Siefke v. Toyota Motor North America, Inc. et al

4:25-cv-00406Txed2 déc. 2025

Texte intégral

United States District Court
EASTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS
SHERMAN DIVISION
PHILIP SIEFKE, individually and on
behalf of all others similarly situated,
Plaintiff,
v.
TOYOTA MOTOR NORTH
AMERICA, INC., PROGRESSIVE
CASUALTY INSURANCE COMPANY,
and CONNECTED ANALYTIC
SERVICES,
Defendants.
§
§
§
§
§
§
§
§
§
§
§
§
§
§
Civil Action No. 4:25-cv-406
Judge Mazzant
OMNIBUS MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER
Pending before the Court are various motions regarding Defendants’ request that the Court
enter an Order to compel arbitration of Plaintiff’s claims and stay all proceedings pending
arbitration. Having considered the motions, all relevant pleadings, and the applicable law, the Court
finds as follows:
1. Defendant Toyota Motor North America, Inc.’s (“Toyota”) Motion to Compel
Arbitration and Stay Litigation and Memorandum of Law in Support (the “Motion
to Compel”) (Dkt. #31) should be GRANTED;
2. Defendant Connected Analytic Services’ (“CAS”) Joinder to Motion to Compel
Arbitration (Dkt. #32) should be GRANTED;
3. Defendant Progressive Casualty Insurance Company’s (“Progressive”) Joinder in
Motion to Compel Arbitration and Memorandum of Law in Support (Dkt. #33)
should be GRANTED;
4. Plaintiff’s Motion to Extend Time to File Response to Defendant’s Motion to
Compel Arbitration and Stay Litigation (Dkt. #36) should be DENIED as moot;
5. Toyota’s Motion to Strike, and in the Alternative, Motion for Leave to File Sur-Sur-
Reply (Dkt. #48) should be DENIED as moot;
Case 4:25-cv-00406-ALM Document 71 Filed 12/02/25 Page 1 of 22 PageID #:
<pageID>
2
6. Progressive’s Joinder in Toyota’s Motion to Strike, and in the Alternative, Motion
to File Sur-Sur Reply (Dkt. #50) should be DENIED as moot; and
7. CAS’s Joinder to Motion to Strike, and in the Alternative, Motion to File Sur-Sur
Reply (Dkt. #51) should be DENIED as moot.
BACKGROUND
I. Factual Background
Plaintiff Philip Siefke (“Plaintiff”), individually and on behalf of all others similarly
situated (the “Proposed Class Members” and collectively, “Plaintiffs”), brings the instant suit
against Toyota, CAS, and Progressive (“Defendants”) (Dkt. #1). Toyota is an American
multinational automotive manufacturing company, and CAS is Toyota’s data analytics servicer
(Dkt. #1 at ¶ 5; Dkt. #32 at p. 2). Plaintiffs allege Toyota and CAS collected private information
from their owned or leased Toyota vehicles without consent (Dkt. #1 at ¶ 1). The private
information at issue consists of the vehicles’ location, speed, direction, braking and
swerving/cornering events, image and voice data, and other personal identifiable information of
the driver (the “Driving Data”) (Dkt. #1 at ¶ 1).
Plaintiffs allege Toyota sold the Driving Data to third parties such as Progressive, an
insurance company (Dkt. #1 at ¶ 1). Based on this disclosure, Plaintiffs assert several causes of
action—(1) Defendants violated the Federal Wiretap Act, 18 U.S.C. §§ 2510, et seq. (Dkt. #1 at
¶¶ 74–93); (2) Toyota violated the Computer Fraud and Abuse Act, 18 U.S.C. §§ 1030, et seq.
(Dkt. #1 at ¶¶ 94–105); (3) Defendants are liable for invasions of privacy (Dkt. #1 at ¶¶ 106–19);
(4) Toyota is liable for breach of express and implied contract (Dkt. #1 at ¶¶ 120–27); and in the
alternative, (5) Toyota is liable for unjust enrichment (Dkt. #1 at ¶¶ 128–40).
The pertinent facts before the Court today are not found in Plaintiffs’ class action complaint
(the “Complaint”) and exclusively relate to the purported arbitration agreement Plaintiff accepted.
Case 4:25-cv-00406-ALM Document 71 Filed 12/02/25 Page 2 of 22 PageID #:
<pageID>
3
In support of its allegations regarding this agreement, Toyota attaches to its Motion the sworn
declaration of Mike Edwards (the “Edwards Declaration”), Senior Manager for Privacy at Toyota
(Dkt. #31-1; Dkt. #62-2). The Edwards Declaration references Toyota’s policies, practices, mobile
application (the “Toyota App”), and records (Dkt. #31-1 at ¶ 3; Dkt. #62-2 at ¶ 4).
A. The Toyota App
Toyota alleges Plaintiff expressly consented to a clear and conspicuous arbitration provision
(the “Arbitration Agreement”) found in its Connected Services Terms of Use (the “Terms of
Use”) (Dkt. #31 at p. 6). Pursuant to the Arbitration Agreement, Toyota argues Plaintiff agreed to
resolve any disputes or disagreements regarding Toyota’s “Services” and the vehicles’ “System,”
which broadly includes the collection and transmittal of the Driving Data (Dkt. #31 at p. 6). In
support thereof, Toyota alleges its new vehicles sold in the United States are equipped with a
system that wirelessly transmit data to and from the vehicles (Dkt. #31-1 at ¶ 5; Dkt. #62-2 at ¶¶ 6,
15). Toyota offers its “Connected Services” to eligible customers, which is a system that uses the
transmitted data to enhance a customer’s driving experience (Dkt. #31-1 at ¶ 5; Dkt. #62-2 at ¶ 6).
Customers choose to sign up for Toyota’s Connected Services, and only then can Toyota collect
data from the vehicle to use, as appropriate, to support the service (Dkt. #31-1 at ¶ 5; Dkt. #62-2 at
¶ 6).
