Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1982-039

1982-039Kanag

Texte intégral

February 17, 1982
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 82- 39
Roy P. Britton
State Banking Commissioner
State Banking Department
818 Kansas Avenue
Topeka, Kansas 66612
Re: Banks and Banking -- Code; Powers -- Oath of
Director and President
Synopsis: As a necessary incident to the bank commissioner's
due and efficient exercise of his general super-
visory powers, designed to insure compliance with
the banking code, the commissioner has the author-
ity to inquire into the ownership of a bank's
stock by its directors, to determine whether such
stock is owned in good faith, as required by the
banking code. If the commissioner's factual de-
termination indicates the lack of such good faith
ownership, it may provide the basis for a criminal
prosecution for perjury by the appropriate county
attorney or for the removal of offending directors
by the banking board. Cited herein: K.S.A. 1981
Supp. 9-1117, 9-1118, K.S.A. 9-1711, K.S.A. 1981
Supp. 9-1805, K.S.A. 9-2004, 21-3805.
Dear Mr. Britton:
On your behalf, Carl R. Sandstrom, Assistant Bank Commissioner,
has requested our opinion on whether the banking department
has the responsibility to insure compliance with the require-
ments of K.S.A. 1981 Supp. 9-1117 and 9-1118. The former
statute reads as follows:
"No person shall be a member of the board of
directors or a president within the meaning
of K.S.A. 1979 Supp. 9-1114 and K.S.A. 9-1115,
of any bank unless such person is the owner
of record of common stock, having a par value
of not less than five hundred dollars ($500),
in such bank. Such stock may be transferred
to and held in a trust if such trust is revo-
cable by the member or president owning such
stock, but the stock shall not be pledged,
hypothecated or assigned in any other way."
In addition, K.S.A. 1981 Supp. 9-1118 requires that:
"Each director shall take and subscribe an
oath that he or she will administer the af-
fairs of such bank diligently and honestly
and that he or she will not knowingly or will-
fully permit any of the laws relating to banks
to be violated, and each director and the presi-
dent of a bank shall swear that he or she is
the owner in good faith of shares of common
stock having a par value of at least five hun-
dred dollars ($500) of such bank standing in
his or her name and that the same has not been
pledged or assigned, except as authorized by
K.S.A. 1979 Supp. 9-1117, and amendments there-
to. A copy of such oath shall be filed with
the commissioner." (Emphasis added.)
Mr. Sandstrom indicates that certain bank holding companies
are transferring stock in their subsidiary banks to directors
of these banks at a price of one dollar per share, in order
that the directors can comply with the foregoing statutory
requirements. However, the stock so transferred has a par
value ranging from $25 to $100 per share and a book value of
from $350 to $1,000 per share. In addition, it is our under-
standing that such stock is annotated or lettered, so as to
restrict its subsequent sale, by requiring that it must be
offered to or sold back only to the holding company, and
that dividends on such stock are waived by the stockholder/
director for the benefit of the holding company.
Under these factual circumstances, Mr. Sandstrom suggests
that it "appears to be a 'sham' when a director makes a cer-
tification that he owns such stock in good faith." Therefore,
the question presented for our consideration is whether the
banking department has the responsibility to "ferret out"
such transactions or whether the bank director's oath puts
the onus on the director.
In our judgment, the statutes quoted above make it clear
that, not only must bank directors "own the stock of record,"
but they must take an oath, to be filed with the bank commis-
sioner, that they are "owners in good faith" of such stock.
Considered in pari materia these statutes evidence a legis-
lative intent that directors have a bona fide ownership inter-
est in the banks they serve.
While there is no specific statutory duty requiring the bank
commissioner or banking board to "ferret out" potential vio-
lations of K.S.A. 1981 Supp. 9-1117 and 9-1118, the purpose
of the bank commissioner's general supervision of banks is
to assure compliance with the banking code. Accordingly, we
believe the commissioner has implicit authority to ensure
compliance with the banking code's requirements as to the
good faith ownership of a bank's stock by its directors. The
