2:11-bk-20046•Ted Jorgensen and Cynthia Jorgensen
Texte intégral
In re
IN THE UNITED STATES BANKRUPTCY COURT
FOR THE DISTRICT OF WYOMING
TED JORGENSEN and
CYNTHIA JORGENSEN,
Debtors.
)
)
)
)
)
)
Case No. 11-20046
CHAPTER 7
MEMORANDUM OPINION ON
DEBTORS' MOTION FOR VIOLATION OF STAY
On September 20, 2011, this matter came before the court for an evidentiary
hearing on the Motion for Violation of Stay, filed by Ted Jorgensen and Cynthia
Jorgensen, ("Debtors") and the Bank of Jackson Hole's ("Bank") Opposition. The
Debtors were represented by Justin Rammel. Isaac Sutphin represented the Bank. The
court having reviewed the record, testimony, evidence and applicable law and based
upon the following, denies the motion.
Prior to filing their bankruptcy petition, Debtors operated Grant Interiors of Star
Valley, LLC ("Grant Interiors"). Grant Interiors executed a promissory note with the
Bank on February 2, 2010, borrowing $99,639.44. Debtors, as "Members of Grant
Interiors ... ," executed the note. The Debtors also executed a Commercial Security
Agreement to secure the payment of the note. The collateral was described as "Accounts
and Other Rights to Payment," "Inventory," "Equipment," and, "General Intangibles."
The Debtors filed for individual chapter 7 bankruptcy protection on January 19, 20 11
Case 11-20046 Doc 60 Filed 11/30/11 Entered 11/30/11 10:20:04 Desc Main
Document Page 1 of 10listing the Bank as an unsecured creditor on Schedule F with a claim in the amount of $818.00. On April21, 2011, the Bank sent a "Notice ofDefault and Demand for Immediate Payment" by certified mail, to: Grand Interiors of Star Valley, LLC Ted R. Jorgensen, Manager/Member Cynthia Jorgensen, Manager/Member P.O. Box 770 Thayne, WY 83127-0771 The letter asserted that Grand Interiors was in default under the terms of the promissory note; demanded immediate payment of all sums due and owing ... that failure to have the amount in the hands of the Bank by the close ofbusiness on May 9, 2011 would result in the taking legal action to protect its interests. Subsequently, a summons was issued from the State of Wyoming Third Judicial District on June 23, 2011 and served, with a complaint, upon: Grand Interiors of Star Valley, LLC c/o Registered Agent Ted R. Jorgensen 199 Alta Way Thayne, WY 83127 Discussion The Debtors argue that the Bank violated the automatic stay upon filing a case in the Third Judicial District for Lincoln County, State of Wyoming on June 23, 2011; and, by contacting the Debtors and Debtors' attorney requesting the ability to inspect or recover the collateral for its loan. The Debtors assert that the collateral is property of the bankruptcy estate and the Bank's action violated the automatic stay of their bankruptcy case. The court's review of the docket shows that the Bank was later allowed to inspect Page2 Case 11-20046 Doc 60 Filed 11/30/11 Entered 11/30/11 10:20:04 Desc Main Document Page 2 of 10
the collateral. The review also shows that the Bank requested and was granted relief from the automatic stay to recover and foreclose on the collateral "against the borrower, Grand Interiors of Star Valley, LLC." The Debtors did not object and the Order Granting Bank of Jackson Hole's Motion for Relief from Stay was entered on October. 18, 2011. Under 11 U.S.C. § 362(a)(3), 1 a bankruptcy petition triggers a stay against any act aimed at obtaining possession of property belonging to the debtor's estate. Section 362(k)(1) provides, in part, that an individual injured by any willful violation of the automatic stay shall recover actual damages, including costs and attorneys' fees. The issue before this court is whether the Bank was attempting to foreclose on property of the bankruptcy estate. Defining property of a bankruptcy estate under §541(a) is a question of federal law, but the nature and extent of the bankruptcy debtor's interest in the property is determined by applicable state law. Section §541(a)(l) focuses on the rights ofthe debtor in property as of the date the bankruptcy petition was filed. 2 The Wyoming Statues, regarding the dissolution and winding up a limited liability company, provide, as relevant: Wyo. Stat. § 17-29-701. Events causing dissolution. (a) A limited liability company is dissolved, and its activities must 1 Unless otherwise indicated, all future statutory references are to the Bankruptcy Code, Title II of the United States Code. 2 In re Aldape Telford Glazier, Inc., 410 B.R. 60 (Bankr. D. Idaho 2009). Page 3 Case 11-20046 Doc 60 Filed 11/30/11 Entered 11/30/11 10:20:04 Desc Main Document Page 3 of 10
Page4 be wound up, upon the occurrence of any of the following: (i) An event or circumstance that the operating agreement or articles of organization states causes dissolution; (ii) The consent of all the members; (iii) The passage of ninety (90) consecutive days during which the company has no members; (iv) On application by a member, the entry of a court order dissolving the company on the grounds that: (A) The conduct of all or substantially all of the company's activities is unlawful; or (B) It is not reasonably practicable to carry on the company's activities in conformity with the articles of organization and the operating agreement; or (v) On application by a member or dissociated member, the entry of a court order dissolving the company on the grounds that the managers or those members in control of the company: (A) Have acted, are acting, or will act