Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1981-014

1981-014Kanag

Texte intégral

January 16, 1981
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 81- 14
Mr. Steven Opat
Geary County Attorney
County Courthouse
Junction City, Kansas 66441
Col. Paul J. Rice
J.A.G.C.
Staff Judge Advocate
Fort Riley
Riley, Kansas 66531
Re: Infants - Juvenile Code - Jurisdiction of Court Over
Matters On Federal Enclave
Synopsis: Where there is no federal legislation preempting a state's
interest in exercising jurisdiction over juveniles residing
within federal enclaves, the jurisdiction of a state district
court does extend to hear and adjudicate proceedings pursuant
to the juvenile code, with respect to neglected, wayward
or abused children, concerning incidents occurring on the
Fort Riley Military Reservation. Cited herein: K.S.A.
27-101, 27-102, 27-105, K.S.A. 1980 Supp. 38-806, U.S.
Const. Art. I, §8, ci. 17.
Dear Mr. Opat and Colonel Rice:
You request our opinion whether the jurisdiction of the District
Court of Geary County, Kansas, in juvenile matters "extends to hear
and adjudicate issues of neglected, wayward, and abused children, when
said issues arise from incidents which occur on the Fort Riley Military
Installation."
We note pertinent constitutional and statutory provisions by way of
general background.
Article I, Section 8, Clause 17 of the United States Constitution provides
that Congress is empowered
"[t]o exercise exclusive legislation in all cases whatsoever
over such district (not exceeding ten miles square) as may,
by cession of particular States and the acceptance of Congress,
become the seat of the Government of the United States,
and to exercise like authority over all places purchased
by the consent of the legislature of the State in which the
same shall be, for the erection of forts, magazines, arsenals,
dockyards, and other needed buildings."
The area comprising Fort Riley in Geary County was made a federal enclave
by the Secretary of War on March 30, 1853, under the provisions of
General Orders #9 issued from the Headquarters of the Sixth Military
Department, Jefferson Barracks, Missouri, over which the United States
has exclusive jurisdiction within the meaning of the foregoing
constitutional provision. Consent by the State of Kansas to the
federal government's acquisition thereof is provided by K.S.A. 27-101,
and said jurisdiction was ceded to the United States by the State
pursuant to Section 1 of Chapter 150 of the 1899 Session Laws of Kansas.
(See K.S.A. 27-105.) Also of importance is K.S.A. 27-102, which
provides:
"That exclusive jurisdiction over and within any lands
so acquired by the United States shall be, and the same
is hereby, ceded to the United States, for all purposes;
saving, however, to the state of Kansas the right to
serve therein any civil or criminal process issued
under the authority of the state, in any action on
account of rights acquired, obligations incurred or
crimes committed in said state, but outside the boundaries
of such land; and saving further to said state the right
to tax the property and franchises of any railroad,
bridge or other corporations within the boundaries of
such lands; but the jurisdiction hereby ceded shall
not continue after the United States shall cease to own
said lands."
The question arises, therefore, whether the State's consent to the
federal government's acquisition of land comprising Fort Riley, and
the cession of exclusive jurisdiction over said land to the federal
government, precludes the exercise of the State's authority over
juveniles residing on the Fort Riley Military Reservation.
Generally, the federal government will exercise exclusive jurisdiction
over persons residing within a federal enclave. However, the field
of domestic relations, including the adjudication of custody of an
abused and neglected child, is reserved to the several states. "It is
understood that the whole subject of the domestic relations of husband
and wife, parent and child, belongs to the laws of the states, and not
to the laws of the United States." [Citations omitted.] State of Ohio v.
Agler, 280 U.S. 379, 74 L.Ed. 489, 497, 498, 50 S.Ct. 154 (1929). This
does not conflict with the exclusiveness of federal jurisdiction over
Fort Riley or any other federal enclave, since the state may exercise
its power over federal areas within its boundaries so long as there is
no interference with said jurisdiction asserted by the United States.
Howard v. Commissioners of the Sinking Fund of the City of Louisville,
344 U.S. 624, 97 L.Ed. 617, 73 S.Ct. 465 (1953). In Howard, the Court
states:
"The fiction of a state within a state can have no validity
to prevent the state from exercising its power over the
federal area within its boundaries. . . . The sovereign
rights in this dual relationship are not antagonistic.
Accomodation and cooperation are their aim." 344 U.S. at 627.
At the present time, there is no legislation preempting a state's interest
in neglected juveniles or status offenders residing within federal
enclaves, and the jurisdiction of military tribunals does not extend to
non-military persons, including military dependents who reside within
federal enclaves. Reid v. Covert, 354 U.S. 1, 21, 1 L.Ed.2d 1148, 77
S.Ct. 1222 (1957). Even in the case of a juvenile violation of federal