The Edwards Declaration outlines how an eligible Toyota driver (the “User’) activates
Connected Services on the Toyota App (Dkt. #31-1 at ¶¶ 8–15; Dkt. #62-2 at ¶¶ 12–16). First, a
User would download the Toyota App and link their new Toyota vehicle by inputting the Vehicle
Identification Number (“VIN”), an optional vehicle nickname, preferred servicing dealer, and
vehicle capabilities (Dkt. #31-1 at ¶ 11; Dkt. #62 at p. 9; Dkt. #62-2 at ¶ 12). To continue, the User
clicks a button labeled “Save Changes” (Dkt. #31-1 at ¶ 11; Dkt. #62 at pp. 9–10; Dkt. #62-2
Case 4:25-cv-00406-ALM Document 71 Filed 12/02/25 Page 3 of 22 PageID #:
<pageID>
4
at ¶ 12). Above this “Save Changes” button is a notice that states, “By continuing, you agree to
Toyota’s handling of vehicle data according to the Connected Services Terms of Use and
Connected Services Privacy Notice” (Dkt. #31-1 at ¶¶ 10, 11; Dkt. #62-2 at ¶ 12). The terms
“Connected Services Terms of Use” and “Connected Services Privacy Notice” are in red,
boldface text, and they provide a hyperlink sending the User to digital copies of Toyota’s Terms of
Use and Privacy Notice (Dkt. #31-1 at ¶¶ 10–11; Dkt. #62-2 at ¶ 12).
Next, the User is taken to a screen that provides them with the option to participate in a
free Connected Services trial (Dkt. #31-1 at ¶¶ 12–13; Dkt. #62-2 at ¶ 14). The User is notified that,
“Terms of use apply” (Dkt. #31-1 at ¶¶ 12–13; Dkt. #62-2 at ¶ 14). To enroll in the trial, the User
must click a red button labeled “Continue” at the bottom of this screen (Dkt. #31-1 at ¶¶ 12–13;
Dkt. #62-2 at ¶ 14). The User then proceeds to a screen titled “Connected Services Master Data
Consent,” with two red buttons at the bottom of the page labeled, “Accept” and “Decline”
(Dkt. #31-1 at ¶¶ 14–15; Dkt. #62-2 at ¶ 16). The User is given the following notice above these two
red buttons:
When you click the ‘Accept’ button, you agree that on a regular and continuous
basis, your vehicle wirelessly transmits location, driving and vehicle health data to
Toyota and its affiliates in order to deliver Connected Services and for internal
research, development and data analysis.
To learn more, review the Connected Services Terms of Use and Connected
Services Privacy Notice.
To disable your vehicle data transmission capability, press “Decline” or press the
vehicle’s SOS button.
(Dkt. #31-1 at ¶ 15; Dkt. #62-2 at ¶ 16).
Again, the terms “Connected Services Terms of Use” and “Connected Services Privacy
Notice” are in red, boldface text, and they provide a hyperlink to digital copies of Toyota’s Terms
Case 4:25-cv-00406-ALM Document 71 Filed 12/02/25 Page 4 of 22 PageID #:
<pageID>
5
of Use and Privacy Notice (Dkt. #31-1 at ¶ 15; Dkt. #62-2 at ¶ 16). If the User declines the
“Customer Services Master Data Consent,” they cannot access any Connected Services and data
transmission from the vehicle is turned off (Dkt. #31-1 at ¶ 16; Dkt. #62-2 at ¶ 17). If the User
accepts the “Customer Services Master Data Consent,” they are given the option to select which
Connected Services to enroll in, either Toyota’s Service Connect Communication (“Service
Connect”), Insure Connect, and Wi-Fi Connect (Dkt. #31-1 at ¶ 17; Dkt. #61-3).
B. The Terms of Use
Toyota alleges that at all relevant times,1 Toyota’s Connected Services Terms of Use
included the Arbitration Agreement.2 The Terms of Use included a text box at the top of the first
page titled “NOTICE OF MANDATORY ARBITRATION PROVISION” in boldface text, which
read as follows:
Use of our Services (as defined below) is subject to mandatory and binding individual
arbitration of any disputes which may arise, as provided in Section 19 below. Please read all
of that section carefully and do not use any of Services if you are unwilling to arbitrate all
disputes you may have with us as provided in that section.
(Dkt. #31-5 at p. 2) (the “Notice of Mandatory Arbitration Provision”).
Section 19 of the Terms of Use is titled “DISPUTE RESOLUTION AND MANDATORY
ARBITRATION” (Dkt. #31-5 at p. 15). It reads, in relevant part, as follows:
PLEASE READ THIS PROVISION CAREFULLY. IT INCLUDES AN
AGREEMENT TO MANDATORY ARBITRATION, WHICH MEANS THAT
YOU . . . AND TOYOTA EACH AGREE TO SUBMIT ANY DISPUTE
RELATED TO THIS AGREEMENT (INCLUDING THE SOFTWARE OR
SERVICES) TO BINDING INDIVIDUAL ARBITRATION RATHER THAN
PROCEED IN COURT. . . :
1 Toyota provided the Court with the various versions of the Terms of Use that were effective from March 20, 2021,
to January 22, 2025 (the “Relevant Period”) (See Dkt. #31-2; Dkt. #31-3; Dkt. #31-3; Dkt. #31-4; Dkt. #31-5).
2 Plaintiff does not allege the minor differences in the various Arbitration Agreement affect his arguments, so the
Court will focus its analysis on the language in Toyota’s Terms of Use, effective March 7, 2023.
Case 4:25-cv-00406-ALM Document 71 Filed 12/02/25 Page 5 of 22 PageID #:
<pageID>
6
(a) Informal Resolution of Disputes. If you or Toyota has a dispute or disagreement
with the other regarding the Services, System, Software or Service Content or any
other aspect of this Agreement (each, a “Dispute”) . . . .
(b) Mandatory Arbitration of Unresolved Disputes. If after 60 days the parties are
unable to resolve the Dispute, YOU AND TOYOTA BOTH AGREE, TO THE
FULLEST EXTENT PERMITTED BY LAW, TO USE BINDING
ARBITRATION, NOT A LAWSUIT (except for small claims court cases as
described below) TO RESOLVE THE DISPUTE.
(c) Arbitration Entity & Rules. Arbitration under this Agreement shall be conducted
and administered by the American Arbitration Association pursuant to its Consumer
Arbitration Rules. If you and Toyota both agree, the arbitration may be conducted
and administered by another arbitration entity.
