Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1982-074

1982-074Kanag

Texte intégral

March 24, 1982
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 82-74
The Honorable Ruth. E. Luzzati
State Representative, Eighty-Fourth District
Room 272-W, Statehouse
Topeka, Kansas 66612
Re: Monopolies and Unfair Trade -- Restraint of Trade --
Application of Kansas Antitrust Laws to Motor Carrier
Rate Bureaus
Synopsis: Despite the state corporation commission's long-
standing acquiescence to the filing of rate appli-
cations with the commission by rate bureaus on
behalf of motor carriers having Kansas intrastate
authority, such practice is without basis in law.
Kansas statutes neither recognize nor provide for
the regulation of rate bureaus. Moreover, nothing
in the Kansas statutes provide rate bureaus with
immunity from prosecution under Kansas antitrust
laws, and it would appear that the collective rate-
making activities of rate bureaus constitute a re-
straint of trade in violation of said laws. How-
ever, before this conclusion can be made as a matter
of law, an independent investigation of such acti-
vities would be necessary. Cited herein: K.S.A.
50-101, 50-112, 50-148, 50-152, 50-157, 66-101,
66-107, 66-1,105, 66-1,112, 66-1,142.
Dear Representative Luzzati:
You have requested our opinion as to whether the actions of
discussing, planning, voting or submitting a rate bureau appli-
cation, and the subsequent approval, denial or partial ap-
proval of such an application by the state corporation com-
mission, constitute a violation of the Kansas antitrust laws.
In responding to your request, it is important initially to
understand the nature of rate bureaus. Our understanding
of such organizations has been assisted by the following ex-
cerpt from the testimony of the administrator of the corpora-
tion commission's transportation division before the Senate
Committee on Transportation and Utilities on January 26, 1982:
"[A rate bureau] is an organization, often an
association or corporation, engaged in the
business of preparing, submitting and publish-
ing those rates proposed to be charged by a
group of carriers that will be filed with the
state regulatory commissions or with the In-
terstate Commerce Commission (ICC) on behalf
of the member carriers."
Although rate bureaus have been instrumental in managing the
rate structures of motor carriers and in the submission of
rates, on behalf of motor carriers seeking collective rates,
to the state corporation commission since 1937, we have been
unable to discover any recognition of or reference to rate
bureaus in the statutes prescribing the jurisdiction and au-
thority of the corporation commission.
The corporation commission is granted authority to regulate
public utilities and motor carriers by K.S.A. 66-101 et seq.,
with additional powers being extended by the motor carrier
act of 1925, as expanded in 1931 (K.S.A. 66-1,105 through
66-1,142). The commission has a duty "to license, supervise
and regulate every public motor carrier of property or of
passengers in this state, and to fix and approve reasonable
maximum or minimum, or maximum and minimum rates, fares,
charges, classifications and rules and regulations pertaining
thereto." K.S.A. 66-1,112.
It is also pertinent to note that "joint rates" are contem-
plated by K.S.A. 66-107, which provides:
"Every common carrier and public utility gov-
erned by the provisions of this act shall be
required to furnish reasonably efficient and
sufficient service, joint service and facili-
ties for the use of any and all products or
services rendered, furnished, supplied or pro-
duced by such public utility or common carrier
and to establish just and reasonable rates,
joint rates, fares, tolls, charges and exac-
tions and to make just and reasonable rules,
classifications and regulations; and every
unjust or unreasonable discriminatory or unduly
preferential rule or regulation, classifica-
tion, rate, joint rate, fare, toll or charge
demanded, exacted or received is prohibited
and hereby declared to be unlawful and void,
and the state corporation commission shall
have the power, after notice and hearing of
the interested parties, to require any com-
mon carriers and all public utilities governed
by the provisions of this act to establish
and maintain just and reasonable joint rates
wherever the same are reasonably necessary to
be put in, in order to maintain reasonably
sufficient and efficient service from such
public utilities and common carriers."