fact that the legislature has directed that a copy of a di-
rector's oath be filed with the commissioner lends further
credence to our conclusion.
In addition, it is pertinent to note two other sections of
the banking code, K.S.A. 1981 Supp. 9-1805 and K.S.A. 9-2004.
The latter section provides as follows:
"Every officer or employee of a bank required
by this act to take an oath . . . for] affir-
mation, who shall willfully swear or affirm
falsely, shall be deemed guilty of perjury,
and upon conviction thereof shall be punished
as provided by the law of this state in case
of perjury."
K.S.A. 1981 Supp. 9-1805 states, in pertinent part:
"If it shall come to the attention of the
'banking] board that any officer or director
of any bank or trust company has been dishon-
est, reckless or incompetent in performing
his or her duties as such officer or director
or willfully or continuously fails to observe
any order of the commissioner or board legally
made, the [banking] board, upon proof thereof,
may remove such officer or director . . . ."
Furthermore, K.S.A. 9-1711 requires the bank commissioner to
notify the county attorney of the county in which a bank is
located, of any violations of the banking code which consti-
tute a felony or misdemeanor.
Therefore, if bank directors are not good faith owners of
the required amount of stock, yet willfully swear to be
owners in good faith of such stock, by virtue of K.S.A. 9-2004
they would be guilty of perjury, which is made a felony by
K.S.A. 21-3805, and K.S.A. 9-1711 requires the commissioner
to inform the appropriate county attorney of such violations.
Furthermore, under such circumstances, the banking board
could remove a director from office in accordance with the
procedures set forth at K.S.A. 1981 Supp. 9-1805.
We have little difficulty, in light of the banking code pro-
visions discussed above, in concluding that the bank commis-
sioner has implicit authority to determine compliance with
the code's requirements as to the good faith ownership of a
bank's stock by its directors. Our conclusion as to the
commissioner's responsibility is consistent with the general
rule set forth at 67 C.J.S. Officers, §197, p. 649, that:
"Generally, the duties of a public office in-
clude those lying fairly within its scope,
those essential to the accomplishment of the
main purpose for which the office was created,
and those which, although incidental and col-
lateral, serve to promote the accomplishment
of the principal purposes."
In accord with this general principle is the following state-
ment of the Kansas Supreme Court in The State, ex rel., v.
Younkin, 108 Kan. 634 (1921):
"While the powers of a public officer or board
are those and those only which the law confers,
yet when the law does confer a power or pre-
scribe a duty to be performed or exercised by
a public officer, the powers granted and duties
prescribed carry with them by necessary impli-
cation such incidents of authority as are neces-
sary for the effectual exercise of the powers
conferred and duties imposed. In Throop on
Public Officers, §542, the correct rule is
stated:
"'The rule respecting such powers is, that in
addition to the powers expressly given by sta-
tute to an officer or a board of officers, he
or it has, by implication, such additional
powers as are necessary for the due and effi-
cient exercise of the powers expressly granted,
or as may be fairly implied from the statute
granting the express powers.' (See, also,
Comm'rs of Brown Co. v. Barnett, 14 Kan. 627.)"
Id. at 638.
Accordingly, we believe the bank commissioner may inquire into
the good faith ownership of a bank's stock by its directors
as an incident of his general supervisory powers over banks
to insure compliance with the banking code. However, while
the code requires a director to be a good faith owner of
such stock, determination of good faith ownership is in part
a question of fact. Thus, we believe it is initially the
bank commissioner's responsibility to weigh and consider evi-
dence as to a bank director's lack of good faith in becoming
a record owner of bank stock. Such factual determination
will provide the basis for seeking criminal prosecution by
the appropriate county attorney under K.S.A. 9-2004 and for
action of the banking board under K.S.A. 1981 Supp. 9-1805.
Very truly yours,
''ROBERT T. STEPHAN ATTORNEYGENERALOFKANSAS
W. Robert Alderson
First Deputy Attorney General
RTS:WRA:hle

Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude

Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.