(d) Federal Arbitration Act. You and Toyota each enter this arbitration agreement in
connection with a transaction involving interstate commerce. Accordingly, this
arbitration agreement and any proceedings thereunder shall be governed by the
Federal Arbitration Act, 9 U.S.C. §§ 1–16 (“FAA”).
. . .
(i) Applicable Law. To the extent that the FAA does not supply substantive law
necessary for the resolution of the Dispute, the laws of the State of Texas shall apply
to the Arbitration . . . .
(Dkt. #31-5 at pp. 15–16).
C. Plaintiff’s Use of the Toyota App
On March 20, 2021, Plaintiff purchased a new 2021 Toyota vehicle (the “Toyota Vehicle”),
identified through its VIN, 2T3W1RFVXMC122334 (Dkt. #1 at ¶ 35; Dkt. #31-1 at ¶ 4; Dkt. #62
at p. 6). On March 21, 2021, Plaintiff downloaded the Toyota App, linked his vehicle, accepted the
Customer Services Master Data Consent, and signed up for Connected Services—specifically,
Service Connect and Wi-Fi Connect (Dkt. #61 at p. 6; Dkt. #62-2 at ¶¶ 7–8; Dkt. #62-19 through
Dkt. #62-41). After that day, Plaintiff would continue to interact with the Toyota App. On March
9, 2024, Plaintiff enrolled in Service Connect but declined to enroll in Insure Connect, at which
Case 4:25-cv-00406-ALM Document 71 Filed 12/02/25 Page 6 of 22 PageID #:
<pageID>
7
time Toyota ceased sharing his driving data with CAS (Dkt. #62 at pp. 13–14; Dkt. #62-2 at ¶¶ 10,
21; Dkt. #62-21 through Dkt. #62-41); and on January 22, 2025, Plaintiff used the Toyota App to
opt-out of Connected Services entirely (Dkt. #62-2 at ¶ 22; Dkt. #62-28 through Dkt. #62-52).
II. Procedural History
On July 8, 2025, Toyota filed its Motion to Compel (Dkt. #31), arguing that each of
Plaintiffs’ claims are subject to the Arbitration Agreement found in its Terms of Use. That same
day, both CAS and Progressive each filed their respective Motions for Joinder, requesting the same
relief asserted in Toyota’s Motion (Dkt. #32; Dkt. #33). On August 5, 2025, Plaintiffs filed their
Motion for Extension of Time to Respond (Dkt. #36).3 Defendants’ Motion to Compel and two
Motions for Joinder are opposed (Dkt. #40). The parties exchanged a series of responses and
replies briefing the Court on whether the parties agreed to arbitration (Dkt. #41; Dkt. #42;
Dkt. #43; Dkt. #44; Dkt. #45; Dkt. #46; Dkt. #47; Dkt. #49).4 On November 14, 2025, in response
to the Court’s October 10, 2025 Order (Dkt. #52), Plaintiff and Toyota filed Supplemental Briefs
(Dkt. #61; Dkt. #62).5 All pending motions are now ripe for adjudication.
LEGAL STANDARD
Under the Federal Arbitration Act, “parties to a contract may agree that an arbitrator rather
than a court will resolve disputes arising out of the contract.” Henry Schein, Inc. v. Archer & White
3 The Court advised Plaintiff that its Motion for Extension of Time to Respond did not include a proposed order,
which is why the Motion remains unresolved.
4 On October 7, 2025, Toyota filed its Motion to Strike, and in the alternative, Motion for Leave to File a
Sur-Sur-Reply (Dkt. #48), asking the Court to strike Section II and III of Plaintiff’s Sur-Reply (Dkt. #47). On that
same day, Progressive and CAS joined Toyota’s Motion to Strike (Dkt. #50; Dkt. #51), and Toyota filed its Sur-Sur-
Reply in Support of its Motion to Compel (Dkt. #49).
5 On October 10, 2025, the Court granted Plaintiffs’ Motion for Limited Discovery and ordered the parties to
complete limited arbitration-related discovery on the issue of contract formation (Dkt. #52). The parties complied
and briefed the issue for the Court (Dkt. #61; Dkt. #62).
Case 4:25-cv-00406-ALM Document 71 Filed 12/02/25 Page 7 of 22 PageID #:
<pageID>
8
Sales, Inc., 586 U.S. 63, 65 (2019). The FAA provides that written agreements to arbitrate
controversies arising out of an existing contract “shall be valid, irrevocable, and enforceable, save
upon such grounds as exist at law or in equity for the revocation of any contract.” 9 U.S.C. § 2.
“The FAA was designed to overrule the judiciary’s long-standing refusal to enforce agreements to
arbitrate and to place such agreements upon the same footing as other contracts.” Volt Info. Scis.,
Inc. v. Bd. of Trs. of Leland Stanford Junior Univ., 489 U.S. 468, 478 (1989) (internal quotations
omitted). Thus, the FAA establishes “‘a liberal federal policy favoring arbitration agreements.’”
CompuCredit Corp. v. Greenwood, 565 U.S. 95, 98 (2012) (quoting Moses H. Cone Mem’l Hosp. v.
Mercury Constr. Corp., 460 U.S. 1, 24 (1983)). Because arbitration is a creature of contract, the FAA
“requires courts to enforce agreements to arbitrate according to their terms.” Id. at 98 (citing Dean
Witter Reynolds, Inc. v. Byrd, 470 U.S. 213, 221 (1985)).
Although there is a strong federal policy favoring arbitration, the policy “does not apply to
the determination of whether there is a valid agreement to arbitrate between the parties.” Lloyd’s
Syndicate 457 v. FloaTEC, L.L.C., 921 F.3d 508, 516 n.5 (5th Cir. 2019) (quoting Will-Drill Res., Inc.
v. Samson Res. Co., 352 F.3d 211, 214 (5th Cir. 2003)). The FAA “does not require parties to
arbitrate when they have not agreed to do so . . . .” Volt, 489 U.S. at 478 (citing Byrd, 470 U.S.
at 219). Rather, “arbitration is a matter of contract and a party cannot be required to submit to
arbitration any dispute which he has not agreed so to submit.” United Steelworkers of Am. v. Warrior
& Gulf Nav. Co., 363 U.S. 574, 582 (1960). The FAA “simply requires courts to enforce privately
negotiated agreements to arbitrate, like other contracts, in accordance with their terms.” Volt, 489
U.S. at 478 (citing Prima Paint Corp. v. Flood & Conklin Mfg. Co., 388 U.S. 395, 404 n.12 (1967)).
