Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1982-077

1982-077Kanag

Texte intégral

April 1, 1982
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 82-77
The Honorable Jack Steineger
Senate Minority Leader
State Senator, Sixth District
State Capitol Building, Room 347-N
Topeka, Kansas 66612
Re: Finance and Taxation--Internal Improvements--
Construction of Fish Hatchery
Synopsis: The construction of a state-owned fish hatchery,
pursuant to the provisions of 1982 House Bill No.
3131, would not violate Article 11, Section 9 of
the Kansas Constitution. Cited herein: K.S.A.
32-101, 32-201, 32-202, 32-212, 32-214, Kan. Const.,
Art. 11, §9.
Dear Senator Steineger:
You inquire regarding Article 11, Section 9 of the Kansas
Constitution. Specifically, you wish to know the application of
this section to 1982 House Bill No. 3131 and the expenditures of
state moneys authorized thereby.
The bill proposes to authorize the Kansas Fish and Game Commission
to issue and sell revenue bonds "for the purpose of paying all
or part of the costs of constructing, equipping, stocking and
maintaining a fish hatchery, including the acquisition of a
site therefor." The bill also provides for payment of principal
and interest on the bonds by authorizing the issuance and sale
of "hatchery stamps" by the Commission.
Article 11, Section 9 of the Constitution of the State of Kansas
provides as follows:
"The state shall never be a party in carrying
on any work of internal improvement except
that: (1) It may adopt, construct, reconstruct
and maintain a state system of highways, but
no general property tax shall ever be laid nor
general obligation bonds issued by the state
for such highways; (2) it may be a party to
flood control works and works for the con-
servation or development of water resources;
(3) it may, whenever any work of internal
improvement not authorized by (1) or (2) is
once authorized by a separate bill passed by
the affirmative vote of not less than two-thirds
of all members then elected (or appointed) and
qualified to each house, expend or distribute
funds received from the federal government
therefor and may participate with the federal
government therein by contributing any state
funds appropropriated in accordance with law
for such purpose in any amount not exceeding
the amount received from the federal govern-
ment for such improvement, but no general
property tax shall ever be laid nor general
obligation bonds be issued by the state there-
for; and (4) it may expend funds received from
the federal government for any public purpose
in accordance with the federal law authorizing
the same."
Prior to determining whether any of the listed exceptions, whereby
the state may be a party to "works of internal improvement," is
applicable, it is necessary to consider whether the construction
of a fish hatchery, as proposed by 1982 House Bill No. 3131, would
constitute a prohibited work of internal improvement. Although the
Kansas Supreme Court has never had occasion to address this specific
question, the Court has interpreted and applied the prohibition
in numerous other instances which provide guidance as to its
scope.
The purpose of Article 11, Section 9 of the Kansas Constitution
is to defend the state treasury from insolvency, "logrolling"
and involvement in commercial enterprise. See State v. Kelly,
71 Kan. 811 (1905); State ex rel., v. Board of Regents, 167 Kan.
587 (1949).
Yet, in view of Article 11, Section 6 of the Kansas Constitution,
which specifically authorizes the state to contract a public
debt for "public improvements," the Kansas courts, from time to
time, have been required to classify a given legislative endeavor
as either a constitutional "public improvement" or an unconsti-
tutional work of "internal improvement." In so doing, the Court
has framed its distinctions around the nature of the project
and its relationship to the performance of necessary government
functions. In Leavenworth County v. Miller, 7 Kan. 479, 493
(1871), Chief Justice Valentine declared:
"The state, as a state, is a bsolutely pro-
hibited from engaging in any works of internal
improvement. We will concede that this
prohibition does not extend to the building
of a statehouse, penitentiary, state university,
and such other public improvements as are used
exclusively by and for the state, as a sovereign
corporation; but it does extend to every other
species of public improvement. It certainly
extends to the construction of every species
of public improvement which is used, or may
be used, by the public generally--by any and
every private individual who may choose to use
it--such as public roads, bridges, etc . . . ."
The Court then added, by way of example, that the state, not
cities or counties, is "prohibited from opening up or constructing
any roads, highways, bridges, ferries, streets, sidewalks, pave-
ments, wharfs, levees, drains, waterworks, gas works, or the
like."
In State ex rel., v. Board of Regents, supra, the Court classi-
fied a university dormitory as a "public improvement" because
of its obvious connection with a recognized governmental function,
namely, education. The legislative action was held to be valid.
On the other hand, in State v. Kelly, supra, the Court held that
a law attempting to establish, in connection with one another,
an oil refinery and a branch penitentiary, was void as an
unconstitutional attempt by the state to participate in an
"internal improvement."
Applying the judicial determinations herein cited to the facts
of the present situation, it is our opinion that a fish hatchery
is a "public improvement," rather than an "internal improvement."
Conservation of fish and wildlife is an acknowledged state purpose
(see K.S.A. 32-212), and, in our judgment, the operation of a
fish hatchery in pursuance of such purpose is a governmental
function, particularly in light of the declared policy of the
state of Kansas to protect and propagate the fish of the state.
See K.S.A. 32-201, 32-202, 32-212, 32-214, and 32-101. Thus,
we believe the enactment of 1982 House Bill No. 3131, and con-
struction of a fish hatchery pursuant to the provisions thereof,
would not violate the provisions of Article 11, Section 9 of the
Kansas Constitution. This conclusion makes it unnecessary to
consider the question of whether the issuance of revenue bonds
makes the state a "party" to an improvement, for purposes of
applying the provisions of said constitutional provision.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
Attorney General of Kansas
Terrence R. Hearshman
Assistant Attorney General
PTS:BJS:TRH:jm

Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude

Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.