in a manner that is illegal or fraudulent; or (B) Have acted or are acting in a manner that is oppressive and was, is, or will be directly harmful to the applicant. (b) In a proceeding brought under paragraph (a)(v) of this section, the court may order a remedy other than dissolution. Wyo. Stat. §17-29-702. Winding up. (a) A dissolved limited liability company shall wind up its activities and the company continues after dissolution only for the purpose of winding up. (b) In winding up its activities, a limited liability company: (i) Shall discharge the company's debts, obligations, or other liabilities, settle and close the company's activities and marshal and distribute the assets of the company; and (ii) May: (A) Deliver to the secretary of state for filing articles of dissolution stating the name of the company and that the company is dissolved; (B) Preserve the company activities and property as a going concern for a reasonable time; (C) Prosecute and defend actions and proceedings, Case 11-20046 Doc 60 Filed 11/30/11 Entered 11/30/11 10:20:04 Desc Main Document Page 4 of 10
Page 5 whether civil, criminal or administrative; (D) Transfer the company's property; (E) Settle disputes by mediation or arbitration; (G) Perform other acts necessary or appropriate to the winding up ... Wyo. Stat. § 17-29-703. Known claims against dissolved limited liability company. (a) Except as otherwise provided in subsection (d) of this section, a dissolved limited liability company may give notice of a known claim under subsection (b) of this section, which has the effect as provided in subsection (c) of this section. (b) A dissolved limited liability company may in a record notify its known claimants of the dissolution. The notice shall: (i) Specify the information required to be included in a claim; (ii) Provide a mailing address to which the claim is to be sent; (iii) State the deadline for receipt of the claim, which may not be less than one hundred twenty (120) days after the date the notice is received by the claimant; and (iv) State that the claim will be barred if not received by the deadline. (c) A claim against a dissolved limited liability company is barred if the requirements of subsection (b) of this section are met and: (i) The claim is not received by the specified deadline; or (ii) If the claim is timely received but rejected by the company: (A) The company causes the claimant to receive a notice in a record stating that the claim is rejected and will be barred unless the claimant commences an action against the company to enforce the claim within ninety (90) days after the claimant receives the notice; and (B) The claimant does not commence the required action within the ninety (90) days. (d) This section does not apply to a claim based on an event occurring after the effective date of dissolution or a liability that on that date is contingent. Wyo. Stat. § 17-29-704. Other claims against dissolved limited liability company. Case 11-20046 Doc 60 Filed 11/30/11 Entered 11/30/11 10:20:04 Desc Main Document Page 5 of 10
Page 6 (a) A dissolved limited liability company may publish notice of its dissolution and request persons having claims against the company to present them in accordance with the notice. (b) The notice authorized by subsection (a) of this section shall: (i) Be published at least once in a newspaper of general circulation in the county in this state in which the dissolved limited liability company's principal office is located or, if it has none in this state, in the county in which the company's designated office is or was last located; (ii) Describe the information required to be contained in a claim and provide a mailing address to which the claim is to be sent; and (iii) State that a claim against the company is barred unless an action to enforce the claim is commenced within three (3) years after publication of the notice. (c) If a dissolved limited liability company publishes a notice in accordance with subsection (b) of this section, unless the claimant commences an action to enforce the claim against the company within three (3) years after the publication date of the notice, the claim of each of the following claimants is barred: (i) A claimant that did not receive notice in a record under w.s. 17-29-703; (ii) A claimant whose claim was timely sent to the company but not acted on; and (iii) A claimant whose claim is contingent at, or based on an event occurring after, the effective date of dissolution. (d) A claim not barred under this section or W.S. 17-29-703(c) may be enforced: (i) Against a dissolved limited liability company, to the extent of its undistributed assets; and (ii) If assets of the company have been distributed after dissolution, against a member or transferee to the extent of that person's proportionate share of the claim or of the assets distributed to the member or transferee after dissolution, whichever is less, but a person's total liability for all claims under this paragraph does not exceed the total amount of assets distributed to the person after dissolution. Wyo. Stat. § 17-29-708. Distribution of assets in winding up limited liability company's activities. Case 11-20046 Doc 60 Filed 11/30/11 Entered 11/30/11 10:20:04 Desc Main Document Page 6 of 10
Page 7
(a) In winding up its activities, a limited liability company shall
apply its assets to discharge its obligations to creditors, including members
that are creditors.