Case 4:25-cv-00406-ALM Document 71 Filed 12/02/25 Page 8 of 22 PageID #:
<pageID>
9
When considering a motion to compel arbitration, courts apply a two-step framework. First,
the Court must determine “whether the parties entered into any arbitration agreement at all.”
Kubala v. Supreme Prod. Servs., Inc., 830 F.3d 199, 201 (5th Cir. 2016). “This first step is a question
of contract formation only—did the parties form a valid agreement to arbitrate some set of claims.”
IQ Prods. Co. v. WD-40 Co., 871 F.3d 344, 348 (5th Cir. 2017), cert. denied, 584 U.S. 1031 (2018).
This initial question is for the Court. Kubala, 830 F.3d at 201. To determine whether there is a valid
agreement to arbitrate, courts “‘apply ordinary state-law principles that govern the formation of
contracts.’” Webb v. Investacorp, Inc., 89 F.3d 252, 258 (5th Cir. 1996) (quoting First Options of Chi.,
Inc. v. Kaplan, 514 U.S. 938, 939 (1995)).
If the Court finds that there is a valid agreement to arbitrate, it proceeds to the second
question: whether the claim at issue is covered by the arbitration agreement. IQ Prods., 871 F.3d
at 348. In the second step, the Court must determine “‘whether legal constraints external to the
parties’ agreement foreclosed the arbitration of those claims.’” Webb, 89 F.3d at 258
(quoting Mitsubishi Motors Corp. v. Soler Chrysler-Plymouth, Inc., 473 U.S. 614, 628 (1985)). This
second question is usually for the Court, unless the arbitration clause contains a valid delegation
clause for an arbitrator to determine whether the claim falls within the arbitration
agreement. Kubala, 830 F.3d at 201–02.
The party seeking to compel arbitration must prove the existence of an agreement to
arbitrate by a preponderance of the evidence. Grant v. Houser, 469 F. App’x 310, 315 (5th Cir. 2012)
(per curiam). Once the Court determines that there is a valid agreement to arbitrate, the strong
federal policy favoring the enforcement of the arbitration agreements applies, and all ambiguities
must be resolved in favor of arbitration. Banc One Acceptance Corp. v. Hill, 367 F.3d 426, 429 (5th
Case 4:25-cv-00406-ALM Document 71 Filed 12/02/25 Page 9 of 22 PageID #:
<pageID>
10
Cir. 2004) (citing Primerica Life Ins. Co. v. Brown, 304 F.3d 469, 471 (5th Cir. 2002)). As the
Supreme Court has stated: “‘[a]n order to arbitrate the particular grievance should not be denied
unless it may be said with positive assurance that the arbitration clause is not susceptible of an
interpretation that covers the asserted dispute. Doubts should be resolved in favor of coverage.’”
AT & T Techs., Inc. v. Commc’ns Workers of Am., 475 U.S. 643, 650 (1986) (quoting United
Steelworkers, 363 U.S. at 582–83 (1960)). In this scenario, the party opposing arbitration bears the
burden to demonstrate either that the agreement is invalid or that the claims are outside of the
agreement’s scope. See Carter v. Countrywide Credit Indus., Inc., 362 F.3d 294, 297 (5th Cir. 2004).
ANALYSIS
Defendants move to compel Plaintiff to arbitrate his claims (Dkt. #31; Dkt. #32; Dkt. #33),
arguing Plaintiff agreed to Toyota’s Terms of Use, which contained the relevant Arbitration
Agreement and class action waiver (Dkt. #31 at p. 13; Dkt. #31-5 at pp. 15–16).6 The instant dispute
hinges on the validity of the Arbitration Agreement under substantive Texas contract law.7 The
Court’s analysis will be divided into three sections to determine whether Plaintiff must arbitrate
his claims against each of the three Defendants: (1) Toyota; (2) CAS; and (3) Progressive.
6 Toyota repeatedly references a class action waiver found in its Terms of Use throughout its Motion; however, Toyota
requests the Court to compel arbitration and stay the case as to Plaintiff only (Dkt. #31 at pp. 6, 25). Toyota does
not ask the Court to compel the Proposed Class Members to individual arbitration. For this reason, the Court does
not analyze the class action waiver.
7 Generally, the Court must first decide whether the FAA applies to the Agreement. Here, the Terms of Use state
explicitly that “this arbitration agreement and any proceedings thereunder shall be governed by the Federal
Arbitration Act, 9 U.S.C. §§ 1–16” (Dkt. #31-5 at p. 16). Moreover, the parties do not dispute the applicability of the
FAA (Dkt. #31 at p. 15; Dkt. #61), which provides that a party seeking to enforce an arbitration provision may
petition a court for “an order directing the parties to proceed to arbitration in accordance with the terms of the
agreement.” 9 U.S.C. § 2. Accordingly, because the Terms of Use explicitly state that the FAA governs the
Arbitration Agreement and because this is an uncontested issue, the Court will apply the FAA to procedural matters.
See Pedcor Mgmt. Co., Inc. Welfare Benefit Plan v. Nations Pers. of Tex., Inc., 343 F.3d 355, 361 (5th Cir. 2003)
(explaining that the FAA generally governs the construction of an agreement to arbitrate).
Case 4:25-cv-00406-ALM Document 71 Filed 12/02/25 Page 10 of 22 PageID #:
<pageID>
11
I. Toyota
Enforcement of an arbitration agreement involves two analytical steps. Kubala, 830 F.3d at
201. The first is contract formation—whether the parties entered into any arbitration agreement at
all. Id. The second is contract interpretation—whether the claim at issue is covered by the
arbitration agreement. Id. Generally, both steps are determinations for the Court to make. Id.
However, “if a valid agreement exists, and if the agreement delegates the arbitrability issue to an
arbitrator, a court may not decide the arbitrability issue.” Henry Schein, Inc., 586 U.S. at 69.