However, the joint rates provided for by K.S.A. 66-107 are
distinguishable from the agency or group rates filed by rate
bureaus. Here, again, we premise our conclusion on the pre-
viously referenced testimony of the administrator of the com-
mission's transportation division. Accordingly, it is our
understanding that a "joint rate" is a rate published by two
or more motor carriers to cover transportation over part of
either of their routes. The effect is to allow a shipper
to obtain a single price for movement of a shipment involving
more than one carrier. And pursuant to the commission's
procedure, joint rates are normally approved by the commission
as a result of a "joint filing," which is the filing of an
application with the commission by the parties to the pro-
posed joint rate. On the other hand, a "rate bureau or group
filing" is an application with the commission for approval
of tariffs containing rates for all member carriers who haul
a particular commodity or group of commodities, and it is our
understanding that all carriers participating in the group
filing agree to charge the same rate once the filing is
approved by the commission, although an individual carrier
member may submit separate filings providing for rates which
differ from the group's tariff.
It is apparent, then, that the statutes authorizing joint
rates and joint filings do not authorize or in any way pro-
vide legal support for group rates or group filings. Simply
stated, joint rates and filings are not synonymous with group
rates and filings, and it is clear that joint filings may be
made by the appropriate carriers without rate bureau involve-
ment.
Thus, our research discloses that the Kansas legislature has
not provided a statutory basis for the existence or operation
of rate bureaus in the 45 years these bureaus have been en-
gaged in collective rate-making activities before the commis-
sion. However, even though the commission is not expressly
authorized to entertain applications based on collective rate
making by rate bureaus, the commission has traditionally
accepted and acted upon such applications.
The question then arises as to whether the collective or
group rate-making activities of rate bureaus violate the
Kansas antitrust laws. Unlawful antitrust activities are
detailed in K.S.A. 50-101 and 50-112. K.S.A. 50-101 provides:
"A trust is a combination of capital, skill,
or acts, by two or more persons, firms cor-
porations, or associations of persons, or
either two or more of them, for either, any
or all of the following purposes:
"First. To create or carry out restrictions
in trade or commerce, or aids to commerce, or
to carry out restrictions in the full and free
pursuit of any business authorized or permit-
ted by the laws of this state.
"Second. To increase or reduce the price of
merchandise, produce or commodities, or to
control the cost or rates of insurance.
"Third. To prevent competition in the manu-
facture, making, transportation, sale or pur-
chase of merchandise, produce or commodities,
or to prevent competition in aids to commerce.
"Fourth. To fix any standard or figure, where-
by its price to the public shall be, in any
manner, controlled or established, any article
or commodity of merchandise, produce or com-
merce intended for sale, use or consumption
in this state.
"Fifth. To make or enter into, or execute or
carry out, any contract, obligation or agree-
ment of any kind or description by which they
shall bind or have to bind themselves not to
sell, manufacturer, dispose of or transport
any article or commodity, or article of trade,
use, merchandise, commerce or consumption be-
low a common standard figure; or by which
they shall agree in any manner to keep the
price of such article, commodity or transpor-
tation at a fixed or graded figure; or by
which they shall in any manner establish or
settle the price of any article or commodity
or transportation between them or themselves
and others to preclude a free and unrestricted
competition among themselves or others in
transportation, sale or manufacture of any
such article or commodity; or by which they
shall agree to pool, combine or unite any
interest they may have in connection with the
manufacture, sale or transportation of any
such article or commodity, that its price may
in any manner be affected. And any such com-
binations are hereby declared to be against
public policy, unlawful and void."
K.S.A. 50-112, which was enacted in 1889 (L. 1889, ch. 257,
§1), states:
"All arrangements, contracts, agreements,
trusts, or combinations between persons or
corporations made with a view or which tend
to prevent full and free competition in the
importation, transportation or sale of arti-
cles imported into this state, or in the pro-
duct, manufacture or sale of articles of do-
mestic growth or product of domestic raw ma-
terial, or for the loan or use of money, or
to fix attorneys' or doctors' fees, and all
arrangements, contracts, agreements, trusts
or combinations between persons or corpora-
tions, designed or which tend to advance, re-
duce or control the price or the cost to the
producer or the consumer of any such products
or articles, or to control the cost or rate
of insurance, or which tend to advance or
control the rate of interest for the loan or
use of moneys to the borrower, or any other
services, are hereby declared to be against
public policy, unlawful and void."
