Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1981-047

1981-047Kanag

Texte intégral

February 17, 1981
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 81- 47
The Honorable William W. Bunten
State Representative, 54th District
State Capitol, Room 501-S
Topeka, Kansas 66612
Re: Finance and Taxation--Internal Improvements--State
Supervision of Improvements
Synopsis: Article 11, Section 9 of the Kansas Constitution permits
the state to become a party to works of internal improvement
under the conditions specified therein. However, the
state may expend state moneys in its role as coordinator,
supervisor and regulator of internal improvement projects
without becoming a "party" to such project in contravention
of this section. Cited herein: Kan. Const. Art. 11, Sec. 9.
Dear Representative Bunten:
You inquire regarding the expenditure of federal funds and moneys of
local units of government for the revitalization of various Kansas
railroads. Specifically, you desire to know if use of federal or state
dollars by the Kansas Department of Transportation to "write contract
specifications, make inspections, and audit," would make the State of
Kansas an unlawful party to a work of internal improvement.
Your concern arises as a result of Article 11, Section 9 of the Consti-
tution of Kansas which states:
"The state shall never be a party in carrying on
any work of internal improvement except that: (1)
It may adopt, construct, reconstruct and maintain
a state system of highways, but no general property tax
shall ever be laid nor general obligation bonds issued
by the state for such highways; (2) it may be a party to
flood control works and works for the conservation
or development of water resources; (3) it may, whenever
any work of internal improvement not authorized by (1)
or (2) is once authorized by a separate bill passed by
the affirmative vote of not less than two-thirds of all
members then elected (or appointed) and qualified to
each house, expend or distribute funds received from the
federal government therefor and may participate with the
federal government therein by contributing any state funds
appropriated in accordance with law for such purpose in
any amount not exceeding the amount received from the
federal government for such improvement, but no general
property tax shall ever be laid nor general obligation
bonds be issued by the state therefor; and (4) it may
expend funds received from the federal government for
any public purpose in accordance with the federal law
authorizing the same."
As you know Article 11, Section 9 was offered to the voters, amending the
prior provision, pursuant to L. 1980, ch. 350 (see 1980 Senate Concurrent
Resolution No. 1669), and was approved November 4, 1980. As this
provision now reads, the State of Kansas may participate as a "party"
in some projects which are deemed to be works of internal improvement..
Where federal and state funds are used, a separate bill supported by a
two-thirds vote is required. Where federal funds only are to be expended,
no such extraordinary vote is required.
You wish to know if the state involvement described above would necessitate
the two-thirds vote requirements of numbered clause (3) of Article 11,
Section 9. For the reasons stated below, we would conclude that the
two-thirds vote is not required.
First, to the extent only federal funds are used to fund the state
activities, numbered clause (4) of the section is applicable, hence no
two-thirds vote is mandated.
Second, if state moneys are to be utilized with or without reimburse-
ment, numbered clause (3) would normally be applicable in the case of
a work of internal improvement involving railroads. However, the role of
the State Department of Transportation, as you describe it, is
not sufficient, in our judgment, to make the State a "party" to the
work of internal improvement. As we understand it, the proposed federal
and local dollars would pay for the actual construction or repair of
the railroad property. No state dollars would be utilized. State
moneys would be used to pay contract administration costs, inspections
and auditing of the overall projects. In short, the state's role would
be that of supervisor, coordinator and _regulator. If this is the context
in which the state funds are to be expended the state is not a "party" to
the work of internal improvement; hence, the exceptions to Article 11,
Section 9 and their limitations are inapplicable.
Just over sixty years ago the Kansas Supreme Court interpreted the
language of Article 11, Section 9 (then Article 11, Section 8) in an
almost identical context. State ex rel. Hopkins v. Raub, 106 Kan.
196 (1920). The high court found the state not to be a "party to a work
of internal improvement" in the supervision, coordination and regulation
of the construction of local roads, where the roads were paid for by
local, not state, sources.
There, the court reasoned extensively as follows:
"Nor is there any valid basis for the contention that the
statute infringes the constitutional limitation that 'the
state shall never be a party in carrying on any works of
internal improvements.' (Art. 11, §8, Gen. Stat. 1915,
§235.) The construction of highways is of course a work
of internal improvement within the meaning of the consti-
tution, and one in which the state as a state may not engage.
(The State, ex rel., v. Knapp, 99 Kan. 852, 163 Pac. 181.)
However, this limitation does not apply to counties, town-
ships, and cities of the state, and the validity of the acts
of these municipalities in building roads, streets and bridges
is not and cannot be seriously questioned. It is urged that
the fact of the legislature having provided for a state highway
commission, which exercises supervisory power over the building
of roads, and having appropriated considerable sums of money
to pay salaries and the expenses of the department, makes the
state a party to the improvement. The commission is authorized
to administer the road laws and is given regulatory powers in
the construction of roads and bridges throughout the state. The
highway commissioners are state functionaries and their
authority is state-wide, but the fact that they exercise
a regulatory authority over the planning and building of highways,
and over the expenditures made by municipalities for these
purposes, gives no ground for the claim that the state as a
state is engaged in carrying on a work of internal improvement.
The public utilities commission is given supervisory power
over the building, maintenance and operation of railroads and
other public utilities, and the expenses of that commission
are paid by the state, but it would hardly be contended that the
state was engaged in railroading. The state also has a state
oil department, which inspects and to some extent controls
the oil business, and considerable money is appropriated to pay
for the inspection and supervision of that department, but it
never has been suggested that the state is in the oil business.
So of other public boards and officers who are given supervisory
authority over enterprises and works having a public interest,
carried on by others. The fact that state funds are expended
for inspection and regulation does not make the state a party
to the business or the work carried on. In the building of
roads and bridges the state neither buys nor furnishes any
material, and does not directly invest any money in the work.
The state highway commission is performing a very important
work in an educational and regulatory way and in coordinating
the efforts of the communities and municipalities of the state
to build and maintain trunk and lateral highways throughout
the state, but important as the work is, it does not furnish
a basis for the complaint that the state itself is engaged in
carrying on a work of internal improvement." Id. at 201, 202.
We believe this case to be dispositive of your inquiry, but we must
caution that should the expenditure of state funds go beyond the purposes
described in your letter and discussed in the Raub case, supra, the
mandates of Article 11, Section 9(3) would become applicable.
In sum, Article 11, Section 9 of the Kansas Constitution permits the state
to become a party to works of internal improvement under the conditions
specified therein. However, the State may expend state moneys in its
role as coordinator, supervisor and regulator of internal improvement
projects without becoming a "party" to such project in contravention
of this section.
Sincerely,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
Attorney General of Kansas
Bradley	Deputy . Smoot
Attorney General`
RTS:BJS:phf

Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude

Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.