The Court must first determine whether the Arbitration Agreement constitutes a valid
contract. To make this determination, courts apply “‘ordinary state-law principles that govern the
formation of contracts.’” Carey v. 24 Hour Fitness, USA, Inc., 669 F.3d 202, 205 (5th Cir. 2012)
(quoting Morrison v. Amway Corp., 517 F.3d 248, 254 (5th Cir. 2008)). Here, both parties agree that
Texas law applies (Dkt. #31 at pp. 16–17; Dkt. #61 at p. 9). Thus, the validity of the Agreement will
be determined under Texas contract law. Kubala, 830 F.3d at 202. As the following discussion will
demonstrate, the Arbitration Agreement, which includes a delegation clause, is valid because it
satisfies the elements of a binding contract and is not illusory.
A. The Arbitration Agreement satisfies the elements of a binding contract.
Under Texas law, a binding contract requires: “(1) an offer; (2) an acceptance in strict
compliance with the terms of the offer; (3) a meeting of the minds; (4) each party’s consent to the
terms; and (5) execution and delivery of the contract with intent that it be mutual and binding.” In
re Capco Energy, Inc., 669 F.3d 274, 279–80 (5th Cir. 2012) (citation modified) (quoting Coffel v.
Stryker Corp., 284 F.3d 625, 640 n.17 (5th Cir. 2002) (applying Texas law)). The parties dispute
whether Plaintiff accepted the Arbitration Agreement (Dkt. #61 at pp. 9–18; Dkt. #62 at pp. 9–14).
Specifically, Plaintiff argues, “nothing in the [Toyota App] interface relied upon by Toyota led
Case 4:25-cv-00406-ALM Document 71 Filed 12/02/25 Page 11 of 22 PageID #:
<pageID>
12
[Plaintiff ] or any other reasonable consumer to believe that he had ‘agreed’ to the [Terms of Use]
or the Arbitration Agreement therein” (Dkt. #61 at p. 10). Because Plaintiff’s consent is dependent
on his usage of the Toyota App and activation of Toyota’s Connected Services, the parties
characterize the Arbitration Agreement found in its Terms of Use as a “clickwrap agreement”
(Dkt. #62 at pp. 9–14). The Court considers the nuances between “clickwrap,” “browsewrap,” and
“sign-in-wrap” agreements. See Phillips v. Neutron Holdings, Inc., No. 3:18-CV-3382-S, 2019 WL
4861435, at *3 (N.D. Tex. Oct. 2, 2019) (distinguishing between the various types of agreements in
the context of electronically assenting to an arbitration agreement).
First, “[a] ‘clickwrap agreement’ allows a consumer to assent to the terms of a contract by
selecting an ‘accept’ button on the web site. If the consumer does not accept the terms of the
agreement, the web site will not complete the transaction.” Am. Eyewear, Inc. v. Peeper’s Sunglasses
& Accessories, Inc. peepers, 106 F. Supp. 2d 895, 905 (N.D. Tex. 2000) (citation omitted). Second, a
“a browsewrap . . . does not require the user to manifest assent to the terms and conditions
expressly-the user need not sign a document or click on an ‘accept’ or ‘I agree’ button,” instead,
“[a user] instead gives [their] assent simply by using the website.” S.W. Airlines Co. v. BoardFirst,
L.L.C., No. 3:06-CV-0891-B, 2007 WL 4823761, at *4 (N.D. Tex. Sept. 12, 2007). “Browsewraps
may take various forms but typically they involve a situation where a notice on a website conditions
use of the site upon compliance with certain terms or conditions, which may be included on the
same page as the notice or accessible via a hyperlink.” Id. at *4. “The same principles apply to
downloading and using smartphone apps.” Phillips, 2019 WL 4861435, at *4 (citing Wilson v.
Huuuge, Inc., 351 F. Supp. 3d 1308, 1313 (W.D. Wash. 2018) (“When a user visits a website or
downloads an app, they may be bound by the accompanying terms . . . through a ‘clickwrap’
Case 4:25-cv-00406-ALM Document 71 Filed 12/02/25 Page 12 of 22 PageID #:
<pageID>
13
agreement or a ‘browsewrap’ agreement.”)). Third, sign-in-wraps are agreements that “notify the
user of the existence of the website’s terms of use and, instead of providing an ‘I agree’ button,
advise the user that he or she is agreeing to the terms of service when registering or signing up.”
Phillips, 2019 WL 4861435, at *4 (quoting Meyer v. Uber Techs., Inc., 868 F.3d 66, 75-76 (2d Cir.
2017)).
Here, the Toyota App seemingly relies on sign-in-wraps. First, to link a User’s vehicle to
the Toyota App, the User must input specific information and can only proceed by clicking the
“Save Changes” button (Dkt. #31-1 at ¶ 11; Dkt. #62 at pp. 9–10; Dkt. #62-2 at ¶ 12). Above this
“Save Changes” button is a notice that states, “By continuing, you agree to Toyota’s handling of
vehicle data according to the Connected Services Terms of Use and Connected Services Privacy
Notice” (Dkt. #31-1 at ¶¶ 10, 11; Dkt. #62-2 at ¶ 12). This page reflects a sign-in-wrap because it
notifies the User of the existence of Toyota’s Terms of Use; however, instead of providing an “I
agree” or “Accept” button specifically referencing the Terms of Use, the Toyota App notifies the
User that they are agreeing to the Terms of Use by “continuing” with their vehicle’s registration
(Dkt. #31-1 at ¶¶ 10–11; Dkt. #62-2 at ¶ 12). Phillips, 2019 WL 4861435, at *4 (quoting Meyer, 868
F.3d at 75–76).
