Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1982-068

1982-068Kanag

Texte intégral

March 16, 1982
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 82- 68
Roy P. Britton
State Banking Commissioner
Suite 600, 818 Kansas Avenue
Topeka, Kansas 66612
Re: Banks and Banking -- Code; Powers -- Investments
Synopsis: Interest rate futures contracts and forward place-
ment contracts are not securities for purposes of
the state banking code. Hence, state banks may
not participate in such contracts pursuant to the
authority granted banks under the state banking
code to acquire investment securities. Cited
herein: K.S.A. 9-1101, K.S.A. 1981 Supp. 9-1715,
K.S.A. 17-1252, K.A.R. 17-11-1, 17-11-2, 17-11-6,
12 C.F.R., §1.3.
Dear Commissioner Britton:
On your behalf, Carl R. Sandstrom, Assistant Bank Commissioner,
has requested our opinion on whether interest rate futures
contracts and forward placement or delayed delivery contracts
can be considered investment securities which may be acquired
by banks under the state banking laws. This question appar-
ently arises because Kansas state banks, as do National banks,
have been using interest rate futures contracts to hedge
against interest rate fluctuations, and your office is con-
cerned that there is no specific statutory authority for
state banks to become involved in these contracts.
K.S.A. 9-1101(3) permits banks to buy and sell securities of
or fully guaranteed by the United States. A futures contract
represents "a commitment to purchase or sell a standard amount
of the deliverable grade security at a specified price during
a specified delivery month in accordance with the exchange
rules regarding delivery procedures." Comptroller of the
Currency Banking Circular - . 79, issued March 19, 1980.
Forward placement contracts have been described as
"over-the-counter contracts for delayed de-
livery of securities in which the buyer (long)
agrees to purchase and the seller (short)
agrees to make a delivery of a specified se-
curity at a specified price for future deli-
very. Cash market transactions other than
'when issued' transactions, specifying deli-
very (settlement) in excess of thirty (30)
days following the trade date shall be deemed
to be forward contracts. Forward contracts
are not traded on organized exchanges, the
terms are not standardized, and the contracts
can only be terminated by agreement of both
parties to the transaction." Id.
From a comparison of this definition with the one for futures
contracts, it can be seen that the underlying goods are the
same, with the primary differences being that forward placement
contracts are not traded on organized exchanges and the settle-
ment date in forward placement contracts is generally, at least
30 days after the trade date. Neither forward placement con-
tracts nor futures contracts are guaranteed by or obligations
of the United States. Therefore, these contracts cannot be
regarded as securities of the United States within the con-
templation of K.S.A. 9-1101(3).
Further analysis of this issue leads us to the conclusion
that neither the futures nor forward placement contracts are
securities at all and, as a consequence, are not securities
of the United States, within the meaning of K.S.A. 9-1101(3),
or investment securities, within the meaning of K.S.A. 9-1101(7)
or (13).
While the Kansas Banking Code does not define the term
"security," the Kansas Securities Act provides that:
"'Security' means any note; stock; treasury
stock; bond; debenture; evidence of indebted-
ness; certificate or interest or participation
in any profit-sharing agreement; collateral-
trust certificate; preorganization certificate
or subscription; transferable share; invest-
ment contract; voting-trust certificates;
thrift certificates or investment certificates,
or thrift notes issued by investment companies;
certificate of deposit for a security; certi-
ficate of interest in oil and gas royalties;
leases or mineral deeds; or, in general, any
interest or instrument commonly known as a
' security,' or any certificate of interest or
participation in, temporary or interim certi-
ficate for, guarantee of, or warrant or right
to subscribe to or purchase, any of the fore-
going. 'Security' does not include an insur-
ance or endowment policy or annuity contract
under which an insurance company promises to
pay money either in a lump sum or periodically
for life or some other specified period."
K.S.A. 17-1252(j).
In our judgment, whether interest rate futures contracts and
forward placement contracts are securities must be determined
with reference to the foregoing definition, in the absence
of any definition in the banking code. "Ordinarily, identi-
cal words or terms used in different statutes on a specific
subject are interpreted to have the same meaning in the ab-
sence of anything in the context to indicate that a different
meaning was intended." Williams v. Board of Education, 198
