Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1981-033

1981-033Kanag

Texte intégral

February 6, 1981
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 81-33
The Honorable Paul Hess
State Senator, 30th District
State Capitol, Room 123-S
Topeka, Kansas 66612
Re: Cities and Municipalities--City and County Service
Programs for the Elderly--Procedure for Submitting
Tax Levy Proposition to Voters
Synopsis: The provisions of K.S.A. 1980 Supp. 19-117 are uniformly
applicable to all counties in restricting the exercise of
home rule powers regarding the enactment of tax and other
revenue measures. Pursuant thereto, if there is no statutory
procedure for levying any such tax or revenue measure, the
provisions of K.S.A. 1980 Supp. 19-117 must be followed.
However, if such a procedure has been prescribed by legislative
enactment, a board of county commissioners must follow such
statutorily-prescribed procedure.
Thus, county home rule powers do not permit a board of
county commissioners on its own initiative to submit to
the county's electors the question of levying a tax to
fund a service program for the elderly, because the procedure
prescribed by K.S.A. 1980 Supp. 12-1680 for making such levy
does not contemplate such action. To the extent of its
conflicting conclusions, Attorney General Opinion No. 75-415
is to be disregarded. Cited herein: K.S.A. 1980 Supp.
12-1680, 19-101a, 19-117.
Dear Senator Hess:
You have inquired whether "it is possible for a board of county
commissioners to pass a resolution authorizing a levy of 1.00 mill
for the aged for referendum without a petition of 5% of the qualified
electors of that county."
Your inquiry has obvious reference to K.S.A. 1980 Supp. 12-1680, which
provides in pertinent part:
"Whenever a petition containing the signatures
of not less that five percent (5%) of the registered
voters of any city or county is filed with the appro-
priate election officer requesting an election on the
question of whether a tax levy of not more than one mill
shall be made on all of the taxable tangible property
in the city or county for the purpose of creating or
continuing a service program for the elderly operated
by municipalities as defined in K.S.A. 10-101 or non-
profit organizations, such proposition shall be submitted
to the voters of the city or county at a question submitted
election held in accordance with the provisions of K.S.A.
1979 Supp. 10-120. . . . If a majority of the qualified
electors voting on the proposition vote 'yes' such tax
levy shall be made annually on all of the taxable tangible
property within the city or county for such purpose . . . .
In any year after the year in which a tax is first levied
under the provisions of this act, the board of county commissioners
of the county or the governing body of the city may resubmit
the proposition to make a levy in such amount as may be
determined necessary to fund such program or may on their own
motion by resolution or ordinance fix the amount of such levy
in any amount, not exceeding the amount stated in the original
proposition submitted to and approved by the electors of the
county or city, which such board of commissioners or governing
body deems necessary to finance the service program in such
year."
It is clear from the foregoing that, "[i]n any year after the year
in which a tax is first levied" pursuant to 12-1680, a board of county
commissioners has the authority to "resubmit" the proposition of
making such levy without the necessity of a petition therefor being
filed. However, with respect to submission of the question of making
the initial tax levy under this section, provision is made for having
an election on this proposition only after the filing of a petition
signed by not less than five percent of the county's registered voters.
No provision is made in this statute for the board of county commissioner.
calling an election on the original question on its own motion. Thus,
we understand your inquiry to be whether the statute's silence in this
regard precludes such action. In our judgment, it does.
In reaching this conclusion we have reviewed Attorney General Opinion
No. 75-415 in which former Attorney General Curt Schneider reached the
opposite conclusion, which is expressed in the opinion's synopsis, as
follows:
"A city or county may, in the exercise of its constitutional
or statutory powers of self-government, respectively, submit
the question of a levy for services to the elderly to the
voters on the initiative of the governing body, without the
filing of a petition therefor. . . ."
Attorney General Schneider's opinion was predicated on the fact that
"[n]othing in the statute prohibits the city or county governing body
from providing by ordinary ordinance or resolution for the submission