Second, to enroll in the free Connected Services trial, the User must click a red button
labeled “Continue” at the bottom of this screen (Dkt. #31-1 at ¶¶ 12–13; Dkt. #62-2 at ¶ 14). In the
text above “Continue,” the User is notified that, “Terms of use apply” (Dkt. #31-1 at ¶¶ 12–13;
Dkt. #62-2 at ¶ 14). This page also reflects a sign-in-wrap because it notifies the User of the
existence of Toyota’s Terms of Use, and again, instead of providing an “I agree” or “Accept”
button, the Toyota App notifies the User that by clicking “Continue” and signing up for the free
Case 4:25-cv-00406-ALM Document 71 Filed 12/02/25 Page 13 of 22 PageID #:
<pageID>
14
Connected Services trial, they are agreeing to Toyota’s Terms of Use (Dkt. #31-1 at ¶¶ 12–13;
Dkt. #62-2 at ¶ 14). Phillips, 2019 WL 4861435, at *4 (quoting Meyer, 868 F.3d at 75-76).
Third, the User will eventually land on the screen titled “Connected Services Master Data
Consent,” with two red buttons at the bottom of the page labeled, “Accept” and “Decline”
(Dkt. #31-1 at ¶¶ 14–15; Dkt. #62-2 at ¶ 16). The User is given the following notice above these two
red buttons:
When you click the ‘Accept’ button, you agree that on a regular and continuous
basis, your vehicle wirelessly transmits location, driving and vehicle health data to
Toyota and its affiliates in order to deliver Connected Services and for internal
research, development and data analysis.
To learn more, review the Connected Services Terms of Use and Connected
Services Privacy Notice.
(Dkt. #31-1 at ¶ 15; Dkt. #62-2 at ¶ 16).
This page also reflects a sign-in-wrap because it notifies the User of the existence of
Toyota’s Terms of Use, and again, instead of providing an “I agree” or “Accept” button specific
asking for consent to the Terms of Use, the Toyota App invites the User to review Toyota’s Terms
of Use before accepting the Connected Services Master Data Consent and signing up for this
service. Phillips, 2019 WL 4861435, at *4 (quoting Meyer, 868 F.3d at 75-76).
“Courts typically enforce sign-in-wraps where the user had reasonable notice of the
existence of the terms—i.e., whether the notice was reasonably conspicuous. In making that
determination, courts consider the perspective of a reasonably prudent smartphone user.” Phillips,
2019 WL 4861435, at *4 (citation modified) (first citing Meyer, 868 F.3d at 75-76; then citing Selden
v. Airbnb, Inc., No. 16-cv-00933, 2016 WL 6476934, at *5 (D.D.C. Nov. 1, 2016)). In May v. Expedia,
Inc., the court found that the plaintiff had actual knowledge and sufficient notice that by continuing
Case 4:25-cv-00406-ALM Document 71 Filed 12/02/25 Page 14 of 22 PageID #:
<pageID>
15
with a transaction, they were agreeing to the defendant’s Terms and Conditions that were in effect
at the time. No. A-16-CV-1211-RP, 2018 WL 4343445, at *3 (W.D. Tex. July 19, 2018), report and
recommendation adopted, No. 1:16-CV-1211-RP, 2018 WL 4343427 (W.D. Tex. Aug. 27, 2018). In
that case, the “Terms and Conditions” and “Privacy Policy” found above a “Continue” button
were in blue, as opposed to black, font to indicate they were hyperlinks. Id. at *3.
Here, in the first screen, above the “Save Changes” button, the terms “Connected Services
Terms of Use” and “Connected Services Privacy Notice” are in red, boldface text, and they
provide a hyperlink sending the User to digital copies of Toyota’s Terms of Use and Privacy Notice
(Dkt. #31-1 at ¶¶ 10–11; Dkt. #62-2 at ¶ 12). Similarly, in the last screen regarding the Connected
Services Master Data Consent, the terms “Connected Services Terms of Use” and “Connected
Services Privacy Notice” are in red, boldface text, and they provide a hyperlink to digital copies of
Toyota’s Terms of Use and Privacy Notice (Dkt. #31-1 at ¶ 15; Dkt. #62-2 at ¶ 16).
The Court finds the hyperlinks to Toyota’s Terms of Use found on the various screens with
which Plaintiff interacted were reasonably conspicuous and placed Plaintiff on notice of the
Arbitration Agreement. Accordingly, by signing up and linking his vehicle to the Toyota App and
activating Connected Services, Plaintiff manifested his assent to be bound by Toyota’s Terms of
Use, which included the Arbitration Agreement. For this reason, the Court concludes the
Arbitration Agreement satisfies the elements of a valid contract.
B. The Arbitration Agreement is not illusory.
The Court next examines Plaintiff’s illusory contract argument in detail. Plaintiff argues
the Terms of Use, which includes the Arbitration Agreement, provide “the unilateral right for
Toyota to modify the Terms, and to provide notice in a variety of ways, rendering any consent
obtained illusory” (Dkt. #61 at p. 20). Plaintiff specifically points to Section 11 of the Terms of Use,
Case 4:25-cv-00406-ALM Document 71 Filed 12/02/25 Page 15 of 22 PageID #:
<pageID>
16
effective August 1, 2019, titled “Modification to Agreement” (Dkt. #61 at p. 20; Dkt. #31-2 at p. 2).
This section mirrors Section 10(b) in the most recent version of the Terms of Use, effective March
7, 2023, titled “Modification to Terms of Use/Services” (Dkt. #31-5 at pp. 8–9).8
Texas law rejects the validity of any arbitration agreement found to be “illusory.” In re 24R,
Inc., 324 S.W.3d 564, 567 (Tex. 2010). In Texas, “an arbitration clause is illusory if one party can
‘avoid its promise to arbitrate by amending the provision or terminating it altogether.’” Carey, 669
F.3d at 205 (quoting In re 24R, 324 S.W.3d at 567). “Put differently, where one party to an
arbitration agreement seeks to invoke arbitration to settle a dispute, if the other party can suddenly
change the terms of the agreement to avoid arbitration, then the agreement was illusory from the
outset.” Id.
