Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1981-003

1981-003Kanag

Texte intégral

January 5, 1981
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 81- 3
John D. Randolph, Executive Director
Mental Health Center of East Central Kansas
705 South Commercial Street
Emporia, Kansas 66801
Re: Infants--Crimes Affecting Children--Reporting of Neglect
or Abuse
Synopsis: K.S.A. 1979 Supp. 38-717 imposes a duty on specified classes
of persons involved in medical or health-related professions
to report suspected cases of physical or mental abuse or
neglect which involve children under the age of 18 whom
they have examined, attended or treated. The statutory duty
would not be imposed in the case where information regarding
the suspected abuse was obtained from an indirect source
(i.e. a parent or other individual), although the statute
does make reporting in such situations discretionary. However,
a failure to act, even in situations made discretionary by
statute, could create the potential for liability in tort
should further injury result. Cited herein: K.S.A. 1979 Supp.
38-716, 38-717.
*
Dear Mr. Randolph:
As Executive Director of the Mental Health Center of East Central
Kansas, you request our opinion as to whether members of your staff
are subject to the provisions of K.S.A. 1979 Supp. 38-717, which
require the reporting of suspected cases of child abuse by specified
groups of individuals. Included among these are all persons licensed
to practice the healing arts and all certified psychologists, which
classes include some of your personnel. You inquire whether the
terms of the statute apply to these personnel when the information they
obtain comes not from the child, but from counseling sessions involving
a parent or other person.
The statute which must be construed with regard to your inquiry is
K.S.A. 1979 Supp. 38-717, which in part states:
"Every person licensed to practice the healing arts or
dentistry, persons licensed to practice optometry, persons
engaged in postgraduate training programs approved by the
state board of healing arts, certified psychologists,
Christian Science practitioners, licensed social workers,
every licensed professional nurse or licensed practical
nurse, examining, attending or treating a child under the
age eighteen (18), every teacher, school administrator or
other employee of a school which such child is attending,
the chief administrative officer of a medical care facility,
every person licensed by the secretary of health and environ-
ment to provide child care services or employee of the
person so licensed at the place where the child care services
are being provided to the child, or any law enforcement
officer having reason to suspect that a child has had
injury or injuries inflicted upon him or her as a result
of physical or mental abuse or neglect, shall report, and
all other persons who have reason to suspect that a child
has had injury or injuries inflicted upon him or her as a
result of physical or mental abuse or neglect may report,
the matter promptly to the district court of the county in
which such examination or attendance is made, treatment is
given, school is located or such abuse or neglect is
extant or to the department of social and rehabilitation
services." (Emphasis added.)
Originally adopted in 1965, the statute has been subsequently amended
so as now to be prolix in the extreme. For example, it may be noted
that the above quote consists of but a single sentence. As a result,
it is necessary to break the statute down into its component parts
in order to determine who is subject to its requirements. Once this
is done, it is our opinion that the personnel in the situations you
posit would not be required to report their suspicions to the district
court or to SRS, although, as will also be noted, they might be wise
to at least take some action.
As it now reads, the statute specifies 16 different groups or professions
whose practioners must comply with the reporting procedures if they
have "reason to suspect that a child has had injury or injuries
inflicted upon him or her as a result of physical or mental abuse or
neglect." Even the making of this preliminary conclusion, however,
must ignore a strict reading of the statute, for the quoted material
immediately above appears, on the face of the statute, to apply only
to law enforcement officers. However, as this would make the prior
portion of the statute unintelligible, such a construction should
be avoided. See, e.g., Whitehead v. State of Kansas Labor Dept.,
203 Kan. 159 (1969), Williams v. Bd. of Education of City of Wichita,
198 Kan. 115 (1967).
Of the groups named, nine are listed in the statute in such- a way
that the mandatory reporting requirements are applicable to them
only when they are "examining, attending or treating a child under
the age eighteen (18)." Included among these are those persons
licensed to practice "the healing arts," as well as "certified
psychologists." Accordingly, it would appear that if members of
these professions obtain their information from sources other than a
direct contact with the child, e.g., counseling with a parent, they
would not be included under this portion of the statute, and we
would so conclude.
However, a further problem arises due to the inclusion of the
phrase "chief administrative officer of a medical care facility" with
those professions which are listed after the "examine, attend or treat"
language quoted above. Although an administrator of such a facility
like yourself would presumably not perform such functions, it appears
that persons in your position, along with teaches, law enforcement
officers, persons licensed by the Department of Health and Environment,
etc., are not required to have the kind of direct contact which
is required of the professions listed initially in the statute. This
gives the somewhat incongruous result that while your staff would not
be subject to the statute (no direct contact), as chief administrator,
you would be required to do so if your staff reported to you, as you
would now have "reason to suspect" that abuse was occurring, even though
your information, like theirs, was indirect. While such contradictory
results are to be avoided, in our opinion the statute is so worded
as to require this result.
While it is our opinion that under K.S.A. 1979 Supp. 38-717 your
counseling staff would not be required to report suspected cases of
abuse, we feel constrained to advise you that case law does exist
which may impose a duty to disclose apart from any statutory require-
ment. While the leading cases in this area are from states other
than Kansas, the concept is a developing one of which you should
be aware, in that a failure to disclose may leave the counselor liable
in tort for injuries which may subsequently occur. A concise state-
ment of this common law duty appears at Tarasoff v. Regents of Univ.
of California, 17 Ca1.3d 425, 131 Cal.Rptr. 14, 551 P.2d 334 (1978),
where it is stated:
"When a therapist determines, or pursuant to the
standards of his profession should determine, that
his patient presents a serious danger of violence
to another, he incurs an obligation to use reasonable
care to protect the intended victim against such danger.
The discharge of this duty may require the therapist
to take one or more of various steps, depending upon
the nature of the case. Thus it may call for him to
warn the intended victim or others likely to apprise
the victim of the danger, to notify the police, or to -:'
take whatever other steps are reasonably necessary under
the circumstances." 131 Cal.Rptr. at 20.
Additionally, the existence of the doctor-patient privilege does not
obviate the duty to warn of impending danger. Tarasoff, 131 Cal.Rptr.
at 27, McIntosh v. Milano, 131 N.J. Super. 466, 403 A.2d 500 (1979).
Finally, while your counselors would not necessarily have to contact
the district court or SRS (the entities prescribed by K.S.A. 1979
Supp. 38-717) where their information of abuse was acquired indirectly,
they would be responsible to take "steps reasonably necessary under
the circumstances."
In conclusion, K.S.A. 1979 Supp. 38-717 imposes a duty on specified
classes of persons involved in medical or health related professions
to report suspected cases of physical or mental abuse or neglect
which involve children under the age of 18 whom they have examined,
attended or treated. The statutory duty would not imposed in
the case where information regarding the suspected abuse was obtained
from an indirect source (i.e. a parent or other individual), although
the statute does make reporting in such situations discretionary.
However, a failure to act, even in situations made discretionary by
statute, Could create the potential for liability in tort should further
injury result.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
Attorney General of Kansas
Jeffrey S. Southard
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:BJS:JSS:phf

Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude

Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.