Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1982-021

1982-021Kanag

Texte intégral

February 4, 1982
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 82-21
Mr. Robert E. Davis
Leavenworth County Attorney
County Courthouse
4th and Walnut Street
Leavenworth, Kansas 66048
Re: Public Health -- Solid and Hazardous Waste --
Restrictions on Local Authorities
Snyopsis: A county may not limit the use of a county sanitary
landfill to local county refuse sources by virtue
of the prohibition in K.A.R. 1981 Sup?. 28-29-1
against local agencies enforcing requirement
which would impede interstate or intrastate trans-
portation or disposal of solid waste. Cited
herein: K.S.A. 65-3401, K.A.R. 1981 Supp. 28-29-1.
Dear Mr. Davis:
You state that the Leavenworth County Commission granted a
special use permit to a private individual to allow his pro-
perty to be used as a sanitary landfill for the county, sub-
ject to certain conditions to be set by the county commission.
One of the conditions under consideration is the restriction
of the landfill to Leavenworth County refuse sources. You
ask whether this restriction may be properly imposed in
light of K.S.A. 65-3401 et seq. and K.A.R. 1981 Supp. 28-29-1
et seq.
K.S.A. 65-3401 states that the policy of the State of Kansas
regarding the safe and sanitary disposal of solid wastes is
to:
"(a) Establish and maintain a cooperative
state and local program of planning and tech-
nical and financial assistance for comprehen-
sive solid waste management.
"(b) Utilize the capabilities of private en-
terprise as well as the services of public
agencies to accomplish the desired objectives
of an effective solid waste management program.
"(c) Require a permit for the operation of
solid waste processing and disposal systems."
We note that issuance of the special use permit to a private
individual is plainly within the scope of subsection (b) of
the statute.
K.A.R. 1981 Supp. 28-29-1, promulgated by the Kansas Depart-
ment of Health and Environment to regulate the disposal of
solid wastes within the state in accordance with K.S.A.
65-3401 et seq., provides as follows:
"Nothing in these regulations shall interfere
with the right of cities or counties to enact
ordinances or resolutions for control of solid
waste management practices which are more
stringent than the requirements of these regu-
lations except that no local agency shall en-
force a requirement, other than those in this
article, which would impede interstate or in-
trastate transportation, or disposal of solid
waste, or which would impede establishment or
use of facilities for regional management of
solid waste."
We find no Kansas cases, nor do we find an administrative
ruling or opinion by the Department of Health and Environ-
ment, which interpret the phrase, "no local agency shall en-
force a requirement . . . which would impede interstate or
intrastate transportation, or disposal of solid waste, or
which would impede establishment or use of facilities for
regional management of solid waste." Inasmuch as this regu-
lation is legislative in nature, rules of interpretation
applicable to statutes are to be utilized to interpret its
meaning. Sutherland, Statutory Construction, 3rd Ed., §31.06.
The Kansas Supreme Court, in Hunter v. Haun, 210 Kan. 11
(1972), has set forth rules of statutory construction thus:
"A primary rule for the construction of a sta-
tute is to find the legislative intent from
its language, and where the language used is
plain and unambiguous and also appropriate to
the obvious purpose, the court should follow
the intent as expressed by the words used and
is not warranted in looking beyond them in
search of some other legislative purpose or
extending the meaning beyond the plain terms
of the act." Id. at Syl.
Looking at the plain language of the regulation, we find
that no local agency may enforce a requirement which would
"impede" interstate or intrastate transportation or disposal
of solid waste. "Impede" has been defined as meaning, "To
retard in movement or progress by means of obstacles or hind-
rances" or "obstruct" or "hinder." The New Century Diction-
ary, p. 798 (1953). "Enforce" has been defined in part as
meaning, "put or keep (laws or rules) in force; compel obe-
dience to." Id. at 499. Thus, the regulation may be inter-
preted as saying, "no local agency" -- which in this case
would be the county -- "may put or keep a rule or regulation
in force which would obstruct or hinder either interstate or
intrastate disposal of solid waste."
In our judgment, a condition imposed by the county commission
to prevent persons from outside the county from disposing of
solid waste in the county landfill, whether those persons
are from within or without the state, would constitute a re-
quirement which would impede interstate or intrastate trans-
portation or disposal of solid waste, and would thus be vio-
lative of the clear intent of K.A.R. 1981 Supp. 28-29-1.
Therefore, it is our opinion the county commission may not
impose such a condition upon the operation of the landfill.
In conclusion, a county may not limit the use of a county
sanitary landfill to local county refuse sources by virtue
of the prohibition in K.A.R. 1981 Supp. 28-29-1 against local
agencies enforcing a requirement which would impede inter-
state or intrastate transportation or disposal of solid waste.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF KANSAS
Brenda L. Hoyt
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:BJS:BLH:hle

Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude

Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.