Before analyzing the activities of rate bureaus in light of
these statutes, we think it appropriate at this point to note
that, in the summer of 1979, the corporation commission on
its own motion opened its Docket No. 119,183-R. Following a
pre-hearing conference in this investigative docket on July 5,
1979, the commission issued a pre-hearing order which iden-
tified the central issue of the investigation as being the
practice and procedure of joint, agency or bureau tariff
filing by motor carriers having intrastate authority in
Kansas. One of the specific issues concerning the primary
thrust of the investigation was whether such practice and
procedure satisfy current statutory requirements, particu-
larly the antitrust laws (K.S.A. 50-101 to 50-157, inclusive)
and the 1925 motor carrier act and amendments thereto (K.S.A.
66-1,105 to 66-1,142, inclusive).
The parties to the investigation included motor carriers,
associations of motor carriers and motor carrier rate bureaus.
These parties and the commission's 'staff filed extensive,
well-documented briefs on the various issues, and we have
found these briefs to be most helpful to our understanding
of terminology, the history of current practices and proce-
dures and the various legal questions having pertinence to
this opinion.
We mention this investigation here because of the considera-
tion given by the various parties participating in the docket
to the provisions of K.S.A. 50-148. That statute provides
in pertinent part: "This act shall not apply to persons whose
business is under the supervision and control of the state
corporation commission . . . ." We do not believe this sta-
tute extends antitrust immunity to rate bureaus.
Even though motor carriers themselves are subject to the
commission's supervision and control, rate bureaus are not.
As noted previously, rate bureaus are neither recognized nor
regulated pursuant to Kansas statutes. Despite the commis-
sion's long-standing acquiescence to the filing of rate appli-
cations by rate bureaus on behalf of motor carriers, we have
found no statutory basis for such practice. Moreover, we
have not been advised of any statutory interpretation by
this or any prior commission providing legal support for this
practice.
However, assuming arguendo that such rate bureaus are in fact
included in the exemption afforded by K.S.A. 50-148, it is
clear that this statute's exemption extends only to the pro-
visions of "this act," i.e., such exemption has application
only to the provisions of Chapter 368 of the 1915 Session
Laws of Kansas, now codified at K.S.A. 50-148 to 50-152, in-
clusive. Accordingly, since the antitrust laws contained in
Chapter 50 of Kansas Statutes Annotated are composed of a
series of separate legislative enactments, each of which is
independent of the others except where specifically stated
otherwise, it is clear that K.S.A. 50-148 has no application
to the various other acts proscribing antitrust activities.
Hence, we believe it appropriate to measure the collective
rate-making activities of motor carrier rate bureaus against
the previously quoted prohibitions in K.S.A. 50-101 and
50-112. In this regard, we should note our concurrence with
the commission's staff that the rate bureaus, not the commis-
sion, establishes rates. As noted at pages IV-1 and IV-2
of the staff's brief filed in Docket No. 119,183-R:
"The statutory framework for the regulation
of motor carrier rates adds support to the
proposition that the rate bureaus, not the
commission, determine the rates. K.S.A.
66-107 requires carriers to establish just
and reasonable rates. The commission only
establishes maximum, minimum or maximum and
minimum rates. K.S.A. 66-1,112."
In other words, the commission approves limitations on carrier
rates, but the actual rates are established by the rate
bureaus. And as previously noted, except where individual
filings are made, all carriers participating in a rate bureau
or group filing agree to charge the same rates once the filing
is approved by the commission.
It is also relevant to consider the impact of rate bureaus.
As noted in the above-referenced testimony of the administra-
tor of the commission's transportation division:
"The State Corporation Commission currently
has on file nine intrastate bureau or agency
tariffs. These tariffs were developed through
the process of collective rate making and
represent the rates or price of transportation
charged by 721 motor carrier firms authorized
by the Commission to operate in Kansas. These
721 motor carrier firms represent approximately
48% of the 1,509 intrastate common and contract
motor carriers authorized to operate in Kansas
by the Commission."
The question, then, is whether the collective rate-making of
these rate bureaus constitutes an infringement of our anti-
trust laws. Based on the factual data available to us, we
believe it does. As stated by the commission's staff at
page IV-4 of its brief in Docket No. 119,183-R, in quoting
an authority on collective carrier ratemaking: "'By defini-
tion, the collective ratemaking system involves restrictions
upon rate competition of a type which would normally be pro-
hibited by the anti-trust laws.'" (Footnote omitted.)