That is not the case here. On the contrary, had Plaintiff attempted to enforce the Arbitration
Agreement, Defendant would have been bound by its own terms. Moreover, if there was a
modification, Toyota was required to provide Plaintiff notice, and the effective date of any
applicable change would have applied to prospective claims and not retroactively (Dkt. #31-5 at
8 Section 10(b) reads as follows:
We reserve the right in our sole discretion and at any time and for any reason, to amend, change or
modify these Terms of Use. We also reserve the right in our sole discretion and at any time and for
any reason, to amend, change or modify or discontinue any aspect or feature of our Services. This
includes Services provided directly by us, as well as Services provided or supported by Service
Providers (such as third party applications available via the App or the multimedia equipment in the
Vehicle). The notice we provide you of such changes will vary based on the nature of the change. For
instance, we will notify you of changes to the Terms of Use, by posting a revised version in the App,
in the Agreement section of www.Toyota.com/privacyvts/, and/or in other relevant parts of the
Website. For changes to the Services, and certain changes to the Terms of Use (such as changes we
believe materially affect your rights under this Agreement), we will provide you notice via email or
other written notice, through the App and/or through the multimedia equipment in the Vehicle. The
effective date of the applicable change will be as set forth, as applicable, in the revised Terms of Use
or the other notice we provide you. IF YOU DO NOT AGREE WITH ANY SUCH CHANGE,
YOUR SOLE RECOURSE IS TO CANCEL YOUR SERVICE PLAN AND THE SERVICE. Your
continued access or use of the Services after our notice indicates your acceptance of the change(s).
(Dkt. #31-5 at pp. 8–9).
Case 4:25-cv-00406-ALM Document 71 Filed 12/02/25 Page 16 of 22 PageID #:
<pageID>
17
pp. 8–9). See Long v. Omni Hotels Mgt. Corp., No. CV H-15-1283, 2016 WL 11811587, at *3 (S.D.
Tex. Mar. 24, 2016) (“The Fifth Circuit interprets Halliburton as holding the ability to modify an
agreement does not render it illusory under Texas law where the ‘power (1) extends only to
prospective claims, (2) applies equally to both the employer’s and employee’s claims, and (3) so
long as advanced notice to the employee is required before termination is effective.’” (quoting
Lizdale v. Vista Quality Mkts., 746 F.3d 222, 226 (5th Cir. 2014)). Plaintiff’s lack of consideration
argument also fails. Having determined the Arbitration Agreement is not illusory, “a mutual
agreement to arbitrate claims is sufficient consideration to support an arbitration agreement.”
Nelson v. Watch House Int’l, L.L.C., 815 F.3d 190, 193 (5th Cir. 2016).
Accordingly, the Arbitration Agreement is valid and enforceable.
C. The Arbitration Agreement includes a valid delegation clause.
The Supreme Court has instructed courts to look no further than the arbitrability of a
particular claim when determining whether to compel arbitration; indeed, “courts must examine a
complaint with care to assess whether any individual claim must be arbitrated,” and “[t]he failure
to do so is subject to immediate review.” KPMG LLP v. Cocchi, 565 U.S. 18, 22 (2011). However,
“parties may agree that the ‘gateway’ question of arbitrability should be decided by an arbitrator,
rather than a court.” See Beaumont Foot Specialists, Inc. v. United Healthcare of Tex., Inc., No. 1:15-
CV-216, 2015 WL 9703796, at *2 (E.D. Tex. Dec. 22, 2015) (citing Rent–A–Ctr., W., Inc. v. Jackson,
561 U.S. 63, 68–69 (2010)), report and recommendation adopted, No. 1:15-CV-216, 2016 WL 165023
(E.D. Tex. Jan. 14, 2016). “Pursuant to such a ‘delegation’ clause, an arbitrator is empowered to
determine whether the agreement in fact requires the parties to arbitrate the dispute at hand.” Id.
(citing Rent–A–Ctr., W., Inc., 561 U.S. at 68–69). “[This] is true even if the court thinks that the
Case 4:25-cv-00406-ALM Document 71 Filed 12/02/25 Page 17 of 22 PageID #:
<pageID>
18
argument that the arbitration agreement applies to a particular dispute is wholly groundless.” Henry
Schein, Inc., 586 U.S. at 69.
Here, Toyota identifies a delegation clause through the incorporation of the American
Arbitration Association (“AAA”) rules in the Arbitration Agreement (Dkt. #31 at p. 23).9 Plaintiff
argues Toyota fails to consider the entire delegation clause which “does not contemplate that the
AAA is the exclusive arbitral forum” (Dkt. #62 at p. 23). Specifically, the entire delegation clause
states: “Arbitration under this Agreement shall be conducted and administered by the [AAA]
pursuant to its Consumer Arbitration Rules. If you and Toyota both agree, the arbitration may be
conducted and administered by another arbitration entity.” (Dkt. #31-5 at p. 15). Plaintiff argues,
“AAA’s rules, including Rule 7(a) that provides that the arbitrator may determine its own
jurisdiction, are optional” and thus, “[a]nother arbitral forum, with different rules that do not
contain a Rule 7(a) analog, may apply, undercutting Toyota’s claim that the delegation clause is
clear and unmistakable” (Dkt. #61 at p. 23).
The Court disagrees. The express incorporation of the AAA Consumer Arbitration Rules,
including Rule 7(a), “constitutes clear and unmistakable evidence that the parties agreed to
arbitrate arbitrability.” Edwards, 888 F.3d at 746 (citation modified) (quoting Crawford Prof’l Drugs,
Inc. v. CVS Caremark Corp., 748 F.3d 249, 262–63 (5th Cir. 2014)). Because Toyota has not agreed
that the arbitration would be conducted and administered by another arbitration entity other than
the AAA, adherence to Rule 7(a) of the AAA’s Consumer Arbitration Rules is not optional as
Defendant contends.
9 Under Rule 7(a) of the AAA’s Consumer Arbitration Rules, “[t]he arbitrator shall have the power to rule on his or
her own jurisdiction, including any objections with respect to the existence, scope, or validity of the arbitration
agreement or to the arbitrability of any claim or counterclaim.” Edwards v. Doordash, Inc., 888 F.3d 738, 746 (5th Cir.
2018).
Case 4:25-cv-00406-ALM Document 71 Filed 12/02/25 Page 18 of 22 PageID #:
<pageID>
19
Accordingly, the delegation clause is valid and Plaintiff’s remaining arguments regarding
the validity of the Arbitration Agreement should be addressed by the arbitrator.
II. CAS
The Court will next consider CAS’s Joinder to Toyota’s Motion to Compel (Dkt. #32).