(b) After a limited liability company complies with subsection (a) of
this section, any surplus shall be distributed in the following order, subject
to any charging order in effect under W.S. 17-29-503:
(i) To each person owning a transferable interest that reflects
contributions made by a member and not previously returned,
an amount equal to the value of the unreturned contributions;
and
(ii) In equal shares among members and dissociated
members, except:
(A) To the extent otherwise provided in a written or
verbal operating agreement as set forth in W.S. 17-29-
110;
(B) To the extent necessary to comply with any
transfer effective under W.S. 17-29-502; or
(C) To the extent otherwise represented by the
company through an authorized representative in tax
filings with the Internal Revenue Service in which the
status elected by the company is not timely disputed by
any member.
(c) If a limited liability company does not have sufficient surplus to
comply with paragraph (b )(i) of this section, any surplus shall be
distributed among the owners of transferable interests in proportion to the
value of their respective unreturned contributions.
(d) All distributions made under subsections (b) and (c) of this
section shall be paid in money.
Under the Wyoming Statues, the limited liability company ("LLC")
does not cease to exist upon dissolution. Rather, it continues to exist for
the purpose of winding up its affairs. 3 Wyo. Stat. § 17-29-702 indicates
which persons are authorized to wind up the business affairs of an LLC and
3 Wyo. Stat.§ 17-29-701 (2011).
Case 11-20046 Doc 60 Filed 11/30/11 Entered 11/30/11 10:20:04 Desc Main
Document Page 7 of 10Page 8 the particular acts such a person may take to complete the wind-up. The person authorized to wind up the LLC's affairs "shall4 discharge the company's debts, obligation or other liabilities ... settle and close the company's activities ... and marshal and distribute the assets of the company." 5 Additionally, the person "may preserve the company's activities and property as a going concern for a reasonable time; prosecute and defend actions; transfer the company's property; settle disputes by mediation or arbitration; and, perform other acts necessary or appropriate to the winding up." 6 The procedures which a LLC may follow to give notice to a known claim are set out in Wyo. Stat. § 17-29-703. Additional procedures for notice to unknown claims against a dissolved LLC are described in Wyo. Stat. § 17-29-704. The manner in which assets of the LLC shall be distributed upon winding up are set out in Wyo. Stat. § 17-29- 708. First, the LLC "shall apply its assets to discharge its obligations to creditors, including creditors that are members." 7 Secondly, any surplus shall be distributed, and paid in moneyS, to (1) each person owning an 4 Emphasis added. 5 Wyo. Stat. § 17-29-702(a)(20 11 ). 6 Wyo. Stat. § 17 -29-702(b)(20 11 ). 7 Wyo. Stat. § 17-29-708 (20 11 ). Emphasis added. 8 Wyo. Stat. § 17-29-708(d)(201 I). Case 11-20046 Doc 60 Filed 11/30/11 Entered 11/30/11 10:20:04 Desc Main Document Page 8 of 10
Page 9 interest reflecting a member's contributions and not previously returned; and (2) in equal shares among its members. 9 There was not any evidence presented that the winding up process for Grand Interiors was concluded according to the requirements of the Wyoming Statutes. In fact, there was testimony that the Bank had not been paid its claim based upon the promissory note executed by Grand Interiors. The Bank, based on the Wyoming Statutes, cannot have received any distribution of assets from Grand Interiors, as assets must first be distributed to creditors, and only then to the members. In this case the Debtors gained possession of Grand Interiors' assets, as they were the members, and should have been proceeding with the wind up of the dissolved LLC. However, their possession of the assets does not equate to ownership. The dissolution of Grand Interiors triggered the winding up process. The members of the dissolved LLC, Grand Interiors, did not automatically retain its assets as their own. The Debtors' holding and distribution of these assets is strictly controlled by the Wyoming Statutes. Grand Interiors was required to "apply its assets to discharge its obligations to creditors." Only after the creditors claims are discharged, and in the event that there is 9 Wyo. Stat. § 17-29-708 (a) and (b) (2011). Case 11-20046 Doc 60 Filed 11/30/11 Entered 11/30/11 10:20:04 Desc Main Document Page 9 of 10
Page 10
a surplus, are the Debtors provided for distribution of the assets in
accordance with Wyo. Stat. § 17-29-708, and then only in the form of
"money."
The court finds that the collateral that secured the promissory note
signed by the members of Grand Interiors, as an LLC, in favor of the
Bank, is not property of the estate. Therefore, the Bank did not violate the
automatic stay.
This opinion constitutes the Court's findings of fact and conclusions
oflaw. A separate order shall be entered pursuant to Fed. R. Bankr. P.
9021.
DATED this l "?{2 day ofNovember, 2011.
Service to:
Justin Rammel
Isaac Sutphin
By the Court
Case 11-20046 Doc 60 Filed 11/30/11 Entered 11/30/11 10:20:04 Desc Main
Document Page 10 of 10Vous vous demandez comment ce texte s’applique à votre situation ?
Consultation gratuite, sans engagement
Décrivez votre situation. Notre équipe vous recontactera par e-mail pour votre consultation.
Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude
Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.