law, through the guidelines stated in 18 U.S.C. §5032, Congress has expressed
an intent to subject juveniles to the jurisdiction of state courts if
that state has proper jurisdiction over the juvenile, will accept
jurisdiction, and has available programs and services adequate for the
needs of said juvenile.
A similar issue was presented in State in Interest of D.B.S., 349
A.2d 105 (1975). Here, the question presented was whether a state
court had jurisdiction over a juvenile delinquent who committed
an act of delinquency within a federal enclave. The New Jersey court
held:
"Here, the juvenile was housed on a federal enclave but
received his education in the public school system of New
Jersey and benefited from the extracurricular activities
provided by the school and the surrounding community.
As stated in State v. Toddles, 38 N.J. 565, 571, 186 A.2d
284 (1962), the legislative approach to juvenile delinquency
is protective and rehabilitative, and not punitive. The
statutory scheme is designed to permit the exercise of the
powers of the State as parens patriae, for the purpose of
rehabilitating youthful offenders and not of punishing
them for the commission of a crime.
"Accordingly, not only would it be inconsistent to hold
that a juvenile who benefits from the State's educational
system and community life cannot also benefit from its
juvenile laws, but it is our view that the State has an
obligation to protect and rehabilitate a juvenile such as
D.B.S. who, although housed on land ceded to the Federal
Government, is a member of the social community of New
Jersey. Cf. Burlington Cty. Freeholders v. McCorkle,
98 N.J. Super. 451, 237 A.2d 640 (Law Div. 1968.) So
long as there is no interference with the jurisdiction
asserted by the Federal Government, the State's jurisdiction
continues. In re Salem Transportation Co.of New Jersey,
55 N.J. 559, 563, 264 A.2d 47 (1970)." Id. at 107, 108.
Clearly, application of state jurisdiction would be a benefit to juveniles
and would be in accord with the policy of the United States, and it is our
understanding the personnel of Fort Riley do not oppose the jurisdiction
of the Geary County courts. Army Regulation 608-1, Chapter 7, issued by
order of the Secretary of the Army on October 1, 1978, which describes
the Army Child Advocacy Program (ACAP), announces that "[m]ost foster
care placements will be done by direction of appropriate civilian
authorities." (Id. at §III, p. 7-7).
We also find persuasive the case of In re Terry v. Benny, 80 Daily Journal
D.A.R. 264 (Cal. C.A., 1980)., in which the court concluded that
application of state jurisdiction over a juvenile residing on a federal
enclave did not conflict with federal sovereignty. There, reference
was made to the Social Security Act to support the court's decision:
"[I]n Title IV-B of the Social Security Act (42 U.S.C. §§620-626),
Congress has authorized grants to the states for establishing,
extending and strengthening 'child welfare services' (§§620,
621). 'Child welfare services' include, inter alia, public
social services which supplement or substitute for parental
care and supervision for the purpose of preventing or
remedying the neglect or abuse of children and protecting
and caring for dependent or neglected children (§625). In
order to qualify for funds under Title IV-B, a state must
make a satisfactory showing that it is making available its
child welfare services 'in all political subdivisions of
the State, for all children in need thereof' (42 U.S.C.
5622(a)(2)). As federal enclaves such as Fort Ord remain
geographically and legally a part of the state in which
they are located ( Howard v. Commissioners of Sinking Fund
of Louisville, supra, 344 U.S. 624), it follows that Congress
contemplated that the state would make its services available
to the children on federal enclaves."
Jurisdiction of the district courts over juvenile proceedings is
stated in K.S.A. 1980 Supp. 38-806, which provides in pertinent part:
"(a) Except as provided in K.S.A. 1978 Supp. 21-3611, and
subsection (b) of 38-808, proceedings concerning any child,
living or found within the county, who appears to be a
delinquent, miscreant, wayward or deprived child or a
traffic offender or truant, as defined in K.S.A. 1978 Supp.
38-802, shall be governed by the provisions of the Kansas
juvenile code."
The above stated provision does not interfere with federal jurisdiction,
absent a Congressional enactment amounting to preemption of the questioned
area. In addition, Geary County's exercise of its statutory jurisdiction
promotes the federal policy regarding abused children, as reflected in
the applicable Army Regulations and the Social Security Act. Accordingly,
it is our opinion the jurisdiction of the Geary County District Court
does extend to hear and adjudicate proceedings pursuant to the juvenile
code, with respect to neglected, wayward, or abused children, concerning
incidents occurring on the Fort Riley Military Reservation.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT	T	.STEPHAN
Attorney General of Kansas
Elsbeth D. Schafer
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:TDH:EDS:may

Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude

Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.