CAS contends it is a Toyota affiliate as it provides Toyota’s Insure Connect program through the
Connected Services at issue (Dkt. #32 at p. 2). CAS argues The Terms of Use expressly provide
that Toyota and its affiliates—including CAS—can compel any dispute “regarding the Services,
System, Software or Service Content” to binding arbitration (Dkt. #32 at pp. 2–3). The Court
agrees. Toyota and its affiliates are considered collectively as “Toyota” within the Terms of Use
(Dkt. #31-5 at p. 2). Accordingly, the Arbitration Agreement extends to the disputes between CAS
and Plaintiff.
III. Progressive
The Court will next consider Progressive’s Joinder in Toyota’s Motion to Compel
(Dkt. #33). Progressive’s ability to rely on the Arbitration Agreement is distinguishable from CAS’s
status as a Toyota affiliate. Although it is non-signatory to the Arbitration Agreement, Progressive
contends that Plaintiff should be compelled to arbitrate his claims against Progressive under an
equitable estoppel doctrine (Dkt. #33 at p. 10).
The Fifth Circuit has held, “in certain limited instances, pursuant to an equitable estoppel
doctrine, a non-signatory-to-an-arbitration-agreement-defendant can nevertheless compel
arbitration against a signatory-plaintiff.” Grigson v. Creative Artists Agency L.L.C., 210 F.3d 524, 526
(5th Cir. 2000). In Grigson, the Fifth Circuit echoed the Eleventh Circuit’s guardrails when
applying the equitable estoppel doctrine:
Case 4:25-cv-00406-ALM Document 71 Filed 12/02/25 Page 19 of 22 PageID #:
<pageID>
20
Existing case law demonstrates that equitable estoppel allows a nonsignatory to
compel arbitration in two different circumstances. First, equitable estoppel applies
when the signatory to a written agreement containing an arbitration clause must rely
on the terms of the written agreement in asserting its claims against the
nonsignatory. When each of a signatory’s claims against a nonsignatory makes
reference to or presumes the existence of the written agreement, the signatory’s
claims arise out of and relate directly to the written agreement, and arbitration is
appropriate. Second, application of equitable estoppel is warranted when the
signatory to the contract containing an arbitration clause raises allegations of
substantially interdependent and concerted misconduct by both the nonsignatory
and one or more of the signatories to the contract. Otherwise the arbitration
proceedings between the two signatories would be rendered meaningless and the
federal policy in favor of arbitration effectively thwarted.
Id. at 527 (quoting McBro Planning & Dev. Co. v. Triangle Elec. Constr. Co., 741 F.2d 342 (11th Cir.
1984)).
Whether or not the first prong of equitable estoppel applies, the second one does. Plaintiffs
sued Progressive for obtaining the Driving Data from Toyota without their consent (Dkt. #1 at
¶ 1). Based on this purportedly unlawful disclosure, Plaintiffs asserts Progressive violated the
Federal Wiretap Act, 18 U.S.C. §§ 2510, et seq. (Dkt. #1 at ¶¶ 74–93) and Progressive is liable for
invasions of privacy (Dkt. #1 at ¶¶ 106–19). Plaintiff argues his “claims against Progressive are not
based on a violation of the [Terms of Use], and are not so intertwined with those against Toyota, as
to render meaningless any arbitration against Toyota without Progressive’s participation”
(Dkt. #61 at p. 29).
The Court sees it differently. Whether or not Progressive violated the Federal Wiretap Act
and is liable for invasions of privacy will be affected by the existing contracts between Plaintiffs and
Toyota. Specifically, whether Toyota was authorized to disclose the Driving Data to Progressive
will depend on arguments made in reliance on the Connected Services Terms of Use and Privacy
Case 4:25-cv-00406-ALM Document 71 Filed 12/02/25 Page 20 of 22 PageID #:
<pageID>
21
Notice. As a result, the Arbitration Agreement extends to disputes between Progressive and
Plaintiff.
IV. Remaining Motions
Having determined each of Plaintiff’s claims are subject to the Arbitration Agreement
found in its Terms of Use, the Court need not consider Toyota’s Motion to Strike, and in the
Alternative, Motion for Leave to File Sur-Sur-Reply (Dkt. #48), Progressive’s Joinder in Toyota’s
Motion to Strike, and in the Alternative, Motion to File Sur-Sur Reply (Dkt. #50), and CAS’s
Joinder to Motion to Strike, and in the Alternative, Motion to File Sur-Sur Reply (Dkt. #51).
Further, because the Court granted Plaintiffs’ Motion for Limited Discovery and ordered the
Plaintiff to supplement his briefing on the Arbitration Agreement (Dkt. #52), the Court need not
consider Plaintiff’s Motion to Extend Time to File Response to Defendant’s Motion to Compel
Arbitration and Stay Litigation (Dkt. #36).
CONCLUSION
It is therefore ORDERED that Defendant Toyota Motor North America, Inc.’s Motion to
Compel (Dkt. #31), Defendant Connected Analytical Services’ Joinder to Motion to Compel
Arbitration (Dkt. #32), and Defendant Progressive Casualty Insurance Company’s Joinder in
Motion to Compel Arbitration and Memorandum of Law in Support (Dkt. #33) are hereby
GRANTED.
It is further ORDERED the case against Defendants is STAYED pending arbitration, and
the parties must notify the Court upon completion of the arbitration to reinstate the case.
It is further ORDERED that Plaintiff’s Motion to Extend Time to File Response to
Defendant’s Motion to Compel Arbitration and Stay Litigation (Dkt. #36), Toyota’s Motion to
Strike, and in the Alternative, Motion for Leave to File Sur-Sur-Reply (Dkt. #48), Progressive’s
Case 4:25-cv-00406-ALM Document 71 Filed 12/02/25 Page 21 of 22 PageID #:
<pageID>
22
Joinder in Toyota’s Motion to Strike, and in the Alternative, Motion to File Sur-Sur Reply
(Dkt. #50), and CAS’s Joinder to Motion to Strike, and in the Alternative, Motion to File Sur-Sur-
Reply (Dkt. #51) are hereby DENIED as moot.
IT IS SO ORDERED.
Case 4:25-cv-00406-ALM Document 71 Filed 12/02/25 Page 22 of 22 PageID #:
<pageID>

Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude

Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.