of the question of such a levy to the voters on the initiative of the
governing body itself, and omitting the requirement of the filing of
a petition as a prerequisite therefor." Id. at p. 2. Thus, citing
Attorney General Opinion No. 74-303 as authority, he concluded "that it
was within the lawful exercise of county home rule powers, K.S.A. 19-101a
to provide for the levy of a tax for which there was no express authority
provided." Att'y Gen. Op. No. 75-415 at p. 2.
The county home rule powers relied upon in that prior opinion are
those prescribed in K.S.A. 1980 Supp. 19-101a. Pursuant to that
statute, "[c]ounties are . . . empowered to transact all county business
and perform such powers of local legislation and administration as they
deem appropriate," subject only to the thirteen enumerated restrictions
contained therein. The first such restriction is that "counties shall
be subject to all acts of the legislature which apply uniformly to all
counties." At the time Opinion No. 75-415 was written, there were no
uniformly applicable statutory provisions relating to the adoption of
tax or other revenue measures by counties. Thus, it was concluded
in that prior opinion that, since 12-1680 was silent as to the
authority of a board of county commissioners to adopt a resolution
providing for a tax levy to fund a service program for the elderly,
subject to a referendum of the county's electors, a county commission
could exercise its home rule powers in this manner so as "to provide a
supplemental procedure for submission of the question of the levy."
Att'y Gen. Op. No. 75-415 at p. 2.
However, in 1977 the legislature enacted what is now K.S.A. 1980
Supp. 19-117. (See L. 1977, ch. 56, §5.) This statute prescribes
a procedure for the adoption of county tax or other revenue measures that
is uniformly applicable to all counties. It not only provides for the
submission of such measures to the county's electors upon presentation
of proper petitions, but it also authorizes the adoption of such
measures by the board of county commissioners on its own initiative.
The procedure prescribed for the exercise of such authority is substan-
tially the same as that required for the adoption of a charter resolu-
tion, and it requires that such procedure be utilized
"[w]heretheboardofcountycommissionersof
any county by resolution proposes to levy for
revenue purposes any tax, excise, fee, charge
or other exaction other than permit fees or
license fees for regulatory purposes, a procedure
for the levy of which is not otherwise prescribed
by enactment of the legislature . . . ." (Emphasis
added.)
Clearly, therefore, the manifest purpose of the legislature in enacting
this statute is to restrict the exercise of a county's home rule powers
with respect to tax or other revenue measures. Thus, if there is no
statutory procedure prescribed for levying any such tax or revenue
measure, the provisions of K.S.A. 1980 Supp. 19-117 must be utilized.
However, if such a procedure has been prescribed by enactment of the
legislature, the emphasized portion of the foregoing quoted language
evidences a clear legislative intent that the county must follow such
statutorily-prescribed procedure.
As a result, since K.S.A. 1980 Supp. 12-1680 prescribes a procedure for
levying a tax to fund a service program for the elderly, such tax
levy can be made only in accordance with the procedure prescribed
by that statute. Such procedure contemplates that the question of
making the initial levy may be submitted to the county's electors only
pursuanttopetitionsfiledbytherequisitenumberofqualified
electors. Therefore, a board of county commissioners may not submit
such question to the voters on its own initiative.
At the time Attorney General Opinion No. 75-415 was issued, the
legislature had not prescribed any specific limitations on a county's
home rule powers regarding tax and revenue measures that did not
conflict with statutory provisions. Thus, that prior opinion's
determination that a county commission could supplement the tax levy
procedure set forth in 12-1680 was in harmony with the then existing
statutory provisions. However, because of the restrictions on a
county's home rule powers concerning tax and revenue measures effected
by the subsequent enactment of K.S.A. 1980 Supp. 19-117, that determina-
tion is no longer consonant with the statutory scope of county home
rule, and that portion of Opinion No. 75-415 in conflict herewith
should be disregarded.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
Attorney General of Kansas
W. Robert Alderson
First Deputy Attorney General
RTS:WRA:phf

Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude

Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.