Kan. 115, 124, 125 (1967). In addition, the legislatively
prescribed rules of statutory construction require that
"technical words and phrases, and such others as may have
acquired a peculiar and appropriate meaning in law, shall be
construed according to such peculiar and appropriate meaning. . "
K.S.A. 77-201, Second. We think there is little question
that "security" is a technical term which has "acquired a
peculiar and appropriate meaning" through its definition by
the legislature in the Kansas Securities Act and its inter-
pretation by the courts.
Moreover, insofar as K.S.A. 9-1101(3), (7) and (13) and K.S.A.
17-1252(j) relate to the same subject, they must be construed
together as statutes in pari materia. "It is well settled,
that different statutes relating to the same subject are to
be construed together." Kansas v. Young, 17 Kan. 414, 417
(1877). And the fact that the Securities Act was enacted
ten years after the banking code does not diminish the appli-
cability of this principle. "'Statutes relating to the same
subject, although enacted at different times are in pari
materia and should be construed together.'" Thoman v. Farmers
& Bankers Life Ins. Co., 155 Kan. 806, 810 (1942), quoting
Morrill County v. Bliss, 125 Neb. 97, 249 N.W. 98.
Although the Kansas Supreme Court has not passed on the spe-
cific matter of whether interest rate futures contracts or
forward placement contracts are securities, it has interpreted
the definition of "security" in K.S.A. 17-1252, stating:
"Generally the term 'security,' which has no
precisely defined legal definition aside from
statutory provisions, has reference to written
instruments, usually for the payment of money
or to evidence a debt, and being more than a
mere promise of the debtor of a general lia-
bility on his part has as collateral to it a
pledge of property or some additional boliga-
tion. By common usage, however, the term has
acquired a much broader meaning. It is now
generally used to refer to instruments for
the payment of money, or evidencing title or
equity, with or without some collateral obli-
gation, and which are commonly dealt in for
the purpose of financing and investment. In-
struments, whether secured or unsecured, which
are used for the purpose of financing enter-
prises and promoting a distribution of rights
in or obligations of such enterprises, and
which are designed as a means of investment,
are termed 'securities.'" State v. Hodge,
204 Kan. 98, 103 (1969).
Since futures contracts and forward placement contracts are
generally not used by banks for the purpose of financing their
enterprises or promoting a distribution of rights of such
enterprises, but rather as a means of "hedging," these con-
tracts do not constitute securities under the above defini-
tion.
K.S.A. 9-1101(7) allows banks to buy and sell investment
securities which are evidences of indebtedness, subject to
certain limitations. K.S.A. 9-1101(13) permits banks to buy
any type of investment security with the approval of the
bank commissioner. An investment security is defined in
K.A.R. 17-11-1 as
"a marketable obligation, i.e., it must be
salable under ordinary circumstances with
reasonable promptness at a fair value; and
with respect to the particular security,
there must be present one or more of the
following characteristics:
"(A) A public distribution of the securities
must have been provided for or made in a man-
ner to protect or insure the marketability of
the issue; or
"(B) Other existing securities of the obligor
must have such a public distribution as to
protect or insure the marketability of the
issue under consideration; or
"(C) In the case of investment securities for
which a public distribution, as set forth in
(A) or(B) above, cannot be so provided, or
so made, and which are issued by established
commercial or industrial businesses or enter-
prises, that can demonstrate the ability to
service such securities, the debt evidenced
thereby must mature not later than ten years
after the date of issuance of the security,
and must be of such sound value or so secure
as reasonably to assure its payment; and such
securities must, by their terms, provide for
the amortization of the debt evidenced thereby
so that at least seventy-five percent of the
principal will be extinguished by the maturity
date by substantial periodic payments: Pro-
vided, That no amortization need be required
for the period of the first year after the
date of issuance of such securities."
It is our understanding that futures contracts are traded
in organized markets regulated by the Commodities Futures
Trading Commission, which would make them "salable under
ordinary circumstances with reasonable promptness." Further-
more, even though forward placement contracts are not traded
in organized markets they, too, would seem to meet the prompt
salability requirement, in light of the recent expansion of
their use by firms in credit markets, including national
banks. However, K.A.R. 17-11-2 states in part:
