this procedure by charter ordinance, and
cities of the second class which are not subject to
this statute may provide by ordinance for the dispo-
sition of such firearms. Cited herein: K.S.A.
12-4103, K.S.A. 1981 Supp. 14-10a02, K.S.A. 20-2801,
21-4206, 22-2102, 22-2512, Kan. Const., Art. 12, §5.
*
Dear Mr. Martin:
As city attorney for the City of Mission, you inquire whether a city
may sell firearms which are in its possession and retain the proceeds.
Specifically, you ask if such a sale would be proper under the following
circumstances:
1. When the firearms were seized as evidence for district
court cases;
2. When the firearms were seized as evidence for municipal
court cases; or
3. When firearms have been found and are unclaimed.
Since Mission is a city of the second class, we assume that your
questions are phrased in this context, and we will respond accordingly.
One procedure for disposing of firearms seized under a valid search
warrant or validly seized without a warrant is set forth in K.S.A.
22-2512, which provides in part:
"When property seized is no longer required as evidence,
it shall be disposed of as follows . . . . (5) Firearms,
ammunition, explosives, bombs, and like devices, which
have been used in the commission of crime, may be returned
to the rightful owner, destroyed or sold in the discretion
of the court having jurisdiction of the property. The
sale and distribution of the proceeds shall be as provided
in K.S.A. 21-4206."
K.S.A. 21-4206 states that the proceeds of any such sale "shall be
paid to the state treasurer pursuant to K.S.A. 20-2801," which requires
district court clerks to remit "all moneys payable to the state
treasurer from fines, penalties and forfeitures to the state treasurer"
on at least a monthly schedule.
From the foregoing, it is apparent that the manner of disposition of
firearms used as evidence in district court is within the discretion
of the district court. If the district court should authorize sale
of the firearms pursuant to K.S.A. 22-2512, the proceeds of such
sale would necessarily be remitted to the state treasurer in accordance
with K.S.A. 21-4206 and 20-2801.
K.S.A. 22-2512 is a part of the Kansas Code of Criminal Procedure,
the scope of which is set forth in K.S.A. 22-2102, as follows:
"The provisions of this code shall govern proceedings
in all criminal cases in the courts of the state of
Kansas, but shall have application to proceedings in
police and municipal courts only when specifically
provided la law." (Emphasis added).
As you will note, the emphasized portion of the foregoing states that
the Code of Criminal Procedure, which includes K.S.A. 22-2512, is not
applicable to municipal court proceedings, unless specifically provided
by law. After extensive research, we have been unable to locate any
law which specifically makes K.S.A. 22-2512 applicable to municipal
court proceedings. Therefore, we conclude that K.S.A. 22-2512 does not
apply to municipal court proceedings.
We also have reviewed the Kansas Code of Procedure for Municipal Courts.
Although this Code does not contain a specific provision concerning
disposition of property seized as evidence for use in municipal courts,
K.S.A. 12-4103 states, in part: "If no procedure is provided by this
code, the court shall proceed in any lawful manner consistent with any
applicable law and not inconsistent with this code." We believe that
K.S.A. 1981 Supp. 14-10a02 is one such applicable law.
K.S.A. 1981 Supp. 14-10a02 provides for the establishment of police
and fire department pension funds by certain cities of the second
class and states, in part:
"For the purpose of creating, maintaining and funding
such pension funds, the governing body of each city
of the second class is hereby authorized and shall:
"(c) place into said funds the proceeds of all lost or
stolen securities, money or personal property which
shall remain unclaimed in possession of any department
of the city for six months, together with the proceeds
of all unclaimed or confiscated property of any nature
which shall have been in custody of the police department
for a period of six months, and the city is hereby
authorized to sell at public auction such property and
place the proceeds into said pension funds in equal
shares . . . ." (Emphasis added.)
A city of the second class availing itself of this statute would
be authorized to sell lost or stolen firearms which remain unclaimed
in the possession of any city department; or unclaimed or confiscated
firearms in the custody of the police department, after a period of
six months. Under this statute, proceeds from all such sales would be
required to be placed in the above described pension funds. (Incidentally,
since municipal courts are not authorized to issue search warrants
( see K.S.A. 12-4103), it is presumed that the "confiscated" property
described in K.S.A. 1981 Supp. 14-10a02 and relevant to this opinion
is limited to property seized subject to valid arrest.)
K.S.A. 1981 Supp. 14-10a02 is a permissive, as opposed to mandatory,
statute. This statute indicates that certain cities of the second
class (which would include Mission) " may establish and maintain a
separate pension fund." However, should a city elect to establish
funds under the authority of this statute, the language in 14-10a02(c)
would require that the proceeds of lost or stolen property shall be
placed in the pension funds.
Certainly, a city of the second class could avoid the effects of
14-10a02 simply by not electing to establish the pension fund as
authorized by that statute. There is also a possibility that a
city, such as Mission, could avoid the requirements of K.S.A. 1981
Supp. 14-10a02 by enacting a charter ordinance in accordance with the
grant of home rule power to cities under Article 12, Section 5
of the Kansas Constitution.
By this amendment, a city is empowered to determine its "local affairs
and government," subject only to specified legislative enactments,
including enactments applicable uniformly to all cities. In City of
Junction City v. Griffin, 227 Kan. 332 (1980), the Kansas Supreme
Court analyzed the legislature's ability to limit a city's exercise
of its home rule powers, as follows:
"Regardless of whether an enactment of the state
legislature addresses a matter of statewide or a
matter of local concern, a city may in either case
act by charter ordinance to exempt itself from all
or part of the enactment unless the state enactment
applies uniformly to all cities. Kan. Const. art. 12,
55(c)(1). The legislature may foreclose municipal
legislative action only by an enactment of uniform
application to all cities." 227 Kan. at 337.
With this in mind, it requires little discussion to note that, since
K.S.A. 1981 Supp. 14 -10a02 is applicable only to certain cities of the
second class, it is susceptible of modification by a second class city's
charter ordinance.
This office has not found any other statutes dealing with disposition
of this type of property. Therefore, in the event a city should decide
not to proceed under K.S.A. 1981 Supp. 14-10a02, there appears to be no
other statutory authority precisely on point. In discussing the effect
of legislative silence on the home rule power, the Kansas Supreme Court
has held:
"[L]egislative silence on a subject no longer means
absence of a city's authority to act in that area.
No longer must Kansas cities rely on enabling statutes
by the legislature in order to act by ordinance in
matters of local concern." City of Junction City v.
Lee, 216 Kan. 495, 498 (1975). See also Andersen
Construction Co. v. City of Topeka, 228 Kan. 73, 79
(1980).
Therefore, it is apparent that since the legislature has not enacted
a statute pertaining to disposition of this type of property, cities
are free to enact ordinances addressing this issue.
Therefore, it is our opinion that a city of the second class which has
established pension funds pursuant to K.S.A. 1981 Supp. 14-10a02 is
statutorily required to sell lost, stolen or confiscated firearms
in the possession of city officials after a period of six months,
and apply the proceeds to police and fire department pension funds;
however, pursuant to its home rule power, any such city could enact
a charter ordinance exempting the city from the pertinent provisions
of this statute and prescribing a different procedure for the disposition
of such property. Cities of the second class which have not established
such pension funds are free to adopt city ordinances regarding the
disposition of such property.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
Attorney General of Kansas
Mary Mudrick
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:JEF :MM:my

Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude

Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.