Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1982-141

1982-141Kanag

Texte intégral

June 25, 1982
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 82- 141
The Honorable Wendell E. Lady
Speaker of the Kansas House
8732 Mackey
Overland Park, Kansas 66212
Re: State Departments; Public Officers, Employees --
Kansas Open Meetings Act -- Notice of Interim Study
Committees; Kansas Register
Synopsis: The Kansas Open Meetings Act requires notice of all
regular and special meetings of bodies subject to
the Act to be provided to all persons requesting it.
Publication of notice of legislative interim study
committees in the Kansas Register is adequate notice
to those persons who subscribe to that publication.
However, individual notice is still required for
persons who do not subscribe to the Register. Ab-
sent changes in the law or the rules of the House
and Senate, such persons may not be denied notice
of interim study committees for failure to pay the
subscription fee for the Register or mailing and
postage charges arising from the providing of in-
dividual notice. Cited herein: K.S.A. 1981 Supp.
75-430 (as amended by 1982 House Bill No. 2717),
K.S.A. 75-4317, K.S.A. 1981 Supp. 75-4318, 77-421
(as amended by 1982 House Bill No. 2712), L. 1981,
ch. 324, §33.
Dear Mr. Speaker:
As chairperson of the Legislative Coordinating Council, you
request the advice of this office on the notice and agenda
requirements of the Kansas Open Meetings Act, K.S.A. 75-4317
et seq. Specifically, you inform us that the Council voted
to discontinue the expensive practice of mailing notice and
agenda of interim committee meetings and hearings to indivi-
duals who have requested such notification. In lieu thereof,
the council intends to rely upon the general publication
notice available in the Kansas Register, which pursuant to
K.S.A. 1981 Supp. 75-430(a)(6) (as amended by 1982 House
Bill No. 2717), will publish "all notices of hearings of
special legislative interim study committees." Unlike the
previous practice of providing individual notice at public
expense, the Kansas Register charges a subscription fee.
Hence, the recent move is seen as a cost savings measure.
In this context you desire to know if the notice and agenda
provided in the Kansas Register is sufficient to comply with
the mandates of K.S.A. 1981 Supp. 75-4318. For the reasons
discussed below, we are constrained to find that the Kansas
Open Meetings Act requires the giving of individual notice
(to any and all persons requesting it) of all meetings of
legislative interim committees, and the notice provided in
the Kansas Register in itself does not fulfill the statutory
notice obligations.
Certainly the Kansas Open Meetings Act applies to legislative
interim committees. K.S.A. 1981 Supp. 75-4318(a) states in
pertinent part:
"Except as otherwise provided by state or fed-
eral law or by rules of the house or senate,
and except with respect to any impeachment in-
quiry or other impeachment matter referred to
any committee of the house of representatives
prior to the report of such committee to the
full house of representatives, all meetings
for the conduct of the affairs of, and the
transaction of business by, all legislative
and administrative bodies and agencies of the
state and political and taxing subdivisions
thereof, including boards, commissions, au-
thorities, councils, committees, subcommittees
and other subordinate groups thereof, receiv-
ing or expending and supported in whole or in
part by public funds shall be open to the pub-
lic and no binding action by such bodies shall
be by secret ballot . . . ."
We note that the legislature is free to provide an exemption
from the requirements of the Act with regard to any of its
committee meetings, including interim study committees, but,
to date, has not seen fit to do so except in circumstances
covered by Kansas Senate Rule 23 discussed in Kansas Attorney
General Opinion No. 81-26. Naturally, this office is not at
liberty to comment on the advisability of such exemptions as
they are matters of public policy clearly within the legisla-
tive perogative.
With regard to the notice requirement, K.S.A. 1981 Supp.
75-4318(b) provides:
"Notice of the date, time and place of any
regular or special meeting of a public body
designated hereinabove shall be furnished to
any person requesting such information, ex-
cept that:
"(1) If notice is requested by petition, the
petition shall designate one person to receive
notice on behalf of all persons named in the
petition, and notice to such person shall con-
stitute notice to all persons named in the
petition; and
"(2) if notice is furnished to an executive
officer of an employees' -organization or trade
association, such notice shall be deemed to
have been furnished to the entire membership
of such organization or association." (Em-
phasis added.)
We think the command of this section is clear and unambiguous,
requiring little comment except to note that the Act does not
