Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1982-089

1982-089Kanag

Texte intégral

April 19, 1982
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 82 - 89
The Honorable James L. Francisco
State Senator, Twenty-Sixth District
Room 136-N, Statehouse
Topeka, Kansas 66612
Re: Mentally Ill, Incapacitated and Dependent Persons --
Adult Care Homes -- Boarding Care Homes; Similarity
to Adult Family Homes; Distinction from Adult
Family Homes
Synopsis: As part of the Alternate Care Services program of
the Department of Social and Rehabilitation Ser-
vices, adult family homes have been established
which provide community-based living facilities
for elderly or disabled individuals who can no
longer live independently. In that adult family
homes do not provide nursing care, they are dis-
tinguishable from most forms of adult care homes,
which are licensed by the Department of Health
and Environment. However, in that they do offer
the same type of services as do boarding care
homes (a type of adult care home), adult family
homes serving 3 or more clients are required to
be licensed by the Department of Health and En-
vironment before operating. Cited herein: K.S.A.
39-923, K.S.A. 1981 Supp. 75-3307b.
Dear Senator Francisco:
As State Senator for the Twenty-Sixth District, you request
our opinion on a question concerning facilities for the care
of the elderly and disabled. Specifically, you inquire whether
the adult family home program administered by the Department
of Social and Rehabilitation Services (SRS) is subject to
the provisions of K.S.A. 39-923 et seq., the Adult Care Home
Licensure Act.
Initially, we note that the adult family home program is part
of Alternate Care Services, which was authorized by the 1981
Legislature and implemented on a statewide basis on December
1, 1981. As Alternate Care Services is merely part of a
general appropriation to SRS, no specific statutes or admin-
istrative rules and regulations exist which authorize the
adult family home program or define its parameters. Rather,
the program operates through the Alternate Care Handbook,
an SRS document which defines department procedures for
adult family homes. The handbook also establishes conditions
which must be met as a prerequisite to the receipt of pay-
ments by the operators of such facilities. These payments,
it may be observed, are made to the provider as a supplement
to those funds provided by the individual client, according
to a rate schedule set out in the handbook.
Further, we note from the handbook that the homes selected
to participate in the program are limited to a maximum of
four clients at any one time, and additionally must meet
other specified requirements concerning the health, safety
and supervision of the clients. There are no sections re-
garding the rendering of health care or nursing services.
Indeed, the provider of the home is limited to rendering the
following health-related assistance:
"#6. All medicine shall be kept safely away
from where it may be used by irresponsible
persons. The operator may assist residents
with the taking of medications only when: (1)
the medication is in a pharmacy-labeled bottle
which clearly shows physician's orders and
(2) when the resident requires assistance be-
cause of tremor, visual impairment, or simi-
lar reasons due to health conditions not re-
quiring the exercise of professional judgment.
The provider, with appropriate training, may
assist or perform for the resident those phy-
sical activities/tasks which do not require
daily medical supervision such as: insulin
injection, bathing, dressing, help with brace
or walker, transferring from wheelchairs."
(Emphasis original.)
"#25. The provider shall help [the] client
arrange for emergency and regular medical care
when necessary from a physician of the client's
choice."
Such guidelines may be compared with the statutes and regu-
lations which govern adult care homes. At K.S.A. 39-923 et
seq., are a series of statutes which set forth strict and
detailed requirements for such facilities, which range in
size from one-bed to many beds, and from simple up to
skilled levels of nursing care. With the exception of
"boarding care homes," each facility that is defined contains
a designation of the type of nursing care which must be
provided. For example, an "intermediate personal care home"
is defined at K.S.A. 39-923(a)(4) to involve the giving of
"simple nursing care," which itself is defined at subsection
(a)(10). Other facility definitions are likewise linked to
the offer of "skilled nursing care" [defined at (a)(8)] and
"supervised nursing care" [(a)(9)].
The sole exception to the above is found at K.S.A. 39-923(a)(6),
wherein boarding care homes are defined as including
"any place or facility operating for not less
than twenty-four (24) hours in any week and
caring for three (3) or more individuals not
related within the third degree of relation-
ship to the administrator or owner by blood
or marriage who by reason of aging, illness,
disease, or physical or mental infirmity are
unable to sufficiently or properly care for
themselves and for whom reception, accommoda-
tion, board and supervision is provided and
which place or facility is staffed, maintained
and equipped primarily to provide shelter to
residents who require some supervision, but
who are ambulatory and essentially capable of
managing their own care and affairs."
This definition may be compared with the statement of purpose
contained at the beginning of the adult family home section
of the Alternate Care Handbook issued by SRS. There, it is
stated:
"This program provides a homelike living situ-
ation to assist elderly and/or disabled cli-
ents unable to live independently because of
handicapping mental and/or physical conditions.
Adult Family Homes represent a less restric-
tive alternative for community living, and
may enable clients to live within their home
communities with a minimum of supervision and
guidance." (Emphasis supplied.)
Further, in the section on the general philosophy of alternate
care, we find the following statement:
"This program along with the pre-admission
screening program is for the purpose of
filling an identifiable gap in the continuum
of care. There is a lack of services for
elderly and/or disabled persons who require
less than medical care facilities offer, but -
need more supervision than total independent
living affords. Alternate Care Services en-
able clients to remain in the community and
live in the least restrictive environment
their health will allow." (Emphasis supplied.)
In our opinion, the services offered by the adult family home
program resemble those provided in a boarding care home as
defined by K.S.A. 39-923(a)(6). While the absence of nursing
care differentiates an adult family home' from the other types
of adult care homes defined at K.S.A. 39-923, the definition
of boarding care homes is silent as to any level of nursing
care which must be afforded. Indeed, this latter definition
speaks specifically to those persons who need some supervi-
sion, due to age or physical or mental infirmity, but who
are still basically able to care for themselves. Our read-
ing of the alternate services manual indicates that no real
distinction can be made between the degree of care offered
in adult family homes and in boarding care homes. Accord-
ingly, in our opinion, the licensure requirements of K.S.A.
39-923 et seq. would apply to adult family homes serving 3
or more clients.
In conclusion, as part of the Alternate Care Services program
of the Department of Social and Rehabilitation Services, adult
family homes have been established which provide community-
based living facilities for elderly or disabled individuals
who can no longer live independently. In that adult family
homes do not provide nursing care, they are distinguishable
from most forms of adult care homes, which are licensed by
the Department of Health and Environment. However, in that
they do offer the same type of services -as do boarding care
homes (a type of adult care home), adult family homes serving
3 or more clients are required to be licensed by the Depart-
ment of Health and Environment before operating.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF KANSAS
JeffreyS.Southard
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:BJS:JSS:hle

Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude

Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.