Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1982-031

1982-031Kanag

Texte intégral

February 8, 1982
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 82- 31
Mr. Wayne M. Stallard
Attorney at Law
307 Leonard Street
Onaga, Kansas 66521
Re: Townships and Township Officers -- Hospitals --
Expenditure of Hospital District Funds for Recruit-
ment by Paying for Medical Education
Synopsis: A hospital Board of Directors acting pursuant to
K.S.A. 80-21,101 et seq. is without authority to
expend hospital district funds to provide for a
medical education in return for a promise to prac-
tice medicine in a certain area. Cited herein:
K.S.A. 1981 Supp. 80-21;101, 80-21,111.
Dear Mr. Stallard:
As legal counsel for Community Hospital District No. 1 of
Pottawatomie and Jackson counties, you request an opinion of
this office regarding the authority of the Hospital District
Board of Directors to enter into an agreement with a prospec-
tive local medical student, to the effect that the hospital
district will provide funds for the medical education of the
student in return for a promise to practice in your district
upon obtaining a license to practice. You state that your
hospital district is organized pursuant to K.S.A. 1981 Supp.
80-21,101 et seq., and that it is in dire need of at least
one more doctor. Specifically, you inquire whether authority
for such action may be found pursuant to K.S.A. 1981 Supp.
80-21,111 (e), which grants the board of directors power to
"expend funds of the district for recruitment of professional
staff."
It is well established in Kansas "that subdivisions of the
state, being creatures of the state, have only such powers as
are conferred upon them by statute." Township Board of Ash
Creek v. Robb, 166 Kan. 138, 139, (1948). Thus, the board
of directors does not have the power to enter into the contem-
plated agreement unless such power has been conferred or is
necessarily implied. It is our opinion that the enabling
statutes of the hospital district, specifically the authori-
zation to expend funds for recruitment of professional staff,
do not confer the power required to take the contemplated
action.
The language conferring the power to expend funds to recruit
professional staff was added to K.S.A. 1981 Supp. 80-21,111
by L. 1972, ch. 44, §18. An examination of the legislative
history of this enactment shows no intent to allow hospital
boards to finance the education of medical students in return
for a promise to practice in a certain geographical area.
The minutes of the Senate Public Health and Welfare Committee
on February 2, 1972 show the following:
"Chairman Thomas advised that the committee
would break from the hearings on Substitute
for Senate Bill No. 291 to hear from Senator
Smith on S.B. 584 - AN ACT CONCERNING CITY,
TOWNSHIP, COUNTY AND DISTRICT HOSPITALS.
Senator Smith advised that even though this
bill is lengthy, it basically only makes one
change in the law and that is to allow hospi-
tals to spend funds for recruitment of hospi-
tal personnel. Senator Janssen asked if this
could open the way for hospitals to pay a por-
tion or all of a student's expenses during
medical school as an enticement to come back
to the hospital. Senator Smith does not in-
vision [sic] this."
The above is an indication that the legislature did not in-
tend to confer the power to pay for a medical student's edu-
cation in return for a promise to practice medicine in your
area. The primary rule of statutory construction in Kansas
is that the intent of the legislature controls. See Jolly v.
Kansas Public Emp. Retirement System, 214 Kan. 200, (1974).
Because nothing in the statute or its legislative history
indicates the intent to include the contemplated action with-
in the authority conferred in K.S.A. 1981 Supp. 80-21,111, we
cannot say as .a matter of law that said action is authorized.
We reached a similar conclusion regarding the authority of a
county hospital's board of trustees in Attorney General Opin-
ion No. 82-32, and we are enclosing a copy of that opinion
for your consideration.
To summarize, it is our opinion that a Hospital Board of
Directors acting pursuant to K.S.A. 80-21,101 et seq. is
without authority to expend hospital district funds to pro-
vide for a medical education in return for a promise to prac-
tice medicine in a certain area.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF KANSAS
BradleyJ.Smoot
Deputy Attorney General
RTS:BJS:hle
Enclosure: Att'y Gen. Op. No. 82-32

Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude

Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.