contemplate that notice may be denied for failure to pay a
fee, postage or a subscription charge. As we concluded in
Kansas Attorney General Opinion No. 81-137:
"The Kansas Open Meetings Act does not autho-
rize any charge for the providing of notice.
It only requires that such notice shall be
provided.
"The providing of notice of public meetings is
an integral part of conducting the public's
business. It is a cost of doing business.
Nothing in the Kansas Open Meetings Act sug-
gests that local government bodies may erect a
barrier to the providing of requested notice.
Absent authorization by the legislature for
such charge (see K.S.A. 1980 Supp. 45-204 au-
thorizing a charge for the copying of public
documents), we would conclude such charge is
contrary to the public policy expressed in the
Act." Id. at 3,4.
We reaffirm the above conclusion and find it applicable to
meetings of legislative study committees. If the Kansas
Register were provided at no expense to members of the pub-
lic, the notice contained in its pages, when provided to
those requesting it, would be adequate. However, requiring
persons to subscribe to the Register in order to receive such
notice is contrary to law, since it erects a financial barrier
to the receipt of notice. We can only presume that not all
of the approximately 1350 persons who have requested and nor-
mally receive the notice of interim study committees are
current subscribers to the Kansas Register. Those non-sub-
scribers are entitled to individual notice of interim study
committee meetings and hearings. However, we see no reason
why the Council should require duplicate notice to subscribers
of the Register where the notice provided therein is timely
and accurately displayed. Of course, there may be adminis-
trative problems inherent in maintaining separate lists of
subscribers and non-subscribers. For example, where subscrip-
tions are discontinued or emergency meetings are called, the
notice provided in the Register would be ineffective in pro-
viding the notice required by the Act. A determination to
rely, in part, upon notice provided in the Register is an
administrative decision beyond the scope of this opinion,
but one which has obvious limitations.
In light of the above conclusion, there is little to add re-
garding your additional questions labeled (a) and (b), except
to reaffirm our conclusion stated in Attorney General Opinion
No. 137 that "a government agency . . . cannot refuse notice
to any person on the basis of his or her failure or refusal
to provide stationary and postage or pay charges." Absent a
change in the Kansas Open Meetings Act or the amending of
House or Senate Rules, such charges are impermissible.
We note in passing the possibility that the language of K.S.A.
1981 Supp. 75-430 as amended, acts as an implied repeal of
the notice requirements of K.S.A. 1981 Supp. 75-4318. We
offer little interest and space to this legal concept since
the notice requirements of these two statutes are not inher-
ently conflicting, nor do they require mutually exclusive
courses of action. Only in the event that some subscribers
to the Kansas Register have also requested notice of interim
study committees is there any duplication of notice.
By way of contrast, we call the Council's attention to recent
legislative changes in the notice requirements for state ad-
ministrative rules and regulations. Prior to 1981, K.S.A.
77-421 required the giving of notice concerning the adoption
of such regulations to "all parties of interest known to the
state agency." In 1981 House Bill No. 2480, L. 1981, Ch. 324
§33, the legislature eliminated this language and substituted
a reference to the Kansas Register. In 1982, the legislature
further clarified the notice requirements for administrative
regulations by declaring in 1982 House Bill No. 2712 that
"[p]ublication of such notice in the Kansas register shall
constitute notice to all parties affected by the rules and
regulations." No such explicit exception to the notice re-
quirements of other statutes, specifically, K.S.A. 1981 Supp.
75-4318, has been made by the requirement for publication of
interim study committee notices in the Kansas Register.
Finally, you inquire whether the Council may discontinue notice
except to those who request (orally or in writing) that such
notice continue to be sent. We believe this question is ade-
quately addressed in Attorney General Opinion No. 81-137
(copy enclosed) which discussed at great length the issue of
how long a request for notice remains valid. In light of
this opinion, we think a proposal to update your mailing list
by requesting those listed to advise of their continued in-
terest in receiving notice is appropriate and lawful.
Very truly yours,
''ROBERT T. STEPHAN
Attorney General of Kansas
BradleyJ.SmootDeputyAttorneyGeneral
RTS:BJS:hle
Enc.

Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude

Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.