"All purchases of investment securities for
the account of the bank must be of securities
'in the form of bonds, notes, and/or deben-
tures, commonly known as investment securi-
ties'. . . ."
Although the forward placement and futures contracts meet
the marketable obligation standard, they are not in the form
of bonds, notes, and/or debentures as required by K.A.R.
17-11-2. Therefore, even though the "underlying good" or
commodity is in the form of a bond or note, the instrument
being sold is merely a contract to buy or sell that commodity
and not an investment security which. banks are authorized to
purchase.
Furthermore, the definition of "investment securities" set
forth in the Kansas regulations is similar to the one found
in federal regulations. See, 12 C.F.R. §1.3(b). That defi-
nition, issued by the Comptroller of the Currency, has sub-
sequently been interpreted by the Comptroller as excluding
both futures contracts and forward placement contracts.
(Comptroller of the Currency Banking Circular - 79, issued
March 19, 1980.) The interpretation of the Comptroller need
not bind us in interpreting Kansas regulations; however,
such an interpretation is persuasive. We also note that,
notwithstanding this interpretation, the Comptroller has
specifically authorized national banks to participate in
financial futures contracts and forward placement contracts
because, when used carefully, "the use of these contracts
is considered incidental to banking." Id. Thus, pursuant
to the Comptroller's interpretive ruling, national banks may
participate in futures contracts and forward placement con-
tracts as an incident to their general banking business.
Here, it is appropriate to note K.S.A. 1981 Supp. 9-1715,
which provides in part:
"(a) In addition to any and all other powers
heretofore granted to the state bank commis-
sioner, the commissioner shall have the power
to authorize any state bank or trust company
to engage in any activity in which such bank
or trust company could engage were they operat-
ing as a national bank at the time such au-
thority is granted, including but without
limitation because of enumeration the power
to do any act, and own, possess and carry as
assets, property of such character including
stocks, bonds or other debentures which, at
the time said authority is granted, is au-
thorized under federal laws and regulations
for transactions by national banks notwith-
standing any restrictions elsewhere contained
in the statutes of the state of Kansas. Upon
receipt of a written request from any state
bank or trust company, the commissioner shall
exercise such power by the issuance of a spe-
cial order therefor if such commissioner deems
it reasonably required to preserve and pro-
tect the welfare of such. an institution and
promote the general economy of this state. A
copy of each such special order shall be mailed
to all state banks and trust companies."
The foregoing pertains to special orders applicable to par-
ticular banks, but subsection (b) of this statute contains
similar authority to issue general orders applicable to all
state banks. Arguably, these provisions vest in the bank
commissioner the power to authorize state banks to purchase
futures contracts and forward placement contracts, since
national banks are engaged in that activity, pursuant to a
comptroller's banking circular, a federal reserve board
policy statement and an FDIC policy statement, all found at
CCH Federal Banking Law Reporter, ¶98170. However, while
we are unaware of any decisions of the Kansas Supreme Court
or prior opinions of this office construing the scope and
extent of the general powers granted the Commissioner by
this statute, that issue is not presented for our considera-
tion.
Thus, we must conclude that the banking regulations discussed
above preclude state banks from participating in futures and
forward placement contracts. We also note that K.A.R. 17-11-6
prohibits the purchase of distinctly or predominantly specula-
tive securities. From our understanding of futures and forward
placement contracts, it would appear that improper use of
these contracts increases rather than decreases risk of loss
due to changes in interest rates; therefore, such fact may
well prompt your determination that, even if these contracts
were regarded as securities, they are improper investments
because of their speculative nature.
In conclusion, it is our opinion that interest rate futures
contracts and forward placement contracts are not securities
for purposes of the state banking code. Hence, state banks
may not participate in such contracts pursuant to the au-
thority granted banks under the state banking code to ac-
quire investment securities.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEYGENERALOFKANSAS
W.	RobertAlderson
First Deputy Attorney General
RTS:WRA:hle

Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude

Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.