Certainly the relationship of a rate bureau and its members
in the filing of applications for rate increases and, upon
commission approval, the publishing of tariffs for those mem-
bers, accomplish the very thing the legislature sought to
prevent by the enactment of the antitrust laws. Collective
ratemaking, where neither provided for by statute nor exempt
from antitrust prosecution, appears to violate each of the
five enumerated provisions of K.S.A. 50-101, as well as the
more general provisions of K.S.A. 50-112. On the basis of
factual information we have obtained from a review of the
record in the commission's Docket No. 119,183-R and from a
consideration of the previously-referenced testimony of the
commission's staff, we believe the agreement between the
rate bureau and its members to collectively establish group
rates and to publish group tariffs constitutes the formation
of a trust or combination. It would be difficult to assume
that the purpose was other than to "create or carry out re-
strictions in trade or commerce," to "carry out restrictions
in the full or free pursuit of business," to "increase or
reduce the price of merchandise," to "prevent competition in
the manufacture, making, transportation, sale or purchase
of merchandise," to "fix any standard or figure, whereby its
price to the public shall be, in any manner, controlled or
established, [for] any article or commodity of merchandise,"
or to "make or enter into, or execute or carry out, any con-
tract, obligation or agreement . . . by which they shall
bind . . . themselves not to sell, manufacture, dispose of
or transport any article or commodity . . . below a common
standard figure," all prohibited activities under K.S.A. 50-101.
Such a combination would also contravene K.S.A. 50-112, if
it would "tend to prevent full and free competition in the
importation, transportation or sale of articles imported into
this state . . . or . . . [would] tend to advance, reduce or
control the price or the cost to the producer or to the con-
sumer of any such products or articles."
There is a dearth of case law in Kansas, and in other juris-
dictions, dealing with rate bureaus which would be of appre-
ciable benefit. However, a recent federal case in Georgia
appears analogous to the situation presented here. In U.S. v.
Southern Motor Carrier Rate Confer., Inc., 467 F. Supp. 471
(1979), an action was brought to enjoin the continuing viola-
tion of the Sherman Act by three rate bureaus representing
common carriers before state regulatory commissions in five
states. These rate bureaus publish tariffs containing pro-
posed rates for intrastate for-hire transportation of general
commodities on behalf of their members. In granting the
government's motion for summary judgment, Judge Freeman of
the United States District Court for the Northern District
of Georgia, traced the history of the state action immunity
doctrine, since the violation alleged was of a federal law
(Sherman Act). Upon determining that the practice of collec-
tive rate publication did not fall within the category of
private activities that are immune from antitrust laws under
the "state action" doctrine, the court went on to find that
coordinating and fixing of rates, presenting collectively
set rates to the commissions, and putting those rates into
effect "constitute independently cognizable acts outside
the scope of First Amendment protection or the Noerr-Pennington
doctrine." Id. at 485. That doctrine concludes that concerted
action consisting solely of activities aimed at influencing
public officials is not a violation of the Sherman Act. Id.
at 484.
The provisions of the Kansas antitrust laws are quite similar
to those of the Sherman Act, and the rate bureau activities
here appear to be virtually identical to those described in
the Southern case, supra. Although we concede that final
adjudication is pending (the Southern case is now on appeal
in the Eleventh Circuit), we find the trial court's opinion
persuasive.
Therefore, based on our understanding of the collective rate-
making activities of motor carrier rate bureaus in Kansas,
and in light of the persuasive opinion of the trial court in
the Southern case, supra, such collective rate-making acti-
vities appear to violate various provisions of the Kansas
antitrust laws. However, it should be recognized that not
only has the decision in Southern been appealed, but our
factual data as to rate bureau activities has been acquired
through third-party sources. Thus, before we could state
conclusively, as a matter of law, that collective rate-making
activities of rate bureaus are in violation of our antitrust
statutes, it would be necessary for this office to conduct
an independent investigation of these activities.
Very truly yours,
ROBERTT.STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF KANSAS
Carl M. Anderson
-Assistant Attorney General
RTS:WRA:CMA:hle

Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude

Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.